WE MAY NEED SOME COMPENSATION...FLEX POINTS FOR THIS TBH
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
Painmaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Animalmother
Solutions?
1) List or identify everyone with access
1 - Possible, but you'll probably find testers withdrawing rather than be "outed" and nobody ever willing to do it again.
Completely unfounded concern. You'd only lose the testers looking to take advantage of the system imo. People doing it selflessly for love of the game aren't worried about impressing people, they're just having fun playing the game.
Really?
So you're saying someone told that they cannot play the game would continue to test the game for free?
Rather than walking away from testing knowing that Bort will hire an asshat who doesn't actually care beyond his paycheque?
You can still play the game as a known tester, you just do so with others knowing that you have additional access to information which they do not. So there's not a whole lot of impressing people with how smart you are, but you can still have fun playing the game. I can't imagine any Pro teams wanting to associate with testers though, so that fun will generally be had at lower levels or at least not on the very top teams who are worried about their reputations for winning on their own merit alone. Teams struggling to keep up might be OK with having a tester on board since they're not shooting for the #1 spot.
Playing as someone who secretly has such access is tantamount to cheating imo. That deserves no respect at all.
His (and various others) suggestion was you LOSE your right to play the game by being declared a tester.
Option 1 wasn't to lose access -- he offered losing access as a different (and much less viable imo) option. I don't think any game would work well if its testers didn't also play to some extent tbh. If you're good with having testers identified publicly, then we're on the same page.
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Animalmother
Solutions?
1) List or identify everyone with access
1 - Possible, but you'll probably find testers withdrawing rather than be "outed" and nobody ever willing to do it again.
Completely unfounded concern. You'd only lose the testers looking to take advantage of the system imo. People doing it selflessly for love of the game aren't worried about impressing people, they're just having fun playing the game.
Really?
So you're saying someone told that they cannot play the game would continue to test the game for free?
Rather than walking away from testing knowing that Bort will hire an asshat who doesn't actually care beyond his paycheque?
You can still play the game as a known tester, you just do so with others knowing that you have additional access to information which they do not. So there's not a whole lot of impressing people with how smart you are, but you can still have fun playing the game. I can't imagine any Pro teams wanting to associate with testers though, so that fun will generally be had at lower levels or at least not on the very top teams who are worried about their reputations for winning on their own merit alone. Teams struggling to keep up might be OK with having a tester on board since they're not shooting for the #1 spot.
Playing as someone who secretly has such access is tantamount to cheating imo. That deserves no respect at all.
His (and various others) suggestion was you LOSE your right to play the game by being declared a tester.
Option 1 wasn't to lose access -- he offered losing access as a different (and much less viable imo) option. I don't think any game would work well if its testers didn't also play to some extent tbh. If you're good with having testers identified publicly, then we're on the same page.

Banned
offline
offline
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
THORN WHERE IS BORT OR DD?
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
THORN WHERE IS BORT OR DD?
Banned
offline
offline
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Boltz
WE MAY NEED SOME COMPENSATION...FLEX POINTS FOR THIS TBH
OH YEAH!
Originally posted by Boltz
WE MAY NEED SOME COMPENSATION...FLEX POINTS FOR THIS TBH
OH YEAH!
TerrellOwns
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
His (and various others) suggestion was you LOSE your right to play the game by being declared a tester.
"Right" to play the game? Seriously? Which amendment gives you that right?
The bottom line is that most users have been lead to believe that we're all on a level playing field and no one has advance knowledge of changes coming down the line. Giving certain unknown players a substantial advantages severely damages the integrity of the game.
His (and various others) suggestion was you LOSE your right to play the game by being declared a tester.
"Right" to play the game? Seriously? Which amendment gives you that right?
The bottom line is that most users have been lead to believe that we're all on a level playing field and no one has advance knowledge of changes coming down the line. Giving certain unknown players a substantial advantages severely damages the integrity of the game.
Osmlol
offline
offline
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by JHight
I've been on test servers before for two different mainstream MMORPGs and I hate to break it to you guys, but they aren't all that they are cracked up to be. You may think that you can get an advantage by testing builds, but remember, the builds are only for current or near current coding, far away from what will be effective in the 4+ months it takes to actually create the build you want.
As for listing names and the like, no, it shouldn't happen. I had my guild/kin/group outed as being on a test server and everyone thought our accomplishments were tainted. What they didn't know was that we often were testing redundant things just to make sure no bugs occurred, not even getting a set strategy down.
You guys just need to calm down. This is a NECCESSARY part of MMOs. It happens in EVERY GAME. They are trying to get rid of the bugs in coding before it comes to live, not trying to get a leg up on anyone. Yes, there are those that attempt that, but for the most part, they fail because the coding is so different.
This.
Test Servers on MMORPG's are always public and welcome everyone. Some games allowed you to get things you are not allowed to on regular live servers.
IE:
Ultima Online, Test Center. - Had skill gates and gave you a bank full of gear and gold. Also you could use commands to set your skills/stats.
Shadowbane: Test Server - has Admin ran Rune Huts to get free discs and 3x the gold drop rate and XP gains.
So no that is not correct. Test Servers nearly always allow for you to TEST quicker. IE Stat adjustment/Free Money
Originally posted by JHight
I've been on test servers before for two different mainstream MMORPGs and I hate to break it to you guys, but they aren't all that they are cracked up to be. You may think that you can get an advantage by testing builds, but remember, the builds are only for current or near current coding, far away from what will be effective in the 4+ months it takes to actually create the build you want.
As for listing names and the like, no, it shouldn't happen. I had my guild/kin/group outed as being on a test server and everyone thought our accomplishments were tainted. What they didn't know was that we often were testing redundant things just to make sure no bugs occurred, not even getting a set strategy down.
You guys just need to calm down. This is a NECCESSARY part of MMOs. It happens in EVERY GAME. They are trying to get rid of the bugs in coding before it comes to live, not trying to get a leg up on anyone. Yes, there are those that attempt that, but for the most part, they fail because the coding is so different.
This.
Test Servers on MMORPG's are always public and welcome everyone. Some games allowed you to get things you are not allowed to on regular live servers.
IE:
Ultima Online, Test Center. - Had skill gates and gave you a bank full of gear and gold. Also you could use commands to set your skills/stats.
Shadowbane: Test Server - has Admin ran Rune Huts to get free discs and 3x the gold drop rate and XP gains.
So no that is not correct. Test Servers nearly always allow for you to TEST quicker. IE Stat adjustment/Free Money
Stu618
offline
offline
People just want to know if we were taken advantage of. I am hoping no, but I am guessing yes. 

cbarge
offline
offline
Originally posted by PackMan97
Transperancy. That's change we can believe in!
He used bold! Get him Mithra!
Transperancy. That's change we can believe in!
He used bold! Get him Mithra!
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
We understand Thorn but we are wondering why the things found aren't released to a GLB population and how do you know EVERY tester is telling bort every exploit they find? It's human nature to be selfish and look out for yourself so how do we know that one of them did not find an exploit and not report it then abused it?
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
We understand Thorn but we are wondering why the things found aren't released to a GLB population and how do you know EVERY tester is telling bort every exploit they find? It's human nature to be selfish and look out for yourself so how do we know that one of them did not find an exploit and not report it then abused it?
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by Painmaker
Option 1 wasn't to lose access -- he offered losing access as a different (and much less viable imo) option. I don't think any game would work well if its testers didn't also play to some extent tbh. If you're good with having testers identified publicly, then we're on the same page.
I was taking his options as not entirely mutually exclusive.
And, for the record, I'd quit.
Option 1 wasn't to lose access -- he offered losing access as a different (and much less viable imo) option. I don't think any game would work well if its testers didn't also play to some extent tbh. If you're good with having testers identified publicly, then we're on the same page.

I was taking his options as not entirely mutually exclusive.
And, for the record, I'd quit.
Painmaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
Thorn, far and away the thing that most has people upset here is the secrecy and lack of "read-only" access to the knowledge available on the test servers -- builds being tested, game replays, test forum discussions, etc. Can you tell us why this secrecy is necessary?
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is what I have a problem with, why select a few to "test" things? Afterall we are in beta, why not allow GLB MEMBERS the right to also "test" things and you will get a much better conclusion of a bug than just say a hand picked amount trying some things out. Like some have said these testers are human, It's human nature to gain an advantage of an individual no matter who you are.
IMO Bort and co should of set up a test site and allow anyone to go in and try things out. If you had 1000 players making different builds and saw some shocking results, a core group of people would easily pick them out as opposed to however many they have now and we do not even know how many. If lkike some have said, if a LB puts 100 into blocking to test him out and they saw the results, it would get fixed and caught the attention of many users as opposed to just a handful.
The people who get selected have shown a good understanding of the game, and have offered useful/constructive feedback. They are people that communicate well and know what to look for to see if something is broken, or exploitable. They than report that to us.
If we opened up the test server to everyone, outside of the resource issue with the servers, the communication would break down. I do agree with you that having 1000 people making different builds and testing stuff out would probably help to find bugs/exploits quicker, but the communication wouldn't be there nearly as well as it is now.
What I'm trying to get across to your very valid question, is that too many people on the test server would not work out as well as having a smaller number of people on it. Now some day in the future we may want to stress test things, and we would open it up. But for now smaller numbers is all that is needed.
-Thorn
Thorn, far and away the thing that most has people upset here is the secrecy and lack of "read-only" access to the knowledge available on the test servers -- builds being tested, game replays, test forum discussions, etc. Can you tell us why this secrecy is necessary?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























