User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
Page:
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
And what if 4 OPL are in the bottom 16 but you're only promoting 2 up from there.


The OPL loses two teams and one or two other regions gain a team. If OPL wants to expand their world league presence, they need to have their promoted teams make the playoffs. Easy as cheesy.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Hikariu

Originally posted by Hikariu


Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.





And what if 4 OPL are in the bottom 16 but you're only promoting 2 up from there.


Simple 2 go for natural demotion.

Next 2 go if they are any cut/cpu teams (most likely there will be)

Next 2 go back to OPL and when OPL demotion naturally occurs the 2 worst teams are demoted to AAA.
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
If you demote the bottom 16 teams in WPL is makes even teams out of the running have to fight to stay in the show.
 
VegasABD
offline
Link
 
Are you in favor of the World League, World Tournament, or neither?
World Champion League (promoted from Pro leagues)

231
World Champion Tournament (as posted today)

45
Neither. I like it the way it is now.

22

OH MY
 
Link
 
LOL DrkSandman
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Bort would just need to modify his natural demotion script to account for any extra demoted world league teams.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SheVegas
Are you in favor of the World League, World Tournament, or neither?
World Champion League (promoted from Pro leagues)

231
World Champion Tournament (as posted today)

45
Neither. I like it the way it is now.

22

OH MY


wait, you have these posted wrong

EDIT:

45 is for the tourney, 22 is for neither!
Edited by The Strategy Expert on Jul 27, 2009 19:05:50
Edited by The Strategy Expert on Jul 27, 2009 19:05:02
Edited by The Strategy Expert on Jul 27, 2009 19:03:56
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
LOL DrkSandman


QFT
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
Originally posted by SheVegas

Are you in favor of the World League, World Tournament, or neither?
World Champion League (promoted from Pro leagues)

231
World Champion Tournament (as posted today)

45
Neither. I like it the way it is now.

22

OH MY


Neither is up again a tiny amount.

See I'm telling you that "neither" is getting biased out due to the poll design. There should be a runoff poll done, with paragraph explanations for both, and then see how many votes "neither" would get, you could jack that up bigtime with some supporting rationale for each choice. (which in a sense the top one does as it states there's a fresh posting describing it right in the announcements, place an announcement pitch, or forum pitch for "neither" and then see what happens!)


How does "neither" need a description? It's for maintaining the status quo.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert

Originally posted by SheVegas


Are you in favor of the World League, World Tournament, or neither?
World Champion League (promoted from Pro leagues)

231
World Champion Tournament (as posted today)

45
Neither. I like it the way it is now.

22

OH MY


Neither is up again a tiny amount.

See I'm telling you that "neither" is getting biased out due to the poll design. There should be a runoff poll done, with paragraph explanations for both, and then see how many votes "neither" would get, you could jack that up bigtime with some supporting rationale for each choice. (which in a sense the top one does as it states there's a fresh posting describing it right in the announcements, place an announcement pitch, or forum pitch for "neither" and then see what happens!)


How does "neither" need a description? It's for maintaining the status quo.


EDIT: nvm I'm an idiot, the copy/paste is throwing the numbers off the visual alignment so I flip-flopped the "neither" and "tourney" numbers.

People like me however vote for "neither" NOT because I want status quo, but because I want a compromise of the other 2 options. i.e. I like a tourney to have some impact in the decision myself, but not in the way described "today". And I'm fine with not using a tourney, but also not in the way that has been described. So in either of those choices they aren't tailor made for an optimal solution, thus "neither" is a vote for an "abstention" to signal that the poll creator explore more definitive options regarding the other two, which is where the best solution lies.

Also, my other point is that there are active discussions in the forum talking about the tourney structure and much dissent in the forums that are swaying the voters. There is not a fair representation of all the options, including some options that aren't even on the poll. My point is that the best solutions for GLB aren't represented in the poll, nor adequately described. It's just done haphazardly and we don't have any way of qualifying what information the voters are using to make their decisions, or where they are getting the pros/cons for each decision. Overall things are just out of whack.

If you had a link to say a pros/cons thread for all choices and options possible, and the voter had to link through each thread and read each case before deciding, then these numbers would surely not be identical, they would be different, and in what way? You couldn't possibly know for sure unless each argument was logically presented and understood by each voter so that they are informed at a more qualified and fair fashion.
Edited by The Strategy Expert on Jul 27, 2009 20:37:59
Edited by The Strategy Expert on Jul 27, 2009 19:13:54
Edited by The Strategy Expert on Jul 27, 2009 19:11:34
 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
Well this thread died earlier than I thought.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RTJakarta
Well this thread died earlier than I thought.


Yeah, it was flurrious for a few hours then it hit a wall and the talk has moved to demotion discussions.
 
WinkYouOut
offline
Link
 
Once the poll came up, it died down.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
It's funny how once we opened up the discussion to the user base in regards to how to actually fix the problem, all the rioting kind of settled down.

I don't know why the user base isn't consulted more. Seems like there is a lot of one on one head banging with the developers and not enough town forum discussion.
 
Krille820
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
It's funny how once we opened up the discussion to the user base in regards to how to actually fix the problem, all the rioting kind of settled down.

I don't know why the user base isn't consulted more. Seems like there is a lot of one on one head banging with the developers and not enough town forum discussion.


Common sense FTW!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.