User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Addle
offline
Link
 

Personally with a powerback I think it should be based off a momentum type variable. For a run up the gut where he gets contacted early it should be easier to stop him from getting more than 2-3 yards with a 10% chance or so of him busting through into the secondary. If he actually makes it through and gets enough speed built up then he should have a larger chance of just running over people. Its hard to give actual suggestions without knowing how things are programmed. Do players have the option of going low on a powerback? If a corner tries to hit a powerback high due to failing a vision check he should get knocked on his ass and its up to the next defender to be smarter. All of this is based on the powerback going against a team correctly built. Also is weight a deciding factor? A 190 pound powerback will have less momentum than a 220 pound back. The player tackling the back shouldn't have to be as strong but he should have high tackling to be able to wrap him up and set him up for the gang tackling if he can't bring him down himself due to str/tackler's momentum/vision for knowing how to tackle correctly. Strength should really only be used to determine hit intensity (for fumbles/injuries) and how long a player is able to maintain the tackle if waiting for others to help. Tackling should be used to decide if its a good tackle or just some weak ass hit that gets him thrown to the ground.


Basically I just don't see strength as being the biggest factor in tackling. It should be used for figuring out things after the tackle has been confirmed. Strength should just let you keep wrapped up or force the fumble while tackling and vision should be the big ones. This is assuming that vision is used as a "football knowledge" type attribute as well. SA's should add bonuses to your tackling if activated or strength if its huge hit. Confidence should be used to help smaller players tackle larger players and larger players to run over smaller players. Sorry about the big block of text its early and I don't have all my thoughts totally organized.


 
johncu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gaz
Velocity would be great in theory, I love the idea. But its gonna be hard for a lot of players who rolled and rolled to find a decent build when creating their player, and ended up undersized. I have an RB who is a power back - he's 5'11 and 185lbs - we'd need to be able to train to gain weight etc, or else make the player creation more user friendly.



I agree. It wouldn't be fair at all for size to all of a sudden become an important factor. My power back is 5'11 180, he is a great player right now but he would be worthless if size was important.
 
Link
 
I made it through page twenty of the thread then couldn't go any farther so I'm jumping to the post. This is what I posted in another thread:
>>>
Originally posted by photofinishron
My question is... How many missed tackles are to many? It would seem logical to me, if any line backer and any running back meet one on one in an open field there if a percentage chance for the line backer to miss a tackle. I don't think a 10% missed tackle ratio is unrealistic. maybe I'm wrong? Maybe just too high on the percentage? Maybe if your not getting any missed tackles your not getting enough shots at the ball carrier?


Personally I think the missed tackle thing is BS. Agents are wanting to make every single tackle. It ain't going to happen. Hey I'm a line backer owner so there's nothing I'd like more than getting 100% tackles. On the other hand, If I were an agent for a HB I'd be whining about getting tackled every play!

In reality, the Line backer or any other defensive player is going to and should miss a few tackles. A good running back should and will break a few tackles and should even break a few for the long run too.

If the algorithms are set up right then a pair of maxed out players, 1 offense and 1 defense, should get a percentage of missed tackles and breaks for the long run. Players less than maxed out should get a different ratio of percentages. Maybe a target max percentage of misses and breaks should be 8%. (Just throwing out a random number).
 
Scoot
offline
Link
 
maybe this has been mentioned already but it just occurred to me. all of these missed tackles, what are your SA's like? snarl anybody? no aura of intimidation? building up big/monster hit? if you're tackling a power back with 7's in power through, stiff arm, and lower shoulder ... wouldnt it make sense in a gaming standpoint to have more than basic 48 str/tak and no SA's to bring him down?
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by johncu
Originally posted by Gaz

Velocity would be great in theory, I love the idea. But its gonna be hard for a lot of players who rolled and rolled to find a decent build when creating their player, and ended up undersized. I have an RB who is a power back - he's 5'11 and 185lbs - we'd need to be able to train to gain weight etc, or else make the player creation more user friendly.



I agree. It wouldn't be fair at all for size to all of a sudden become an important factor. My power back is 5'11 180, he is a great player right now but he would be worthless if size was important.


How many 5'11" power backs do you know? 6'2" 240 sound better?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner


How many 5'11" power backs do you know? 6'2" 240 sound better?


This guy?

1 Rodgers, Jacquizz RB 5-6 180 Fr Oregon State. Ok he's still college and he's probably not really classified as a powerback but if you've ever seen him play you'd call him a powerback. At least in the college level.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner


How many 5'11" power backs do you know?


Michael Turner

Last edited Jan 8, 2009 23:56:22
 
Scoot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner
How many 5'11" power backs do you know? 6'2" 240 sound better?


i think this guy wasnt bad ... the tyler rose, rookie of the year, MVP, consecutive rushing titles, hall of fame, arguably the hardest player in nfl history to tackle ...
 
ElManu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Donner



How many 5'11" power backs do you know?


Michael Turner



Jamal Lewis
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ElManu
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by Donner




How many 5'11" power backs do you know?


Michael Turner



Jamal Lewis


Marion Barber and Jerome Bettis
Last edited Jan 9, 2009 09:50:13
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Thurman Thomas?
 
dudley
offline
Link
 
Terrell Davis

Jamal Anderson
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
Originally posted by ElManu

Originally posted by Rage Kinard


Originally posted by Donner





How many 5'11" power backs do you know?


Michael Turner



Jamal Lewis


Marion Barber and Jerome Bettis


Earl Campbell..GOAT as a powerback..arguably all time..shorter than 5'11 too

Last edited Jan 9, 2009 09:57:32
 
dudley
offline
Link
 
Ironhead Heyward

A better question might be how many powerbacks weren't 5'11
 
JackLambert
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
Originally posted by ElManu

Originally posted by Rage Kinard


Originally posted by Donner





How many 5'11" power backs do you know?


Michael Turner



Jamal Lewis


Marion Barber and Jerome Bettis


I've heard the Maurice Jones-Drew is pretty hard to tackle also, he's 5'7'' I think.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.