User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
ggezhb
offline
Link
 
haha 89 pages.. well i'm certainly not gonna try to "catch up" so i'll just throw in some data...
i have a DT with 63 scouted tackling (so very high str/tackling/whatever) and i tried out power tackling today.

he made 1 tackle and missed 5.

so certainly he shouldn't be anywhere near 6 for 6, but uhm if he can't at least go 50% with it, would power tackling EVER be useful? it doesn't force enough fumbles (maybe 1-2 extra per season?) to be worth the trade off if you're gonna have to miss an extra 2-3 tackles a game.

and don't give me crap about just not using it, every option in the game should be balanced enough to be useful for someone/some build or it's just plain broken.
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ggezhb
haha 89 pages.. well i'm certainly not gonna try to "catch up" so i'll just throw in some data...
i have a DT with 63 scouted tackling (so very high str/tackling/whatever) and i tried out power tackling today.

he made 1 tackle and missed 5.

so certainly he shouldn't be anywhere near 6 for 6, but uhm if he can't at least go 50% with it, would power tackling EVER be useful? it doesn't force enough fumbles (maybe 1-2 extra per season?) to be worth the trade off if you're gonna have to miss an extra 2-3 tackles a game.

and don't give me crap about just not using it, every option in the game should be balanced enough to be useful for someone/some build or it's just plain broken.


what's his confidence level at? he might have been pretty demoralized from both missing tackles and fighting in the trenches?

 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Anyone else have a powerback that was very dominant last season and 1st scrimmage go to shit today.


My guy sure did

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=730931

I find it funny that the elusive with under 20 STR had 1 less broken tackle.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
OK, this game is pretty stupid

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=344567

Every run seems to be like this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344567&pbp_id=1160985



If those Powerbacks are gonna destroy everyone, whats the point of elusive backs. Even the best elusives aren't getting 5+ a carry.
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 13:05:25
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
OK, this game is pretty stupid

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=344567

Every run seems to be like this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344567&pbp_id=1160985



If those Powerbacks are gonna destroy everyone, whats the point of elusive backs. Even the best elusives aren't getting 5+ a carry.


Mine did last season and will this season tbh
 
seanb1979
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Faux Bear
Originally posted by ggezhb

haha 89 pages.. well i'm certainly not gonna try to "catch up" so i'll just throw in some data...
i have a DT with 63 scouted tackling (so very high str/tackling/whatever) and i tried out power tackling today.

he made 1 tackle and missed 5.

so certainly he shouldn't be anywhere near 6 for 6, but uhm if he can't at least go 50% with it, would power tackling EVER be useful? it doesn't force enough fumbles (maybe 1-2 extra per season?) to be worth the trade off if you're gonna have to miss an extra 2-3 tackles a game.

and don't give me crap about just not using it, every option in the game should be balanced enough to be useful for someone/some build or it's just plain broken.


what's his confidence level at? he might have been pretty demoralized from both missing tackles and fighting in the trenches?



yeah i was gonna say confidence is HUGE when tackling power backs
 
riccor25
offline
Link
 
Soft capping strength, tackling, and vision with 40+ confidence should work 85% of the time on the RB you mentioned Bort. In my opinion the player you described doesn't really exist in real life therefore it's impossible to compare it to real life, but I'll try.

DeMeco Ryans for instance.

He's slow for LB standards. He's also smallish, but he spends immense amounts of time in the film room and has a natural vision and nose for the ball. He rarely misses tackles, but he rarely makes spectacular plays. He's not Ray Lewis if you know what I mean, but he doesn't miss tackles.

I'm worried where this line of questioning is headed to be honest. I'm guessing people started making super human RBs that can't be tackled. I think you were on the right track a few seasons ago when you brought some of these builds back to earth by linking attributes for effectiveness.

I think cookie cutter builds should be avoided, and emphasis should be put on diversity, but at the same time.. DEs who can't bench press the bar, but can run a 4.25 didn't make sense to me. WRs who can't catch a cold, but could break land speed records didn't make sense to me so RBs who are stronger than Lineman don't make a whole lot of sense either. It seems like their biggest advantage would be their biggest problem as well.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
OK, this game is pretty stupid

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=344567

Every run seems to be like this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=344567&pbp_id=1160985



If those Powerbacks are gonna destroy everyone, whats the point of elusive backs. Even the best elusives aren't getting 5+ a carry.


Well, Bort should let RB's go at full speed on pitches.

But outside of that, you'll have to be patient as LB's adapt to the improvement of power backs. As more LB's are made to stop power backs, elusives (including mine) will perform better, because (as some people wrongly lamented) you can't make a LB who's great at stopping both.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by riccor25
Soft capping strength, tackling, and vision with 40+ confidence should work 85% of the time on the RB you mentioned Bort.


That's ridiculous. He listed the ultimate power back and you're saying simply soft-capping strength and tackling should stop him almost always, persumably so you can make LB's who almost always stop everyone.

The guy he mentioned (who I don't think could be built at today's levels) shouldn't be stopped even 75% of the time without 60+ Strength and 70+ Tackling. LB's have to learn to be great tacklers to stop guys who are both stronger than them and expert at breaking tackles (the latter is what 10 Power Thru means).

Otherwise, a CB should only have to soft-cap Speed and Agility to cover the best WR's (which is equally ridiculous, but only equally ridiculous).
 
riccor25
offline
Link
 
Well I didn't say just strength and tackling.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by riccor25
Well I didn't say just strength and tackling.


Also soft-capped Vision and 40 Confidence. Vision helps to get the chance to tackle him by reading the play, and might increase the tackle chances a bit by a better approach, but it's more about "if you get the chance to tackle him, what does it take?" And soft-capped Vision isn't all that much, either.

Confidence I don't think directly affects the play; it just helps keep morale up when you do miss a tackle. And again, 40 Confidence isn't that much. People neglect it, but Level 40 players of any sort should generally have at least 40 Confidence IMO, for their own good.
 
riccor25
offline
Link
 
It's just my opinion..

Sup par athletes makes tackles all the time in college and the NFL. I didn't even mention what I think his speed and agility should be.

They way I've stated it if the RB that Bort described met the LB I described in the hole the LB gets plowed over 15% of the time. If he doesn't have the speed, agility, and vision he doesn't ever even make it to the hole, but that's another topic. Obviously, higher strength and tackling would take that % much lower.
 
riccor25
offline
Link
 
Don't forget you also have to balance tactics too. 15% failure rate with wrap-up. 20% failure rate with balanced, and 25-35% failure with power.
 
ssaints4ever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EastBayFunk
Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


>_>

and MJD blew up Merriman (a huh LB) on a block.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
When we talk about tackling say a Brandon Jacobs - Strength is just one component of many necessary to tackle somebody - let alone a big back like say Brandon Jacobs.

In real life there are 3 components other than Strength that go into tackling a beast like Jacobs:

1) Being in the proper position to make a successful tackle (In GLB that would be Vision - i.e. football awareness). Low Vision guys would be more likely to do something they shouldn't - i.e. come straight at the ballcarrier instead of taking a better tackling angle.

2) Using proper technique - you don't arm tackle a beast like Jacobs and you certainly don't go after him up at the pad level - even guys like Ray Lewis wouldn't consistently make a living tackling a beast like that. (in GLB that would be Tackling).

3) Having the stones to even attempt the tackle in the first place (in GLB that would be Confidence) - think Deion Sanderclaus trying to seal the edge with Jacobs barreling down on him - hehe. A guy who never saw a tackle he wouldn't shy away from in run support.

The Strength disparity between the runner and the would-be tackler doesn't affect #1 at all, has some effect on #2 and probably has a greater effect on #3.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.