User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
Page:
 
Hoth-Boy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by Hoth-Boy

Since we are going to be taking bigger stamina hits each game, and over the season, are we going to get bye weeks in the schedule to help everybody recover/heal up?


Bye weeks in the NFL are not for injuries. Bye weeks in the NFL are to make the season longer so they can get more TV money.


The NFL may have put them in for money, but teams use them to heal and rest.
 
Solaris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Okole
I love the change, but one position I'd like to see handled a little differently is QB. While most teams rotate people at virtually all positions, the QB generally plays the whole game in the NFL. When you have a backup on your roster, he ends up getting in too much (and seemingly at the most inopportune times!)


Actually, you don't often see substitutions on the O-Line either. My suggestion would be to scale the energy "expended" based on "real-life" expectations. IOW, QB's "drain" at a lower rate than DT's (especially in a run-heavy offense...which is another nit).

Further, substitutions should be handled better (perhaps a tactic thing). In real-life, you don't see the starting RB run his 40 plays then drop out for the backup to run the remaining running plays. Perhaps an "in-game energy factor," that raises and lowers substantially (in a per-position scaled manner) on a per-play basis. You could manage substitutions such that the starting RB could take a breather after 3-4 runs in a row, which would give him a boost in "in-game energy" (allowing him to come back into the game, and drop out when necessary). Leave energy as a "season fatigue factor," that can only be recovered over time and gets lost in scaled-per-position manner much like you've established. The other obvious thing is that your starter would likely be out there to start a drive, having been resting on the sidelines while the other side played...You'd get effectively the same scale of substitution being managed without having teams dealing with a game that looks more like a pre-season game (with the backups playing the 4th quarter)...

yeah, I know, easy to suggest... ;-)


 
Link
 

Actually, you don't often see substitutions on the O-Line either. My suggestion would be to scale the energy "expended" based on "real-life" expectations. IOW, QB's "drain" at a lower rate than DT's (especially in a run-heavy offense...which is another nit).

Further, substitutions should be handled better (perhaps a tactic thing). In real-life, you don't see the starting RB run his 40 plays then drop out for the backup to run the remaining running plays. Perhaps an "in-game energy factor," that raises and lowers substantially (in a per-position scaled manner) on a per-play basis. You could manage substitutions such that the starting RB could take a breather after 3-4 runs in a row, which would give him a boost in "in-game energy" (allowing him to come back into the game, and drop out when necessary). Leave energy as a "season fatigue factor," that can only be recovered over time and gets lost in scaled-per-position manner much like you've established. The other obvious thing is that your starter would likely be out there to start a drive, having been resting on the sidelines while the other side played...You'd get effectively the same scale of substitution being managed without having teams dealing with a game that looks more like a pre-season game (with the backups playing the 4th quarter)...

yeah, I know, easy to suggest... ;-)




This is a great suggestion.

The biggest issue with substitutions at the moment is that they don't make tactical sense. As this poster stated, OL rarely rotate out, QBs never do unless there's a yanking or an injury.

Also, no coach would just run his players into the ground in the first half then rely on backups in the 4th quarter or OT.

Our team lost in the playoffs in OT with our 3rd and 4th stringers playing ... ugh.
 
jmadsen
offline
Link
 
I am going to play a starting QB next season, but I think it would be fine if GLB was different from RL football with regards to backups playing a lot more plays, also for QBs (and O-linesmen etc.).

Of course, as many people have stated, it's important that the "big guns" can be set to play the "crucial plays"/4th quarter/overtime/etc., but I don't think it would make the game any worse at all, if a team would benefit from having 2 QBs playing, say, 50/30 plays each.
 
mdibias33
offline
Link
 
I like the new substitution suggestions. I agree that our starting skill players seemed to be on the bench at inopertune times. I have a RB and it always seemed that he would return the kick or punt, be in the entire drive, and come out once we got inside the 5 yardline. It sucked because he didn't get any scores. They all wen t ot the back-ups.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Solaris
Originally posted by Okole

I love the change, but one position I'd like to see handled a little differently is QB. While most teams rotate people at virtually all positions, the QB generally plays the whole game in the NFL. When you have a backup on your roster, he ends up getting in too much (and seemingly at the most inopportune times!)


Actually, you don't often see substitutions on the O-Line either. My suggestion would be to scale the energy "expended" based on "real-life" expectations. IOW, QB's "drain" at a lower rate than DT's (especially in a run-heavy offense...which is another nit).

Further, substitutions should be handled better (perhaps a tactic thing). In real-life, you don't see the starting RB run his 40 plays then drop out for the backup to run the remaining running plays. Perhaps an "in-game energy factor," that raises and lowers substantially (in a per-position scaled manner) on a per-play basis. You could manage substitutions such that the starting RB could take a breather after 3-4 runs in a row, which would give him a boost in "in-game energy" (allowing him to come back into the game, and drop out when necessary). Leave energy as a "season fatigue factor," that can only be recovered over time and gets lost in scaled-per-position manner much like you've established. The other obvious thing is that your starter would likely be out there to start a drive, having been resting on the sidelines while the other side played...You'd get effectively the same scale of substitution being managed without having teams dealing with a game that looks more like a pre-season game (with the backups playing the 4th quarter)...

yeah, I know, easy to suggest... ;-)




if you saw what i posted before you know i am not a big fan of this new change, but I think it work if there is one easy advanced option added.
the sub out\in needs to be set per position not the entire team.
I think this is a critical and neccessary change since we have guys with different stamina and needs. It changes alot. When you dont have alot of depth at a position and they get warn out you dont what to affect the whole team for that position. Or 1 game you might focus on run, so you set the HB on a lower setting and save the QB or vise versa.

if this has been discused and implemented with the new changes then great. if not this is still a hard pill for me to swallow.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by uofi316

While I like the increased stamina role, I would like to see the "major update" to the tactics we can use. With the inceasing need for depth it would be nice to control who is in on what play. If you have a big HB and a speed HB, it would be beneficial to only have the speed guy in on outside runs, instead of tiring him out trying to run up the middle.

I know it takes time to modify all these things, it just seems like getting that done is the next logical step.


That's the next big update, for sure. Just gotta get past all the random little stuff getting ready for the next season and the new teams. Once season 2 is in swing, I plan to focus on getting that done as soon as I can.

I will probably start with the basic stamina settings per position, and then expand it to include some other options for crunch time overrides, and then finally add the major situational settings. A lot of the work with the major settings update is in entering and testing all the plays that will go with all the possible setting combinations.



never mind at my above post... the sooner the better on the per position stamina.
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud


if this has been discused and implemented with the new changes then great. if not this is still a hard pill for me to swallow.


I think I remember DD saying that the advanced tactics options that would let you set the sub out/in per position would get implemented sometime during season 2, maybe mid season 2 or something like that. That would mean a half season of figuring out how to best use your bench without a lot of options to do so, unfortunately.
 
trendon
offline
Link
 
SOB! I just started paring down my roster
 
porkies
offline
Link
 
About my previous post. I read it again today and it seemed long and whiny. I was trying to say that it would be nice to have another guide once the stamina update is completed so we know where we should be with stamina at a particular position and level. It would be even better if it was an "official" guide rather than a unofficial guide.
 
Carbor123
offline
Link
 
Maybe for the problem about the stamina for the Oline and QB, make a different sub in/ sub out bar for them. I would like to set my RB sub in/out around 85 and 90 so he is always fresh, and if i have depth at RB. My QB though, his bar would be around 30 and 40.
 
hud
offline
Link
 
seems like all the new teams cant go three deep. Hope the new change doesnt hurt the game
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
seems like all the new teams cant go three deep. Hope the new change doesnt hurt the game


It sure can't hurt anymore than having teams playing guys both ways to ramp XP...Or all players playing the entire game on either side of the ball because they don't have backups and their energy was restored after a couple of days training on relaxed. I suspect there will be a few minor issues with this, but guys can ALWAYS sign CPU players for depth if it becomes a problem. You may not want to, but no one gets everything they want in life.

Last edited Apr 24, 2008 15:17:14
 
mattydqb8
offline
Link
 
Can I just check (as a new GM of a team) are all subs used in games when starters stamia hits the set level?

Is there anyway of choosing percentage that starter v's 2nd string vs 3rd string etc will play?

If not could this be considered as seems hard to know how much time (as in plays) a back up will get when you are new to the stamina system? Plus this would help in contract discussions as you could be honest about rough playing time.

At the moment I am finding it hard to know how much 1st string v's 2nd string will get?
 
odt
offline
Link
 
I don't know if the 50 cutoff is low enough, there are a lot of players on a team who get over than currently and they shouldn't be hurt XP-wise
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.