User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Announced Changes > Change to Age Based League Structures Discussion Thread
Page:
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boogie21
Most of what I read sounded pretty harsh.


Boogie21: Non-boosters are not hated and despised... they are just as much a part of this community as anyone else in any category. The new system will just have them playing like minded teams, taking away the advantage of playing 3 season younger dots. A couple of posts up, I pointed out where Catch's comment said that they would use effective level each season when moving teams to the new leagues.... but many choose to not notice that. Non boosting will not be dead.. Some people are just mad that the advantage is being taken away, and making others whom don't so it for an advantage mad as well(because they are buying into the doom and gloom being projected by them).
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
How they sort the teams is not the entire issue. Free agency is the key to the problems that will arise.


and I'm sure they will put stipulations in the contracts preventing that from happening. The whole system hadn't been laid out by any means yet, just mentioned with a brief overview. There is alot of filling in dots and reading between the lines going on. Who knows, once the final drawup is announced, we may all hate it..... on the other hand, we may all like it.
 
Link
 
How can they force only "bad" boosters into an age cap? They can't. They can only sort the teams based on how they did the previous season. The common leagues will be dominated by the few teams that are able to load up on the good boosters that want to statpad.
 
Strwy2Hevn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by martyrzade
I have a question. Anyone feel free to give their answer.

How is this age-based system preferable to sorting by Effective level?


More profitable for GLB
 
kingjonb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarBro456
Originally posted by Catch22
We have our reasons and are still using effective level both in the initial sort and in placement of teams in tiers each season(along with rivalry points, performance, etc).

By using an age based level structure we keep players together that should be similar in their abilities and skills and thus make the lower level experience a much more competitive and fun one. You can't guarantee that with using effective level as the sole sorting criteria.




Everyone seems to overlook this bolded part of what Catch22 said. each season


then what's this?

-- Promotions/demotions will work similarly to the current system. The best teams would be in the upper tiers (Elite) and the worst teams would be in the lowest tiers (Normal).
-- The initial sort for the new league structure will be based upon the age of the oldest player on the team. Teams will then be compared using effective level and performance to be placed in their initial league for their age bracket.

what you're talking about only goes into effect for teams already in the same tier, not to place them in a tier.
 
Bobaganoosh
offline
Link
 
Bort and Co. You best hope that there isn't some kind of law preventing games in BETA form from asking for money. Your product is INCOMPLETE.

Here's the definition of a BETA so maybe you'll understand.

Originally posted by
BETA - a quality-control technique in which hardware or software is subjected to trial in the environment for which it was designed, usually after debugging by the manufacturer and immediately prior to marketing.


You say that this game is still in BETA form yet it does not resemble the definition at all because you are already marketing it and accepting money to boot. The only reasonable reason to ask for money is to finance the game (so that you can make the proper changes to complete the product) in which you are supposed to give all of the money or at least a portion of it back to your financiers. Plan on doing this anytime soon? Didn't think so.

Like I said, this game is in BETA form. EVERYONE who plays this (boosters and non-booster alike so really the two are irrelevant at this point) is testing the game for you. You are NOT paying people to test the game (which MOST companies with products in BETA form do) but are asking them to pay to test it. That's not how it works and unfortunately you are probably going to find out the hard way with a class-action lawsuit of some sort. It's pretty much a slam dunk case for the Plaintiffs. BUT, you might just be lucky enough to find some kind of loophole that will save your conniving/stealing behinds.

Notot mention, this game isn't free as you've already stated. You get a free 'trial' and that's it. I'm pretty sure catch states this himself. However, it does not state that anywhere on the homepage (actually I'm sure it states that it's FREE) so that would be called false advertising which is illegal in its own right.

I won't be surprised to find myself banned tomorrow and if I do, it only proves I am right. It must suck knowing there are people out there that thought this through more than the actual creators themselves. Kind of makes Bort and Co. rather worthless in the big picture.
Edited by Bobaganoosh on Oct 24, 2010 20:10:44
 
Link
 
If this gets finalized then GLB will lose over 200 users.
 
ETime
offline
Link
 
Sales must be down and this will make everyone have to boost to be in a competitive league
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
This game can still be played as free fwiw.
 
Thundercat_12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bobaganoosh
Bort and Co. You best hope that there isn't some kind of law preventing games in BETA form from asking for money. Your product is INCOMPLETE.

Here's the definition of a BETA so maybe you'll understand.

Originally posted by

BETA - a quality-control technique in which hardware or software is subjected to trial in the environment for which it was designed, usually after debugging by the manufacturer and immediately prior to marketing.


You say that this game is still in BETA form yet it does not resemble the definition at all because you are already marketing it and accepting money to boot. The only reasonable reason to ask for money is to finance the game (so that you can make the proper changes to complete the product) in which you are supposed to give all of the money or at least a portion of it back to your financiers. Plan on doing this anytime soon? Didn't think so.

Like I said, this game is in BETA form. EVERYONE who plays this (boosters and non-booster alike so really the two are irrelevant at this point) is testing the game for you. You are NOT paying people to test the game (which MOST companies with products in BETA form do) but are asking them to pay to test it. That's not how it works and unfortunately you are probably going to find out the hard way with a class-action lawsuit of some sort. It's pretty much a slam dunk case for the Plaintiffs. BUT, you might just be lucky enough to find some kind of loophole that will save your conniving/stealing behinds.

Notot mention, this game isn't free as you've already stated. You get a free 'trial' and that's it. I'm pretty sure catch states this himself. However, it does not state that anywhere on the homepage (actually I'm sure it states that it's FREE) so that would be called false advertising which is illegal in its own right.

I won't be surprised to find myself banned tomorrow and if I do, it only proves I am right. It must suck knowing there are people out there that thought this through more than the actual creators themselves. Kind of makes Bort and Co. rather worthless in the big picture.


interesting
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
This game can still be played as free fwiw.


also you're not the first person to threaten GLB with a lawsuit...
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kingjonb
then what's this?

-- Promotions/demotions will work similarly to the current system. The best teams would be in the upper tiers (Elite) and the worst teams would be in the lowest tiers (Normal).
-- The initial sort for the new league structure will be based upon the age of the oldest player on the team. Teams will then be compared using effective level and performance to be placed in their initial league for their age bracket.

what you're talking about only goes into effect for teams already in the same tier, not to place them in a tier.


That was a post that Catch made on page 19.. http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4344313&page=19#39076297

The announcement mentions the system coming up in season 20. It probably isn't even finalized yet just exactly all the stipulations to it. There is too much filling in the blanks and reading between the lines going on. It's gonna happen anyway regardless... (Catch made another post as such, but I'm not spending my time looking up everything he said because people choose to ignore it) I'll just continue to read over this thread, as it has been a fun read for sure.
 
Thrym
offline
Link
 
I'm sure someone has already said it...but I've spent over $300 on this BETA...I won't spend another until the game is FINISHED!

By finished I mean, get the rules set and quit overhauling them every other season! I've been here since season 2...the pinnacle of fun for me was around season 6-9. We had rivalries with other teams, we felt like we were a real league. Then GLB started flipping teams around every season...then they changed the way we build out dots a few seasons ago and the fun has just drained away since then...forums are dead even on the big organizations.

This is a social game...without someone on a team REALLY working at it to keep the forum active, its dead. And that's no fun. So, we have a Beta game with endless changes(GLB calls them improvements) but not one change I've seen in the time I've been here has been for the good of me...just like this change, its for the good of the one making money---and that's GREAT for him...just don't piss down my back and tell me its raining! So a game that's constantly changing, rules that are not set in stone that means I can't plan one season to the next cause the only SURE thing is, something will change. So with all this going for the game you want to INSIST I spend more money.

Why would I spend money on this? It really has become an NFL simulator...no fun league!

Good luck with the changes, I will be here lurkin...but I ain't spending any more money...nope, nope nope!

Oh, and one last thought...until its out of Beta, I will steer anyone I can AWAY from here now. I use to grab anyone I could, 'its free, come on they don't MAKE you pay to have fun!" Well, that's not true anymore huh...
Edited by Thrym on Oct 24, 2010 20:56:06
 
Bobaganoosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
also you're not the first person to threaten GLB with a lawsuit...


True but I might be the first person with a case that could and probably would be won. Thanks for coming out though, your response was truly stimulating and I don't know what I would have done without it...
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thrym
a bunch of stuff


You can still play for free. That hasn't changed.


The sky is not falling, and thanks for playing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.