User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Xiong Yoshi...

If this idea gets endorsed then it would have to mean, imo, all players reaching prestige are NOT allowed to play in teams or leagues of non-prestige players. People who own teams not allowed to have teams of all their own players playing in like A5 league or friends allowed to bring all their players into a team etc, and the reverse of that, where teams in some new "prestige" league were not allowed to sign non-prestige players. And I dont like that idea either.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 17:36:52
 
Phaedron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Phaedron

Bort is totally trying to taunt me by posting in this thread and not the other one... epic fail!


I generally look at drifter's stuff, cuz it's good. Not that your's isn't...but I like to reply to well constructed and thought out suggestions with lots of potential, and I only have so much time.

Also, if you weren't aware (like if you didn't read the state of the game starting the season) we have some more player building stuff upcoming. Fame, training changes, and some cool new stuff for equipment.


That statement was totally a joke on my part Bort, but thanks for responding all the same

I can see why it'd take less time to implement this system over a whole level-activated 3rd SA tree like I suggested. Just keep an open mind about it for the future when you are um... bored? Not that I think you're in that position a lot, but you never know.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Imo, it's a well brought-together idea but it doesn't help the game. Creates more disparity between levels (more 100-0) scores, panders only to the veteran players (doesnt try to make the game better for noobs or back-ups) and isn't the right way to go about creating individualization/customization of players.

I'm not putting down the OP or the effort taken by him/her. I just don't agree that this idea is the right idea to implement. And if Bort is interested in over-hauling then I would think there are some better ideas already out there (including my 200 & new SA idea) that would be better long-term.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Xiong Yoshi...

If this idea gets endorsed then it would have to mean, imo, all players reaching prestige are NOT allowed to play in teams or leagues of non-prestige players. People who own teams not allowed to have teams of all their own players playing in like A5 league or friends allowed to bring all their players into a team etc, and the reverse of that, where teams in some new "prestige" league were not allowed to sign non-prestige players. And I dont like that idea either.


Why would it mean that? just because a L32/P7 is a lot better than a L27/P0 Player? Well the same argument could apply to the difference between L16/P0 and L13/P0 Players - there is a power difference so they shouldn't be allowed to be on the same teams?

What it really would mean is that Bort would need to seriously (read: manditorily) implement dramatic incentives for Players to play at as high leagues as they are able to. As long as there is no difference between Playing for BBB or Pro - the game will continue to be broken as hell.. regardless of whether this idea gets implemented or not. True, the game becomes "more broken" if this idea is implemented - but it's kinda irrelevent. Wait until level 40 Players are playing in BBB leagues.. where the hell is a level 8 player that just left D-Leagues going to compete? In a different game is where.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Xiong Yoshi...

If this idea gets endorsed then it would have to mean, imo, all players reaching prestige are NOT allowed to play in teams or leagues of non-prestige players. People who own teams not allowed to have teams of all their own players playing in like A5 league or friends allowed to bring all their players into a team etc, and the reverse of that, where teams in some new "prestige" league were not allowed to sign non-prestige players. And I dont like that idea either.


It's not that big of a discrepancy. As I posted earlier:

Originally posted by drifter

Again, the effects are fairly minor so a level 31 Prestige Level 5 character isn't going to be monstrously better than a level 30. Just a small amount. Now, a level 45, Prestige level 25 character is going to be quite a bit better than a Level 30 character but he should be - he's 50% higher than him in levels. That said, I do agree that I prefer some kind of tiered system than unlocking further abilities at higher levels.



If you have a problem with a player being better when he is 10 levels higher than the competition, then you probably shouldn't be playing any form of RPG. Significantly higher levels means significantly better players.

100-0 scores comes from stratification of levels not happening quickly enough. The game will still get there in time. I'm not sure what you think the solution is. If a team is 10 levels better than the competition do you really think it should be a competitive game?

If you make enough perks and add the ability to raise the soft cap there will be too many options for people to zero in on just one. You'll have attribute people raising soft caps and you'll have SA people focusing on perks. You'll also have people who want to just focus on one and make it great or those that want to take a more balanced approach. There will be plenty of differentiation.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Imo, it's a well brought-together idea but it doesn't help the game. Creates more disparity between levels (more 100-0) scores, panders only to the veteran players (doesnt try to make the game better for noobs or back-ups) and isn't the right way to go about creating individualization/customization of players.

I'm not putting down the OP or the effort taken by him/her. I just don't agree that this idea is the right idea to implement. And if Bort is interested in over-hauling then I would think there are some better ideas already out there (including my 200 & new SA idea) that would be better long-term.


This idea is nowhere near an overhaul. I'm not sure why you keep posting that. It fits perfectly into the existing system without changing anything that is already in place.

 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by GG

Xiong Yoshi...

If this idea gets endorsed then it would have to mean, imo, all players reaching prestige are NOT allowed to play in teams or leagues of non-prestige players. People who own teams not allowed to have teams of all their own players playing in like A5 league or friends allowed to bring all their players into a team etc, and the reverse of that, where teams in some new "prestige" league were not allowed to sign non-prestige players. And I dont like that idea either.


Why would it mean that? just because a L32/P7 is a lot better than a L27/P0 Player? Well the same argument could apply to the difference between L16/P0 and L13/P0 Players - there is a power difference so they shouldn't be allowed to be on the same teams?

What it really would mean is that Bort would need to seriously (read: manditorily) implement dramatic incentives for Players to play at as high leagues as they are able to. As long as there is no difference between Playing for BBB or Pro - the game will continue to be broken as hell.. regardless of whether this idea gets implemented or not. True, the game becomes "more broken" if this idea is implemented - but it's kinda irrelevent. Wait until level 40 Players are playing in BBB leagues.. where the hell is a level 8 player that just left D-Leagues going to compete? In a different game is where.



I'm all on board with more incentives to play at the higher levels. Bort is banking on fame and sportsmanship as being drivers but I think something else will be needed as well. We'll see
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I agree that vet players (and their agents) need more bells and whistles to make the game interesting/challenging for them, as their leveling has stalled. But there needs to be just as much thought (if not more) given to the noobs and the general back-ups and low level players. The people who quit GLB are more in the noob-range than the vet-range.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I agree that vet players (and their agents) need more bells and whistles to make the game interesting/challenging for them, as their leveling has stalled. But there needs to be just as much thought (if not more) given to the noobs and the general back-ups and low level players. The people who quit GLB are more in the noob-range than the vet-range.


The level caps have helped some. Hopefully fame and sportsmanship help more.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by GG

I agree that vet players (and their agents) need more bells and whistles to make the game interesting/challenging for them, as their leveling has stalled. But there needs to be just as much thought (if not more) given to the noobs and the general back-ups and low level players. The people who quit GLB are more in the noob-range than the vet-range.


The level caps have helped some. Hopefully fame and sportsmanship help more.


Level caps, as currently implemented, are a bandaid fix. Eventually all of the regions will be filled out, and either teams will have to be "recycled" or all future team purchases will come from pre-existing (and most likely) gutted teams located in non-capped leagues.

 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
I think this will be great with intergrading the teams with a mix of high level and lower level players.

Awsome concept. I'm all for it.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
I like the theory (see the other thread for my own thoughts on what should happen at higher levels - I'm all for ANYTHING that would make the game better for those of us with higher level players) but by adding in a new bunch of (what are effectively) SAs by any other name, are we not just introducing another set of potential bugs??

Given that some of the current SAs don't work and people are avoiding them more and more in favour of (mostly) more stable attributes, why introduce more that may (or may not) work and may (or may not) just add more bugs to an already pretty buggy game??
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Now this is a thread that I can get behind, ride hard and pull hair all the the same time.

It is nice to know bort has read my thread just deems it unworthy of his time... but that is ok, most of my ranting happens while I am at work and i dont' ahve the time to actually put the effort and thought that drifter has put into this concept. Though I am probably deemed as "trouible maker #1" from an episode with an owner in season one, and continuosly finding ways to get more out of the game.

Great job Drifter.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 18:31:09
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

This idea is nowhere near an overhaul. I'm not sure why you keep posting that. It fits perfectly into the existing system without changing anything that is already in place.



Im not putting you or your ideas down, drifter. You're always a great thinker and poster etc.

I read Bort said a few pages back that my 200/SA idea was "scrap everything" and wasnt presented well...but a) it wasnt scrapping everything at all, it was returning SPs to people and working on the SAME attribute system that exists now, people re-doing their players, b) was presented well but at the time GLB wasn't as in uproar over how the game was broken, and i became scapegoated by everyone. So it became easier to just put me down personally as well as my idea and chuckle at me not appreciating that the game IS broken and the warnings about people leaving and the 100-0 scores and noobs losing interest weren't being taken seriously....admin just seeing people at the time spend money and think i was an idiot.

It's interesting that in time, all the people who put me down back then are today now accepting the game is broken at the core player-build level and needs re-doing. Look at the people in my 200 thread back then mocking me then today and the last couple of months have all ended up creating threads demanding overhauls and being angry at the broken game.

im not jealous if Bort likes other peoples ideas more than mine. That's totally not it. I dont care where ideas come from, and it's just great to have Bort genuinely interested and commits to literally over-hauling/re-doing things to improve the game. But it is a slap in the face to say "drifter has good ideas and so i cant be bothered reading anyone elses". There are millions of pages of suggestions over the last 6 months that have been made and yet the effort to bring them to Bort has broken down and it's a matter of people bumping and rebumping threads hoping to get Bort to notice, and he doesnt always either due to his time-contraints.

For instance, how many weeks has that Individual Player Tactics thread been rebumping, and ive asked for it to be stickied because it's bringing together everyone's ideas into one thread...but Bort hasnt noticed it, it hasnt been stickied, and instead 50 other people create new threads on the same topic. Where's the effort to grab that thread and make it happen? It's not even a re-do of anything. Just adding more tactics to their players.

And just one more thing, about the idea in this thread itself....

While level 35 players with level 5 prestige may not be significantly stronger than level 28 players with 0 prestige, it IS. Because already today level 25 players destroy level 20 players. So it's like another 10+ levels amplified. Also, youre just going to see teams signing level 35-40 players to BBB teams etc because they can. Because admin dont want to 'forbid' people from owning teams and bringing in all their own players. Which I agree with. But this idea would only create more disparity between vets and noobs, and will need then to have people/friends not allowed to bring in their own players to prevent that disparity from imbalancing the leagues and creating 100-0 scores or the effect it will have on back-ups.

It's the noobs who need to be focused on, not the vets. The noobs (new customers who try and MAYBE buy) are the ones abandoning the game in droves. While I agree vets need new hoops to jump thru, the very fabric of player-creation needs an idea like 200 because it does address that whole disparity and customization of players, does focus on the noob and lessening the 100-0 scores. New bells and whistles for vets can still be implemented on top of a player building model such as the '200' one.

The priority or chronology of re-doing a more robust/customizable player building model needs to be first establishing a kind of '200' concept where noobs and vets are put on a level playing field, and then secondly looking to enhance the vet experience thru bells and whistles. Not the latter first.


 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kentrol72
I think this will be great with intergrading the teams with a mix of high level and lower level players.

Awsome concept. I'm all for it.


Yikes - last thing I want to see is a league where level 40 RBs are stomping the living shit out of level 15 teams.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.