User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Thorn
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Thorn

Originally posted by LordEvil


Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.


The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn


We understand Thorn but we are wondering why the things found aren't released to a GLB population and how do you know EVERY tester is telling bort every exploit they find? It's human nature to be selfish and look out for yourself so how do we know that one of them did not find an exploit and not report it then abused it?


That is a very valid point. There is no way we can ever know if a tester is holding back on us. All I can say is that the people who are testers generally enjoy playing this game. They don't have to win the game to have fun, and they want to see the game increase and get better. I wouldn't say it is unthinkable that maybe they find a trick and be quiet, but I don't think it is very likely.
However if we ever do find that a tester found a bug/exploit and didn't report it only to take advantage of it we will be very, *very* strict with them. I fully understand your worry that a team in your league will have insider information when you play them next season, but keep in mind that the testers are playing on a test server. So things don't translate one to one from test to live server.
When Bort made the decision to open up a test server, he selected the people for it carefully, and I trust his decision. If his trust is proved to be misplaced we will deal with the people.
-Thorn
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz


NO THEIR HAVING BETTER PLAYERS AND ARE MONEY IS BEING WASTED THIS GAME COULD BE A SCAM


plzdie
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


You have 4 lvl 4 players. Why wouldnt you be fine with it?
 
FireAce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Thorn


Originally posted by Boltz




THORN WHERE IS BORT OR DD?


Driving to the bank?


fyp


LOL TO CASH OUT ALL THE MONEY....TBH THIS COULD BE FRAUD IN RL, IF BORT DOESNT SAY ANYTHING


Dude seriously STFU. You are are not helping with your annoying cap typing ignorance
 
Link
 
I do enjoy that the only people backing Bort up on this decision are practically all mods and admins who probably have access to it.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4

You pay money to boost your player, not make him 2x as good as non boosters.


Except when the boosters hit level 60, and the non booster made the same season hits level 30? What?
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
thorn y doesnt DD sell his teams
 
Skeptikal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by williamcohms
50% of this game is knowing how to build your players. All the tactics, gameplanning, and AI in the world don't matter if the team you're playing has better built players based on which builds are the most dominant. To make matters worse, builds that are dominant one season will suck the next based on changes made to the game.

You're giving a select few people access to a test server that allows them to determine exactly how to best build their players. Which SA and VA work best. Of course there's outrage. In those other games someone mentioned nobody is playing someone else head to head. Where some users are getting special access to a test server for their money and I'm not, so my players and teams are at a disadvantage. Are the Mods willing to come forward and take a stand that not one of their testers changed his build based on what he saw? That not one of them suggested tweaks to the builds of a player on their team? That no equipment was moved around? And that's not even taking into account the advantage in testing out AI changes.


 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by bootyslayer4

Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


You have 4 lvl 4 players. Why wouldnt you be fine with it?


Clearly he's a multi.
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
Edit: Answered whilst typing.

I am blown away at how this is affecting people. I believe I even saw mention of this a few seasons ago. I think a little icon for beta tester, like the alpha one would fix some of the complaints.

Last edited Feb 13, 2009 17:55:49
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Yes, I understand. The point I was making is that it might also be possible that the testers are not the kind of people to do this. It is always possible that they are as well though. The problem I see with this thread is that the majority of people are making the negative assumptions associated with the usual style of internet witch hunt, and not many are thinking rationally about it.


Darkus, people are being plenty rational about it. They just expect the worst which is not the best way of thinking but in GLB, sadly, the worst thing is what usually ends up happening.


It is a shame that it has become so cynical around here though. I think I will talk about this thread on the radio show starting in 5 minutes. Click on the GLB radio link above or call in to discuss it live on the air. (646) 716-7443
 
bootyslayer4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by bootyslayer4

Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


Don't you get it? The point is that this information isn't coming to the public. The changes that affect your players and teams were known beforehand by god knows how many players/teams in your league.


Who cares? Its not that big of an advantage. I really wouldn't think that many people test it, let alone make builds to cheat it. They use those builds on...the TEST SERVER maybe? Jeesus. Its like you people have never been on a test server for an mmorpg before. Its nothing special.
 
Thorn
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
thorn y doesnt DD sell his teams


Because of DD's secret plan to turn them all into prison teams. But it is a secret, so don't tell anyone.
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
I think Bort is BERNIE MADOFF.. what ponzi scheme this has become!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Thorn


Originally posted by LordEvil



Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.


The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn


We understand Thorn but we are wondering why the things found aren't released to a GLB population and how do you know EVERY tester is telling bort every exploit they find? It's human nature to be selfish and look out for yourself so how do we know that one of them did not find an exploit and not report it then abused it?


That is a very valid point. There is no way we can ever know if a tester is holding back on us. All I can say is that the people who are testers generally enjoy playing this game. They don't have to win the game to have fun, and they want to see the game increase and get better. I wouldn't say it is unthinkable that maybe they find a trick and be quiet, but I don't think it is very likely.
However if we ever do find that a tester found a bug/exploit and didn't report it only to take advantage of it we will be very, *very* strict with them. I fully understand your worry that a team in your league will have insider information when you play them next season, but keep in mind that the testers are playing on a test server. So things don't translate one to one from test to live server.
When Bort made the decision to open up a test server, he selected the people for it carefully, and I trust his decision. If his trust is proved to be misplaced we will deal with the people.
-Thorn


Well hopefully you do if something happens because it could be a HUGE problem if a tester starts giving away secret exploits.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.