User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Larry Legend
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock


Dumb statement. Strength is far more than how much weight someone can bench press... ever hear of leg strength?


every hear of leg speed? thats how punters get that velocity on the ball. do punters here train much speed?

 
whatspeakyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Legend
Originally posted by whatspeakyou



obviously you know nothing about running backs then?

Go take your RL 10 strength and go tackle Brandon Jacobs. And then tell me his strength is irrelevant.

You failed to mention that Larry Allen was 325 pounds. Kinda hard to juke to a hole or build up speed... or have a burst at all... at 325 pounds.


If you're going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


and you failed to mention brandon jacobs has run a sub 4.5 40 yard dash.

if your going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


besides, id woops his ass, hed get hurt throwing his first punch.


he ran a 4.56 at the combine. you fail. again.
Last edited Jan 2, 2009 12:07:20
 
Larry Legend
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whatspeakyou
Originally posted by Larry Legend

Originally posted by whatspeakyou




obviously you know nothing about running backs then?

Go take your RL 10 strength and go tackle Brandon Jacobs. And then tell me his strength is irrelevant.

You failed to mention that Larry Allen was 325 pounds. Kinda hard to juke to a hole or build up speed... or have a burst at all... at 325 pounds.


If you're going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


and you failed to mention brandon jacobs has run a sub 4.5 40 yard dash.

if your going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


besides, id woops his ass, hed get hurt throwing his first punch.


he ran a 4.56 at the combine. you fail. again.


i didn't say AT THE COMBINE

he has run multiple mid 4.4's.

but hey, you got to be a jerk on the forums so i guess i did fail
 
whatspeakyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Legend
Originally posted by whatspeakyou

Originally posted by Larry Legend


Originally posted by whatspeakyou





obviously you know nothing about running backs then?

Go take your RL 10 strength and go tackle Brandon Jacobs. And then tell me his strength is irrelevant.

You failed to mention that Larry Allen was 325 pounds. Kinda hard to juke to a hole or build up speed... or have a burst at all... at 325 pounds.


If you're going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


and you failed to mention brandon jacobs has run a sub 4.5 40 yard dash.

if your going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


besides, id woops his ass, hed get hurt throwing his first punch.


he ran a 4.56 at the combine. you fail. again.


i didn't say AT THE COMBINE

he has run multiple mid 4.4's.

but hey, you got to be a jerk on the forums so i guess i did fail


hmmm sounds like some made up bullshit to me, especially since 40 times are good signs of initial burst and Joe Carini (his trainer, also trains Larry Johnson and a few other backs) said his initial burst is average with NFL backs at best. It's when he gets to full speed that he's dangerous.


Guess his trainer must be retarded, eh?

On top of that, Michael Turner has recently been clocked at running a 4.4 40-yard dash. You're trying to tell me Brandon Jacobs is as fast as Turner? Really? Think about that for more than 1 second man, honestly.
 
Fulchalin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


consiantly (as in stoping him 80% of the time without broken tackles) and this is without wrap up / diveing tackel SA's

I would say 65ish strength 50 tackeling 50 vision

semi consisatntly (65% stop w/o broken tackle)

I would say 50 / 50 /40

Mid - 505 stop w/o broken tackles

40 / 40 / 30
 
Okole
offline
Link
 
i read some of this thread and my eyes started to hurt, so i stopped.....then i had an idea a few hours later

i think speed should factor into the equation as well. if you think about any collision -- the speed of the collision impacts the damage (as does the size)

i don't know if player weight is involved, but that should be as well.

strength.... tackling.....speed....player weight.....probably something about the angle being hit at.... plus any bonuses for VA or whatnot

i'll leave the equation to someone who knows more about how this actually works, but i wanted to mention the speed and size thing.

of course if someone already brought it up in the other 92 pages, then consider this my +1
 
Titus Pullo
offline
Link
 
Well the physics equation for force is F = m*a, where the m is mass (ie the players weight) and the a is acceleration (a combo of speed and agility in GLB terms). Thus being a power back should have little to do with a players strenght, but rather the weight of the RB and how quickly he can get up to speed. Only heavy, quick guys should be able to run right through a defender without slowing down much. Everyone else should get slowed down significantly once they are hit, even on broken tackles.

Once a tackle is made leg strenght would be used to push through for a few more yards before going down, and he may even be able to break out of a weak tackle but his speed would be reduced to around zero, allowing other tacklers the time to catch up and pile on and bring him down. Thus a 100 strenght RB should be effective at gaining a few extra yards after the initial contact in the open field, he may even be able to push 2 weak tacklers back before going down. But when running stright into a massive DT or when a MLB hits him going full speed in an opposing direction, that high strenght isn't going to do much. After initial contact is also the time when players get 'stood up' by one or more defenders while another defender tries to 'strip' or 'punch' loose the ball. That 100 strenght should make it nearly impossible for someone to strip the ball though as he should have an iron grip on the ball. Thus a 100 strenght RB should rarely fumble at the end of the tackle. A poor carry ability would still result in the RB fumbling while running though as the carrying ability should relate to how well the ball is secured, not how hard it is held onto. The strongest guy in the world can carry the ball improperly and have it get knocked loose.

As far as CBs tackling a powerback 1 on 1, no they should not be doing it, but they should be able to slow him down enough to allow a LB to tackle him from behind or even push the guy out of bounds. A low tackling/strength CB shouldn't single handley bring a RB down, but niether should be get run over without the RB losing a step.



High agility/ high jumping RBs should be effective at side stepping or jumping over a tackler to cause a missed tackle and not lose much speed. When they do get hit, that should be the end of their forward progress.

Heavy, fast RBs should be able to 'power trough' or break tackles, but get slowed down quite a bit in the process.

High strenght RBs should be able to push forward for extra yards and never get stripped of the ball.

A RB without a high carry ability should loose the ball more often then just when a big hit occurs.
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TuNice
in before epic thread


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


=================================================================================================

Been a long time since I have cyphered I had to find my Big Chief pad and a red crayola.

P1 = STR
P2 = TACKLING
S1 = AGILITY
S2 = SPEED
R1 = VISION
R2 = CONFIDENCE
Randoms
SE = Special equip modifiers
VP1 = Veteran’s
VP2 = Veteran’s
SA’s =

{(P1+P2) +[(S1+S2)/2] + [(R1+R2)/4]} / % Stamina + random modifiers.=

What I am so badly saying is the combination of the 2 primary, plus a percentage of the 2 secondary, and again the percentage of the random stats, all modified by existing Morale plus randoms.

Basically for a tackle it would require a total of 170 + in a combination of Str and tackling, for other positions it would require the combination of those top two stats. Equal amounts of speed and agility, as well as the VP’s to offset, as well as some AEQ.

So its 170+ 1% divided in any combination in STR and Tackling for a NT. Ex: Str 86/tackling 85, Str 95/tackling 75, etc……. I think a DT or DE might be the same except change the primary from Strength to Agility possibly, every position has it's own main primary stat.

Been decades since I have been in school, but something like that anyway. This was all figured as to the word "Consistently". I don't think any player, specialty built, where its all speed and agility with 25 tackling should be more than a 15 to 25% chance of stopping a monster back. Although I do believe that a gang tackle should involve more than just a small lose to a balance modifier, maybe a percentage of a combined amount?
Last edited Jan 3, 2009 00:50:03
 
Nv1sion
offline
Link
 
Fix the holding that isn't being called by Offensive linemen before you even think about helping out the powerback. It's plain and simply ridiculous that a linemen can hold you and prevent you from having a chance of making a tackle on a runningback, when he's on the opposite side of you with no leverage.
 
DennisRodman
offline
Link
 
<3 ken

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347063&pbp_id=1181390
 
skeets4001
offline
Link
 
The best fix would be a stat decrease after a broken tackle. You don't see backs running into 3 people and breaking 3 tackles simultaneously, you are slower, off balance, and easier to tackle when you are breaking a tackle from another member of the defense.

In my mind, carry should also be affected with the decrease, a perfect example would be Adrian Peterson, he runs like an animal but if he tries to stay upright with 2-3 guys hanging on him, he fumbles quite often.
 
Link
 
hits like this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_dm9p03Usw
 
Gazeruth
offline
Link
 
To add my 2 cents in here.. I always thought of Strength as how hard you hit someone.. and Tackling determines how well you tackle someone.

Obviously a lot of strength with low tackling, in this case can still allow players to "bounce" out of the tackle, but a lot of tackling with low strength can allow a player to be run over, or at least fall forwards.

Going back to Bort's question, I'd say you need tackling AND strength at 60-70 to tackle him every time
 
Link
 
Bort cmon...Even the lowliest of CBs can tackle the big guy if they go low. The strength/tackling shouldnt both have to be capped. I dont know.
All I know is this is bullshit dude.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=294205&pbp_id=1601650
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.