I agree completely that Gideon is great. I don't even think it's close comparing Elton to him. Elton is very good, almost undoubtedly the best pass rusher in the conference, but Gideon is a whole other league. And to touch your argument, you believe your DT is "very good" and our DT who had 15 more tackles (can't really include the Maracaibo game) and similar pass rushing numbers in relevant games isn't considered "good?" I don't disagree with you about NTs and DTs. But you can compare DTs to other DTs in the league and realize that there isn't a level 26 in our conference that even compares to him at DT. 24 tackles at NT is very good at this point and I am certain that your guy is built well. I really think we probably agree on almost all points tbh. Everything is relative and the only real way to compare is at the end of the season after week 15 on a position by position basis. Of course, now that the Maulers have collapsed anyone who plays them after now (including us who just played them) will have a little more bloated stats. Hell, Dingleberry had 21 tackles (10 TFLs), 9 sacks, 8 hurries and 2 FFs today. I'm sure that's more than a lot of DTs season stats.
joeami
offline
offline
Like Bukowski said, levels really don't count for anything any more. My level 23 guard, when he was looking for teams, I had teams with level 30 starters asking me to replace him. Why? Because he's stacked in speed and agility. When he boosts, he's gonna get a boost to his strength which will make him an unstoppable blocker.
But, that IS an impressive stat line, not too sure about the maulers, though. I haven't looked at them, nor did I hear about a collapse. But, yeah, we'll see on week 15 how the two compare. Although we are in different conferences. I guess the best thing for us is that we have a week 16 mathcup and we'll have to see there how they compare. I do believe we both agree that they are both good DTs, but I don't think we have a GREAT DT in this league as we have a GREAT DE in Gideon.
But, that IS an impressive stat line, not too sure about the maulers, though. I haven't looked at them, nor did I hear about a collapse. But, yeah, we'll see on week 15 how the two compare. Although we are in different conferences. I guess the best thing for us is that we have a week 16 mathcup and we'll have to see there how they compare. I do believe we both agree that they are both good DTs, but I don't think we have a GREAT DT in this league as we have a GREAT DE in Gideon.
GMathiasf
offline
offline
we might have a playoff slot on the line in the game and though I originally marked it on the chart as a can't win (I think i put it 90/10 you guys), maybe I'll call for the boost if it means we get a shot at DV in round 1 and we get to give you guys a game. 
As someone who did plenty of recruiting for 3 different teams this off-season, trust me I know the perils of finding good builds. I landed one of the best LOT builds I've ever seen for our starting LOT for the Ligers and then went in search of one for another team I'm on. What a nightmare. Everyone thinks that they're a pancake machine so finding a good LOT or RG and hell an ROT needs to be more agile and fast now as well, is a nightmare at times.

As someone who did plenty of recruiting for 3 different teams this off-season, trust me I know the perils of finding good builds. I landed one of the best LOT builds I've ever seen for our starting LOT for the Ligers and then went in search of one for another team I'm on. What a nightmare. Everyone thinks that they're a pancake machine so finding a good LOT or RG and hell an ROT needs to be more agile and fast now as well, is a nightmare at times.
Last edited Oct 10, 2008 12:15:31
joeami
offline
offline
The craziest thing about my guard was that I had a pro and AAA teams coming after me. The pro team was a gut job, but the AAA team was 8-1 and had an easy schedule.
It's alright, you don't have to waste the boost on us. We're not THAT good. Plus, do you really want DV in round 1? Just work on winnning your games ahead of us and you should be good. The Sentinels are gonna lose at least 2 games, no doubt.
It's alright, you don't have to waste the boost on us. We're not THAT good. Plus, do you really want DV in round 1? Just work on winnning your games ahead of us and you should be good. The Sentinels are gonna lose at least 2 games, no doubt.
tigerbait22
offline
offline
Originally posted by GMathiasf
we might have a playoff slot on the line in the game and though I originally marked it on the chart as a can't win (I think i put it 90/10 you guys), maybe I'll call for the boost if it means we get a shot at DV in round 1 and we get to give you guys a game.
As someone who did plenty of recruiting for 3 different teams this off-season, trust me I know the perils of finding good builds. I landed one of the best LOT builds I've ever seen for our starting LOT for the Ligers and then went in search of one for another team I'm on. What a nightmare. Everyone thinks that they're a pancake machine so finding a good LOT or RG and hell an ROT needs to be more agile and fast now as well, is a nightmare at times.
Agree for once... Pancakes mean Didly anymore.. wish we had more stats to track on O-lineman...
I think agility and speed are becoming way more important, but can tell you that DV's line is one of the best and we are far from capped in those attributes
We have the right blend between the two... like a perfect Recipe so to speak
As for Gideon... Elton is my boy.. and he will understand this if he reads it..
I believe Elton is the second best DE in this league and is an absolute stud...
We are lucky to have him on DV.. GREAT guy as well... BUT Gideon is truly on a different level than 95% of ALL DE's in the GAME including the Pro's... He has that "secret recipe" mastered for his guy..
Thing that really separates Gideon is that he is not just a sack machine... He is a tackling machine as well. He is as COMPLETE as they come. He dominates games.
we might have a playoff slot on the line in the game and though I originally marked it on the chart as a can't win (I think i put it 90/10 you guys), maybe I'll call for the boost if it means we get a shot at DV in round 1 and we get to give you guys a game.

As someone who did plenty of recruiting for 3 different teams this off-season, trust me I know the perils of finding good builds. I landed one of the best LOT builds I've ever seen for our starting LOT for the Ligers and then went in search of one for another team I'm on. What a nightmare. Everyone thinks that they're a pancake machine so finding a good LOT or RG and hell an ROT needs to be more agile and fast now as well, is a nightmare at times.
Agree for once... Pancakes mean Didly anymore.. wish we had more stats to track on O-lineman...
I think agility and speed are becoming way more important, but can tell you that DV's line is one of the best and we are far from capped in those attributes
We have the right blend between the two... like a perfect Recipe so to speak

As for Gideon... Elton is my boy.. and he will understand this if he reads it..
I believe Elton is the second best DE in this league and is an absolute stud...
We are lucky to have him on DV.. GREAT guy as well... BUT Gideon is truly on a different level than 95% of ALL DE's in the GAME including the Pro's... He has that "secret recipe" mastered for his guy..
Thing that really separates Gideon is that he is not just a sack machine... He is a tackling machine as well. He is as COMPLETE as they come. He dominates games.
PML97
offline
offline
Yup. He's definitely what makes us tick. We have quite a few guys on our D that get little credit because of him but thats the true greatness of one player. When one is so good that he stands above everyone in his group with his accomplishments is pretty amazing.
Funny thing is Gideon "wouldn't" bring him in during our first season because he was committed to trying to help his old team through one more year. Considering we lost that first finals game in the last 2 minutes I doubt he'd have made much impact on the game
Funny thing is Gideon "wouldn't" bring him in during our first season because he was committed to trying to help his old team through one more year. Considering we lost that first finals game in the last 2 minutes I doubt he'd have made much impact on the game

joeami
offline
offline
Originally posted by PML97
Considering we lost that first finals game in the last 2 minutes I doubt he'd have made much impact on the game
He would have had absolutely none at all.
Considering we lost that first finals game in the last 2 minutes I doubt he'd have made much impact on the game

He would have had absolutely none at all.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























