User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
What exactly is it that you/anyone feels are the possible types of exploits or bugs or tactics that we have secret info on?


I think you would be able to get a sense, based on the logic that Bort is running in the sim server, whether there's going to be a sim change to increase fumbles next season (and whether it will be based on attributes or particularly SAs that are currently underpowered, but have not been said to be underpowered by Bort publicly). I can make an educated guess that fumbles will be increased next season due to the general outcry this season, but I don't know for certain and so can't say whether it's worth jacking up my HBs carrying now or putting those points elsewhere for season 8 and plan to increase carrying next season, or whether it's worth putting points in Big Sack or Monster Hit

I'd imagine you could see if Bort was focused on making power rushing viable and whether it was working on the test server, which would allow you to increase the strength of your OTs or DEs with your season 8 boosts.

If there were testers around last season, you probably would have seen the changes to the OT/DE dynamic that Bort made and been able to see what kind of DE builds were most effective/least effective in the new environment. Even if you weren't certain he was going to make this change on the last day of the offseason, you would know it by the first scrimmage and have an immediate idea of how to adjust.

EDIT: Just to be clear, I don't think any of these things could be classified as bugs or exploits, just regular changes to the sim that testers could have advanced notice of as well as a sense of how best to adjust.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:57:02
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
[
There is some scope for this to give the tester a increase in knowledge, but the ceiling on that knowledge is the same for Testers and the general Public, if you follow.


Then why do you need testers if they cant learn anything the general Public cant, if you follow.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by GP1
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by thebigcali


It's really no coincidence to me that simultaneously two respected GLBers are here functioning as test server apologists and attempting to pull the wool over a very simple observation: Testing = An advantage


Are you saying that Mike Rogers was a good OC/DC for many seasons because he got an advantage from testing that he's only had since Feb. 1?


I dont feel that was implied in even the slighest way.


Really? Not even a little? Having had other people question the "accomplishments" of people that have come out as testers doesn't lead you to think there was an undertone of that? Maybe a big?
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by thebigcali

It's really no coincidence to me that simultaneously two respected GLBers are here functioning as test server apologists and attempting to pull the wool over a very simple observation: Testing = An advantage


Are you saying that Mike Rogers was a good OC/DC for many seasons because he got an advantage from testing that he's only had since Feb. 1?


No. haha where do I even use the words "Mike was a good OC/DC" in the past tense.

I am saying it is not a surprise that the only two people functioning like apologists are well-known, respected members of the community. What I am saying is that it feels like a coordinated effort to quell the shitstorm occurring in this thread.

Mike is a great GM and a good person. Dark has personally purchased at least 1200 FPs for me during his 1000th post threads where I won a few times. Both of these guys are cool, upstanding guys.

But what I am saying is that I find it odd that both of these guys are the only ones in this thread defending the test server and minimizing the reality which any elite owner already knows: The ability to test anything more than someone else is an advantage. For example, changing up where your equipment is in scrimmages to see if a different build may be more effective. Now, imagine being able to do this at will at no cost. I fail to see how this is not an advantage since learning anything, good or bad, is an advantage.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 16:57:56
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GP1
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

[
There is some scope for this to give the tester a increase in knowledge, but the ceiling on that knowledge is the same for Testers and the general Public, if you follow.


Then why do you need testers if they cant learn anything the general Public cant, if you follow.



THIS ftw

Mike you can go away now....maybe you are too stupid to learn anythign from the test server, but the other 99.999% of people arent..

KTHXBAI
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali

But what I am saying is that I find it odd that both of these guys are the only ones in this thread defending the test server and minimizing the reality which any elite owner already knows: The ability to test anything more than someone else is an advantage.


+ 1 gazillion.... Bigcali hits the nail on the HEAD here..... It is very odd...Why..WHY? Why would anyone defend this and justify it and act like it isnt a big deal....It is so weird.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by thebigcali


But what I am saying is that I find it odd that both of these guys are the only ones in this thread defending the test server and minimizing the reality which any elite owner already knows: The ability to test anything more than someone else is an advantage.


+ 1 gazillion.... Bigcali hits the nail on the HEAD here..... It is very odd...Why..WHY? Why would anyone defend this and justify it and act like it isnt a big deal....It is so weird.


uhh we don't like each other remember.. *fights you*
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Bigcali

LOL but you made a good point ! I am willing to overlook personal differences, for the love and betterment of the game...I have agreed with everything you have said (that I have seen) on this issue. I think you got it 100% right man.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 17:02:16
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GP1
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by GP1


Exactly right. These guys can figure out in a matter of hours what combinations work whereas it would take a regular GLBer, at 25 SP per season, months and months. THIS is the advantage that people complain about.

And if someone were to tell the team, surely they wouldnt go around telling others.



What exactly is it that you/anyone feels are the possible types of exploits or bugs or tactics that we have secret info on?
I'm trying to address the fears of people who felt they are being cheated here not start arguments, so something less open ended would be helpful, I'll tell you if its possible or not.


There is nothing I have learned in the Sims from the Test Server that I did not already know as far as the Live site is concerned, the structure of it doesnt really allow for it, read back through some of my posts previously.




Something as simple as, say, is 100 sp 70 agi better than 90 sp 80 agi, or which SAs actually work. Just basic information like that. There's countless 'specific' possibilities I can refer to, but in the interests of brevity, I will not. Im sure you catch my drift.



Again this seems to be the biggest fear, and again personally no I havent learned anything that a normal GLB Player does not already know.

100 speed, 70 agility will accelerate slower but reach a higher top speed.
90 speed, 80 agility will accelerate faster and be better at changing direction at speed, but has a lower top speed.

Test games need justification, and builds are open at all times, so if a SA doesnt work, its not hidden from Bort in any way, shape or form.

Its possible that I might be able to hide the fact that 4 in a SA didnt fire in a couple games as far as I can tell from the PBP.
anything more than that though, and its not really possible.

Hope that helps a little with understanding?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by thebigcali

Originally posted by Mike Rogers




What exactly is it that you/anyone feels are the possible types of exploits or bugs or tactics that we have secret info on?



The ratios of skills that work best. Speed to agility being a key. Vision at positions has been known to be a bit odd. Confidence. What kind of individual tactics work best. Any owner with a lot of build experience knows these things can be tweaked for optimum performance. C'mon Mike and Dark.. Seriously, this seems to be a strategic defensive reaction to the masses of GLB. I could be completely off base but it's clear we aren't buying what you both are selling


cali, have you read all my posts from this thread? I am not doing this because I have permission or am being instructed, I am doing it because a Thread that was legit and had some very good points was Deleted for no reason earlier today, then I was posting in a second one of equal merit and that got deleted again.

Pissed me off enough that I felt somebody needed to grow a pair and face the rabble.

In terms of build ratios, no I havent Learned anything new that I didnt already know from testing I or team owners I have helped paid for with scrimmages.

I have said its possible that some Testers didnt know as much as I did when they joined (I highly doubt it, but I cant eliminate that possibility)

There is some scope for this to give the tester a increase in knowledge, but the ceiling on that knowledge is the same for Testers and the general Public, if you follow.


You want to know how much Trash Talk actually helps and what the effect is of confidence. You can run multiple sims per day and set your stats as you wish.

In a few days, you can run 3 sims with a LB having 90 confidence and 12 trash talk, 3 with 25 confidence and 12 trash talk, 3 with 25 confidence and 0 trash talk, and 3 with 90 confidence and 0 trash talk. Hell, you can do it with 5 LBs for each sim.

You can then do that for any stat, ability, VA, or anything else you choose. You're going to pretend you couldn't get an advantage? That you know everything about the sim and the formulas that make it up? That Bort doesn't even know what happens when you get a stat to 100 but you somehow know the effect of everything? Is that really going to be your argument? If so, PLEASE come GM my teams and let me know how everything works.

You knew a lot going into this. To pretend that means you couldn't learn from the testing is disingenuous to say the least.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by GP1

Lets not flame DB. He's a good guy.


I spent money on my peewee team in purchase and boosts. We took it from the #6 seed in the playoffs and knocked off both the #2 and #3 seeds to get to the conference championship, where we then lost to Darkus' team. And now I feel a little cheated.


I spend a lot of money on this game too. The pee wee team that you lost to only lost one game all season and that game was lost because I didn't have the time due to work commitments to game plan for it. You lost your game to me because your team had a two dimensional offense that ran the ball up the middle and chose left or right in alternative games. All I did was pulled my defense in closer to the LOS using the defensive AI. What I didn't do was underestimate your team and I spent around 4-5 hours looking over your games until I worked out what it was you had been doing. If I was able to exploit anything I would have done it against the lol dots instead of getting butt fucked by them.

I know you asked about the defensive formation that I ran in that game on the pee wee forum. The only reason that I didn't say anything in there about it was that I had another game to try and win and I didn't want to tip them off. If you want to know what I did then PM me and I will share it with you by all means. Whether you believe it or not, that win had absolutely nothing to do with any test server or inside information.

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 17:03:49
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Again this seems to be the biggest fear, and again personally no I havent learned anything that a normal GLB Player does not already know.
.....

Hope that helps a little with understanding?



Are you serious?

This is BULLSHIT man. Maybe you didn't learn anything....Maybe you are just a liar...Either way the other 99.9999% of people who test things , would do so to LEARn....Otherwise why test anything?
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I really would just like to a see a well-thought out, public explanation by Bort that isn't buried deep within some thread which a sliver of the community will see after the thread is locked.

Bort really just needs to explain his logic in allowing live server users have seemingly unlimited access to a test server. Did he think it wasn't a big deal? Why does he feel that way? Did he think it wouldn't go public? Why did he feel that way? Etc.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Oh, btw, for anyone else to do that, they need to get multiple level 40+ LBs on board with otherwise similar and put about 3 seasons worth of levels + boosts into the experiment.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
Yeah, I really would just like to a see a well-thought out, public explanation by Bort that isn't buried deep within some thread which a sliver of the community will see after the thread is locked.

Bort really just needs to explain his logic in allowing live server users have seemingly unlimited access to a test server. Did he think it wasn't a big deal? Why does he feel that way? Did he think it wouldn't go public? Why did he feel that way? Etc.


As far as I can tell from talking to more than one tester and more than one mod, no one has any fucking idea.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.