User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Firenze

Probably 80+ Str...70+ Tackling...

Depends on the formula for tackling a player...which only you know


I'm kinda asking: if you were determine how the formula worked, what would you think goes into it?

Opinions vary widely and I want to see where they are.


Diving Tackles trump power backs IMO.

Therefore, I think that you'd need good jumping (50+) and good tackling (50+). Otherwise you'd just need to have an equal (or greater) and opposite force. Same masses? The one traveling faster wins. Otherwise, you'd just have to out-power pure power.

On the other hand, Bort, you've made it very clear in other threads that the dots are controlled by calculus-based vectors. If that is the case, and the centers of gravity hit head on, the resultant force (vector) should continue to move on after subtracting the opposing force. If they collide and the defender has a lower center of gravity, it should take less force to upend the ball carrier. However, if you do not figure in centers of gravity the whole system is borked IMHO...
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Originally posted by EastBayFunk

Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


>_>

and MJD blew up Merriman (a huh LB) on a block.


CoG IMO!
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Powerbacks are too powerful...there is no way plays like this should happen:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=312891&pbp_id=1694364

Solution:

Either powerbacks should get a negative roll on successive broken tackle attempts or 2nd, 3rd, 4th tacklers attempting the tackle should get an exponential increase in their make tackle roll. Kind of a gang tackling bonus. I am all for powerbacks breaking initial tackles but when 4 or 5 defenders surround a powerback and none can bring him down that should not be possible. Maybe the tackle bonus/negative goes away after the back moves another 5 yards or so but when tackle attempts all occur within a few yards the back should have little chance of breaking them all.

It is not a nerf...it is just making the sim more realistic.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Okole
i read some of this thread and my eyes started to hurt, so i stopped.....then i had an idea a few hours later

i think speed should factor into the equation as well. if you think about any collision -- the speed of the collision impacts the damage (as does the size)

i don't know if player weight is involved, but that should be as well.

strength.... tackling.....speed....player weight.....probably something about the angle being hit at.... plus any bonuses for VA or whatnot

i'll leave the equation to someone who knows more about how this actually works, but i wanted to mention the speed and size thing.

of course if someone already brought it up in the other 92 pages, then consider this my +1


Okole, Bort said that speed/momentum is already factored in, as is weight. But even though we have half a dozen defenders flying in with much more momentum than the power back, it often doesn't matter.
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
I think it should all be relative, No set numbers. 100 STR/70 CRY HB should be tackleable by someone with 30 strength/30 tackle. It's the RATE that matters. In this case it should be very low, by far lower than 50% My opinion is you need to create a formula to countermeasure this. You could do (this is the simple formula, not counting other factors) (STR+2/3CRY)-(2/3 STR+TKL)= Adjustment. The adjustment would be the % to add or subtract to the base tackle % (something low like 10-20%) In this case the adjustment would be +97 or 97% more chance to break tackles. Added to the base, that would make him untackleable. But make sure there is a minimum and a maximum, there is always a chance to miss someone, and always a chance to tackle someone, 20/20 for each is my suggestion.
 
quickrch
offline
Link
 
wow, so there should be some sort of probabilistic tackling where the speedy guy could take him down in 5-10 yards (e.g. drag him down) and if he were hit again in that yardage he would be more likely to fumble (fumble re-roll) . If it were a huge strong guy with higher tackling and strength then there would be a shorter yardage estimator and perhaps a reversal of yardage (stuffed).

Important in this is symmetry. Can a lvl 20 LB take down a lvl 20 powerback given similar rolls and player development. I would model this if I were you Bort and create an algorithm to estimate the probabilities. PM me if you want help with that (I have some statistical skills)...
 
Chop_Lobster
offline
Link
 
I think high vision should be taken into consideration when attempting a tackle. A defender with high vision has a better instinct for the game and good football knowledge right? So it would make sense to assume he studies his opponent and knows the most effective technique to bring down the back he's attempting to take down.

Also vision would help him recognize (during the play) who is carrying the ball and what that players physical stature is. Then he could assess his position relative to the ball carrier and make the best decision as to what tackling technique to use. Say a CB is being run at full speed by Brandon Jacobs.... UH OH! He assesses the situation and know he's going get trucked but... he also realizes he has help from the Safety and an olb. What would he do? If he's a real dumb ass he'd try to take him on straight up but if he had any smarts (vision) he would hit him mid level and try to slow him down so his help could finish the job. The issue this causes is that the tackling setting can't be static during a game to make it work. This would effectively require a defender to use his vision to decide which tackling option to use on a play to play basis. Which seems ok to me since setting to balanced tackling simply isn't a good enough option for game planning against teams with both elusive and power backs at this point.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chop_Lobster
I think high vision should be taken into consideration when attempting a tackle. A defender with high vision has a better instinct for the game and good football knowledge right? So it would make sense to assume he studies his opponent and knows the most effective technique to bring down the back he's attempting to take down.

Also vision would help him recognize (during the play) who is carrying the ball and what that players physical stature is. Then he could assess his position relative to the ball carrier and make the best decision as to what tackling technique to use. Say a CB is being run at full speed by Brandon Jacobs.... UH OH! He assesses the situation and know he's going get trucked but... he also realizes he has help from the Safety and an olb. What would he do? If he's a real dumb ass he'd try to take him on straight up but if he had any smarts (vision) he would hit him mid level and try to slow him down so his help could finish the job. The issue this causes is that the tackling setting can't be static during a game to make it work. This would effectively require a defender to use his vision to decide which tackling option to use on a play to play basis. Which seems ok to me since setting to balanced tackling simply isn't a good enough option for game planning against teams with both elusive and power backs at this point.


I like that idea as it does give the secondary a fair chance to make tackles. It cannot be expected that CBs and FSs have 60+ strength and tackling so they can ever tackle a strong running back and they need 90+ speed, 60+ agility, 60+ vision, and high confidence to cover WRs. It will be impossible to build a secondary to cover both scenarios...not enough SPs. There are definitely weak corners in the NFL and I would venture most times they are able to make tackles or at least slow down the runner long enough for a teammate to make a tackle. They should get plowed over sometimes too but the same RB should not run through the entire secondary on one run.

I do not think it needs as complicated as you make it out. High vision should just be a positive modifier to the make tackle roll. Bort has already stated that vision does some how apply when making a tackle...maybe its effect just needs to be increased.



 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
It's sad when this build has 5 Tkl's and 7 missed on the day on wrap up.

Do we really need 70 + STR and Tkl to even tackle these guys 50% of the time. Powerbacks need nerfed asap somehow.

Strength:
65.63
Blocking:
18.11
Speed:
82.11
Tackling:
52.74
Agility:
63.23
Throwing:
8
Jumping:
33.11
Catching:
33.11
Stamina:
53.3
Carrying:
9
Vision:
52.67
Kicking:
7
Confidence:
30.74
Punting:
7
Last edited Jan 3, 2009 13:57:09
 
daddie7120
offline
Link
 
I am not sure how Bort runs things but I think there is a simple fix to make both sides meet in the middle. Its not that people are mad that the power backs are breaking tackles but how they continue to do so after first contact. I am all for the power back as I have one myself and my team mate is Bull Power. The solution is the power back issue they need to lose a little of the power after any contact. The more contact (missed tackles) the more loss. I dont know how to make that part of the formula or to even give an exact # to make a tackle. Its kinda more like real life the guy loses momentum thus becoming less powerful as he has no speed. ANY player moving can tackle a man standing still. So some how reduction of speed/agility should come from contact no matter the build (speed or power) and make tackling them easier. I have NO idea how to formulate this but its definitely relevant.

If this is mentioned in some form shape or fashion I apologize I dont have the time to read 93 pages.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
It's sad when this build has 5 Tkl's and 7 missed on the day on wrap up.

Do we really need 70 + STR and Tkl to even tackle these guys 50% of the time. Powerbacks need nerfed asap somehow.

Strength:
65.63
Blocking:
18.11
Speed:
82.11
Tackling:
52.74
Agility:
63.23
Throwing:
8
Jumping:
33.11
Catching:
33.11
Stamina:
53.3
Carrying:
9
Vision:
52.67
Kicking:
7
Confidence:
30.74
Punting:
7


That's low Tackling for a LB. A LB's job is to tackle and you put over 80 in Speed and only 52 in Tackling.

Power backs should run right over him.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
what he said
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
I still don't think if a guy had 70 Tackling, this problem would be solved if the sim stays the same. The sim easily faors powerbacks right now.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289846&pbp_id=1844463

Where the hell is the slowdown through the line or missed tackle.

Last edited Jan 3, 2009 14:05:01
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
I still don't think if a guy had 70 Tackling, this problem would be solved.


needs moar tackling
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
IN MY HONEST OPINION:

Tackling should be a linebacker's PRIMARY ability. Not speed. In other words, tackling should be a linebacker's HIGHEST attribute. If that means having 85 tackling at level 40, that doesn't sound bad at all.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.