User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Gambit26
offline
Link
 
here are my nominations/votes.

Defensive MVP: Mr. Sack Daddy

Offense: My decision would be between Keloni, Maximus, or King Leonidas. Maximus has had fumbling issues at times in the season, but the only reason Keloni is that high is because of gutted teams.(he had almost 800 yards in one game). My vote would go to King Leonidas for his efficiency at QB(6:1 TD:int ratio), and his ability to show up the best in big games.

Offensive MVP: King Leonidas


....wow I just realized both of those players are owned by the same person. That Douchebag! (just kidding, please don't cut me)
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 21:53:19
 
RayRay99
Bastion of Truth
offline
Link
 
Defensive - Mr. Sack Daddy, consolation goes to Chad Olsen. Olsen is a 1 man defensive squad, and 456 tackles through 14 games deserves some sort of recognition. He also deserves a massage and icepack.

Offensive - You have to look at a lot of factors here. You nominate Keloni and Maximus, but their stats are inflated. Don't get me wrong, they are great HBs, but when you run the ball that much you are going to have big numbers. Hell, Maximus has twice as many carries as Jorvorskie (447 to 226) but only 700 more yards (2882 to 2148). He also seems to be a fumbling machine. With the QBs Garland has more yards then Leonidas, but Leonidas is better in everything else it seems. The 49/8 TD/Int ratio is what puts him over the top and is why he gets my vote as well.
 
Gambit26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RayRay99
Defensive - Mr. Sack Daddy, consolation goes to Chad Olsen. Olsen is a 1 man defensive squad, and 456 tackles through 14 games deserves some sort of recognition. He also deserves a massage and icepack.

Offensive - You have to look at a lot of factors here. You nominate Keloni and Maximus, but their stats are inflated. Don't get me wrong, they are great HBs, but when you run the ball that much you are going to have big numbers. Hell, Maximus has twice as many carries as Jorvorskie (447 to 226) but only 700 more yards (2882 to 2148). He also seems to be a fumbling machine. With the QBs Garland has more yards then Leonidas, but Leonidas is better in everything else it seems. The 49/8 TD/Int ratio is what puts him over the top and is why he gets my vote as well.


It is hard to tell with the gutted teams sometimes. I know Max had done well against good teams, but you can't have an MVP that has fumbled that many times thus far. Jorvorskie has done good also.

 
refguru
offline
Link
 
You guys can have the MVPs. We'll take the MVT!
 
Beatdown
offline
Link
 
It's almost impossible to tell on an MVP with the gutted teams. My DE has 30-something sacks, but I had 15 in one game against a gutted team. It really makes the stats kinda pointless.
 
griz
offline
Link
 
I agree, basing the MVP on the stats makes it difficult. There are many players with slightly lower stats overall that mean more to their respective teams success than some guys with inflated stats.
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
With gutted/weak teams, certain positions get crazy stats. To be honest there should be a way of removing those games from the relevant stats and even then some important contributions in game don't give you stats.

If for example a CB is so good his WR is rarely open and therefore rarely gets a pass, then that CB will be low on tackles/PDs and he was probably the best CB that game...
 
RayRay99
Bastion of Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Spirer
With gutted/weak teams, certain positions get crazy stats. To be honest there should be a way of removing those games from the relevant stats and even then some important contributions in game don't give you stats.

If for example a CB is so good his WR is rarely open and therefore rarely gets a pass, then that CB will be low on tackles/PDs and he was probably the best CB that game...


Everyone plays the gutted teams, so it should be a wash. I agree it is difficult for positions like O-Line and CB, your stats there don't tell the whole story.
 
griz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RayRay99
Originally posted by Spirer

With gutted/weak teams, certain positions get crazy stats. To be honest there should be a way of removing those games from the relevant stats and even then some important contributions in game don't give you stats.

If for example a CB is so good his WR is rarely open and therefore rarely gets a pass, then that CB will be low on tackles/PDs and he was probably the best CB that game...


Everyone plays the gutted teams, so it should be a wash. I agree it is difficult for positions like O-Line and CB, your stats there don't tell the whole story.


But it's not a wash. For example this season, one team in the west gutted halfway through the season. Some guys end up doing way more damage vrs weak teams than others due to the way some game plans are done etc.
 
RayRay99
Bastion of Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griz
Originally posted by RayRay99

Originally posted by Spirer


With gutted/weak teams, certain positions get crazy stats. To be honest there should be a way of removing those games from the relevant stats and even then some important contributions in game don't give you stats.

If for example a CB is so good his WR is rarely open and therefore rarely gets a pass, then that CB will be low on tackles/PDs and he was probably the best CB that game...


Everyone plays the gutted teams, so it should be a wash. I agree it is difficult for positions like O-Line and CB, your stats there don't tell the whole story.


But it's not a wash. For example this season, one team in the west gutted halfway through the season. Some guys end up doing way more damage vrs weak teams than others due to the way some game plans are done etc.


True.
 
Gambit26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griz
Originally posted by RayRay99

Originally posted by Spirer


With gutted/weak teams, certain positions get crazy stats. To be honest there should be a way of removing those games from the relevant stats and even then some important contributions in game don't give you stats.

If for example a CB is so good his WR is rarely open and therefore rarely gets a pass, then that CB will be low on tackles/PDs and he was probably the best CB that game...


Everyone plays the gutted teams, so it should be a wash. I agree it is difficult for positions like O-Line and CB, your stats there don't tell the whole story.


But it's not a wash. For example this season, one team in the west gutted halfway through the season. Some guys end up doing way more damage vrs weak teams than others due to the way some game plans are done etc.


Everyone is free to vote as they want. If you don't agree with mine or anyone's vote, then make your own.....its not like you get an MVP trophy or anything, its all in good fun. I think you are looking way too far into this lol.....

 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
This is totaly unrelated I guess, but was brought up, so replying. Gutted games inflate specific stats, not all, in 2mins I came up with the stuff below:

Playing gutted teams inflates:
- QBs pass
- WRs catches and yards
- HBs rush
- O-line in pancakes
- DEs in sacks
- DT same as DE

Players that "suffer" in gutted games:
1 - Safeties (not much to cover really)
2 - CBs same as above
3 - LBs, D-line stops a lot of stuff and prevents a lot also

It also makes for some high level guy left in a gutted team to be the lead tackler of the league since they will get the most defensive plays easy. Usually also top in missed tackles
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.