You never really showed Break thru in action though.
SmithersOT
offline
offline
Originally posted by arteryman
You never really showed Break thru in action though.
How could he? Break Through is like multiplying something by zero, the end result is always nothing.
You never really showed Break thru in action though.
How could he? Break Through is like multiplying something by zero, the end result is always nothing.
tsherr
offline
offline
If break through works (heck, if any of the DT's SAs work), why doesn't Bort post a couple of examples and say something like "SAs only work about 10% of the time, so you might only see them once every 10 games." Or he could say "Break Through requires attribute X, so get that higher."
Since he hasn't, my only guess is that it doesn't work. Hopefully, he's added this to his list of things that need fixing.
T
Since he hasn't, my only guess is that it doesn't work. Hopefully, he's added this to his list of things that need fixing.
T
Jose Bagg
offline
offline
I don't think it means you are going to plow through the blocks and come out the other side with a free shot on the QB. It is a runstuffing skill. Have you ever seen your DT get double or tiple teamed and he still makes a tackle. I think that is break thru. I just don't think break thru has a nice visually correlated dot movement to judge it by.
CapnCrunch
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by tremele
Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.
Tremele,
The problem with using a single play as an example of things wrong is that there are multiple random rolls on every play. It means that every once in a blue moon, a Level 1 HB can actually get lucky and break tackles due to a variety of reasons. If that same level 1 HB is breaking tackles right and left every game, then you have a statitcial method to point that something might be wrong.
PinTBC
Indeed. A man who plays the lottery once can still win.
from a thread as to why a level 1 HB breaks tackles.... seems that there are standard answers that contradict each other but are used as convenient.
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by tremele
Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.
Tremele,
The problem with using a single play as an example of things wrong is that there are multiple random rolls on every play. It means that every once in a blue moon, a Level 1 HB can actually get lucky and break tackles due to a variety of reasons. If that same level 1 HB is breaking tackles right and left every game, then you have a statitcial method to point that something might be wrong.
PinTBC
Indeed. A man who plays the lottery once can still win.
from a thread as to why a level 1 HB breaks tackles.... seems that there are standard answers that contradict each other but are used as convenient.
Jose Bagg
offline
offline
Originally posted by CapnCrunch
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by tremele
Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.
Tremele,
The problem with using a single play as an example of things wrong is that there are multiple random rolls on every play. It means that every once in a blue moon, a Level 1 HB can actually get lucky and break tackles due to a variety of reasons. If that same level 1 HB is breaking tackles right and left every game, then you have a statitcial method to point that something might be wrong.
PinTBC
Indeed. A man who plays the lottery once can still win.
from a thread as to why a level 1 HB breaks tackles.... seems that there are standard answers that contradict each other but are used as convenient.
Examples?
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by tremele
Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.
Tremele,
The problem with using a single play as an example of things wrong is that there are multiple random rolls on every play. It means that every once in a blue moon, a Level 1 HB can actually get lucky and break tackles due to a variety of reasons. If that same level 1 HB is breaking tackles right and left every game, then you have a statitcial method to point that something might be wrong.
PinTBC
Indeed. A man who plays the lottery once can still win.
from a thread as to why a level 1 HB breaks tackles.... seems that there are standard answers that contradict each other but are used as convenient.
Examples?
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
I don't think it means you are going to plow through the blocks and come out the other side with a free shot on the QB. It is a runstuffing skill. Have you ever seen your DT get double or tiple teamed and he still makes a tackle. I think that is break thru. I just don't think break thru has a nice visually correlated dot movement to judge it by.
This is quite true. Break thru is not an actual "skill" per se. It's mainly just a bonus towards breaking the block when you're double teamed.
I don't think it means you are going to plow through the blocks and come out the other side with a free shot on the QB. It is a runstuffing skill. Have you ever seen your DT get double or tiple teamed and he still makes a tackle. I think that is break thru. I just don't think break thru has a nice visually correlated dot movement to judge it by.
This is quite true. Break thru is not an actual "skill" per se. It's mainly just a bonus towards breaking the block when you're double teamed.
CapnCrunch
offline
offline
Ok, could you go back to the original point:
Nobody is talking about anything except rushing plays when the NT is double teamed. Having 90 str and 9 in break thru results in breaking double team blocks zero times which is exactly equal to having 0 points in Break Thru.
If 90 str and 9 in Break Thru is not enough to get you to break the double team even once in 7 games, Break Thru is either busted or it is so ineffective as to be pointless. After 7 games, it has to be one or the other.
Oh, and before someone chimes in with Agility, I switched up the equipment so he has 73 str and 60 agility and again, zero break through.
Nobody is talking about anything except rushing plays when the NT is double teamed. Having 90 str and 9 in break thru results in breaking double team blocks zero times which is exactly equal to having 0 points in Break Thru.
If 90 str and 9 in Break Thru is not enough to get you to break the double team even once in 7 games, Break Thru is either busted or it is so ineffective as to be pointless. After 7 games, it has to be one or the other.
Oh, and before someone chimes in with Agility, I switched up the equipment so he has 73 str and 60 agility and again, zero break through.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 11:59:05
CapnCrunch
offline
offline
The thread that the quote was from...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=853494&page=2
and the follow up...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=854606
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=853494&page=2
and the follow up...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=854606
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 12:03:35
Laggo
offline
offline
Maybe break thru is just allowing your tackle radius to not get fucked by the blocks while double teamed as opposed to shedding the blocks entirely.
PROBLEM SOLVED
PROBLEM SOLVED
CapnCrunch
offline
offline
Originally posted by Laggo
Maybe break thru is just allowing your tackle radius to not get fucked by the blocks while double teamed as opposed to shedding the blocks entirely.
PROBLEM SOLVED
huh? so the solution is to make up a reason that has nothing to do with the SA and then be satisfied that all is well in the world? Maybe it really means that he wears better shoes so he can run faster, that works as well. Wait, maybe it means thta he gets a nice fish dinner at halftime. Hey, this works great!!!
(now to ensure its validity, Ill post in all caps!!)
PROBLEM SOLVED
Woot! Im a friggin genius!!!!
Maybe break thru is just allowing your tackle radius to not get fucked by the blocks while double teamed as opposed to shedding the blocks entirely.
PROBLEM SOLVED
huh? so the solution is to make up a reason that has nothing to do with the SA and then be satisfied that all is well in the world? Maybe it really means that he wears better shoes so he can run faster, that works as well. Wait, maybe it means thta he gets a nice fish dinner at halftime. Hey, this works great!!!
(now to ensure its validity, Ill post in all caps!!)
PROBLEM SOLVED
Woot! Im a friggin genius!!!!
Jose Bagg
offline
offline
Originally posted by CapnCrunch
The thread that the quote was from...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=853494&page=2
and the follow up...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=854606
I was wanting examples of contradictory explanantions. I think the explanation of those is quite clear to anyone who looks deeper than the replay. The team was up 56-0 early in the second quarter. The two DTs were completely worn down from covering 8 kickoffs in about 1 quarters time. You will recall that kick off coverage takes much more energy. So here you have two level 21 guys who are exhausted AND they are coasting because of the 56 point lead (a new feature for this season) and a level 1 HB breaks two of their tackles, but doesn't gain an extra yard from it because the first one he breaks gets up and finishes the job. Whats the problem.
The thread that the quote was from...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=853494&page=2
and the follow up...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=854606
I was wanting examples of contradictory explanantions. I think the explanation of those is quite clear to anyone who looks deeper than the replay. The team was up 56-0 early in the second quarter. The two DTs were completely worn down from covering 8 kickoffs in about 1 quarters time. You will recall that kick off coverage takes much more energy. So here you have two level 21 guys who are exhausted AND they are coasting because of the 56 point lead (a new feature for this season) and a level 1 HB breaks two of their tackles, but doesn't gain an extra yard from it because the first one he breaks gets up and finishes the job. Whats the problem.
CapnCrunch
offline
offline
I have no problem with any of that - I actually know very little about that thread, I am pointing out the explanation and how it conveniently applies to one thing but not another. If we could stay focused and not zip off on tangents every other post, that would be super.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 12:14:17
Jose Bagg
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78565&pbp_id=248851
I just did a little hunting on your DT, this was the second play I looked at.
In all fairness, I think this is break thru as well. It was the first play I looked at. It looks like the center tries to double, you break him off and he releases to the LB.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78565&pbp_id=245837
I just did a little hunting on your DT, this was the second play I looked at.
In all fairness, I think this is break thru as well. It was the first play I looked at. It looks like the center tries to double, you break him off and he releases to the LB.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78565&pbp_id=245837
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 12:17:32
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























