User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by JackLambert

I've heard the Maurice Jones-Drew is pretty hard to tackle also, he's 5'7'' I think.


32 Maurice Jones-Drew, RB
Height/Weight: 5-7/208
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
this is a powerback at work against a damn good SS

http://www.rootzoo.com/videos/view/NFL-Football/Mike-Sellers-trucks-B-Dawk/91
 
freekonastick
offline
Link
 
its all a matter of player build trends, both irl and in GLB...

for example, the NFL for the past few years (really since the greatest show on turf rams teams) has been a pass happy league built around speed. because of this teams started going out of their way to get speedy defensive players too, pass rushers, cover corners, etc.

so now because of this the running offenses are becoming more prolific. look at the playoffs this year: giants, panthers, steelers, titans....those are the 4 teams that got a first round bye and all of them are run first teams. not to mention atlanta, miami, san diego, baltimore.....notice a trend here?

now equate this to GLB...every player wants to be as fast as possible. LBs for example, are all boss bailey and no zach thomas. because of this these power backs are running right over and through them. my LB is a much more balanced player, which most people on this board are going to make fun of me for having because it isnt "the best build" but you know what, i havent seen an increase to my missed tackles at all. and yes i know im not playing level 40+ players but im playing players that are relative to my level.

like someone said earlier, if someone built a strong possession receiver they would probably do quite well because all corner backs are deangelo hall and there are no antoine winfields to keep them in check. the elusive backs are sucking right now because all defensive players are super fast, but the power backs are dominating....

did anyone ever think maybe it isnt game mechanics but its player builds?
Last edited Jan 9, 2009 10:44:04
 
StatPadder3
offline
Link
 
well, my LB has 81 strength
 
Coriantumr
offline
Link
 
If I am correct its a ratio which applies to the builds and the different VA's and such. A RB with about 5-8 broken tackles on 20 carries is not overabundant. I think that is about right even for NFL standards. A good power back even with a decent LB or DLine can break one tackle but then is slowed down to allow the others to actually tackle him. A good way to offset this is drop the speed when there is a broken tackle by 50% for every broken tackle. This in turn can be mitigated by a VA which allows 3-5% of speed regained per tackle. Spreading the field of VA's that a power back can have also limits the use of the bruiser VA and behind the line VA unless further into a career. So this will slow down the broken tackles. I agree with a previous poster its not broken its the speed builds. My power back was stopped on several occasions and only allowed 3-5 broken tackles in a game because of superior builds. Game not broken people chose to build players a certain way to stop one thing and until they level up more and put points into other areas it should stay that way.
 
Cobrakai44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
I still think power tackling should be more effective against power rushers...

I mean, power rushers charge into people to break tackles. Power tackling misses more often because they get side-stepped. Missing tackles against powerbacks because of being on power tackling makes no sense...


I would disagree, if you're charging at a powerback and try to blow him up with a high tackle and force a fumble, that's when he's going to plow right through you. Meeting a powerback up high is not how you tackle one. You wrap his legs up and hope someone else comes along and helps take him down.
 
ellix
offline
Link
 
Str 55ish, tackling 70.

people keep bringing up speed should be important in tackling or that 40ish or 50ish str/tackling should be enough, you guys are just coverage DBs who are trying to adjust their build to compensate and be good at all facets of the game with as little effort as possible. What corner out there can tackle any players in the NFL and still be shutdown coverage? No one. Pick what you want to do, you say but if we give up on speed then we'll get burned by WRs. Yeah, you will, so either choose to be a coverage DB or to be a run-stopping DB. The best someone 40 and below at either strength or tackling should do is slow the player down for a step or two. 50+ in both to start seeing consistent stops, and a bit more tackling than that to be very reliable. Maybe with changes like that, you'd start to see actual...DIVERSITY in player builds. imo.
 
ep3388
offline
Link
 
A powerback with 100+ strength and 10 Power Thru and 10-15 Bruiser also needs a good bit of speed/agility. Think of all the so called "powerbacks" in the NFL, how many of them run slow? If you got 50 speed/agility RB in GLB with all that great strength, you are arent running fast enough/with enough steam where a defender with much lower strength and tackling cant bring him down or slow him down considerably.

Speed and agility for a defender should come into play where a 50 strength/50 tackling may not make the tackle 90% of the time but he has plenty of speed/agility to slow down the powerback to where the powerback will be taken down easily by the next guy granted the next defender has adequate tackling/strength where he can tackle a near stand still object.

--Real tough to have a balanced defender with 60-70 strength and tackling but also have enough speed to operate. Teams in rl in all levels football stress speed/agility and that is where they can slow down a powerback pretty easily making the next defender come in and clean up. It shouldnt be where a powerback stacks 120+ strength and loads up on everything imaginable (SA, VA, etc) and be impossible to tackle. A 60 strength/tackling back 7 defense with good speed/agility/confidence/vision should be plenty enough to slow down and gang tackle the RB. 70 strength and tackling with good speed/agility/vision/confidence should render a powerback obsolete and that offense with said powerback better have other weapons (preferably weapons with speed) to counter the 60-70 strength/tackling back 7.

--Speed and agility should play more of a part on Offense in breaking tackles (accelerate and pick up enough steam) and speed and agility should play more of part on Defense in at least slowing down powerbacks to where they have to stop and that is where the gang tackling/clean up tackling comes into play.

Shouldnt a 300 pound lineman or hulking FB be the teams leading rusher b/c they really got the most strength of everyone? No, b/c they dont have much speed to pick up steam/accelerate to the line and break tackles making them a near stand still object where you or I could help bring him down.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.