User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by djgomez33

Originally posted by awesome


My problem with this whole situation is as follows:

1. Some users (presumably early users) are given access to a test server where they can gain knowledge of the game without having to spend the money that the rest of us do. This knowledge is likely gained at a much faster rate as well because while it takes seasons to develop a player on the main game, it seems that on the test server they can jump to higher equivalent levels immediately to do the testing. Anyone who has access to this test server now has much greater insight into the inner workings of the game and can now apply this knowledge to the main game against other paying users.

2. The test server is a secret. Until today, many people likely had no idea that there was a group of users who were given this advantage. As such, many users were likely paying money to play a game that they believed contained a level playing field for all customers. This has been clearly shown to not be the case. Since it is not unreasonable for GLB to know that thousands of users had this belief, yet they purposefully kept the testing server information a secret, it is reasonable to conclude that GLB fraudulently has been taking money from its userbase.

3. This conclusion of fraud is only perpetuated by the actions of the GLB staff today. Once someone raised this issue in the main forum and that thread, not surprisingly, gained popularity, it was moved without reason or message to a private forum where the general populace of GLB could not access it. To make matters worse, every single thread that had anything remotely to do with the test server was deleted within seconds. The staff purposefully was trying to quash any discussion of what many people believe to be an issue of utmost importance.

Because of what has gone down today, there are some steps that GLB should take to restore some semblance of consumer confidence in its service.

Remedies:

1. Immediate disclosure of everything that has to do with the test server. This includes, but is not limited to: users who have access, what they have access to, how long they have had access, and all testing data that they had access to.

2. Public censure of the staff members that were responsible for the unreasoned attempts to quash any and all discussion of this topic.

3. If it is found that these testers did, indeed, gain an advantage, GLB should be prepared to refund any money spent by any user who feels that they have been misled by GLBs representations that the game was setup as a "level playing field."


+1


+1 for naievete


+1 for proper use of inflected form of naive
 
bootyslayer4
offline
Link
 
Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Yes, I understand. The point I was making is that it might also be possible that the testers are not the kind of people to do this. It is always possible that they are as well though. The problem I see with this thread is that the majority of people are making the negative assumptions associated with the usual style of internet witch hunt, and not many are thinking rationally about it.


Darkus, people are being plenty rational about it. They just expect the worst which is not the best way of thinking but in GLB, sadly, the worst thing is what usually ends up happening.


 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Thorn

Originally posted by Boltz



THORN WHERE IS BORT OR DD?


Driving to the bank?


fyp


LOL TO CASH OUT ALL THE MONEY....TBH THIS COULD BE FRAUD IN RL, IF BORT DOESNT SAY ANYTHING
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Drago


Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by Drago

You haven't been around the internet very much, huh?


Long enough to have used a 14.4k modem. Just because a person has access to the internet it doesn't automatically make them an evil mind with the desire to rule the dot world.


Well listen hear youngin' - I had a 2400 baud modem at one point. You don't know how tough it was back then. YOU DON'T EVER WANT TO KNOW.

With that said, the Anonymous nature of the internet does lead a large group of individuals to perform selfish actions. Coupled with the fact this is a competitive game by nature, I think it's safe to say the greater of the "community" would take this information and do their best to put it to good use for selfish reasons.


Are you and Coach Jim going to sit out on your lawn, yell at kids who walk past to stay off your lawn and talk about the old days?


Dang, I remember thinking a 2400 baud modem was such an incredibly fast way to access my BBSes (waaaaay better than 300 btw). Are saying I'm old jrry?


I'm not saying you're young.

 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by djgomez33

Originally posted by awesome


My problem with this whole situation is as follows:

1. Some users (presumably early users) are given access to a test server where they can gain knowledge of the game without having to spend the money that the rest of us do. This knowledge is likely gained at a much faster rate as well because while it takes seasons to develop a player on the main game, it seems that on the test server they can jump to higher equivalent levels immediately to do the testing. Anyone who has access to this test server now has much greater insight into the inner workings of the game and can now apply this knowledge to the main game against other paying users.

2. The test server is a secret. Until today, many people likely had no idea that there was a group of users who were given this advantage. As such, many users were likely paying money to play a game that they believed contained a level playing field for all customers. This has been clearly shown to not be the case. Since it is not unreasonable for GLB to know that thousands of users had this belief, yet they purposefully kept the testing server information a secret, it is reasonable to conclude that GLB fraudulently has been taking money from its userbase.

3. This conclusion of fraud is only perpetuated by the actions of the GLB staff today. Once someone raised this issue in the main forum and that thread, not surprisingly, gained popularity, it was moved without reason or message to a private forum where the general populace of GLB could not access it. To make matters worse, every single thread that had anything remotely to do with the test server was deleted within seconds. The staff purposefully was trying to quash any discussion of what many people believe to be an issue of utmost importance.

Because of what has gone down today, there are some steps that GLB should take to restore some semblance of consumer confidence in its service.

Remedies:

1. Immediate disclosure of everything that has to do with the test server. This includes, but is not limited to: users who have access, what they have access to, how long they have had access, and all testing data that they had access to.

2. Public censure of the staff members that were responsible for the unreasoned attempts to quash any and all discussion of this topic.

3. If it is found that these testers did, indeed, gain an advantage, GLB should be prepared to refund any money spent by any user who feels that they have been misled by GLBs representations that the game was setup as a "level playing field."


+1




Oh hell yes.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Thorn


Originally posted by Boltz




THORN WHERE IS BORT OR DD?


Driving to the bank?


fyp


LOL TO CASH OUT ALL THE MONEY....TBH THIS COULD BE FRAUD IN RL, IF BORT DOESNT SAY ANYTHING


No it couldn't.
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


NO THEIR HAVING BETTER PLAYERS AND ARE MONEY IS BEING WASTED THIS GAME COULD BE A SCAM
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Thorn, far and away the thing that most has people upset here is the secrecy and lack of "read-only" access to the knowledge available on the test servers -- builds being tested, game replays, test forum discussions, etc. Can you tell us why this secrecy is necessary?


Because an exploit may be identified, but a fix takes a week to fix. It's instantly visible (not that exploits don't spread like wildfire anyway) and everyone has fun beating on each other with the screen pass or a nano-blitz rendering 3 games in the schedule null.

We've had it before without testing, it's feasible (especially with the defensive play creator) that it'll happen again.

Personally I'd just go for an announcement system - otherwise, if I was a tester, I'd move my discussions onto a private forum away from GLB.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Solutions?
1) List or identify everyone with access
2) Give everyone access
3) Forbid anyone with access from also playing GLB
4) Allow everyone to "re-roll" and test builds
5) 100% Flex return for retiring anyone created before this point
6) Deny and downplay this whole thing and pray it goes away
7) ?



7) Just take the money and the run ?
 
williamcohms
offline
Link
 
50% of this game is knowing how to build your players. All the tactics, gameplanning, and AI in the world don't matter if the team you're playing has better built players based on which builds are the most dominant. To make matters worse, builds that are dominant one season will suck the next based on changes made to the game.

You're giving a select few people access to a test server that allows them to determine exactly how to best build their players. Which SA and VA work best. Of course there's outrage. In those other games someone mentioned nobody is playing someone else head to head. Where some users are getting special access to a test server for their money and I'm not, so my players and teams are at a disadvantage. Are the Mods willing to come forward and take a stand that not one of their testers changed his build based on what he saw? That not one of them suggested tweaks to the builds of a player on their team? That no equipment was moved around? And that's not even taking into account the advantage in testing out AI changes.
 
Osmlol
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Just Osmo
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by JHight


I've been on test servers before for two different mainstream MMORPGs and I hate to break it to you guys, but they aren't all that they are cracked up to be. You may think that you can get an advantage by testing builds, but remember, the builds are only for current or near current coding, far away from what will be effective in the 4+ months it takes to actually create the build you want.

As for listing names and the like, no, it shouldn't happen. I had my guild/kin/group outed as being on a test server and everyone thought our accomplishments were tainted. What they didn't know was that we often were testing redundant things just to make sure no bugs occurred, not even getting a set strategy down.

You guys just need to calm down. This is a NECCESSARY part of MMOs. It happens in EVERY GAME. They are trying to get rid of the bugs in coding before it comes to live, not trying to get a leg up on anyone. Yes, there are those that attempt that, but for the most part, they fail because the coding is so different.


This.


Test Servers on MMORPG's are always public and welcome everyone. Some games allowed you to get things you are not allowed to on regular live servers.

IE:

Ultima Online, Test Center. - Had skill gates and gave you a bank full of gear and gold. Also you could use commands to set your skills/stats.

Shadowbane: Test Server - has Admin ran Rune Huts to get free discs and 3x the gold drop rate and XP gains.


So no that is not correct. Test Servers nearly always allow for you to TEST quicker. IE Stat adjustment/Free Money


 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


Don't you get it? The point is that this information isn't coming to the public. The changes that affect your players and teams were known beforehand by god knows how many players/teams in your league.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
The problem I see with this thread is that the majority of people are making the negative assumptions associated with the usual style of internet witch hunt, and not many are thinking rationally about it.


That is going to happen when you keep secrets. Secrets are bad and they always come out. Even if they are good secrets, assumptions will be made until the secret keeper comes clean.
 
bootyslayer4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz
Originally posted by bootyslayer4

Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


NO THEIR HAVING BETTER PLAYERS AND ARE MONEY IS BEING WASTED THIS GAME COULD BE A SCAM


What the fucking hell are you talking about?!

You pay money to boost your player, not make him 2x as good as non boosters.
You pay money for a team, you get your team.
You pay money for flex points, you get flex points.

You DO NOT pay money for better players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.