User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
Originally posted by jrry32

5 points of attribute value from 100 to 95 is like 90 skill points. I am being realistic, I am using this thing called math. I don't see how 12 SPs = 92 SPs.


Did you spend 90 SP getting an attribute from 95 to 100? Let me answer for you ---- NO....

It would have been stupid to do that....and you know it, so it's a stupid argument....

For a player at level 74, in first season of decline, age 441-480, first would never be able to EARN 92 SP to HAVE them to spend....

He would have been able to EARN 120 BTs, plus the actual training value on an attribute....so BT conversion is 10 SP, and at best for a level 74 player, training value could have generated 40 * 5% or 8 SP, so MAYBE 18 SP.....but not on a top attr...

For a top attribute, he would have maybe 1 (assuming 12:1 conversion on an attribute) attribute point and maybe 1 point from training value....


lolno

And an attribute that would get 5% progress would be at 50 so that's actually 4 SP.

As for the 95-100, you might not have SPENT the SP but you still gained those SPs from proper planning and thus still lose them. If your only argument is that ALGs did it so you lose nothing then lololololololololol.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
For a player at level 74, in first season of decline, age 441-480, first would never be able to EARN 92 SP to HAVE them to spend....


You don't understand. It's not that you earned 92 SPs on your build at age 441-480. It's that you get 92 SPs taken away from your build by the decline. There's no way that you make that up with BTs.
Edited by TrevJo on Jun 25, 2010 16:26:45
Edited by TrevJo on Jun 25, 2010 16:23:41
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
That's not math, that is an accounting trick....

Did you spend 90 SP getting an attribute from 95 to 100? Let me answer for you ---- NO....

It would have been stupid to do that....and you know it, so it's a stupid argument....

For a player at level 74, in first season of decline, age 441-480, first would never be able to EARN 92 SP to HAVE them to spend....

He would have been able to EARN 120 BTs, plus the actual training value on an attribute....so BT conversion is 10 SP, and at best for a level 74 player, training value could have generated 40 * 5% or 8 SP, so MAYBE 18 SP.....but not on a top attr...

For a top attribute, he would have maybe 1 (assuming 12:1 conversion on an attribute) attribute point and maybe 1 point from training value....


That's not the point.

We lose 5% because we got 80 extra TPs. Those 80 extra TPs are no where near the value of losing 5% of your physical attributes.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
I can sympathize with both sides of this debate, for players with dots who would be just under 480 days old at the end of the season the previous announcement had to look like Christmas. Meanwhile the extra season of development is a clear advantage. However this suggestion looks interesting:

Originally posted by im4ut999
Two wrongs don't make a right....

How about allowing a "buyback" of the 5% penalty using TP and/or BTs since those are the "value" generated.
80 TP = 5%
120 BT = 5%

Allow a 1 time "sell" of equipment upgrades to get 120 BTs.

At least players would have an option of getting SOME of the penalty back to a more reasonable value....


If the advantages of the extra season were essentially removed, it would be a win/win.

I'd slightly tweak the numbers though. 56 days of training on light = 168 BT's. Then you also have to consider the training itself which has some value even on light, lets call this the equivalent of 82 BT's. For a total buyback value of 50BT's = 1%decline.

So for players in that tricky 440-480 range, they'd have their VP's reset. And they'd have the option to repurchase decline at 50BT's per 1%.

 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Imo, anyone who as counting on BTs for their decline season to finish off AE is either...

(a) A high level player who should have been optimizing their player for before the decline season anyhow. Also the addition of the new training system this season gave them more AE upgrades than they would have had anyhow

or

(b) Is a low level guy who has plenty of time to adjust the change (though again I'd contend they should have been planning to finish equip before their final decline season anyhow (not during it).

Imho, all this "we need another 40 days to train" stuff is complete bs. Its because of complaints/wineing like this, that the true complaints get ignored. Having 3 seasons of true decline > 2 seasons of true decline. Imho anyone complaining about the end of training at day440 should be happy for the extended plateau and stop acting like their goal for their dot all along was to have a 3rd or 4th piece of AE ready for their season of 1-5% decline.

/mini-rant
 
Gunner65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mstr_October


Why do you not understand how much time, effort and planning that we do based on announcements? I spent countless hours of the past 2 days re-working recruiting and trying to get our Season 17 team set up. How can you just nuke it like this?



Your first mistake ... assuming that they actually give a hoot about what you do or think ... its all about making a game built on logic ... as illogical as possible
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
I can sympathize with both sides of this debate, for players with dots who would be just under 480 days old at the end of the season the previous announcement had to look like Christmas. Meanwhile the extra season of development is a clear advantage. However this suggestion looks interesting:

Originally posted by im4ut999

Two wrongs don't make a right....

How about allowing a "buyback" of the 5% penalty using TP and/or BTs since those are the "value" generated.
80 TP = 5%
120 BT = 5%

Allow a 1 time "sell" of equipment upgrades to get 120 BTs.

At least players would have an option of getting SOME of the penalty back to a more reasonable value....


If the advantages of the extra season were essentially removed, it would be a win/win.

I'd slightly tweak the numbers though. 56 days of training on light = 168 BT's. Then you also have to consider the training itself which has some value even on light, lets call this the equivalent of 82 BT's. For a total buyback value of 50BT's = 1%decline.

So for players in that tricky 440-480 range, they'd have their VP's reset. And they'd have the option to repurchase decline at 50BT's per 1%.



Only 40, Saris. They don't get the 8 days of post-season if Bort moves this in immediately and those 8 days of pre-season was done before they hit day 441.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
That change makes no sense. If you're removing the extra VAs, then why do you need to keep the decline?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by jdbolick

That change makes no sense. If you're removing the extra VAs, then why do you need to keep the decline?


Because they want to piss everyone off.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Only 40, Saris. They don't get the 8 days of post-season if Bort moves this in immediately and those 8 days of pre-season was done before they hit day 441.


Ok tweaking the numbers then would give 120 BT's, and 40 BT's worth of training, for 32 BT's per 1%, that sounds pretty reasonable.
Edited by Saris on Jun 25, 2010 16:26:49
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

That change makes no sense. If you're removing the extra VAs, then why do you need to keep the decline?


I agree with this 100%. but you need to balance the training for younger dots so nobody is at a disadvantageOriginally posted by jrry32
Because they want to piss everyone off.
They just have no clue about how this game is played and how dots are planned out. The game is way beyond their grasp, and they have 0 clue what its like to be an average user playing this game.

 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
ANNOUNCEMENT

Nothing will change this offseason while we pull our heads out of our booties and make changes that actually make sense to a majority of the GLB community and not just a few guys sitting in a room who like to make changes and then change those changes 24 hours later only to realize they swung the pendulum to far again.
___

^^^ Admins, you can just copy and paste that and thank me later ^^^
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by jrry32

Only 40, Saris. They don't get the 8 days of post-season if Bort moves this in immediately and those 8 days of pre-season was done before they hit day 441.


Ok tweaking the numbers then would give 120 BT's, and 40 BT's worth of training, for 32 BT's per 1%, that sounds pretty reasonable.


I don't have those BTs.

I DEMAND LESS OF A DECLINE!
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by jdbolick

That change makes no sense. If you're removing the extra VAs, then why do you need to keep the decline?


So that it's fair, obviously. Why else would they announce something then change it 3 days later after people had already resigned players and were going to keep their S5 Dots
 
coach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Mostly it's just annoying to have something promising and then have the rug pulled out from under you, time and time again.


http://img651.imageshack.us/img651/4900/mysuperlamepica2407df94.jpg
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.