User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
My conference was plenty competitive.

Now it is a complete cluster fuck of elite SSB teams.

So how is that fair? My team that was normally built, having to go against Season 7 SSB teams, that are all level 35's?

We're going to lose recruits, fan support and playoff revenue.


So maybe make a suggestion about gold leagues getting extra cash or having higher min fan support, that the lower leagues don't get. Incentivise trying to do well and compete with the big boys. There's lots of ideas to explore that will get us further than sitting around hand-wringing.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Ah, so you bitch about uncompetitiveness, but bitch when you aren't guaranteed a playoff spot.

The obvious flaw in grouping the supposed 32 best teams is that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them won't make the playoffs. Similarly, grouping the supposed 32 worst teams in a tier means that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them will. So under this system we're absolutely certain that 16 bad teams will promote two tiers, as well as that 16 "good" ones will only promote one tier.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

My conference was plenty competitive.

Now it is a complete cluster fuck of elite SSB teams.

So how is that fair? My team that was normally built, having to go against Season 7 SSB teams, that are all level 35's?

We're going to lose recruits, fan support and playoff revenue.


So maybe make a suggestion about gold leagues getting extra cash or having higher min fan support, that the lower leagues don't get. Incentivise trying to do well and compete with the big boys. There's lots of ideas to explore that will get us further than sitting around hand-wringing.


You messed up - again.

I don't care what you say.

The people that aren't associated with these leagues are singing your high praise, which is what you're listening to.

Everyone else that is actually associated with shit shit, is beyond upset, which you've closed your ears to.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
You don't sort again. You make teams even out horizontally as they move up.


Teams that are not good enough to win XX caped leagues are going to and they are going to promote and they are going to get placed somewhere. They are going to promote faster than they should.

On the opposite side very good teams are going to miss the playoffs and move up 1 cap and they are going to be much insanely better than where they end up next season.

How does anything you plan on doing next season solve these two problems. All I see is an idea that will cause huge problems next season.

If you stunt a teams promotions just one season it may keep them significantly better than their competition for 3 or 4 seasons.

If you promote a team multiple caps early it may hurt them for a few seasons.

This season is what it is. What is the exit strategy out of this. It seems to me like a lot of teams are going to be pushed to places they should not be next season and that is going to take a long time to fix. The people that are going to be hurt are those teams that next season will be somewhere that they should not be.
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Deathblade

Ah, so you bitch about uncompetitiveness, but bitch when you aren't guaranteed a playoff spot.

The obvious flaw in grouping the supposed 32 best teams is that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them won't make the playoffs. Similarly, grouping the supposed 32 worst teams in a tier means that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them will. So under this system we're absolutely certain that 16 bad teams will promote two tiers, as well as that 16 "good" ones will only promote one tier.


sorry all I read was "wahhhhhhhhhhhh the game is competitive"
 
Skarie1523
offline
Link
 
Any idea when the new teams will be released?
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Deathblade

Ah, so you bitch about uncompetitiveness, but bitch when you aren't guaranteed a playoff spot.

The obvious flaw in grouping the supposed 32 best teams is that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them won't make the playoffs. Similarly, grouping the supposed 32 worst teams in a tier means that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them will. So under this system we're absolutely certain that 16 bad teams will promote two tiers, as well as that 16 "good" ones will only promote one tier.


Thank you.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So maybe make a suggestion about gold leagues getting extra cash or having higher min fan support, that the lower leagues don't get. Incentivise trying to do well and compete with the big boys. There's lots of ideas to explore that will get us further than sitting around hand-wringing.


Which ones are the gold leagues. Spell that out and I can probably get on board with it. I just don't see how you can promote the winner of 38 #8 the same as you do the winner of 38 #3...
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

The obvious flaw in grouping the supposed 32 best teams is that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them won't make the playoffs. Similarly, grouping the supposed 32 worst teams in a tier means that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them will. So under this system we're absolutely certain that 16 bad teams will promote two tiers, as well as that 16 "good" ones will only promote one tier.


And if they promote and move horizontally together, those 16 "bad" teams will play the 16 "good" teams the next season and likely be a great matchup.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
If Bort really, really, really wants this format for some reason, then a potential solution is to have more than just the 16 playoff teams promote two tiers out of the "best" leagues while allowing fewer than the 16 playoff teams make it out of the "worst" leagues. So maybe to advance two tiers out of the "copper" cap 30 leagues, you'd need to win your first playoff game. And to advance two tiers out of the "gold" cap 30 leagues, you'd need to finish 12th or higher in your conference.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

My conference was plenty competitive.

Now it is a complete cluster fuck of elite SSB teams.

So how is that fair? My team that was normally built, having to go against Season 7 SSB teams, that are all level 35's?

We're going to lose recruits, fan support and playoff revenue.


So maybe make a suggestion about gold leagues getting extra cash or having higher min fan support, that the lower leagues don't get. Incentivise trying to do well and compete with the big boys. There's lots of ideas to explore that will get us further than sitting around hand-wringing.


Incentivise at the top, and punish at the bottom - "suggested prices" for tickets in the crap 38 capped leagues needs to be lower than it is now, fan support should have a maximum number that it can't get over. Make teams want to go up and over.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Triple_A
+1000
I mentioned this too. This means that you will face the championship team every season.


If everyone was the same level, and created around the same time it wouldn't be as bad.

But in the current system, once a team has a level advantage in a league, they maintain it throughout the capped leagues.

Add in SSB teams and it gets even nastier. 3 Cap jumps for conference championships would help. At least you wouldn't have to roll out the championship rug for the same team season after season..
 
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by Deathblade


Ah, so you bitch about uncompetitiveness, but bitch when you aren't guaranteed a playoff spot.

The obvious flaw in grouping the supposed 32 best teams is that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them won't make the playoffs. Similarly, grouping the supposed 32 worst teams in a tier means that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them will. So under this system we're absolutely certain that 16 bad teams will promote two tiers, as well as that 16 "good" ones will only promote one tier.


sorry all I read was "wahhhhhhhhhhhh the game is competitive"



Then you need to read it again.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by jdbolick


The obvious flaw in grouping the supposed 32 best teams is that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them won't make the playoffs. Similarly, grouping the supposed 32 worst teams in a tier means that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them will. So under this system we're absolutely certain that 16 bad teams will promote two tiers, as well as that 16 "good" ones will only promote one tier.


And if they promote and move horizontally together, those 16 "bad" teams will play the 16 "good" teams the next season and likely be a great matchup.


LOL.

And the SSB builds will reign supreme again.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
The obvious flaw in grouping the supposed 32 best teams is that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them won't make the playoffs. Similarly, grouping the supposed 32 worst teams in a tier means that you're guaranteeing that 16 of them will. So under this system we're absolutely certain that 16 bad teams will promote two tiers, as well as that 16 "good" ones will only promote one tier.


Originally posted by 5STAR
sorry all I read was "wahhhhhhhhhhhh the game is competitive"
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.