Originally posted by Saris
I agree that experience yielding plays need to be capped at 60. The rest though is just gaming socialism, and pretty lame.
I also agree on the 60 cap. I would even drop it down to 50 or so.
As for the rest, I think there is definitely something to the idea of player wear and tear. Combining player wear and tear with player aging has a lot of promise I think. But I'm a little skeptical of the proposed method by the OP, for a few reasons:
1. Playing 1000 plays on Intense should cause a lot more wear and tear than 1000 plays on Relaxed.
2. If the # of players per game needed to get max XP is reduced (say to 60), then there is less need to punish players for wear and tear.
3. Playing 80 plays in one game and 0 in the next game should cause more wear and tear than playing 40 plays in one game and 40 in the next game. Similarly, playing 1600 plays in one season and 0 in the next season should cause more wear and tear than playing 800 plays in one season and 800 the next season.
4. I still feel like the primary problem in this game with respect to plays and XP is that there's no incentive to play well, just to play a certain number of plays. Any solution that doesn't deal with that doesn't sit quite right with me. That said, the GLB XP progression method based on playing time is less flawed than the EA Sports (Madden) progression method which is too stat based.
I'll keep thinking, I feel like the answer is out there...
I agree that experience yielding plays need to be capped at 60. The rest though is just gaming socialism, and pretty lame.
I also agree on the 60 cap. I would even drop it down to 50 or so.
As for the rest, I think there is definitely something to the idea of player wear and tear. Combining player wear and tear with player aging has a lot of promise I think. But I'm a little skeptical of the proposed method by the OP, for a few reasons:
1. Playing 1000 plays on Intense should cause a lot more wear and tear than 1000 plays on Relaxed.
2. If the # of players per game needed to get max XP is reduced (say to 60), then there is less need to punish players for wear and tear.
3. Playing 80 plays in one game and 0 in the next game should cause more wear and tear than playing 40 plays in one game and 40 in the next game. Similarly, playing 1600 plays in one season and 0 in the next season should cause more wear and tear than playing 800 plays in one season and 800 the next season.
4. I still feel like the primary problem in this game with respect to plays and XP is that there's no incentive to play well, just to play a certain number of plays. Any solution that doesn't deal with that doesn't sit quite right with me. That said, the GLB XP progression method based on playing time is less flawed than the EA Sports (Madden) progression method which is too stat based.
I'll keep thinking, I feel like the answer is out there...
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 15:52:12






























