User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Saris, that idea is brilliant tbh.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
do we...........?


Until they change it again?
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Saris, that idea is brilliant tbh.


It was another guy's idea, I just reworked some of his numbers.

It still doesn't change the fact though that no one accounted for the need to stockpile a lot of BT's on an already developed build.

There's no easy answer to this one.
Edited by Saris on Jun 25, 2010 16:47:16
Edited by Saris on Jun 25, 2010 16:46:48
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
No, what you aren't understanding(or hopefully you do) is that a 5% loss of skills is not at all equal to what you gain from 1 season of training. I was putting it in SP value which is the only possible way to compare the two.


Yes, I do understand that 5% is WAY more than 1 season of training....but you CAN'T take 5% off the top of a player build, convert it back to SP, and compare that....

But I think I see your point now....but it's a hard argument to make....
5 points (100-95) in ALG is 25 SEASONS worth of ALG growth for a top attr....

I think the proper comparison is what could actually be EARNED during that season and try to figure out a reasonable "decline" to offset that gain.....problem is, it's hard to impose a penalty on the attributes that actually probably benefited from any actaul training or SP conversion....

1% is still 5 seasons worth of ALG for a top attr, but much less for the lower attrs...1% of an attr at 4th cap is .75, or just under 4 seasons of ALG.....

1% of total SP earned over a career is only 5 SP, so probably not enough looking at it this way....

I think a buy-back of penalty using TP and BTs is a good medium choice....let's see if it can get implemented....
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by jrry32


5% decline is worth 1 season of training? Bort...really?


when you consider the bonus tokens that came with it, maybe? i assume he'll do some number crunching and come up with a more accurate figure.


tru dat


I think you guys forgot about this...the more accurate figure part.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
I don't see them changing it again TBH....and consider, the % might be excessive...but those dots have already played an entire season with mild decline on top of the heap and they now get another 3 seasons of plateau which alot of people who don't own 440-480 dots consider unfair.

Nobody loves this new solution, which is pretty much the earmark of a nice compromise....
 
Link
 
Originally posted by coach
Originally posted by TrevJo

+1

New changes are awful. My 478 day old dot (at the end of the season) will have 4% decline and the same number of VAs as a 440 day old dot with 0% decline, and it will remain that way throughout the extended plateau? FFFFFFUUUUUUUUU


ooof.


sooooooooooooo lol
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by jrry32



5% decline is worth 1 season of training? Bort...really?


when you consider the bonus tokens that came with it, maybe? i assume he'll do some number crunching and come up with a more accurate figure.


tru dat


I think you guys forgot about this...the more accurate figure part.


You're implying they forgot.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
I love the idea of the extended plateau. This is the best new feature you have added period. It is going to make the game dramatically better.

This new solution does suck for S5D0 dots.

First you basically tell the user community and the S5D0 agents your players are going to have a nice edge over the entire community for 3 seasons.

Next you make a good decision and backtrack to fix the imbalance.

The new solution now just kills the S5D0 dots for high level teams. They can still be decent players on pro teams...that is where my teams will funnel the ones that don't retire. Hate to lose a generation of useful players when we are entering this 3 season prime period of the game.

I sort of do not understand why you would not make a decision that is balanced and allows the community to be unanimously happy. Even something as simple as removing 50% of the decline would make these players a lot more viable and mostly quiet the critics.

Thanks for the new feature...in the long run it will really help this game.





 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
I don't see them changing it again TBH....and consider, the % might be excessive...but those dots have already played an entire season with mild decline on top of the heap and they now get another 3 seasons of plateau which alot of people who don't own 440-480 dots consider unfair.

Nobody loves this new solution, which is pretty much the earmark of a nice compromise....


So playing 3 more seasons with 5% penalty is a good thing?????

5% is just about the end of the line, and after 2 seasons, you'll be playing against 2 seasons of guys with NO penalty and possibly slightly better builds....

And all the top teams who thought recruiting just got a lot easier are back to square one needing to replace all the guys at 5% decline.....or at least a lot of them.....
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
I don't see them changing it again TBH....and consider, the % might be excessive...but those dots have already played an entire season with mild decline on top of the heap and they now get another 3 seasons of plateau which alot of people who don't own 440-480 dots consider unfair.

Nobody loves this new solution, which is pretty much the earmark of a nice compromise....


It would actually even out when you think about it except D480 dots are buttfucked. If they played this season in decline, and that decline was gotten rid of for the next 3 seasons(with the VAs removed and the training balanced) and then the decline picked up where it left off...they would essentially get the 3 seasons like everyone else but their 1st season of decline happened before the plateau which would be the difference. I guess, I'll make it easier:
D480 Dots:
1st Decline Season(lose 0-5%)
Plateau
Plateau
Plateau
2nd Decline Season(lose 5-10%)

D440 dots:
Plateau
Plateau
Plateau
1st Decline Season(lose 0-5%)
2nd decline season(lose 5-10%)

As you see, everything would even out...but yea, not under the current system.
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 25, 2010 16:54:04
 
skeels
leet
offline
Link
 
This saturates the hell out of the higher levels, pushing more and more level 60ish players down into the AA and AAA ranks. I think this change should be accompanied by capped leagues through the 50's so that good players don't have to ride the pine for two seasons just waiting to get to a high enough level. Other than that, a decent change and I'm looking forward to seeing how it works out.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
I don't see them changing it again TBH....and consider, the % might be excessive...but those dots have already played an entire season with mild decline on top of the heap and they now get another 3 seasons of plateau which alot of people who don't own 440-480 dots consider unfair.

Nobody loves this new solution, which is pretty much the earmark of a nice compromise....


why do you think 480's will get 3 seasons of plateau? I haven't seen any reason to expect that they will last past day 560 tbh.

Very possible I missed that though.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
I'm going to be:
Day 469 on my QB
Day 469 on my P
Day 463 on my LB
Day 463 on my LB
Day 441 on my OT
Day 441 on my FB
Day 441 on my KR/PR/WR
Day 431 on my HB
Day 431 on my FB
Day 424 on my TE

....

Tell me if I hate this idea or not?
 
coach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
It was another guy's idea, I just reworked some of his numbers.

It still doesn't change the fact though that no one accounted for the need to stockpile a lot of BT's on an already developed build.

There's no easy answer to this one.


Yeah, it'd be ok for those who have an "extra" piece of AEQ to sell off but not for those who started cashing in the BTs for SPs after fully upgrading two pieces of AEQ.

Seems like an easier answer would be to come up with a more reasonable decline %. And feel free to drop the third year of paused decline if we have to give something to get something. Two years is two more than our current option, which is effectively zero years.
Edited by coach on Jun 25, 2010 17:06:06
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.