Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
We understand Thorn but we are wondering why the things found aren't released to a GLB population and how do you know EVERY tester is telling bort every exploit they find? It's human nature to be selfish and look out for yourself so how do we know that one of them did not find an exploit and not report it then abused it?
That is a very valid point. There is no way we can ever know if a tester is holding back on us. All I can say is that the people who are testers generally enjoy playing this game. They don't have to win the game to have fun, and they want to see the game increase and get better. I wouldn't say it is unthinkable that maybe they find a trick and be quiet, but I don't think it is very likely.
However if we ever do find that a tester found a bug/exploit and didn't report it only to take advantage of it we will be very, *very* strict with them. I fully understand your worry that a team in your league will have insider information when you play them next season, but keep in mind that the testers are playing on a test server. So things don't translate one to one from test to live server.
When Bort made the decision to open up a test server, he selected the people for it carefully, and I trust his decision. If his trust is proved to be misplaced we will deal with the people.
-Thorn
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
We understand Thorn but we are wondering why the things found aren't released to a GLB population and how do you know EVERY tester is telling bort every exploit they find? It's human nature to be selfish and look out for yourself so how do we know that one of them did not find an exploit and not report it then abused it?
That is a very valid point. There is no way we can ever know if a tester is holding back on us. All I can say is that the people who are testers generally enjoy playing this game. They don't have to win the game to have fun, and they want to see the game increase and get better. I wouldn't say it is unthinkable that maybe they find a trick and be quiet, but I don't think it is very likely.
However if we ever do find that a tester found a bug/exploit and didn't report it only to take advantage of it we will be very, *very* strict with them. I fully understand your worry that a team in your league will have insider information when you play them next season, but keep in mind that the testers are playing on a test server. So things don't translate one to one from test to live server.
When Bort made the decision to open up a test server, he selected the people for it carefully, and I trust his decision. If his trust is proved to be misplaced we will deal with the people.
-Thorn






























