User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
I agree that experience yielding plays need to be capped at 60. The rest though is just gaming socialism, and pretty lame.


I also agree on the 60 cap. I would even drop it down to 50 or so.

As for the rest, I think there is definitely something to the idea of player wear and tear. Combining player wear and tear with player aging has a lot of promise I think. But I'm a little skeptical of the proposed method by the OP, for a few reasons:
1. Playing 1000 plays on Intense should cause a lot more wear and tear than 1000 plays on Relaxed.
2. If the # of players per game needed to get max XP is reduced (say to 60), then there is less need to punish players for wear and tear.
3. Playing 80 plays in one game and 0 in the next game should cause more wear and tear than playing 40 plays in one game and 40 in the next game. Similarly, playing 1600 plays in one season and 0 in the next season should cause more wear and tear than playing 800 plays in one season and 800 the next season.
4. I still feel like the primary problem in this game with respect to plays and XP is that there's no incentive to play well, just to play a certain number of plays. Any solution that doesn't deal with that doesn't sit quite right with me. That said, the GLB XP progression method based on playing time is less flawed than the EA Sports (Madden) progression method which is too stat based.

I'll keep thinking, I feel like the answer is out there...
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 15:52:12
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
But there will be level caps to leagues, so it doesn't matter if you enter the league at level 20, you will be in a league with other people of similar level. The only difference is it will have taken you 6 season (8 months) to get to level 20 and them only 2 seasons to get there. One way or another your player retires after 15 seasons, so if you waste 6 of them on the bench, that makes no sense. Either way you are playing in a league with other players of your level or close. I must be missing something.

BTW I am assuming a 15 season max based on when you make the player not his first game, which would make no sense. The way it has been described is:

Wear and tear per play
15 season max from the time he is created.

It's not like a modern day running back could start playing at 40, no matter how "fresh" he was.


Exactly. But even without a 15 season max, any benefits to it are strictly at the end of the guy's career. You have to be a really long term player to see any benefit at all, and you have to pay a lot up front to get that benefit - both in Flex Points, and in some team's money.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 15:53:15
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
If I have 10 guys, yes I have no problem doing this with 3 of them. I plan on playing this game a long time. Why wouldn't I shelve a small number of the players so that some time down the road they can be 12 levels better than everyone else in the game?


Exactly. I just think this idea makes it sillier with the way people will exploit things is all. I'm not sure it's a real "fix" to everything.
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by drifter

If I have 10 guys, yes I have no problem doing this with 3 of them. I plan on playing this game a long time. Why wouldn't I shelve a small number of the players so that some time down the road they can be 12 levels better than everyone else in the game?


Exactly. I just think this idea makes it sillier with the way people will exploit things is all. I'm not sure it's a real "fix" to everything.


After running the xp numbers through a spreadsheet - I don't think the advantage would ever be as high as 12 levels - maybe 5, tops. Even then, we're talking about an advantage in Season 13-15? At 40 days a season, that's over a year away. After all that time, is it worth it? I don't think so.

How many people truly have the money and patience for that? If they do, more power to them - my guess is that most of the people who would do that as a pure cheat wouldn't have the patience for it -they'd find some other way to cheat instead, and possibly be booted before they could take advantage of it.





Last edited Apr 16, 2008 16:47:21
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
Originally posted by Malachorn

Originally posted by drifter


If I have 10 guys, yes I have no problem doing this with 3 of them. I plan on playing this game a long time. Why wouldn't I shelve a small number of the players so that some time down the road they can be 12 levels better than everyone else in the game?


Exactly. I just think this idea makes it sillier with the way people will exploit things is all. I'm not sure it's a real "fix" to everything.


After running the xp numbers through a spreadsheet - I don't think the advantage would ever be as high as 12 levels - maybe 5, tops. Even then, we're talking about an advantage in Season 13-15? At 40 days a season, that's over a year away. After all that time, is it worth it? I don't think so.

How many people truly have the money and patience for that? If they do, more power to them - my guess is that most of the people who would do that as a pure cheat wouldn't have the patience for it -they'd find some other way to cheat instead, and possibly be booted before they could take advantage of it.








How are you coming up with such a low advantage?

5 seasons x 3 boost per year = 15
Daily Experience = 40*75 (conservatively) = 3000

That's 18 levels by the time the shelved player plays his first play, compared to 4 levels for the player who starts immediately. Now, over the next 10,000 plays the shelved player will gain experience a little lower than the boosted player but not really that much. Conservatively once again, let's say a player starting at 4 will gain 3 levels per year average (not including boosting). Since the shelved player started at a higher level we'll say he gains 2 levels per year from this point on (and I think it wouldn't be that big a disparity, but none of us really know how exp works at higher levels).

That will put the started player at Level 60 after ten years (with boosting) and the shelved player at Level 68. Again, I think this is a conservative estimate and the number will probably be closer to a 12 level difference.

As I said earlier, I don't think this means the idea is not without merit. I just think that every player should get at least 20 plays ever game towards the 10,000 even if he plays less. If this is done, the shelved player will start year 6 at Level 18 but will have 1600 plays towards his limit under his belt meaning that he probably only has around 8.5 years left instead of 10 which will have maxing out at about Level 62 using the calculations above. Now, you are talking a truly negligible difference.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I haven't crunched the numbers myself, but one thing we know is that players will not be able to gain experience or boost after season 10. So one thing we know for sure, if a player using the delayed development strategy hasn't caught the top players by then, then he won't.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

How are you coming up with such a low advantage?

5 seasons x 3 boost per year = 15
Daily Experience = 40*75 (conservatively) = 3000

That's 18 levels by the time the shelved player plays his first play, compared to 4 levels for the player who starts immediately. Now, over the next 10,000 plays the shelved player will gain experience a little lower than the boosted player but not really that much. Conservatively once again, let's say a player starting at 4 will gain 3 levels per year average (not including boosting). Since the shelved player started at a higher level we'll say he gains 2 levels per year from this point on (and I think it wouldn't be that big a disparity, but none of us really know how exp works at higher levels).


Also keep in mind that the smart players wouldn't shelve their guys right away. They'd play the first season at 60 plays per game until they hit level 7, then they'd boost to the proposed cap of 10 and shelve their guy for the rest of the season. Rinse and repeat the next season to 20. At which point they may shelve their guys for a few seasons. Bringing out a player in season 5 who's only a few levels lower than the other players who have 4x as many lifetime plays.

Not to mention the nightmare scenarios this would cause for owners and players. Where players who have capped their level for the season are begging their owners not to play them. Or owners who are threatening to play a player both ways, essentially killing a third of that player's lifespan off in one season if they don't sign a multi-year deal... or they could just do it to be a-holes(not uncommon in mmos).

While the current system may have some flaws, this proposed system would be opening Pandora’s box. And over all it has a very anti-competitive feel to it, it's one step down the slippery slope from saying everyone should have identical players with equal builds.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I haven't crunched the numbers myself, but one thing we know is that players will not be able to gain experience or boost after season 10. So one thing we know for sure, if a player using the delayed development strategy hasn't caught the top players by then, then he won't.


That's based on today's paradigm of having decline start at year 10 regardless. We can't assume that will be the case if some variation of this idea were implemented.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by kristof65

Originally posted by Malachorn


Originally posted by drifter



If I have 10 guys, yes I have no problem doing this with 3 of them. I plan on playing this game a long time. Why wouldn't I shelve a small number of the players so that some time down the road they can be 12 levels better than everyone else in the game?


Exactly. I just think this idea makes it sillier with the way people will exploit things is all. I'm not sure it's a real "fix" to everything.


After running the xp numbers through a spreadsheet - I don't think the advantage would ever be as high as 12 levels - maybe 5, tops. Even then, we're talking about an advantage in Season 13-15? At 40 days a season, that's over a year away. After all that time, is it worth it? I don't think so.

How many people truly have the money and patience for that? If they do, more power to them - my guess is that most of the people who would do that as a pure cheat wouldn't have the patience for it -they'd find some other way to cheat instead, and possibly be booted before they could take advantage of it.








How are you coming up with such a low advantage?

5 seasons x 3 boost per year = 15
Daily Experience = 40*75 (conservatively) = 3000

That's 18 levels by the time the shelved player plays his first play, compared to 4 levels for the player who starts immediately. Now, over the next 10,000 plays the shelved player will gain experience a little lower than the boosted player but not really that much. Conservatively once again, let's say a player starting at 4 will gain 3 levels per year average (not including boosting). Since the shelved player started at a higher level we'll say he gains 2 levels per year from this point on (and I think it wouldn't be that big a disparity, but none of us really know how exp works at higher levels).

That will put the started player at Level 60 after ten years (with boosting) and the shelved player at Level 68. Again, I think this is a conservative estimate and the number will probably be closer to a 12 level difference.

As I said earlier, I don't think this means the idea is not without merit. I just think that every player should get at least 20 plays ever game towards the 10,000 even if he plays less. If this is done, the shelved player will start year 6 at Level 18 but will have 1600 plays towards his limit under his belt meaning that he probably only has around 8.5 years left instead of 10 which will have maxing out at about Level 62 using the calculations above. Now, you are talking a truly negligible difference.


Using 75*40 is not really accurate at all as a longterm measuring stick for XP growth.

Sorry if this is confusing to some, but

In season one, you would gain levels much faster than season 3-5, so using 75 as an average (100xp + 52xp(@ level 12 for Ex)/2 = 75) is not taking into consideration the amount of time your player would be stuck at those higher levels (12-19 or so).

Why?

Each level sees a -4 in XP per day. At level 14 for example (season 2-3 in your scheme), that would be -56 per training day, so only 44 XP per training. If you start that season at level 14, it will take over 22 days to level Once. I don't see many people being THAT patient.


Conclusion: You could probably afford to sit one season before it will no longer be worth it to gain those pitiful XP points vs playing.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 18:15:05
 
Link
 
This all sounds good and all but if we are trying to keep the realism of football in it. Most starting QB's play well over 50 plays per game. Matter of fact what was Brett Favre's backups name? He played every game when he was with the Packers and he was on that team for like 15 years. Not to mention 4 years college. Thats 20 years with maybe 3 years as a backup. Joe Montana did the same thing. So capping the experience gained by a number of plays is not realistic. matter of fact it sounds like punishing a player for excellence. I also believe the plateau at 10 seasons is a bad Idea. Another case ad Point Jeff Hostetler who sat on the bench for 5 years with the Giants after Phil Simms gets hurt comes in and makes the Bills his B^tch in Super Bowl 25. So I think if it wanted to be realistic a players declination should be based of a players stamina. If you get high stamina your obviously going to last longer than someone with a low stamina. Like Ryan Leaf for instance. But that is just my opinion with a few facts feel free to disagree.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by kristof65

Originally posted by Malachorn


Originally posted by drifter



If I have 10 guys, yes I have no problem doing this with 3 of them. I plan on playing this game a long time. Why wouldn't I shelve a small number of the players so that some time down the road they can be 12 levels better than everyone else in the game?


Exactly. I just think this idea makes it sillier with the way people will exploit things is all. I'm not sure it's a real "fix" to everything.


After running the xp numbers through a spreadsheet - I don't think the advantage would ever be as high as 12 levels - maybe 5, tops. Even then, we're talking about an advantage in Season 13-15? At 40 days a season, that's over a year away. After all that time, is it worth it? I don't think so.

How many people truly have the money and patience for that? If they do, more power to them - my guess is that most of the people who would do that as a pure cheat wouldn't have the patience for it -they'd find some other way to cheat instead, and possibly be booted before they could take advantage of it.








How are you coming up with such a low advantage?

5 seasons x 3 boost per year = 15
Daily Experience = 40*75 (conservatively) = 3000

That's 18 levels by the time the shelved player plays his first play, compared to 4 levels for the player who starts immediately. Now, over the next 10,000 plays the shelved player will gain experience a little lower than the boosted player but not really that much. Conservatively once again, let's say a player starting at 4 will gain 3 levels per year average (not including boosting). Since the shelved player started at a higher level we'll say he gains 2 levels per year from this point on (and I think it wouldn't be that big a disparity, but none of us really know how exp works at higher levels).

That will put the started player at Level 60 after ten years (with boosting) and the shelved player at Level 68. Again, I think this is a conservative estimate and the number will probably be closer to a 12 level difference.

As I said earlier, I don't think this means the idea is not without merit. I just think that every player should get at least 20 plays ever game towards the 10,000 even if he plays less. If this is done, the shelved player will start year 6 at Level 18 but will have 1600 plays towards his limit under his belt meaning that he probably only has around 8.5 years left instead of 10 which will have maxing out at about Level 62 using the calculations above. Now, you are talking a truly negligible difference.



Once again a shelved player can come out and be the greatest thing since sliced bread. Look at Joe Ganz in Nebraska
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
I love how you guys keep trying so hard to make this sound like the answer.

You guys say yourselves that it would "only" be a five level experience in the end, if you sit on the bench. Drifter reminds you of boosting, which you conveniently forgot... what about all that?

There is no way around it.
This system would benefit the guys that aren't playing in the beginning of their careers and storing up levels.

It's a ridiculous way to "fix" things and isn't a real fix. It just creates DIFFERENT problems. Problems that I actually think are even more absurd and potentially even more destructive to the game.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardwscollins
Once again a shelved player can come out and be the greatest thing since sliced bread.



That should be the EXCEPTION to the rule. This idea makes it the rule and NOT the exception.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
If the goal is to encourage depth, then reduce the exp cap. Punishing players only leads to workarounds. I'm already seeing the term "shelved player" pop up and I don't like how that makes me feel on the inside. There's no point in enforcing rules/limits that adversely affect the spirit of the game to achieve some egalitarian goal. Your player plays 10 season, you get the creation cost and 70% of invested FP back. Simple. No one wants to calculate the amount of plays they've participated in to see if they're going to retire in the 3rd quarter of the Conference Championship.

And, as an owner, I don't want to have the responsibility of how long a person's player sticks around. I have to worry about enough already, I don't need the fate of virtual alter egos hanging over my head. No thank you.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 18:29:53
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Question: What is currently the max amount of XP a player can gain from one game? (Never mind how many plays it takes, I just want to know what the max possible XP gain is.)
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 18:37:22
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.