User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
-MITH- ~Cult~
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EastBayFunk
Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.



Well hell if thats the case why dont we come up with a formula based on what the average NFL CB benchs and the average NFL HB benchs. Turn it into a percantage and there it is. Perhaps set a percentage based on positions.
 
2005Cardinals
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Just about anyone should be able to bring down a power back. Even punters can tackle return men a good amount of the time. Power backs should be able to break tackles easier against less strong players of course, but it shouldn't be a given even if they have 10 strength.


Agreed. A CB with 35 Tackling/Strength should make the tackle about 2/3 of the time, assuming he's on wrap up tackling.

Wrapping up really does help bring a ball carrier down much easier.

If you get low and wrap up legs, ANYONE will go down fairly easily.
 
Jerry Maquire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


Maybe, more importantly, the question should be, "How many real life power HB's are successful in the NFL"... That may be a good jump off point for determining how that build should perform in your model.

That's isn't to say that power backs don't have a role in a game to game scenario, but their dominance should be dictated by the real game we are imitating.
 
Romeorr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 2005Cardinals
Originally posted by tomcollins

Just about anyone should be able to bring down a power back. Even punters can tackle return men a good amount of the time. Power backs should be able to break tackles easier against less strong players of course, but it shouldn't be a given even if they have 10 strength.


Agreed. A CB with 35 Tackling/Strength should make the tackle about 2/3 of the time, assuming he's on wrap up tackling.

Wrapping up really does help bring a ball carrier down much easier.

If you get low and wrap up legs, ANYONE will go down fairly easily.


but they need confidence of 50 then, because if they are afraid they wont make the wrap up and they wont make the tackle. the players on glb are no where near the nfl players, they may come close physically, but when you add up the confidence they dont come close. infact id say most players on glb would have the confidence of a highschool nerd hitting on a cheerleader
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Tackling != tripping, and there's your problem. Nobody can trip anybody, so low-strength people have issues.

It doesn't take a lot of strength to hit somebody's foot with a diving outstreched hand while they're running full speed to have that level of contact send them off balance to the point where they fall down, and that's as legitimate a tackle as wrapping them up and driving them into the turf.
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
I have a lot to say, but it is so late that it may not make much sense.

Let me start by saying that I think str/tckl is pretty close to not seeing the forest for the trees as far as an answer to this question.

The question is waaaay too generic. Are we talking about open field tackling, gang tackling, or one on one tackling in the hole? What about tackling them before they get going?

DB's, LB's, are often the guys with really nice tackling numbers. That is to say that these are the guys making lots of tackles, and they are not normally the strongest guys on the team. I think 48 str should be adequate for tackling at most every position, and may be too much for some.

Strength at these positions is needed more to get off blocks than it is for tackling slow goal line backs. You do that by keeping them from squaring their shoulders, hitting them before they get going, or by sheer numbers in real life.(ALL of these are done with great vision, speed, and agility, as it translates to GLB) I could see the argument for strength if it was needed to get off blocks so the backer could scrape, to go iso with a monstrous FB, or to meet a diving HB above the pile. I would say that strength needs to be position specific, and also dependant on the vision, agility, speed, and confidence of the player. I have no idea if you can code that, but that is the closest thing to realism.


That brings us to the other end of the question. I don't really understand the tackling attribute. Tackling is a combination of vision, agility, speed, confidence and strength. Therefore, I have always assumed that the "tackling" attribute was more about technique. If that is the case, fundamental football techniques should be learned, for the most part, at a very low level. In this game, I would translate that to 48, but that still doesn't cover all of the scenarios. I mean, there probably aren't many mysterious tackling techniques that you only learn when you get to the NFL.

In short, If you want guys to have higher strength, come up with a legit reason since tackling isn't really it. It would also be nice if you could define what tackling is since it is either redundant, incomplete, or refers sdimply to techniques that are mostly learned very early in a players career?
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
I think strong powerbacks should see more yards after contact (more dragging weak tacklers, particularly those on wrap-up).

Realistically, a powerbacks greatest asset is his ability to keep driving for a few yards after contact- not trucking 6 men, sending them to the ground in pain, and taking it to the house. Granted, good powerbacks do break lots of tackles- but I think it's a little bit overdone in GLB.

One of the biggest differences between powerbacks in GLB and real football is highlighted by short-yardage situations.
-In reality, a power back is great for a situation like that- he is the one guy on the roster with the momentum, the shear will and muscle to drive that one yard no matter who gets in his way.
-In GLB, a power back is generally a riskier runner. He has that sweet chance to smash up a couple tacklers, and get to the second level for a good gain. However, since he's slower, he's also likely to allow the defense to develop, more likely to trod his way into a TFL. His strength is no help if the blockers let someone through- a weak cornerback might miss- but if he does make the tackle, the power HB drops like a fly.

High strength, high tackling should be the only ways to drop an extremely good power back on a dime. Boosting power HBs to the point at which a weak DB or LB always gets run over repeatedly is not realistic. A light cornerback with decent tackling skills CAN take down Brandon Jacobs, Brandon is just going to drag him 2 or 3 yards in the process most of the time.

More plowing, less pancakes for power HBs.
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 03:32:46
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


Like someone else says, depends on what goes into the formula. Tackling being primary, strength secondary, but does confidence, vision and agility add an element? I would hope so, but throwing that out the window..

For the top end power back you suggested, the guy has to be one of the oldest players around to get all of those stats unless he gimped himself totally on stamina, vision, etc, all other stats, so it stand to reason he should play like one of the best power backs.. In short, your average BBB guy with 50/50 in str/tackle shouldnt be able to handle him all day.

I think to stop this guy a simple majority of the time, a solo tackler should need a combination of about 110-120 in str/tackle. (be it 60/60 70/50 or what not, with maybe at least 45 in tackle. To consistently tackle him without a broken tackle, say 90-99% he should have around 80-100 strength, 60-70 tackle.

Outside of that question, I think that a formula for gang tackling or broken tackle weariness should be applied, and frankly should have been applied by now if it hasn't, and I don't think it has. Each time a player takes a hit and breaks the tackle, the formula should apply a penalty for future broken tackles, ideally within a set amount of time. That's true to real football. A guy might be able to run over one opponent, but if he is hit immediately there after or near there after, he's generally going down.. and if 2-3 guys converge on him, the odds of him escaping diminish greatly.

Now if it's a punt return and he sheds the first tackler and meets someone else 30 yards up field, that missed tackle isn't and shouldn't really have an influence on his next tackler.

Also, vision needs to be addressed first and foremost for RBs in my opinion. Right now it's an absolute ludicrous shame that vision is still hurting your RB more than helping it.. Be it from actually having higher vision, or just having gimped yourself of far more valuable stats. Vision is absolutely key to RBs in every real league whether they're big and strong or fast and agile. It always helps.

Vision should help a RB find open areas whenever possible and if you can't think of ways to avoid having a RB be gimped by it, simply boosting its value in formulas for avoiding tackles, fumbles (SA or otherwise), or simply increasing the RBs agility behind the LoS would be better than it is now.
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 03:43:17
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pestface
I think strong powerbacks should see more yards after contact (more dragging weak tacklers, particularly those on wrap-up).

Realistically, a powerbacks greatest asset is his ability to keep driving for a few yards after contact- not trucking 6 men, sending them to the ground in pain, and taking it to the house. Granted, good powerbacks do break lots of tackles- but I think it's a little bit overdone in GLB.

One of the biggest differences between powerbacks in GLB and real football is highlighted by short-yardage situations.
-In reality, a power back is great for a situation like that- he is the one guy on the roster with the momentum, the shear will and muscle to drive that one yard no matter who gets in his way.
-In GLB, a power back is generally a riskier runner. He has that sweet chance to smash up a couple tacklers, and get to the second level for a good gain. However, since he's slower, he's also likely to allow the defense to develop, more likely to trod his way into a TFL. His strength is no help if the blockers let someone through- a weak cornerback might miss- but if he does make the tackle, the power HB drops like a fly.

High strength, high tackling should be the only ways to drop an extremely good power back on a dime. Boosting power HBs to the point at which a weak DB or LB always gets run over repeatedly is not realistic. A light cornerback with decent tackling skills CAN take down Brandon Jacobs, Brandon is just going to drag him 2 or 3 yards in the process most of the time.

More plowing, less pancakes for power HBs.


That bold is also a very valid point. It's a little too much all or nothing in GLB right now, which I know is a challenge of a sim. Like he said, B-Jac might run over a small CB more often than a DT or LB, but he isn't going to do it as much as a PB in GLB seems to do it. Although I think a lot of the "extra yards" you seem to see after contact indicate such a thing is actually happening.
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
Just watch a good power back in the NFL, they will even drag gangs of defenders 5+ yards before finally going down- but most decent defenders will at least hang onto the legs and eventually get the stop. Only on a really good day do you see a power back take out an entire field on his own.
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.


That's kinda why I'm asking this, Larry. People complain about missing tackles, but missing 3-4 tackles in a game vs one of these guys when you have 30 strength and 40 tackling and aren't running full speed with your 90 spd/agility doesn't really seem that out of line to me, even with "wrap up" settings.

I mean, you don't want power backs to be the end-all build, but you want to make their skills worthwhile as well, so a tiny weak CB doesn't take him down every time.



Bort, shouldn't it be more missed tackles? These good cover corners I.E. Prime time, should not be able to make tackles vs runningbacks like Earl campbell, or 100 strength runningbacks 1v1. I dont remember the last time i saw a corner back make a tackle in the open field 1v1 vs All-day. It should never happen. These power backs are built to dominate freaking corners.

Power backs making it into the secondary should be able to dominate cornerbacks.



This is another good point, although I'm so late to the dance I'm sure Bort stopped reading this thread and it's 90 pages.. but if a CB has front position on AD, he can still take him down a majority of the time.. What makes Adrian good is that he can put that CB out of tackling position and he can't bring him down from behind or sideways before he's past him, he's just too strong.

But take a guy like say Mike Alstott back in the day, he's bigger and stronger than Adrian without question, but it's not like he could ever consistently run for more than 3-5 yards at a time when he goes through a pile.

That's the problem in GLB. A power back here also generally has extraordinary speed and agility, and he breaks one tackle on the outside and he's gone. position of the dots should actually play a role in ability to tackle a guy if you wanted to get realistic about it, since it's so much harder to bring down a guy as he's running by you at a greater speed if you're behind him or perpendicular. (even leg tackles don't work great, a lot of times they just step out of them.)

But you can't really get realistic here, it just won't work.. So you just have to find a balance that is fair.. and I think the tackle weariness suggestion is the best bet for that. Let a power guy break his first tackle routinely, but the next one should be tougher.

Or let him break tackles all day, but don't make it so damn easy to block CBs and LBs. The majority of these plays you have one maybe two shots at best to tackle a guy out of 11 defenders.. you almost never see a situation where 8 guys are in position to make a tackle..
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 03:57:30
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Take this play for example.. I just grabbed the first one I could since this guy is fast as hell, agile, and powerful enough to get 4-5 BTs a game..

All of my LBs are 50 strength, 45-50 tackle, 75-85 speed, 60-65 agility, 50-60 vision.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=298557&pbp_id=1866707

You can clearly see that the RO is in position to make a tackle if the DT doesnt shed his block to get him.. but assuming the DT is blocked, which is common, if the RO doesn't make the tackle, he probably runs right by the LO, MLB, and the SS, leaving only a weaker tackling FS to stop the play as the CB is picked up easily and all day by the WR.

Looking at the positions of the LB and SS, and seeing that they're unblocked, there is no reason whatsoever for them not to take a smart angle and put themselves in play to make a tackle.. but this guy with his 90+ speed, probably 70-80 agility, and Im sure 60ish in strength at least just ran by them all day even when they were unblocked. So game logic and AI positioning is a big culprit here too.

It's a big reason why people whine about the broken tackles in GLB. Not because they're unrealistic, but because they always tend to lead to huge plays. You watch an NFL game and count the broken tackles.. a RB might break 10-15 tackles a day, but how many of them end up being inconsequential, adding maybe a yard or two at best? I'd say a lot.


If they can't even get to him to make a tackle, how bad is it when they get ran over because they've only soft-capped str/tackle?

A RB that doesnt have to worry about vision in today's GLB can key on 3 stats like speed agility and strength. They can slowly work their stamina and carry and probably deal with low vision and confidence.

A LB needs speed, agility, strength, tackle and vision to do his job in this speedy powerback scenario. If he's lacking in any of them, he's going to be hurting.. Not to mention that jumping and catching also can't be ignored if you want to be a decent pass defender. The speed power back doesnt really see any bit of a penalty from ignoring catching and jumping completely.. they're just icing. (I know jumping is supposed to help with broken tackles, but they don't need it to be effective.)

Fix vision, MAKE these backs have to take it and lose the ability to stockpile primary atts and your problem gets easier.
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 04:13:35
 
Alfalfa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye


It's a big reason why people whine about the broken tackles in GLB. Not because they're unrealistic, but because they always tend to lead to huge plays. You watch an NFL game and count the broken tackles.. a RB might break 10-15 tackles a day, but how many of them end up being inconsequential, adding maybe a yard or two at best? I'd say a lot.


Good point. it reminds me of the huge number of TDs from fumbled punts and kick returns in past seasons. The problem wasn't just the fumble, it was that invariably it was returned for a TD.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Originally posted by EastBayFunk

Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


All I know is I dont know a lot of Cornerbacks tackling Brandon Jacobs by them selves if at all.. :/


I don't see a lot of Brandon Jacobs taking direct hits from fast-moving defenders and then prancing into daylight without even flinching either.

Sure he can break a tackle, but he runs upright and goes down like a chump when he loses his momentum.
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 07:18:42
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Pwned IRL

Originally posted by EastBayFunk


Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


All I know is I dont know a lot of Cornerbacks tackling Brandon Jacobs by them selves if at all.. :/


I don't see a lot of Brandon Jacobs taking direct hits from fast-moving defenders and then prancing into daylight without even flinching either.

Sure he can break a tackle, but he runs upright and goes down like a chump when he loses his momentum.



It's always aholes like you with the shitty takes, that don't own a runningback. Your a idiot. You musta missed leron landry getting killed by jacobs.
Ever seen earl cambell break 20 tackles on 1 play b4? You are a idiot.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.