Originally posted by Bobaganoosh
You say that this game is still in BETA form yet it does not resemble the definition at all because you are already marketing it and accepting money to boot. The only reasonable reason to ask for money is to finance the game (so that you can make the proper changes to complete the product) in which you are supposed to give all of the money or at least a portion of it back to your financiers. Plan on doing this anytime soon? Didn't think so.
Like I said, this game is in BETA form. EVERYONE who plays this (boosters and non-booster alike so really the two are irrelevant at this point) is testing the game for you. You are NOT paying people to test the game (which MOST companies with products in BETA form do) but are asking them to pay to test it. That's not how it works and unfortunately you are probably going to find out the hard way with a class-action lawsuit of some sort. It's pretty much a slam dunk case for the Plaintiffs. BUT, you might just be lucky enough to find some kind of loophole that will save your conniving/stealing behinds.
Notot mention, this game isn't free as you've already stated. You get a free 'trial' and that's it. I'm pretty sure catch states this himself. However, it does not state that anywhere on the homepage (actually I'm sure it states that it's FREE) so that would be called false advertising which is illegal in its own right.
I won't be surprised to find myself banned tomorrow and if I do, it only proves I am right. It must suck knowing there are people out there that thought this through more than the actual creators themselves. Kind of makes Bort and Co. rather worthless in the big picture.
Absolutely correct Boba.
I talked to one of the guys over at Propellerhead where I have been a tester on their products, and the rule is pretty strict on not being able to charge people for an unfinished software or hardware product. They don't have to pay anyone to beta test but some do it as a discount on the product being tested, while others might pay a small amount. One thing that is crystal clear is that you can't make someone pay to test your unfinished product.
Charging for flex to play this unfinished product is actually illegal.
Since their legal people aren't in on weekends, he couldn't give me the specifics. Also keep in mind that for almost every law, there is a loophole made to circumvent it. I'll know more by tomorrow evening.
While I don't hate Bort and Co. enough to bring a suit against them, they might want to calm down on how they make changes.
Bort's bottom line is moot.
edit: They are allowed to ask for donations, but since that isn't the case here, that point is also moot. They aren't asking for donations, they are setting it up to fleece people for more money.