User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Lohengrin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Pwned IRL


Originally posted by EastBayFunk



Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


All I know is I dont know a lot of Cornerbacks tackling Brandon Jacobs by them selves if at all.. :/


I don't see a lot of Brandon Jacobs taking direct hits from fast-moving defenders and then prancing into daylight without even flinching either.

Sure he can break a tackle, but he runs upright and goes down like a chump when he loses his momentum.



It's always aholes like you with the shitty takes, that don't own a runningback. Your a idiot. You musta missed leron landry getting killed by jacobs.
Ever seen earl cambell break 20 tackles on 1 play b4? You are a idiot.


I remember Jacobs destroying a New England DB in last year's Super Bowl on one of the first plays of the game - the guy was almost afraid to tackle him after that.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Pwned IRL


Originally posted by EastBayFunk



Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


All I know is I dont know a lot of Cornerbacks tackling Brandon Jacobs by them selves if at all.. :/


I don't see a lot of Brandon Jacobs taking direct hits from fast-moving defenders and then prancing into daylight without even flinching either.

Sure he can break a tackle, but he runs upright and goes down like a chump when he loses his momentum.



It's always aholes like you with the shitty takes, that don't own a runningback. Your a idiot. You musta missed leron landry getting killed by jacobs.
Ever seen earl cambell break 20 tackles on 1 play b4? You are a idiot.


Nope, never seen Earl Campbell take 6-7 simultaneous direct hits from the defense and walk away... When he didnt even have much momentum! Nope, never seen him or anyone else be completely unaffected by an unblocked six-man gang tackle!

I've had Brandon Jacobs on my real football simulator (Stratomatic Football) since he came into the league, have had him on every fantasy football team I've owned in the past few years, and watched 90% of Giants games for the past decade.

I didn't say he can't pop a safety he has 50 pounds on, or that this kind of scenario shouldn't be possible in GLB. I'm just saying that when the DT, all three LBs, and both safeties drill a power back in the span of about two seconds, he shouldn't just prance away unhindered for a long TD.

And I don't know if you're mad because your mom beat you as a child or because you wet the bed until you got your GED, but I'll ask you to keep your personal attacks to yourself....
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Pwned IRL


Originally posted by EastBayFunk



Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


All I know is I dont know a lot of Cornerbacks tackling Brandon Jacobs by them selves if at all.. :/


I don't see a lot of Brandon Jacobs taking direct hits from fast-moving defenders and then prancing into daylight without even flinching either.

Sure he can break a tackle, but he runs upright and goes down like a chump when he loses his momentum.



It's always aholes like you with the shitty takes, that don't own a runningback. Your a idiot. You musta missed leron landry getting killed by jacobs.
Ever seen earl cambell break 20 tackles on 1 play b4? You are a idiot.


So every time Jacobs gets past the LBs, he's free for a TD? I don't think so.

You glorify your heroes more than they merit (or would even want you to do). The occasional time a RB blows up a DB is just that: an occasional time. Football is a game of situations... it's a bit more complex than arm-wrestling.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Lohengrin
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by Pwned IRL



Originally posted by EastBayFunk




Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


All I know is I dont know a lot of Cornerbacks tackling Brandon Jacobs by them selves if at all.. :/


I don't see a lot of Brandon Jacobs taking direct hits from fast-moving defenders and then prancing into daylight without even flinching either.

Sure he can break a tackle, but he runs upright and goes down like a chump when he loses his momentum.



It's always aholes like you with the shitty takes, that don't own a runningback. Your a idiot. You musta missed leron landry getting killed by jacobs.
Ever seen earl cambell break 20 tackles on 1 play b4? You are a idiot.


I remember Jacobs destroying a New England DB in last year's Super Bowl on one of the first plays of the game - the guy was almost afraid to tackle him after that.


I also recall little Lito Shepherd single-handedly taking out Jacobs in the backfield on an off-tackle run. What's your point?
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
"You are a idiot"
Grammer Fail^
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Bringing this here because the thread where I originally posted it seems to no longer be one of the five or six main discussion threads on this one topic.

Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by

Don't nerf anything, and make people fix their builds

-an OT with 10 speed and 20 agility should never touch a DE with 90 speed and 80 agility
-a WR with 100 speed and 80 agility should always fly right by a CB with 75 speed and 60 agility
-a WR with 100 speed and 40 agility should take a very, very, very long time to accelerate to full speed
-a RB with 100 strength should always never break the tackle of defender who has 40 tackling
-a DT with 90 strength and 70 agility should always break the tackle of a OG who has 80 strength, 70 blocking, and 30 agility

BUT

-an OT with 50 speed, 60 agility, 80 strength, 80 blocking should always engage and pancake a DE with 40 strength, 90 speed, and 80 agility
-a WR with 100 speed and 80 agility should rarely fly by a CB with 90 speed and 80 agility
-a WR with 80 speed and 100 agility should reach top speed in around 10 yds
-a RB with 100 strength should almost never break the tackle of a defender who has 80 tackling
-a DT with 90 strength and 70 agility should rarely break the tackle of a OG who has 90 strength, 80 blocking, and 50 agility


This mentality is exactly what must be avoided if the game is to maintain anyone's interest for more than a few seasons. Just comparing numbers is a boring game... kind of like playing "War" with cards. The game is much more compelling when it is based on the situations which individual players are able to generate using the tactics selected by the team's leadership, and not based simply on comparing attributes. Direct comparison leads to blowouts because the same result happens over and over all game long... which also makes the game boring.

Of course Bort's question thread seemed to ask for responses in this format...
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 08:05:03
 
Lohengrin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Lohengrin

I remember Jacobs destroying a New England DB in last year's Super Bowl on one of the first plays of the game - the guy was almost afraid to tackle him after that.


I also recall little Lito Shepherd single-handedly taking out Jacobs in the backfield on an off-tackle run. What's your point?


No real point. I have a power back and he does well, but I've always suspected it's because there are so many LBs and CBs who pump up speed and forgo tackling/strength.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Grammer Fail


Intentional or not, the irony made me lol.
 
ksmilkman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Romeorr
Originally posted by 2005Cardinals

Originally posted by tomcollins


Just about anyone should be able to bring down a power back. Even punters can tackle return men a good amount of the time. Power backs should be able to break tackles easier against less strong players of course, but it shouldn't be a given even if they have 10 strength.


Agreed. A CB with 35 Tackling/Strength should make the tackle about 2/3 of the time, assuming he's on wrap up tackling.

Wrapping up really does help bring a ball carrier down much easier.

If you get low and wrap up legs, ANYONE will go down fairly easily.


but they need confidence of 50 then, because if they are afraid they wont make the wrap up and they wont make the tackle. the players on glb are no where near the nfl players, they may come close physically, but when you add up the confidence they dont come close. infact id say most players on glb would have the confidence of a highschool nerd hitting on a cheerleader


To be fair, I doubt many power backs have much confidence either. which basically nullifies your example assuming both players have roughly the same less-than-stellar confidence. Both crap their pants at the thought of contact.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Nuge20

Grammer Fail


Intentional or not, the irony made me lol.


Intentional
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Lohengrin
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by Lohengrin


I remember Jacobs destroying a New England DB in last year's Super Bowl on one of the first plays of the game - the guy was almost afraid to tackle him after that.


I also recall little Lito Shepherd single-handedly taking out Jacobs in the backfield on an off-tackle run. What's your point?


No real point. I have a power back and he does well, but I've always suspected it's because there are so many LBs and CBs who pump up speed and forgo tackling/strength.


Of course CBs forgo tackling/strength. They have to cover WRs that are creeping up past the 110 speed mark. They don't have a choice.
 
tommystv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Deathblade

Make "wrap up" more vulnerable to getting plowed over and the ball carrier getting an extra 1-2 yards.

Make "power" less vulnerable to it, but also more likely to miss an ELUSIVE back, NOT a power back.


Basically have the different tackling styles work differently against different types or rushers.


You can't just say Power tackling works on Power backs, what if there is no strength on the player attempting a power tackle on a RB that has 40 lbs. on him and 30 more points in strength. That tackler should be trucked 9 times out of 10.

My take.

Assuming this back is a pure power build. 6'3 220 type frame.

Think Brandon Jacobs. LBs and Safties either ride him down or come in low, he never gets knocked back head on, so he always falls forward during a head on tackle. The best way to take him down is to hit him from the side. Often he goes straight down that way. So momentum needs to absolutely play a role.

I think within 10 pts of strength should have a really good chance of tackling him. Around 20 pt difference should really start to favor the RB on 1v1 tackles. And anything over 20 pts the tackler should virtually be helpless as a solo tackler.

Variable should favor D if there are more players swarming in for tackle, gang tackling should favor in D player, and Power back should be more vulnerable coming out a broken tackle. The odds of breaking another within a couple of steps of the last one should be low, but once he's gathered 2 or 3 steps on momentum again he should be at full power again.







 
manx
offline
Link
 
Have velocity play a much bigger role in the tackling equation. This would balance out builds with twinked str, str/spd, or str/agi.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by manx
Have velocity play a much bigger role in the tackling equation. This would balance out builds with twinked str, str/spd, or str/agi.


i agree.
Velocity and mass are the only 2 variables in momentum and momentum is always conserved in every collision.
 
Gaz
offline
Link
 
Velocity would be great in theory, I love the idea. But its gonna be hard for a lot of players who rolled and rolled to find a decent build when creating their player, and ended up undersized. I have an RB who is a power back - he's 5'11 and 185lbs - we'd need to be able to train to gain weight etc, or else make the player creation more user friendly.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.