This is exactly what happened to our team in the first round of the playoffs. The team that we played had level 10 starters at almost every position with zero subs behind them on the depth chart. Our team, filled with 9's and 10's got smoked 41-0 because we have a realistic depth chart with lower level guys backing up our starters. When the backups were subbed into the game they got exposed by the other teams level 10 players who should have been worn down by that point.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Jakemall
offline
offline
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
drifter
offline
offline
I absolutely think that Bort's initial concepts were right on the money. Low stamina should absolutely begin to cause you to perform worse as you get tired. Maybe instead of low Stamina making you get tired more quickly, it affects how much you are affected?
For example, Stamina 30 guy is going to be half effected by a low energy level as Stamina 15 guy and so on.
Also, the Energy Bar should definitely come into play more for players with low stamina. By the end of the season you should be thinking, "Maybe I need to rest my starters to get energy back up before the playoffs".
I had assumed this was already in place and am disapointed that Bort was convinced otherwise.
For example, Stamina 30 guy is going to be half effected by a low energy level as Stamina 15 guy and so on.
Also, the Energy Bar should definitely come into play more for players with low stamina. By the end of the season you should be thinking, "Maybe I need to rest my starters to get energy back up before the playoffs".
I had assumed this was already in place and am disapointed that Bort was convinced otherwise.
SoCalWhoDat
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by hud
#1 it was the alpha players who were telling everyone to pump skill points into stamina. We learned in the first season that stamina was by FAR the MOST important stat. Sounds like a real fun way to build, huh? We had no idea, no special insight, that it was gonna work like this.
This was exactly the problem. The only people who knew anything about the game kept telling us newcomers that stamina was SO IMPORTANT so we did what one would logically do in that situation. We pumped stamina and signed depth. Then at the end of the season we see that it was the people telling us stamina was SO IMPORTANT who disregarded it, signed minimal teams, and dominated their leagues. This seems a little shady to me.
Originally posted by hud
Let me ask it this way? If there were enough teams and good owners that we could have teams with 32 active players per team that got more PT and leveled up faster, wouldn't that be more fun that finding 52 players so you could have some sit the bench and hope to get 25% of the plays so he could level 25% as fast as the starters? Wouldnt be more ideal for all players to have 70-90 plays, than some having 60 while other hope to get 20 a game?
My answer to all of this is NO, it wouldn't be more fun. Maybe to you, but the huge outcry against these types of teams underscores the fact that most people would rather have the realism. And a note on realism, basically your argument against it centers on off-the-field issues and injuries, whereas most of our complaints are about on-the-field issues. You can have a realistic simulation of the actual football game and the tactics involved without injuries and off-the-field stuff. To say that because of one small aspect of the football experience, injuries and things that happen off-the-field, we should give up all hope of a realistic on-the-field simulation just doesn't compute.
Here is the best solution I have come up with, which involves combining several good ideas proposed by myself and others.
I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:
1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.
2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.
3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.
4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.
Originally posted by hud
Filling up a roster, worring about more inactives, balancing PT isn't fun to me.
What are you saying? If you hate these things don't be an owner or get a GM to do it for you, because that is what the game is. That would be like saying, "I want to have lots of players, but I hate managing them and their training and their skill points. That just isn't fun to me." It doesn't make any sense. As I have written elsewhere this is a Mass Multiplayer Online game, not a Mass Singleplayer Online game. Dealing with other people, and lots of them (cf. "Mass" in Mass Multiplayer...) is kind of part of the deal. If you hate that, then no one is twisting your arm and making you be an owner. I get tired of all this stuff too. So I went out and got talented GMs to help me.
Originally posted by hud
I play Madden and I adjust the staminas importance so I can play the stars. I want to see T.O. on the field, not Patric Crayton.
You sound like a very casual football fan who just likes to watch the stars and who cares very little about the rest. People like you don't realize that without the Patrick Craytons of the world, the TOs of the world wouldn't be that exciting. Also there are many, many people who are pretty dedicated football fans who follow teams and rosters and watch games for more than just seeing one or two stars play. I assure you there are lots of Cowboys fans, and even I, who am not a Cowboys fan, enjoy watching guys like Patrick Crayton and Sam Hurd and Tony Fasano and other guys who are not top 5 in their position. There is nothing wrong with your mindset oer se, but as I said, it would be a mistake to assume that everyone is as casual a fan as you make yourself seem.
Originally posted by hud
New casual players want to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic].
I simply couldn't disagree with you more. I own six teams and deal with tons and tons of players every day and the biggest three concerns they have are whether they will get playing time (not necessarily starting), will they be on a winning team, and will the team be a fun group of players they can intract with. I have never once heard a player say, "You know, I don't care about winning or being with cool people, or contributing to my team. I just want to see that little number by his name go up." I am sure there are people like this, but I would say they are less than 10% of the people I interact with, which is a substantial number. You have to realize that the number is just a number. If it doesn't somehow translate to more fun for you, who cares whether your DE is level 18 or 88? I think you assume (as many people do) that others think the same way as you and have the same values, when in reality this is rarely the case.
Edit: See the poster below me. He certainly doesn't seem to be the type of person who only wantsOriginally posted by hud
to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic]. The more people who post, the more it will become evident just how cynical and atypical your approach is.
Agree with you there, tpaterniti.
Hud, I'm sorry, but you HATE managing your team and just want to see the top tier guys go all out every game 100% of the time? Don't wanna scout for depth and perhaps groom players to be certain builds (as there are plenty of sponge-like minds that have joined that will believe their owner's opinion on good builds)? Then perhaps you should just be a player. I want a FOOTBALL sim. Since you were so quick to make examples of realism in the other direction, why don't we just go hyper-fantasy and bump everyone up to 100 on everything and just let it sim itself out over a few days? No management, no nothin'. Just make revenue and check stats. Now THAT sounds like fun, eh?
Originally posted by hud
#1 it was the alpha players who were telling everyone to pump skill points into stamina. We learned in the first season that stamina was by FAR the MOST important stat. Sounds like a real fun way to build, huh? We had no idea, no special insight, that it was gonna work like this.
This was exactly the problem. The only people who knew anything about the game kept telling us newcomers that stamina was SO IMPORTANT so we did what one would logically do in that situation. We pumped stamina and signed depth. Then at the end of the season we see that it was the people telling us stamina was SO IMPORTANT who disregarded it, signed minimal teams, and dominated their leagues. This seems a little shady to me.
Originally posted by hud
Let me ask it this way? If there were enough teams and good owners that we could have teams with 32 active players per team that got more PT and leveled up faster, wouldn't that be more fun that finding 52 players so you could have some sit the bench and hope to get 25% of the plays so he could level 25% as fast as the starters? Wouldnt be more ideal for all players to have 70-90 plays, than some having 60 while other hope to get 20 a game?
My answer to all of this is NO, it wouldn't be more fun. Maybe to you, but the huge outcry against these types of teams underscores the fact that most people would rather have the realism. And a note on realism, basically your argument against it centers on off-the-field issues and injuries, whereas most of our complaints are about on-the-field issues. You can have a realistic simulation of the actual football game and the tactics involved without injuries and off-the-field stuff. To say that because of one small aspect of the football experience, injuries and things that happen off-the-field, we should give up all hope of a realistic on-the-field simulation just doesn't compute.
Here is the best solution I have come up with, which involves combining several good ideas proposed by myself and others.
I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:
1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.
2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.
3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.
4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.
Originally posted by hud
Filling up a roster, worring about more inactives, balancing PT isn't fun to me.
What are you saying? If you hate these things don't be an owner or get a GM to do it for you, because that is what the game is. That would be like saying, "I want to have lots of players, but I hate managing them and their training and their skill points. That just isn't fun to me." It doesn't make any sense. As I have written elsewhere this is a Mass Multiplayer Online game, not a Mass Singleplayer Online game. Dealing with other people, and lots of them (cf. "Mass" in Mass Multiplayer...) is kind of part of the deal. If you hate that, then no one is twisting your arm and making you be an owner. I get tired of all this stuff too. So I went out and got talented GMs to help me.
Originally posted by hud
I play Madden and I adjust the staminas importance so I can play the stars. I want to see T.O. on the field, not Patric Crayton.
You sound like a very casual football fan who just likes to watch the stars and who cares very little about the rest. People like you don't realize that without the Patrick Craytons of the world, the TOs of the world wouldn't be that exciting. Also there are many, many people who are pretty dedicated football fans who follow teams and rosters and watch games for more than just seeing one or two stars play. I assure you there are lots of Cowboys fans, and even I, who am not a Cowboys fan, enjoy watching guys like Patrick Crayton and Sam Hurd and Tony Fasano and other guys who are not top 5 in their position. There is nothing wrong with your mindset oer se, but as I said, it would be a mistake to assume that everyone is as casual a fan as you make yourself seem.
Originally posted by hud
New casual players want to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic].
I simply couldn't disagree with you more. I own six teams and deal with tons and tons of players every day and the biggest three concerns they have are whether they will get playing time (not necessarily starting), will they be on a winning team, and will the team be a fun group of players they can intract with. I have never once heard a player say, "You know, I don't care about winning or being with cool people, or contributing to my team. I just want to see that little number by his name go up." I am sure there are people like this, but I would say they are less than 10% of the people I interact with, which is a substantial number. You have to realize that the number is just a number. If it doesn't somehow translate to more fun for you, who cares whether your DE is level 18 or 88? I think you assume (as many people do) that others think the same way as you and have the same values, when in reality this is rarely the case.
Edit: See the poster below me. He certainly doesn't seem to be the type of person who only wantsOriginally posted by hud
to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic]. The more people who post, the more it will become evident just how cynical and atypical your approach is.
Agree with you there, tpaterniti.
Hud, I'm sorry, but you HATE managing your team and just want to see the top tier guys go all out every game 100% of the time? Don't wanna scout for depth and perhaps groom players to be certain builds (as there are plenty of sponge-like minds that have joined that will believe their owner's opinion on good builds)? Then perhaps you should just be a player. I want a FOOTBALL sim. Since you were so quick to make examples of realism in the other direction, why don't we just go hyper-fantasy and bump everyone up to 100 on everything and just let it sim itself out over a few days? No management, no nothin'. Just make revenue and check stats. Now THAT sounds like fun, eh?
FBGBullDozier
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
drifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games.
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games. FBGBullDozier
offline
offline
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games.
The supposed injury updates should take care of that, should they not? How often do you see a team play a QB#2 for stamina reasons? When a team has secured a playoff spot, and sits a Peyton Manning for the second half of a meaningless game, is it to rest him physically, or to eliminate the injury risk of going back out on the field?
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games. The supposed injury updates should take care of that, should they not? How often do you see a team play a QB#2 for stamina reasons? When a team has secured a playoff spot, and sits a Peyton Manning for the second half of a meaningless game, is it to rest him physically, or to eliminate the injury risk of going back out on the field?
GRiPSSL
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kcirdor
I think suspensions are a good idea....
but anyway, other interactive stuff to do b/w games and in the postseason/offseason, will suppliment any loss of fun(PT) you are having. Stuff like signing in daily to click "show up for practice" on your player profile. The more people on your team that "show up for practice" the better your chemistry bonus ist or your whole team gets a bonus to training dependant the percent of players that "show up for practice"
The show up for practice idea is nice...its should add a small bonus to their training stat.
I think suspensions are a good idea....
but anyway, other interactive stuff to do b/w games and in the postseason/offseason, will suppliment any loss of fun(PT) you are having. Stuff like signing in daily to click "show up for practice" on your player profile. The more people on your team that "show up for practice" the better your chemistry bonus ist or your whole team gets a bonus to training dependant the percent of players that "show up for practice"
The show up for practice idea is nice...its should add a small bonus to their training stat.
Damazin1
offline
offline
I like the idea of stamina being important. It'd definately make depth more valuable, and allow backup players to get serious playing time.
I think in the long run, it's going to be tough to have any back up players. Because real players won't want to be backups, because they don't get enough XP to improve. I'd say set the energy level to HURT thin teams, because of lack of depth/stamina.
I think in the long run, it's going to be tough to have any back up players. Because real players won't want to be backups, because they don't get enough XP to improve. I'd say set the energy level to HURT thin teams, because of lack of depth/stamina.
drifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games.
The supposed injury updates should take care of that, should they not? How often do you see a team play a QB#2 for stamina reasons? When a team has secured a playoff spot, and sits a Peyton Manning for the second half of a meaningless game, is it to rest him physically, or to eliminate the injury risk of going back out on the field?
Both.
Anyway, it sounds like it is physical contact more than anything else that contributes to energy drain. A QB like Manning very rarely gets sacked and so wouldn't have the same issues as someone like Roethlisberger at the end of the season.
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games. The supposed injury updates should take care of that, should they not? How often do you see a team play a QB#2 for stamina reasons? When a team has secured a playoff spot, and sits a Peyton Manning for the second half of a meaningless game, is it to rest him physically, or to eliminate the injury risk of going back out on the field?
Both.
Anyway, it sounds like it is physical contact more than anything else that contributes to energy drain. A QB like Manning very rarely gets sacked and so wouldn't have the same issues as someone like Roethlisberger at the end of the season.
FBGBullDozier
offline
offline
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games.
The supposed injury updates should take care of that, should they not? How often do you see a team play a QB#2 for stamina reasons? When a team has secured a playoff spot, and sits a Peyton Manning for the second half of a meaningless game, is it to rest him physically, or to eliminate the injury risk of going back out on the field?
Both.
Anyway, it sounds like it is physical contact more than anything else that contributes to energy drain. A QB like Manning very rarely gets sacked and so wouldn't have the same issues as someone like Roethlisberger at the end of the season.
Exactly, which is why QBs shouldn't be penalized under a stamina system for playing every snap, and that there performance should only be hindered by the injury udpated, IMO.
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by FBGBullDozier
Originally posted by Jakemall
I can see both sides...
I think there should be some sort of balance. A definate push to keep teams from being 1 player deep, but I'd hate to see teams with 5 people at every position also. Look at most nfl teams and they have at least 1 back up for every position and often 2 back ups. Why should it be any different here? Oh and I liked the Bell Curve idea on fatigue. I also like the idea of energy level going lower through out the year. If people play hard every game, it should take a toll. At the same time, I don't want the backups to be more effective than the starters by the last couple of games of the year either.
The problem of trying to work in the realism of player fatigue over the course of a season is that in the NFL, it is positional. A QB can play every snap of every game over the course of the season, and he would not be significantly affected by it. At least not to the extreme that, say, a running back who carried the ball 450 times would. Maybe that is worked into the program already with how stamina affects different players doing different things, but I'd be disapointed if they came up with a system that penalized a QB come playoff time just because he had played every snap of every game for a season.
It simulates the effect of nagging injuries. A lot of times, by the time the playoffs come around, a player will have small injuries that effect his play, if only slightly. Thumbs (Roethlisberger), Shoulders (Tom Brady), Concussions (Troy Aikman
). You also get situations where starters don't practice at all during the week so they can be fresh for the games. The supposed injury updates should take care of that, should they not? How often do you see a team play a QB#2 for stamina reasons? When a team has secured a playoff spot, and sits a Peyton Manning for the second half of a meaningless game, is it to rest him physically, or to eliminate the injury risk of going back out on the field?
Both.
Anyway, it sounds like it is physical contact more than anything else that contributes to energy drain. A QB like Manning very rarely gets sacked and so wouldn't have the same issues as someone like Roethlisberger at the end of the season.
Exactly, which is why QBs shouldn't be penalized under a stamina system for playing every snap, and that there performance should only be hindered by the injury udpated, IMO.
cpwhite
offline
offline
Dozer,
Borts existing formula all ready has built in energy decreases by position & action. I wouldn't worry about QB's too much.
Borts existing formula all ready has built in energy decreases by position & action. I wouldn't worry about QB's too much.
bmedders
offline
offline
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Summary
Basically, from what I read:
-Stamina depends on what the player is doing - making tackles, running deep routes, getting double-teamed or pancaked will all result in losing stamina faster than standing around, covering or running short routes, overmatching your opponent, etc.
-10% stamina does not equal 10% effectiveness. Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.
-No matter how far your stamina falls during the game, you will never lose more than 30 stamina after the game.
10% stamina shouldn't = 10% effectiveness. Just because I'm warmed up doesn't mean I play slower. The only time it really impacts a player is when he's gassed and can't put that extra effort in required to make a play. A gassed player becomes almost useless on the field.
I'd much prefer some sort of bell curve where fatigue starts to set in more rapidly as a player gets more and more gassed.
I think this is a really good idea, and I think injuries should be related as well. IE: a player below 25 energy is more likely to get injured than a guy who is fresh.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Summary
Basically, from what I read:
-Stamina depends on what the player is doing - making tackles, running deep routes, getting double-teamed or pancaked will all result in losing stamina faster than standing around, covering or running short routes, overmatching your opponent, etc.
-10% stamina does not equal 10% effectiveness. Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.
-No matter how far your stamina falls during the game, you will never lose more than 30 stamina after the game.
10% stamina shouldn't = 10% effectiveness. Just because I'm warmed up doesn't mean I play slower. The only time it really impacts a player is when he's gassed and can't put that extra effort in required to make a play. A gassed player becomes almost useless on the field.
I'd much prefer some sort of bell curve where fatigue starts to set in more rapidly as a player gets more and more gassed.
I think this is a really good idea, and I think injuries should be related as well. IE: a player below 25 energy is more likely to get injured than a guy who is fresh.
Beef
offline
offline
From my perspective as a player (not an owner), I'm all for this issue being addressed before we are up and running on the next season.
I don't mind patiently working my way through the ranks as a backup to a point where I might someday start, but I'm appalled that the best way to win a GLB championship in Season 1 was to pare your team's roster down to the minimum number of players and let them play 100% of the snaps. It's inconsistent with the spirit of this "team game" (more participation = more fun, right?) as well as unrealistic at any level of actual football, from Pee Wee to the pros.
Let the players play!
I don't mind patiently working my way through the ranks as a backup to a point where I might someday start, but I'm appalled that the best way to win a GLB championship in Season 1 was to pare your team's roster down to the minimum number of players and let them play 100% of the snaps. It's inconsistent with the spirit of this "team game" (more participation = more fun, right?) as well as unrealistic at any level of actual football, from Pee Wee to the pros.
Let the players play!
FBGBullDozier
offline
offline
Originally posted by cpwhite
Dozer,
Borts existing formula all ready has built in energy decreases by position & action. I wouldn't worry about QB's too much.
Well, there you go. Thx.
Dozer,
Borts existing formula all ready has built in energy decreases by position & action. I wouldn't worry about QB's too much.
Well, there you go. Thx.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























