Warrior General Games

I developed 2 C's this season with 2 purposes. First to see the difference between creating on Day 45 and boosting 3 compared to Day -5. Second, to see the stat padding difference with the same build in the D League. Both C's retain their full boosts for this season and do not have CE. Winner will be boosted and receive CE, loser will either be retired or find his way as a backup.

C1:
Height: 74in. (6'2") Weight: 309lbs
Level Pancakes
11 139

Strength: 61
Blocking: 50
Speed: 8
Tackling: 12
Agility: 18
Throwing: 8
Jumping: 8
Catching: 8
Stamina: 27
Carrying: 8
Vision: 14
Kicking: 9
Confidence: 12
Punting: 8

C2
Height: 76in. (6'4") Weight: 312lbs
Level Pancakes
9 15
Strength: 58
Blocking: 50
Speed: 8
Tackling: 11.6
Agility: 17.6
Throwing: 9
Jumping: 8
Catching: 8
Stamina: 21.6
Carrying: 9
Vision: 11.6
Kicking: 8
Confidence: 11.6
Punting: 8

To take this one step further, CE split between Str/Blk, All Str, All Blk, or ??????

level : 11 9
strengt: 61 58
block : 50 50
stamina: 27 21
vision : 14 12
The other attributes that matter are essentially the same.

The first player has a clear advantage. No question. I cannot see any advantage that the second player has.

When I did the lvl 11 player, he received SP into stamina and was ostracized for it. What clear advantage do you see for the lvl 11? I am not trying to grill you, just trying to pull as much information as possible.

level : 11 9
strengt: 61 58
block : 50 50
stamina: 27 21
vision : 14 12
The other attributes that matter are essentially the same.

The first player has a clear advantage. No question. I cannot see any advantage that the second player has.

Originally posted by timthorn
When I did the lvl 11 player, he received SP into stamina and was ostracized for it. What clear advantage do you see for the lvl 11? I am not trying to grill you, just trying to pull as much information as possible.

The level 11 has higher strentgh, stamina, and vision. Didn't I just spell that out with the chart? If they both continue to put their points into the same places, then the player who has higher points now will have higher points later as well, so this player is better now and will be better later. Or doesn't it matter if some skills are higher. I took the information you provided and did a simple analysis that you should have performed. If an attribute is higher, it is better. If I am missing something, please let me know.

Originally posted by timthorn
was ostracized for it.
They kicked you out and shunned you because you spent points on stamina? Or did they attack you for it?

...just a some shunning. I decided to take out the ole thesaurus; however, the chosen word is out of context. Nice catch.

Ok, I see the difference now. By spending the SP on Stamina early, it allows me to train agi/vis instead of training agi/stam. Thank you for pointing this out for me.

Originally posted by FatLoad
level : 11 9
strengt: 61 58
block : 50 50
stamina: 27 21
vision : 14 12
The other attributes that matter are essentially the same.

The first player has a clear advantage. No question. I cannot see any advantage that the second player has.

Never listen to guys that cannot calculate!


LVL: .11 9 (at 11)
STR: 61 58....60
BLO: 50 50....52
STA: .27 21....21.4
VIS: ..14 12....12.4

... not feel free to spend 10 Skill Points on the second center too.

The lv. 9 is clearly the better guy. He is already ahead of the lv. 11 (if you take lv. 11 to compare), can train stamina and vision at better rates and levels faster.

Originally posted by RAPB
can train stamina and vision at better rates and levels faster.

Agree with everything in your post except that.
Having lower stats isn't beneficial. The fact that they train higher doesn't mean shit, because they're lower and if both players train the same attributes the player with higher ones will always remain higher.

As for the OP, there's a lot of misconception being thrown around in this thread.
But you have to clarify in the first place, do you mean better for their level or better overall? The one with the higher current stats is better overall, the one with more beneficial stats at an equal level is actually better as per level.
For stamina or any other stat, you should never spend skill points in a skill that's below 25. If you've done that with either build, you've wasted skill points.

Short answer: The level 9 is better because he's squandered less SP.