User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
this is a terrible idea bort... what if the NFL reshuffled next season and lumped all the best teams together

I know it was voted for in the poll.. but it seems every poll you do has people voting for something they ultimately wind up hating
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ElvisTCB
this is a terrible idea bort... what if the NFL reshuffled next season and lumped all the best teams together

I know it was voted for in the poll.. but it seems every poll you do has people voting for something they ultimately wind up hating


That's what I said.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Which ones are the gold leagues. Spell that out and I can probably get on board with it. I just don't see how you can promote the winner of 38 #8 the same as you do the winner of 38 #3...


The top half (rounded down to closest 32) at this point are the "top" leagues. So 38's "top" leagues are 1-3.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I thought this was about lining my pockets from low leveled teams? Which is it?

I agree SSB teams have caused problems and we should do something to curtail the practice (though it's not really all that prevalent as a strategy now), but if there are 3 of them in one tier, they just get to play 29 CPU's?


Yes that would help end it.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
And if they promote and move horizontally together, those 16 "bad" teams will play the 16 "good" teams the next season and likely be a great matchup.

Uhm ... no, they don't. The 16 "bad" teams that got to promote two tiers will be at a higher tier than the 16 "good" teams that only promoted once. Moreover, those 16 good teams that got left behind because of your new structure will completely obliterate the really bad teams left over from the "copper" leagues who couldn't even make the playoffs against the worst competition you could find at that tier. Meanwhile the 16 bad teams who made the playoffs in the terrible leagues will end up getting obliterated next season because they won't be ready for the level they'll be joining. Your system actually makes a bigger mess of S15 than the current system would, and the current system royally sucks.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by Bort

I thought this was about lining my pockets from low leveled teams? Which is it?

I agree SSB teams have caused problems and we should do something to curtail the practice (though it's not really all that prevalent as a strategy now), but if there are 3 of them in one tier, they just get to play 29 CPU's?


Yes that would help end it.


Yeah, anything else is just rewarding them, while punishing the people that actually built their teams the correct way.
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
I've already found one 16-0 team that landed in a creampuff conference compared to the stacked one I landed in.. where's the fairness there? Put my team in that conference and move the 16-0 one to mine (we finished 14-2)
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
If Bort really, really, really wants this format for some reason, then a potential solution is to have more than just the 16 playoff teams promote two tiers out of the "best" leagues while allowing fewer than the 16 playoff teams make it out of the "worst" leagues. So maybe to advance two tiers out of the "copper" cap 30 leagues, you'd need to win your first playoff game. And to advance two tiers out of the "gold" cap 30 leagues, you'd need to finish 12th or higher in your conference.


There ya go...something like that, at least. And the gold champs always move up 3.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The top half (rounded down to closest 32) at this point are the "top" leagues. So 38's "top" leagues are 1-3.


So 4-9 are going to promote horizontally instead of vertically? Or less vertically than 1-3? Because I can live with that.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by shield.bearer

Which ones are the gold leagues. Spell that out and I can probably get on board with it. I just don't see how you can promote the winner of 38 #8 the same as you do the winner of 38 #3...


The top half (rounded down to closest 32) at this point are the "top" leagues. So 38's "top" leagues are 1-3.


It's all relative.

There are 32 teams in that league, 3 of which are SSB teams. Those 3 SSB teams are going to ruin the league, for the other 29 teams in that league.

What's worse?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ElvisTCB
I've already found one 16-0 team that landed in a creampuff conference compared to the stacked one I landed in.. where's the fairness there? Put my team in that conference and move the 16-0 one to mine (we finished 14-2)


The fairness if you get a competitive season.

Congratulations.
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
this is a mess.... there are ALWAYS going to be bad teams.. you can't just wave a magic wand and fix it like you attempted to...

we get punished for doing good now... AWESOME..

 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ElvisTCB
this is a mess.... there are ALWAYS going to be bad teams.. you can't just wave a magic wand and fix it like you attempted to...

we get punished for doing good now... AWESOME..



Exactly.

This is how GLB has been from the beginning.

Punish the good agents, reward the bad.

Bort has to make sure that those bad agents keep buying flex, which would be in jeopardy is they actually played good teams like they were supposed to. Now they will go 10-6 (instead of 4-12) and be SO happy that they're doing well. Then they will continue to make dots, supporting Bort's pocket.

It is always about rewarding these shitty agents, so they keep playing the game. Some people just can't seem to see that.
Edited by Bukowski on Jan 21, 2010 12:18:43
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
There ya go...something like that, at least. And the gold champs always move up 3.

Ok, that sounds fine. I think the main thing people are concerned about is promotion. They don't want to get left behind just because you forced them into the toughest league, especially when it's already so difficult to make the Pros (much less the World League) with the same roster due to how many tiers you have to promote through. If a team in the "best" league struggles to a 5-11 record and yet still gets to promote two tiers, I think most would be ok with that.
Edited by jdbolick on Jan 21, 2010 12:18:04
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
The fairness if you get a competitive season.

Congratulations.


I didn't ask for one or sign up for one... people build bad teams.. it happens... and its not my fault
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.