User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Zeke Woodson




We gameplanned running to your outside, as a matter fact. I knew you would try to stop the inside stuff. But it didn't work because, for the most part, the runner ran inside instead. I found it odd that this would happen in this one game when it didn't in any other that season.

I don't deny that your team was damn good. But you still had access to something that we did not. IT'S NOT RIGHT.


Wait are you saying that I used some secret test server bug to force YOUR team to run inside?



You guys had no business being in a playoff game with regular GLB players who didn't have access to what you did.

YOU HAD NO BUSINESS DOING IT. IT WAS WRONG.


You woulda done the same thing and you know it.
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson

Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Zeke Woodson





We gameplanned running to your outside, as a matter fact. I knew you would try to stop the inside stuff. But it didn't work because, for the most part, the runner ran inside instead. I found it odd that this would happen in this one game when it didn't in any other that season.

I don't deny that your team was damn good. But you still had access to something that we did not. IT'S NOT RIGHT.


Wait are you saying that I used some secret test server bug to force YOUR team to run inside?



You guys had no business being in a playoff game with regular GLB players who didn't have access to what you did.

YOU HAD NO BUSINESS DOING IT. IT WAS WRONG.


You woulda done the same thing and you know it.


Bullshit. And don't presume to speak for me again.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Zeke Woodson




We gameplanned running to your outside, as a matter fact. I knew you would try to stop the inside stuff. But it didn't work because, for the most part, the runner ran inside instead. I found it odd that this would happen in this one game when it didn't in any other that season.

I don't deny that your team was damn good. But you still had access to something that we did not. IT'S NOT RIGHT.


Wait are you saying that I used some secret test server bug to force YOUR team to run inside?



You guys had no business being in a playoff game with regular GLB players who didn't have access to what you did.

YOU HAD NO BUSINESS DOING IT. IT WAS WRONG.


I got to the playoff game through the merits of my team and my gameplanning. Nothing else. This is the problem, you won't believe that because you lost. Fortunately I am the kind of person where achievements in life mean something when they are earned so I know that my integrity is intact. You can think and say what you like, it doesn't take the achievement away.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black


I got to the playoff game through the merits of my team and my gameplanning. Nothing else. This is the problem, you won't believe that because you lost. Fortunately I am the kind of person where achievements in life mean something when they are earned so I know that my integrity is intact. You can think and say what you like, it doesn't take the achievement away.


or you could have cheated and we will never know the difference, you only have Bort to blame for putting you in this situation.... but it is still there
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson

Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by Zeke Woodson





We gameplanned running to your outside, as a matter fact. I knew you would try to stop the inside stuff. But it didn't work because, for the most part, the runner ran inside instead. I found it odd that this would happen in this one game when it didn't in any other that season.

I don't deny that your team was damn good. But you still had access to something that we did not. IT'S NOT RIGHT.


Wait are you saying that I used some secret test server bug to force YOUR team to run inside?



You guys had no business being in a playoff game with regular GLB players who didn't have access to what you did.

YOU HAD NO BUSINESS DOING IT. IT WAS WRONG.


I got to the playoff game through the merits of my team and my gameplanning. Nothing else. This is the problem, you won't believe that because you lost. Fortunately I am the kind of person where achievements in life mean something when they are earned so I know that my integrity is intact. You can think and say what you like, it doesn't take the achievement away.


why have you not denied having access to the test server?
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Zeke Woodson


Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by Zeke Woodson






We gameplanned running to your outside, as a matter fact. I knew you would try to stop the inside stuff. But it didn't work because, for the most part, the runner ran inside instead. I found it odd that this would happen in this one game when it didn't in any other that season.

I don't deny that your team was damn good. But you still had access to something that we did not. IT'S NOT RIGHT.


Wait are you saying that I used some secret test server bug to force YOUR team to run inside?



You guys had no business being in a playoff game with regular GLB players who didn't have access to what you did.

YOU HAD NO BUSINESS DOING IT. IT WAS WRONG.


I got to the playoff game through the merits of my team and my gameplanning. Nothing else. This is the problem, you won't believe that because you lost. Fortunately I am the kind of person where achievements in life mean something when they are earned so I know that my integrity is intact. You can think and say what you like, it doesn't take the achievement away.


why have you not denied having access to the test server?


It's easier to just admit you were on the test server and deny that you learned anything at all from it.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
I am sorry, I hate this whole mess and especially that certain users got that advantage but is Zeke Woodson actually bitching that Darkus being on the test server made his HB run inside instead of out? That's the STUPIDEST argument I think have heard this entire time. That's either a bug or your fuckup on the AI. Testers may have had access on ways to improve their builds and may have known if certain nerfs are coming but they sure as hell can't MAKE your team lose. They can only help themselves win. So stop being stupid.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by Zeke Woodson


Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by Zeke Woodson






We gameplanned running to your outside, as a matter fact. I knew you would try to stop the inside stuff. But it didn't work because, for the most part, the runner ran inside instead. I found it odd that this would happen in this one game when it didn't in any other that season.

I don't deny that your team was damn good. But you still had access to something that we did not. IT'S NOT RIGHT.


Wait are you saying that I used some secret test server bug to force YOUR team to run inside?



You guys had no business being in a playoff game with regular GLB players who didn't have access to what you did.

YOU HAD NO BUSINESS DOING IT. IT WAS WRONG.


You woulda done the same thing and you know it.


Bullshit. And don't presume to speak for me again.


Wow, so you are lying now too...either that or you genuinely are stupid.

 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
I am sorry, I hate this whole mess and especially that certain users got that advantage but is Zeke Woodson actually bitching that Darkus being on the test server made his HB run inside instead of out? That's the STUPIDEST argument I think have heard this entire time. That's either a bug or your fuckup on the AI. Testers may have had access on ways to improve their builds and may have known if certain nerfs are coming but they sure as hell can't MAKE your team lose. They can only help themselves win. So stop being stupid.


He's saying that being on the test server might have helped Darkus defend the run in that game.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by jrry32

I am sorry, I hate this whole mess and especially that certain users got that advantage but is Zeke Woodson actually bitching that Darkus being on the test server made his HB run inside instead of out? That's the STUPIDEST argument I think have heard this entire time. That's either a bug or your fuckup on the AI. Testers may have had access on ways to improve their builds and may have known if certain nerfs are coming but they sure as hell can't MAKE your team lose. They can only help themselves win. So stop being stupid.


He's saying that being on the test server might have helped Darkus defend the run in that game.


And I am saying that argument is garbage. The test server might help them with builds but formations and crap, it's not going to do much since according to Bort and all the testers, the sim is different. BTW Darkus is also apart of many good teams, he knows what defensive formations to run.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Ummm, yeah?

I said there is nothing I HAVE learned from my access to the Test server.

I also said there is scope for some knowledge to be gained, if someone had not had as much experience or spent as much time doing 'research the old fashioned way' in games/scrimmages/peewee/test builds etc on the Live Site.


So what you are saying is that you already know everything about GLB that could be learned by testing....

Why were you testing things then? Why not save us all a bunch of time and report your knowledge to Bort / DD and the admins...and tell them to stop the testing servers

You genius.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 17:57:27
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Ummm, yeah?

I said there is nothing I HAVE learned from my access to the Test server.

I also said there is scope for some knowledge to be gained, if someone had not had as much experience or spent as much time doing 'research the old fashioned way' in games/scrimmages/peewee/test builds etc on the Live Site.


So what you are saying is that you already know everything about GLB that could be learned by testing....

Why were you testing things then?


I don't think that is what they are testing, I am fairly sure they are testing for bugs...not knowlledge.(although some probably are doing both)
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by TerrellOwns

Originally posted by jrry32


I am sorry, I hate this whole mess and especially that certain users got that advantage but is Zeke Woodson actually bitching that Darkus being on the test server made his HB run inside instead of out? That's the STUPIDEST argument I think have heard this entire time. That's either a bug or your fuckup on the AI. Testers may have had access on ways to improve their builds and may have known if certain nerfs are coming but they sure as hell can't MAKE your team lose. They can only help themselves win. So stop being stupid.


He's saying that being on the test server might have helped Darkus defend the run in that game.


And I am saying that argument is garbage. The test server might help them with builds but formations and crap, it's not going to do much since according to Bort and all the testers, the sim is different. BTW Darkus is also apart of many good teams, he knows what defensive formations to run.


The conclusion you came up with in your first sentence is not supported by the rest of what you wrote.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

And I am saying that argument is garbage. The test server might help them with builds but formations and crap, it's not going to do much .......<snip>


You just admitted it would help....then you go on to say 'but it wont help that "much."

I call shannannigans, sorry.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 18:02:21
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by tigerbait22


I think Mike will be honest enough to admit that he could have created any build that he wanted to and tested it multiple times IF desired. I know Mike would not do that to gain an edge but he won't deny that It could have been done.


I could build anyway I want, but not in secrecy, it would be fully tackable, and I would have to explain why I did so.

Testing multiple times is fundamental to any testing (Obviously), but again it needs to be focussed and justified.

To gain that edge everyone is worried about, I would need to convince others that there is a legit reason for the test, and all results would be screened by more than just myself, so IF I found anything that was useful it would enter the 'Bug/Exploit' domain and be addressed immediately.

Testing multiple plays against one Play in preperation for a specific game for example, needs to be strongly justified. (I guess this is the biggest concern after builds?)

As for making players too closely related to my own/my team, its doable, but heavily monitored for obvious reasons.



Two things:

1. Doesn't this imply that unless Bort immediately fixes every problem that you discover, that there will definitely be periods of time where a given tester will be aware of problems/exploits that exist in the game that the general public is not aware of or is less aware of the specifics?

2. From what you've said, wouldn't the testing process be more efficient if Bort didn't have to worry about testers using information to their advantage - if the testers were not also players?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.