This is what I get off of work to see? Awesome... Cave in because of a few....
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
jdbolick
offline
offline
One huge problem for any World League is that it doesn't seem realistically achievable for any 13 capped expansion team regardless of how well they do. Theoretically isn't 8 seasons the fastest a 13 cap could reach a World League even if they win gold every single season? And assuming that no one does that, how many could even make it in 9 or 10? It seems to me like the World League will end up being a fairly static group of certain prominent franchises that just replenish rosters every couple of seasons, since there's very little chance of a team starting out at the bottom and working their way to the top in the current system.
CobraKaji
offline
offline
Originally posted by DL24
No, but it's difficult to decide on a fair promotion system for future seasons after the inception of the league. Do regions get 2 teams automatically in? Does each region only have a fixed number(4) of teams in the WPL at any time? It's complicated.
How hard is it?
- Promote the 2 top teams in each Pro League. Unless you want 2 conferences then promote the 4 teams that played for the conference championship.
- 4 teams get promoted from each tier below.
- After the first WPL season, demote half and replace with the top of the Pro Leagues.
- Demoted teams get assigned randomly to the Pro Leagues.
This will allow the teams that do not get in a better shot at getting there. This does suck for the teams like the Wolfpack and OFG's, but it won't take them but maybe a season to get to the WPL. It's more fair for the greater majority, but it does suck a little for teams like OFG and Wolfpack that got beat.
No, but it's difficult to decide on a fair promotion system for future seasons after the inception of the league. Do regions get 2 teams automatically in? Does each region only have a fixed number(4) of teams in the WPL at any time? It's complicated.
How hard is it?
- Promote the 2 top teams in each Pro League. Unless you want 2 conferences then promote the 4 teams that played for the conference championship.
- 4 teams get promoted from each tier below.
- After the first WPL season, demote half and replace with the top of the Pro Leagues.
- Demoted teams get assigned randomly to the Pro Leagues.
This will allow the teams that do not get in a better shot at getting there. This does suck for the teams like the Wolfpack and OFG's, but it won't take them but maybe a season to get to the WPL. It's more fair for the greater majority, but it does suck a little for teams like OFG and Wolfpack that got beat.
SteelersFanatic
offline
offline
Originally posted by CobraKaji
Originally posted by DL24
No, but it's difficult to decide on a fair promotion system for future seasons after the inception of the league. Do regions get 2 teams automatically in? Does each region only have a fixed number(4) of teams in the WPL at any time? It's complicated.
How hard is it?
- Promote the 2 top teams in each Pro League. Unless you want 2 conferences then promote the 4 teams that played for the conference championship.
- 4 teams get promoted from each tier below.
- After the first WPL season, demote half and replace with the top of the Pro Leagues.
- Demoted teams get assigned randomly to the Pro Leagues.
This will allow the teams that do not get in a better shot at getting there. This does suck for the teams like the Wolfpack and OFG's, but it won't take them but maybe a season to get to the WPL. It's more fair for the greater majority, but it does suck a little for teams like OFG and Wolfpack that got beat.
I agree.
Just make it so the top teams that are gonna get promoted have the option of staying in their own league and giving their spot to the next team in line based off your (bort's) tie-breaker system. So teams that don't want to leave their region don't have to.
Originally posted by DL24
No, but it's difficult to decide on a fair promotion system for future seasons after the inception of the league. Do regions get 2 teams automatically in? Does each region only have a fixed number(4) of teams in the WPL at any time? It's complicated.
How hard is it?
- Promote the 2 top teams in each Pro League. Unless you want 2 conferences then promote the 4 teams that played for the conference championship.
- 4 teams get promoted from each tier below.
- After the first WPL season, demote half and replace with the top of the Pro Leagues.
- Demoted teams get assigned randomly to the Pro Leagues.
This will allow the teams that do not get in a better shot at getting there. This does suck for the teams like the Wolfpack and OFG's, but it won't take them but maybe a season to get to the WPL. It's more fair for the greater majority, but it does suck a little for teams like OFG and Wolfpack that got beat.
I agree.
Just make it so the top teams that are gonna get promoted have the option of staying in their own league and giving their spot to the next team in line based off your (bort's) tie-breaker system. So teams that don't want to leave their region don't have to.
Edited by SteelersFanatic on Jul 28, 2009 00:31:54
Talcion
offline
offline
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
bhall43
offline
offline
My proposal to this is if there is no World League and this World Tournament takes its place. Can we open up the season an extra amount of days? So it would be 4 days between league games and 4 days between tournament games. No in game XP for the tourney games obviously...so it would just be more training time during the season for players. Not a huge deal imo...could then make the tournament much like the PWT was in the form of an opening group round. 3 games. With this format, the tournament would take 8 days. Would add about 16 days to the regular season and nobody would have to worry about double gameplanning during the playoffs for their league.
Obviously id rather see the World League itself. But would like to see something far more organized as a tourney if that is the road that this is going to go.
Obviously id rather see the World League itself. But would like to see something far more organized as a tourney if that is the road that this is going to go.
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Talcion
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
I'm no even affiliated with any teams moving up to WPL (minus having forum access to PDD - which MAY move up do to BLPP gutting at the end of the season)
And personally I don't see why people are so uptight about regions... I'm of the mind of Havoc - if you can't hack it in WPL you should be able to drop down INTO ANY Pro League and dominate it... I mean come on, you just came from WPL it's time to prove you belonged there.
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
I'm no even affiliated with any teams moving up to WPL (minus having forum access to PDD - which MAY move up do to BLPP gutting at the end of the season)
And personally I don't see why people are so uptight about regions... I'm of the mind of Havoc - if you can't hack it in WPL you should be able to drop down INTO ANY Pro League and dominate it... I mean come on, you just came from WPL it's time to prove you belonged there.
bhall43
offline
offline
screw it...just change the region names to random things...you take away USA from the logo and nobody cares anymore. especially when teams start dropping to random regions and all leagues start becoming equal.
datongw
offline
offline
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
It is really this simple. But GLB seems to make simple things complicated at times.
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
It is really this simple. But GLB seems to make simple things complicated at times.
datongw
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Not really, it will really only affect a few teams outside of those 16 teams that will be relegated at the end of the season. 99% of the other teams will not find themselves in that situation. The odds of an AAA team making it to WPL in 2 seasons is (busting out my calculator)... 0.4%, probably a bit higher since more than 1 team from each conference is promoted each season due to gutting.
But the point is as long as the AAA/AA/Pro conference champions get promoted as usual, this doesn't effect any other owners other than the 16 WPL teams that are getting relegated. If teams didn't win the conference, they are just trying to get promoted through the back door, I think it should be ok if a few of those back doors got closed.
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Not really, it will really only affect a few teams outside of those 16 teams that will be relegated at the end of the season. 99% of the other teams will not find themselves in that situation. The odds of an AAA team making it to WPL in 2 seasons is (busting out my calculator)... 0.4%, probably a bit higher since more than 1 team from each conference is promoted each season due to gutting.
But the point is as long as the AAA/AA/Pro conference champions get promoted as usual, this doesn't effect any other owners other than the 16 WPL teams that are getting relegated. If teams didn't win the conference, they are just trying to get promoted through the back door, I think it should be ok if a few of those back doors got closed.
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Not really, it will really only affect a few teams outside of those 16 teams that will be relegated at the end of the season. 99% of the other teams will not find themselves in that situation. The odds of an AAA team making it to WPL in 2 seasons is (busting out my calculator)... 0.4%, probably a bit higher since more than 1 team from each conference is promoted each season due to gutting.
But the point is as long as the AAA/AA/Pro conference champions get promoted as usual, this doesn't effect any other owners other than the 16 WPL teams that are getting relegated. If teams didn't win the conference, they are just trying to get promoted through the back door, I think it should be ok if a few of those back doors got closed.
it still effects everyone...unless you feel this will only be a couple seasons and then done.
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Not really, it will really only affect a few teams outside of those 16 teams that will be relegated at the end of the season. 99% of the other teams will not find themselves in that situation. The odds of an AAA team making it to WPL in 2 seasons is (busting out my calculator)... 0.4%, probably a bit higher since more than 1 team from each conference is promoted each season due to gutting.
But the point is as long as the AAA/AA/Pro conference champions get promoted as usual, this doesn't effect any other owners other than the 16 WPL teams that are getting relegated. If teams didn't win the conference, they are just trying to get promoted through the back door, I think it should be ok if a few of those back doors got closed.
it still effects everyone...unless you feel this will only be a couple seasons and then done.
datongw
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Not really, it will really only affect a few teams outside of those 16 teams that will be relegated at the end of the season. 99% of the other teams will not find themselves in that situation. The odds of an AAA team making it to WPL in 2 seasons is (busting out my calculator)... 0.4%, probably a bit higher since more than 1 team from each conference is promoted each season due to gutting.
But the point is as long as the AAA/AA/Pro conference champions get promoted as usual, this doesn't effect any other owners other than the 16 WPL teams that are getting relegated. If teams didn't win the conference, they are just trying to get promoted through the back door, I think it should be ok if a few of those back doors got closed.
it still effects everyone...unless you feel this will only be a couple seasons and then done.
minimal impact to 99% of the teams that won't even feel it. ripple effect is way too small. I just can't imagine that AA team which finished 6th in the conference bitching since they didn't get promoted due to an additional team dropping into their Pro league from WPL.
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Talcion
Personally I think it should come down to the 32 owners of the WPL leagues... it should be whatever they say... if they don't give a shit about what league they drop down into, then so be it.
so those 32 owners represent the future teams of the WPL? Pretty lame idea...this should be a poll for everyone tbh...this effects the future of everyone...not just the current owners of the WPL teams.
Not really, it will really only affect a few teams outside of those 16 teams that will be relegated at the end of the season. 99% of the other teams will not find themselves in that situation. The odds of an AAA team making it to WPL in 2 seasons is (busting out my calculator)... 0.4%, probably a bit higher since more than 1 team from each conference is promoted each season due to gutting.
But the point is as long as the AAA/AA/Pro conference champions get promoted as usual, this doesn't effect any other owners other than the 16 WPL teams that are getting relegated. If teams didn't win the conference, they are just trying to get promoted through the back door, I think it should be ok if a few of those back doors got closed.
it still effects everyone...unless you feel this will only be a couple seasons and then done.
minimal impact to 99% of the teams that won't even feel it. ripple effect is way too small. I just can't imagine that AA team which finished 6th in the conference bitching since they didn't get promoted due to an additional team dropping into their Pro league from WPL.
Talcion
offline
offline
Originally posted by bhall43
screw it...just change the region names to random things...you take away USA from the logo and nobody cares anymore. especially when teams start dropping to random regions and all leagues start becoming equal.
Isn't that what we are going for in the first place
It was proved this season that WSI couldn't really compete in USA PL, but they gave it their best shot... but look at it this way...
Lets say that these teams fail to make the cut of the playoffs
4x OPL
3x SEAPL
2x APL
2x WEPL
2x EEPL
2x SAPL
1x CPL
Those teams get randomly dropped into the 8 leagues with the Conference Champions from each league moving up...
Then the WPL would look like this
USAPL x6
CPL x 5
EEPL x4
WEPL x4
SAPL x4
APL x4
SEAPL x3
OPL x2
And so on and so forth... teams that have been to the big dance (WPL - much like Premier League in English Soccer) should have a much easier time recruiting based on the fact that they were in WPL, and you damn well know once you get a taste of being at the top you always want to go back... Shouldn't matter what region you get dropped into.
Either way, I'm pretty sure teams would like the chance to play some of their scrimmage rivals without paying 25 cents...
Meh, either way I'm an outsider... Just someone who possibly has an idea.
screw it...just change the region names to random things...you take away USA from the logo and nobody cares anymore. especially when teams start dropping to random regions and all leagues start becoming equal.
Isn't that what we are going for in the first place
It was proved this season that WSI couldn't really compete in USA PL, but they gave it their best shot... but look at it this way...
Lets say that these teams fail to make the cut of the playoffs
4x OPL
3x SEAPL
2x APL
2x WEPL
2x EEPL
2x SAPL
1x CPL
Those teams get randomly dropped into the 8 leagues with the Conference Champions from each league moving up...
Then the WPL would look like this
USAPL x6
CPL x 5
EEPL x4
WEPL x4
SAPL x4
APL x4
SEAPL x3
OPL x2
And so on and so forth... teams that have been to the big dance (WPL - much like Premier League in English Soccer) should have a much easier time recruiting based on the fact that they were in WPL, and you damn well know once you get a taste of being at the top you always want to go back... Shouldn't matter what region you get dropped into.
Either way, I'm pretty sure teams would like the chance to play some of their scrimmage rivals without paying 25 cents...
Meh, either way I'm an outsider... Just someone who possibly has an idea.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























