User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by williamcohms
GLB is a great idea by a couple of guys who'd be sitting in a cube writing code living their own little version of Office Space if it weren't for that great idea. They've shown again and again that they don't know how to run a business like this. They've repeatedly made bad decisions in customer service. Outrage like the outrage in this thread seems to be the only thing they take notice of.

This game treats the inner-workings of the game as a huge secret. Nobody knows how it works or exactly what the attributes and abilities do. Giving a select group of people the ability to test those out on a test server, then leak that information to their own players and teams is patently unfair.


Winner winner chicken dinner.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 17:42:05
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
RE: Everyone who thinks my conspiracy post was not a joke

It was a joke.


IM STARTING TO THINK ITS FOR REAL IF YOU REALLY THINK ABOUT IT....
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Drago

Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by jrry32



Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


This assumes that the testers are selfish individuals and not interested in the development of the game though.


You haven't been around the internet very much, huh?


Long enough to have used a 14.4k modem. Just because a person has access to the internet it doesn't automatically make them an evil mind with the desire to rule the dot world.


And nothing automatically makes them not like that. Not much of an argument.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
RE: Everyone who thinks my conspiracy post was not a joke

It was a joke.


Looks like they took over cbarge's account.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
RE: Everyone who thinks my conspiracy post was not a joke
It was a joke.


crap, they got to cbarge. he's one of them now.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by cbarge

RE: Everyone who thinks my conspiracy post was not a joke
It was a joke.


crap, they got to cbarge. he's one of them now.


Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by cbarge

RE: Everyone who thinks my conspiracy post was not a joke

It was a joke.


Looks like they took over cbarge's account.


HIVEMIND
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Koncorde

Originally posted by Painmaker


Originally posted by Koncorde



Originally posted by Animalmother




Solutions?
1) List or identify everyone with access


1 - Possible, but you'll probably find testers withdrawing rather than be "outed" and nobody ever willing to do it again.


Completely unfounded concern. You'd only lose the testers looking to take advantage of the system imo. People doing it selflessly for love of the game aren't worried about impressing people, they're just having fun playing the game.


Really?

So you're saying someone told that they cannot play the game would continue to test the game for free?

Rather than walking away from testing knowing that Bort will hire an asshat who doesn't actually care beyond his paycheque?


You can still play the game as a known tester, you just do so with others knowing that you have additional access to information which they do not. So there's not a whole lot of impressing people with how smart you are, but you can still have fun playing the game. I can't imagine any Pro teams wanting to associate with testers though, so that fun will generally be had at lower levels or at least not on the very top teams who are worried about their reputations for winning on their own merit alone. Teams struggling to keep up might be OK with having a tester on board since they're not shooting for the #1 spot.

Playing as someone who secretly has such access is tantamount to cheating imo. That deserves no respect at all.


His (and various others) suggestion was you LOSE your right to play the game by being declared a tester.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
My problem with this whole situation is as follows:

1. Some users (presumably early users) are given access to a test server where they can gain knowledge of the game without having to spend the money that the rest of us do. This knowledge is likely gained at a much faster rate as well because while it takes seasons to develop a player on the main game, it seems that on the test server they can jump to higher equivalent levels immediately to do the testing. Anyone who has access to this test server now has much greater insight into the inner workings of the game and can now apply this knowledge to the main game against other paying users.

2. The test server is a secret. Until today, many people likely had no idea that there was a group of users who were given this advantage. As such, many users were likely paying money to play a game that they believed contained a level playing field for all customers. This has been clearly shown to not be the case. Since it is not unreasonable for GLB to know that thousands of users had this belief, yet they purposefully kept the testing server information a secret, it is reasonable to conclude that GLB fraudulently has been taking money from its userbase.

3. This conclusion of fraud is only perpetuated by the actions of the GLB staff today. Once someone raised this issue in the main forum and that thread, not surprisingly, gained popularity, it was moved without reason or message to a private forum where the general populace of GLB could not access it. To make matters worse, every single thread that had anything remotely to do with the test server was deleted within seconds. The staff purposefully was trying to quash any discussion of what many people believe to be an issue of utmost importance.

Because of what has gone down today, there are some steps that GLB should take to restore some semblance of consumer confidence in its service.

Remedies:

1. Immediate disclosure of everything that has to do with the test server. This includes, but is not limited to: users who have access, what they have access to, how long they have had access, and all testing data that they had access to.

2. Public censure of the staff members that were responsible for the unreasoned attempts to quash any and all discussion of this topic.

3. If it is found that these testers did, indeed, gain an advantage, GLB should be prepared to refund any money spent by any user who feels that they have been misled by GLBs representations that the game was setup as a "level playing field."


You think you're so smart because you have a law degree!

All joking aside, I agree with what awesome is saying, that is the best course of action.
 
Mithra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
RE: Everyone who thinks my conspiracy post was not a joke

It was a joke.


We couldn't tell because you didn't use bold.

BTW, I wasn't joking about the red herring, I was joking about the only two choices thing. You were right about red herring being a mistake. I finally understand why you think you need to make the point over and over.

Seriously, use bold some more.
 
PhillyFan536
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
GLB is a great idea by a couple of guys who'd be sitting in a cube writing code living their own little version of Office Space if it weren't for that great idea. They've shown again and again that they don't know how to run a business like this. They've repeatedly made bad decisions in customer service. Outrage like the outrage in this thread seems to be the only thing they take notice of.

This game treats the inner-workings of the game as a huge secret. Nobody knows how it works or exactly what the attributes and abilities do. Giving a select group of people the ability to test those out on a test server, then leak that information to their own players and teams is patently unfair.


Winner winner chicken dinner.

 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boltz
OH PLEASE BORT, DONT TELL ME THIS GAME IS A SCAM AFTER ALL THE WORK,TIME,EFFORT AND MONEY I HAVE SPENT PLEASE DONT TELL ME THIS GAME IS A JOKE AND A TRICK, PLEASE DONT TELL ME


/MiB_Red_Laser
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mithra
Originally posted by cbarge

RE: Everyone who thinks my conspiracy post was not a joke

It was a joke.


We couldn't tell because you didn't use bold.

BTW, I wasn't joking about the red herring, I was joking about the only two choices thing. You were right about red herring being a mistake. I finally understand why you think you need to make the point over and over.

Seriously, use bold some more.


Jesus dude, let it go. Everyone uses bold once in a while.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by awesome

My problem with this whole situation is as follows:

1. Some users (presumably early users) are given access to a test server where they can gain knowledge of the game without having to spend the money that the rest of us do. This knowledge is likely gained at a much faster rate as well because while it takes seasons to develop a player on the main game, it seems that on the test server they can jump to higher equivalent levels immediately to do the testing. Anyone who has access to this test server now has much greater insight into the inner workings of the game and can now apply this knowledge to the main game against other paying users.

2. The test server is a secret. Until today, many people likely had no idea that there was a group of users who were given this advantage. As such, many users were likely paying money to play a game that they believed contained a level playing field for all customers. This has been clearly shown to not be the case. Since it is not unreasonable for GLB to know that thousands of users had this belief, yet they purposefully kept the testing server information a secret, it is reasonable to conclude that GLB fraudulently has been taking money from its userbase.

3. This conclusion of fraud is only perpetuated by the actions of the GLB staff today. Once someone raised this issue in the main forum and that thread, not surprisingly, gained popularity, it was moved without reason or message to a private forum where the general populace of GLB could not access it. To make matters worse, every single thread that had anything remotely to do with the test server was deleted within seconds. The staff purposefully was trying to quash any discussion of what many people believe to be an issue of utmost importance.

Because of what has gone down today, there are some steps that GLB should take to restore some semblance of consumer confidence in its service.

Remedies:

1. Immediate disclosure of everything that has to do with the test server. This includes, but is not limited to: users who have access, what they have access to, how long they have had access, and all testing data that they had access to.

2. Public censure of the staff members that were responsible for the unreasoned attempts to quash any and all discussion of this topic.

3. If it is found that these testers did, indeed, gain an advantage, GLB should be prepared to refund any money spent by any user who feels that they have been misled by GLBs representations that the game was setup as a "level playing field."


You think you're so smart because you have a law degree!

All joking aside, I agree with what awesome is saying, that is the best course of action.


Any refunds would have to be limited to events in the past two weeks. Someone pissed because Norse's team beat them in week 3 of the season shouldn't get anything.
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
My problem with this whole situation is as follows:

1. Some users (presumably early users) are given access to a test server where they can gain knowledge of the game without having to spend the money that the rest of us do. This knowledge is likely gained at a much faster rate as well because while it takes seasons to develop a player on the main game, it seems that on the test server they can jump to higher equivalent levels immediately to do the testing. Anyone who has access to this test server now has much greater insight into the inner workings of the game and can now apply this knowledge to the main game against other paying users.

2. The test server is a secret. Until today, many people likely had no idea that there was a group of users who were given this advantage. As such, many users were likely paying money to play a game that they believed contained a level playing field for all customers. This has been clearly shown to not be the case. Since it is not unreasonable for GLB to know that thousands of users had this belief, yet they purposefully kept the testing server information a secret, it is reasonable to conclude that GLB fraudulently has been taking money from its userbase.

3. This conclusion of fraud is only perpetuated by the actions of the GLB staff today. Once someone raised this issue in the main forum and that thread, not surprisingly, gained popularity, it was moved without reason or message to a private forum where the general populace of GLB could not access it. To make matters worse, every single thread that had anything remotely to do with the test server was deleted within seconds. The staff purposefully was trying to quash any discussion of what many people believe to be an issue of utmost importance.

Because of what has gone down today, there are some steps that GLB should take to restore some semblance of consumer confidence in its service.

Remedies:

1. Immediate disclosure of everything that has to do with the test server. This includes, but is not limited to: users who have access, what they have access to, how long they have had access, and all testing data that they had access to.

2. Public censure of the staff members that were responsible for the unreasoned attempts to quash any and all discussion of this topic.

3. If it is found that these testers did, indeed, gain an advantage, GLB should be prepared to refund any money spent by any user who feels that they have been misled by GLBs representations that the game was setup as a "level playing field."


This seems like an idea... Nice!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Drago


Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by jrry32




Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


This assumes that the testers are selfish individuals and not interested in the development of the game though.


You haven't been around the internet very much, huh?


Long enough to have used a 14.4k modem. Just because a person has access to the internet it doesn't automatically make them an evil mind with the desire to rule the dot world.


Well listen hear youngin' - I had a 2400 baud modem at one point. You don't know how tough it was back then. YOU DON'T EVER WANT TO KNOW.

With that said, the Anonymous nature of the internet does lead a large group of individuals to perform selfish actions. Coupled with the fact this is a competitive game by nature, I think it's safe to say the greater of the "community" would take this information and do their best to put it to good use for selfish reasons.


Are you and Coach Jim going to sit out on your lawn, yell at kids who walk past to stay off your lawn and talk about the old days?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.