Originally posted by itsallgood1234
Originally posted by Ken1
By the way, I'm all for new plays being added. I just think Bort had the right focus (players) this season.
He didn't do it exactly how I'd have done it. I'd have expanded upon Drifter's lockerroom attributes idea, and had activities that shaped a personality for players, and players with different personality traits would help the team in different ways.
But the focus for this offseason was right on; and the furor over items is a bit crazy as we already have undershirts that give bonuses to whatever you want in the game. Is there actually an undershirt that will make me faster or stronger or tackle better if I wear it in real life? If eq were realistic, you could choose between only Catching or Carrying for glove bonuses, Speed, Agility, Kicking or Punting for shoe bonuses, all visor/eye black bonuses would be to Vision, and doo-rags as well as undershirts could-- maybe-- help Confidence, as in "I'll do well, I have my lucky shirt on")?
Seeing there are no such restrictions on current equipment, the whining about special equipment is WAY overdone, unless the "rare" items are unbalancing.
I'm all for adding a bunch of new plays for next season, but then a lot of the same people who are bitching will be bitching about the balance of the plays and how the game was wrecked because screen passes work too well or that they never work or whatever (that will likely be an extremely hard play to balance; I almost guarantee that in preseason for Season 6, when we first see the screens, they'll either be way too bad to be worth using or way too powerful).
That's the whole point. The rare items will be unbalancing by the sheer virtue of the fact that it's all up to chance.
You may have a guy who uses his tokens over and over on trying to get some good equipment and all he can get is a plus three item.
Similarly you have a guy who does it once and hits the jackpot and gets a +7 plus whatever else to an attribute.
The fact that you're putting it all up to chance as opposed to something everyone can acheive by doing the same thing ruins the whole idea.
The whole reason the current equipment worked because of the soft caps and it was a fun way too raise those soft caps while still keeping everyone equal in teh fact that you can get that too.
If you didn't have enough money and your owner wouldn't give it to you then you had the ability to switch teams to find someone to pay for your equipment upgrade.
Now it's all going to come down to random chance on who gets what and that takes the whole fairness out of the equation.
You're making an assumption that may or may not be correct.
I agree that if Level 16 special equipment (comparing it, as you did, to +3) can be +7 if you're lucky that would be unbalancing and would be bad for the game.
I'm not sure that he's planning that. The rare equipment might be something like, say, a level 16 FB shirt that gave +2 to Strength and +2 to Power Thru (normally not available to FB's). So, what's special about it is that it's one extra point and that it gives him an SA most FB's can't have.
But, he's still getting something worth only one extra SP (four rather than three), and that would be fine IMO. Or maybe the SA is in his tree, but the bonus would be that he's getting points there without the multiple soft SA caps.