User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
on a pass block when Merriman (IIRC) had slowed to read the qb (he was totally looking over Pocket Hercules).


MJD's Timing, aggression, leverage was > steroid freak Merriman's passiveness and tippey toeing at that moment in time. Heheheh, and it was quite friggin funny.
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 14:26:45
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Originally posted by EastBayFunk

Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


>_>

and MJD blew up Merriman (a huh LB) on a block.


that was halarious
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 14:24:24
 
vt_dolfan
offline
Link
 
Quite honestly....

If we are talking trying to be as close to real football..while also fitting inside a "video game" theme....

A great power runner can run through guys with even more strength then they have....BUT...a backer who isnt quite as strong with perfect tackling technique will drop a back every day and twice on Sunday...

See..IMO...

If I could decide what goes in....

I would build a football intelligence attribute. Look at a guy like Zach Thomas...not all world physical ability..but...he knew the game so well...hed be there to make the tackle BEFORE the runner got there....but because he was small...he could be taken out by a great center like Mawai when he played for the Jets...

I would say a LB to stop this type of back...

Should have at least 60 Str...60 Vision...and 60 agility...AND soft capped stamina and confidence. Confidence is huge...your getting ready to lower your shoulder into Larry Csonka...you better have high confidence or your not gonna get set correctlty to make the tackle.

Confidence is what you have in yourself to play your position the way its supposed to be done.

But also...I think it needs to be alot more difficult to get to 100 of any attribute than it is....and 100 should be the max....I think once it gets to say...75...the only way you can get any better...is by training it...no more EQT points. Only Training...and it should be costly training..if you truly want to seperate yourself and make yourself elite..you gotta put the time in training....
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
You do realize that having Strength and Tackling at the 3:1 (60 raw) means that your other attributes will suffer as a result.. meaning you're going to have a guy who cannot get into position to make a tackle because his vision/speed/agility will be at a minimum soft capped.

I think having the two attributes =100 should hit a power back and get drug for a few extra yards while 120-130 should stop him in his tracks. Again this is going to be positionally dependent like speed is.. CBs/FS's shouldn't need that much STR and TCKL to make tackles. If you're going to penalize the fat guys in speed, you should be able to buff the CB's and FS's.

 
spacetime
offline
Link
 
I say someone at soft caps should have about 40% chance of tackling that guy.

Someone in the 70-80's range for str/tac should have 90% chance of tackling him. Plus whatever modifiers their VA's get.
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 17:36:44
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Here is my proposal:

To have a good chance (~80%) of tackling said power back, a defender should have roughly 70 Str and 50 Tackling. More of either one would make up some for a deficiency in the other, but not perfectly (that is, 100 Strength and 20 Tackling would be a fair bit worse; maybe 50% or less). A defender with 40 Strength and 40 Tackling should probably have a 50/50 shot or so to bring down the back, or at least to slow them enough to let someone else catch up and bring them down.

In addition (and it may already be this way), each additional tackle attempt within some short-ish frame of time should have a dramatically increased chance of success.
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
CBs/FS's shouldn't need that much STR and TCKL to make tackles.


Most absurd statement I've ever read on this forum.

 
Romeorr
offline
Link
 
depends on the weight of the player and how his tackling style is set. Obviously someone weighing 270+ would need less strngth and tackling than someone weighing 180. Also wrap up would need slightly less str, than balanced and power tackling. If i made the formula id put

x is equal to or greater than y than (80%) tackling chance

x is lessthan y but greater than or equal to z than 50% tackling chance

x is less than z but greater than Q than 25% tackling chance

x = str + agi + vision + confidence + tackling

y should be a high enough number that would be optimal for 80% tackling ratio

z should be 50% ratio

q should be 25% ratio
Last edited Jan 2, 2009 03:43:01
 
mikeedangerr
offline
Link
 
So many people are putting stat numbers far far too high imo.

Mention of 150 combined?

I'd say about 90.

55 tackling / 35 strength.

50/60 speed agility isnt going to be higher than many DB's at the same level, so if you're faster than him, he ain't getting away once you're all over him. The chances of his abilities triggering is higher too, so he would probably break free on them plays, but defenders have them too, Linemen and LB's especially, as backs, they're gonna have more pass orientated abilities most the time so perhaps the RB plows through them more often, but he'd have to be considerably slowed down allowing LB's to get back with him and bring him down.
 
mikeedangerr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Have to add a modifier to slow true power backs down to allow for gang tackling. Let them carry a few guys down the field and they'll be happy.


You're probably right - I could see some giddy power back owners laughing as their dot carries a CB dot down the field for 3-4 yards. That's better than just smashing through him LOL.


Isnt that what you want from a true power back though? Trucking someone is always nice, but lets face it, who didnt enjoy watching Michael Turner drag defenders along the floor for 5-6 yards before being brought down
 
Larry Legend
offline
Link
 
why wasn't larry allen a running back.

i mean the dude could bench 700 pounds. people should just bounce right off him and he should jaunt down the field screaming 'power through' 'power through'

str should have very little to do with runningbacks IMO
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
Again this is going to be positionally dependent like speed is.. CBs/FS's shouldn't need that much STR and TCKL to make tackles. If you're going to penalize the fat guys in speed, you should be able to buff the CB's and FS's.



This is phenomenally backwards.
Last edited Jan 2, 2009 10:24:06
 
whatspeakyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Legend
why wasn't larry allen a running back.

i mean the dude could bench 700 pounds. people should just bounce right off him and he should jaunt down the field screaming 'power through' 'power through'

str should have very little to do with runningbacks IMO


obviously you know nothing about running backs then?

Go take your RL 10 strength and go tackle Brandon Jacobs. And then tell me his strength is irrelevant.

You failed to mention that Larry Allen was 325 pounds. Kinda hard to juke to a hole or build up speed... or have a burst at all... at 325 pounds.


If you're going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?
Last edited Jan 2, 2009 10:27:54
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Legend
why wasn't larry allen a running back.

i mean the dude could bench 700 pounds. people should just bounce right off him and he should jaunt down the field screaming 'power through' 'power through'

str should have very little to do with runningbacks IMO


Dumb statement. Strength is far more than how much weight someone can bench press... ever hear of leg strength? Earl Campbell had tree trunks for thighs.

The real problem is that strength is only half of the equation, balance is the other half. Agility and strength should effect a player's chance to break a tackle. Strength to drive through a tackler and agility to see if you maintain your balance to keep going.

Edit: Actually now that I think about it... the ball-carrier's (strength + agility)/2 + carrying.... vs the tackler's (strength + agility)/2 + tackling = bonus to make or break tackle.
Last edited Jan 2, 2009 10:36:17
 
Larry Legend
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whatspeakyou


obviously you know nothing about running backs then?

Go take your RL 10 strength and go tackle Brandon Jacobs. And then tell me his strength is irrelevant.

You failed to mention that Larry Allen was 325 pounds. Kinda hard to juke to a hole or build up speed... or have a burst at all... at 325 pounds.


If you're going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


and you failed to mention brandon jacobs has run a sub 4.5 40 yard dash.

if your going to use real life as a basis for this game, don't be retarded when you do it. kay?


besides, id woops his ass, hed get hurt throwing his first punch.
Last edited Jan 2, 2009 11:25:07
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.