User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort

I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


Wouldn't the correct throwing style be determined by the length of the pass? No QB can really throw a 20 yard bullet.

Also, it wouldn't fix the problem that pass defenders are just too hard to beat. They'll knock lofty passes away even more easily. I realize you might want exactly that tradeoff, but the thing is that if you at least make the right tradeoff, passes should work better than they have been.

I mean, if lofty passes were dropped less but knocked away the same as now, bullet passes dropped as now but knocked away less, and the middle position doing a little of both, then that might work. But still, well, I suppose longer passes could have the degree of loft (they'd all need some) affected by that.


I actually have some "DB reaction time" code running in D-Leagues right now.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Originally posted by GenoBong

Originally posted by Ilok


not every game was unbalanced in our league, but an outstanding performance passing is barely over 200 yards 2 TD and completing 60% of passes. Yes I understand somethings are due to imbalances, but I'm trying to focus on the average not the outrageous.

My QB is level 14 which is way above normal for this league, throwing to WR level 9-7-7, which are normal, yet our passing game is very normal in this league, which means its worthless.


For what it's worth, I looked at the play-by-play of your first game where you went 3 for 13. Your QB started 1 for 5 in the first half, for .5 yards, with 3 drops. Of your 10 incompetions for the game, 5 were drops.

Your first deflection was on a little dump pass to your halfback, over a DE. The DE deflected the pass. That seems fairly realistic. Do you have points in dump pass? Perhaps if your halfback had better jumping/carrying/strength he may have been able to outwork the DE for the ball.

The second deflection you were throwing to a level 3 receiver who was being covered by a level 9 cornerback. Broken?

The third deflection you threw to a level 7 WR covered by a level 7 CB. That's pretty much just a lost dice roll. It happens.

On the fourth deflection, you threw to Harry Adcock (who up until this point has now had 5 drops in the game and is likely suffering from some serious morale issues) and the ball was deflected. I wouldn't be surprised if he would have dropped it even if it wasn't deflected.

Instead of saying the game is broken in some way, I'd first wonder what your qb's confidence is, your wr's catching/confidence is, and the defense's intimidation factors are. With low confidence, it's rare that a player who starts out poorly comes back to have a decent game.

This first game looks like it played out pretty realistically and within the spirit of the game design.


In your second scrim, you went 6 for 12 with 1 drop on your attempts. You had 2 deflected passes, both attempts went to your tight end; none other than Harry Adcock. Stop throwing to that guy. Oh, and you'll never guess who was responsible for the drop. Without your looks to the TE, your quarterback might be having a decent preseason.

Listen, I can understand your frustration (I have a level 16 QB who is making the right reads but his receviers aren't making plays). You mentioned high school level of play. I'd expect Levels 12-16 to be around high school level of talent, 16-20 college, and 20+ pros. Give your player(s) some time to grow before you make a final judgement.


I not surprised out of my QB's performance. The first game was a test with complete basic AI. I don't care what he did. The second game we did some tweaks and we spent more time working back ups than my QB. My build is about as perfect as it could be for the level. We do have problems with WR builds and we know.

The problem I was addressing was not just my team, but basically all teams in the league. There is no incentive to throw a pass, since running is so effective. Throw in the fact that the defensive up grades that have made man coverage supreme (which in real football no team on any level plays complete man all the time) running is that much more imbalanced.

Bort is on the right track that might help passing a little. As it is right now, the QB throws the ball as hard as he can every pass. If he can tweak it where depending on distance and situation the QB uses some touch, it will help out some. I'm not sure what kind of football you are watching, but I've never seen a game where it normal for a QB to complete lower than 50% of their passes. Yes a QB might every once in a while have a bad game and throw 40%, but its rare. As is, stats are going to be completely screwed right now.

oh my qb's build at level 14 is:

Strength: 36.54 Blocking: 8
Speed: 12.6 Tackling: 10
Agility: 12.6 Throwing: 64.2
Jumping: 12.6 Catching: 12.6
Stamina: 16.2 Carrying: 12.6
Vision: 44.2 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 25.64 Punting: 9

and 2 in all pocket passer tree thats with special equipment. It's not my build that's the problem.


Yeah, I wasn't trying to say your QB had issues, but your confidence is a little low as I suspected, and your guy could be susceptible to a bad string of plays. I was merely trying to break down the fact that the issue is not one that relates to a quarterback.

I totally agree with you on the passing touch issue. It's common for deep passes in the NFL to stay in the air for 3 full seconds. What's odd about GLB is the stronger you get, the less time the football stays in the air. It would be neat if the game could factor vector/velocity to lead receivers on deep throws, or to lob it over LB's heads on medium throws, etc.

I also agree on your main point about passing being relatively unsuccesful vs. the run in general. However, there are teams that consistently, and still to this day through the scrims, have largely successful passing games.

However, whenever I looked around league leaders in a bunch of different leagues and league levels for QBs, without fail 9 times out of 10 the best QB in the league was between 80-90 raiting, and 80% of the QBs in the league had a negative touchdown to interception ratio.

It doesn't come as too great of a surprise to me that passing is taking a hit in these scrimmages. Many people are indeed complaining about it, but there's probably a lot of people pretty content, too. I've also read a lot of people complaining about rushing now, but there's also a lot of people who like how rushing is.

I suspect there's far more people posting about things they perceive to be not working as intended (or to their team's or players' advantage)or is broken than it is to post about how much you're impressed with the recent changes.

Anyways, you're absolutely right that passing in this game is not only more difficult to master, but it's downright wonky looking. Pass interference for defenders would definitely help a ton (and might make the smooth operator SA actually useful?).

Implementing some sort of touch pass, or lofty pass, so WRs can take more advantage of jumping/catching/vision/strength so CBs would have to compensate is another step in the right direction.

Perhaps reconfiguring the way receiving SAs work might improve things (e.g. Head fake working on routes, diving/jumping/1-handed catch working more often).

But the bottom line is, bort said he'd make changes to make catching, and other passing related abilities more important. I'm going to wait a while into, or maybe through the season, seeing how players and teams compensate, before rendering a judgement as to whether or not passing needs to be re-worked entirely, or is in fact patently not worth doing to be successful in a game.

Thanks for the post. This has been a good discussion.

edit:

Forgot to mention, Ilok, your comment about man coverage... perhaps that is the reason why rushing is seemingly better than the run. I'm not sure if GLB is the same, I'd have to research some replays, but typically in the NFL zones and zone blitzes are way better for stopping the run. Maybe teams will key on zones and the run more often and passing will catch up.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 17:54:25
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
actually zone coverage has very little to do with run stopping ability. It's base is to prevent mismatches in man coverage and take away the advantages of the west coast and spread offense by using lower number of personnel to cover a greater number of receivers. Most zones actually hurt run stopping, because they are usually ran out of the nickle or dime, taking away a linebacker for a defensive back.

The most effective and talked about zone defense in the NFL is the Tampa 2 defense, which is the most effective zone to be ran out of a base defense. It's run stopping ability is still very dependent on the quality of the defensive line and has variances in a sort of roaming backer, examples Derrick Brooks and Bob Sanders.

Case in point of how personnel is so much a factor in run stopping while in a zone. Take out Sanders from the Colts, how good is there run stopping when he is hurt, same with Freeney hurt, even though his main job is pressure on qb, take out one piece and the defense blows up. It

Look at Chicago's defense with Tank Johnson (2006) and without him (2007).
I could give you many examples.

Man coverage is more effective against the run because the defenders are playing on the reaction of the people they are defending instead of worrying about a scheme. It's why most teams go into man in the red zone. Higher percentages of runs and less area to cover.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Bort


I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


Wouldn't the correct throwing style be determined by the length of the pass? No QB can really throw a 20 yard bullet.

Also, it wouldn't fix the problem that pass defenders are just too hard to beat. They'll knock lofty passes away even more easily. I realize you might want exactly that tradeoff, but the thing is that if you at least make the right tradeoff, passes should work better than they have been.

I mean, if lofty passes were dropped less but knocked away the same as now, bullet passes dropped as now but knocked away less, and the middle position doing a little of both, then that might work. But still, well, I suppose longer passes could have the degree of loft (they'd all need some) affected by that.


I actually have some "DB reaction time" code running in D-Leagues right now.


Cool. You just made me happy.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
actually zone coverage has very little to do with run stopping ability. It's base is to prevent mismatches in man coverage and take away the advantages of the west coast and spread offense by using lower number of personnel to cover a greater number of receivers. Most zones actually hurt run stopping, because they are usually ran out of the nickle or dime, taking away a linebacker for a defensive back.

The most effective and talked about zone defense in the NFL is the Tampa 2 defense, which is the most effective zone to be ran out of a base defense. It's run stopping ability is still very dependent on the quality of the defensive line and has variances in a sort of roaming backer, examples Derrick Brooks and Bob Sanders.

Case in point of how personnel is so much a factor in run stopping while in a zone. Take out Sanders from the Colts, how good is there run stopping when he is hurt, same with Freeney hurt, even though his main job is pressure on qb, take out one piece and the defense blows up. It

Look at Chicago's defense with Tank Johnson (2006) and without him (2007).
I could give you many examples.

Man coverage is more effective against the run because the defenders are playing on the reaction of the people they are defending instead of worrying about a scheme. It's why most teams go into man in the red zone. Higher percentages of runs and less area to cover.


We can agree to disagree then. My belief is that, all talent being equal, zones make run stopping easier because it's easier to read and recognize the run because you're worried about a zone or a gap/containment responsibility rather than where your coverage assignment is.

More often than not it comes down to mismatches regardless of the D call, and how teams exploit those mismatches. A ton of teams are having a hard time rushing with the tweaks to speed/agility and blocking. I'm pretty sure decent teams will recognize where they are getting beat, and fix it quickly.

This is easier to do in the run game than the passing game, however. Which goes back to your main point. It's way easier to work to your offensive strengths and gameplan the ground game. Fast back, fast full back, strong WRs? Take it outside. Strong back with a pancaking fullback? Go up the gut.

You can't really do this in the passing game. You can't take advantage of a tall WR that can jump by telling your QB to throw it high to him. You can't set route preferences for particular WRs that will compliment their builds like you can a halfback.

It would be nice if we could do this WRs. Much like a QB has the preference to favor long passes, it'd be nice for a wide receiver to favor short, medium, or long routes (more complex preferences would be nice, obviously).

 
bluesguy07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Yes, some teams are having success with pass, but there is no incentive to pass. I'm just using my league as an example Oceania #2.

Game 1 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82944

one team completed 51% of the passes, which is great for the league. For a 5.4 yards per attempt. They rushed 4.2 y/r so what real advantage is there to pass, with the high chance of getting no yards and a chance of interceptions?

Game 2 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82960

highest passing team completed 55% of passes for a whopping 5.7 per play. They also rushed for 4.2 per play. Wheres the advantage?

game 3 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82950

65% completion is outstanding. Still only 1.3 yards per play better than rushing

game 4 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82966

41% passes complete but the same team 7.8 yards per rush and 4.4 yards per pass.

game 5 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82956

basically game 4. 45% completion 3.2 yards per attept, 7 yards rushing per attempt

game 6 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82972

60% completion but 4.4 per pass to 3.6 per rush

game 7 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82946

43% comp 3.8 yards per pass .9 rush, not sure what to say here

game 8 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82962

52% comp 5.6 pass 6 run

game 9 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82952

This is the best example of the sim's state. The winning team realized how pointless passing is, only attempted 2 passes and won 63-3. I'm sure the owner is mad that the sim made him pass twice.

game 10

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82968

comp 60% passes 4.6 pass 4.2 r

game 11 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82958

The worst teams in league head to head 28% comp 3.6 pass 1.7 rush

game 12 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82974

59% 5 pass 6 rush

game 13 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82948

60% 5.7 pass 6.8 rush

game 14 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82964

54% 7.5 pass 11.6 rush

game 15 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82954

44% 4 pass 5.4 rush

game 16 http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82970

51% 5.6 pass 7.3 rush



I am no football expert, but as a sports writer for a newspaper I watch an extreme amount of football at many different levels. Outside of small conference high school football, I never seen totals so unjust towards pass. In professional football, passing is more effective than rushing. It’s why even the worst NFL team gains more passing yards than rushing yard. College is the same way outside of the spread option schools. But as a league passing greatly out weighs rushing. High school is different, but am I paying money for a high school simulator? Seriously?

Passing is effective for the risk/reward factor, but this sim has no reward for pass. Passing you either advance the ball greatly or non at all or maybe an interception. There is also a reason why teams throw more interceptions than fumbles. It’s harder to pass, but there is a benefit to do so. Where is the benefit here?

I don’t know the schematics of the sim, but to rush you’re basically dependent on the rusher’s build, plus the o-line’s build against the defender’s build. Passing you have to worry about the passer’s build, plus the receiver’s build plus the o-lines build against the defensive build.

Do something to make passing easier or rushing harder. It’s going to be very boring having a complete cookie cutter league that you basically have to run 80% of the time and have all your defensive players play the run. The only difference between teams will be the ones who may use pass as a trick to try to make running more effective, if that is even possible.

You could put a penalty in to force teams to at least attempt passes, as ineffective as they are, by giving teams that run 75% of the time a penalty to run blocking or use the AI of opposing defenses to recognize and stop the run more affective after the opposing team runs 25 run plays in a row.

Want to see the stat that pisses me off the most? Out of 16 scrimmage games ran today 21 touchdowns were thrown, 53 rushing touchdowns were scored. Show many any league any where, where they had a week where over 71% of the touchdowns scored were rushing. There is a reason why in the NFL a great running back scores 15 touchdowns a year and a great QB throws 30. Same thing in college.

You can deny there is a bug all you want and show many single game stats of one isolated instance but the fact is passing is broke in this game and you’re not getting another dime from me until its fixed.


Wow, with that grammar you call yourself a sports writer?
 
IamJack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GenoBong
Originally posted by Ilok

actually zone coverage has very little to do with run stopping ability. It's base is to prevent mismatches in man coverage and take away the advantages of the west coast and spread offense by using lower number of personnel to cover a greater number of receivers. Most zones actually hurt run stopping, because they are usually ran out of the nickle or dime, taking away a linebacker for a defensive back.

The most effective and talked about zone defense in the NFL is the Tampa 2 defense, which is the most effective zone to be ran out of a base defense. It's run stopping ability is still very dependent on the quality of the defensive line and has variances in a sort of roaming backer, examples Derrick Brooks and Bob Sanders.

Case in point of how personnel is so much a factor in run stopping while in a zone. Take out Sanders from the Colts, how good is there run stopping when he is hurt, same with Freeney hurt, even though his main job is pressure on qb, take out one piece and the defense blows up. It

Look at Chicago's defense with Tank Johnson (2006) and without him (2007).
I could give you many examples.

Man coverage is more effective against the run because the defenders are playing on the reaction of the people they are defending instead of worrying about a scheme. It's why most teams go into man in the red zone. Higher percentages of runs and less area to cover.


We can agree to disagree then. My belief is that, all talent being equal, zones make run stopping easier because it's easier to read and recognize the run because you're worried about a zone or a gap/containment responsibility rather than where your coverage assignment is.

More often than not it comes down to mismatches regardless of the D call, and how teams exploit those mismatches. A ton of teams are having a hard time rushing with the tweaks to speed/agility and blocking. I'm pretty sure decent teams will recognize where they are getting beat, and fix it quickly.

This is easier to do in the run game than the passing game, however. Which goes back to your main point. It's way easier to work to your offensive strengths and gameplan the ground game. Fast back, fast full back, strong WRs? Take it outside. Strong back with a pancaking fullback? Go up the gut.

You can't really do this in the passing game. You can't take advantage of a tall WR that can jump by telling your QB to throw it high to him. You can't set route preferences for particular WRs that will compliment their builds like you can a halfback.

It would be nice if we could do this WRs. Much like a QB has the preference to favor long passes, it'd be nice for a wide receiver to favor short, medium, or long routes (more complex preferences would be nice, obviously).




Why is LSU one of the best run defenses in the nation year in and year out? We play tight man coverage on the outside and stuff the box.

 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Bort


I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


Wouldn't the correct throwing style be determined by the length of the pass? No QB can really throw a 20 yard bullet.

Also, it wouldn't fix the problem that pass defenders are just too hard to beat. They'll knock lofty passes away even more easily. I realize you might want exactly that tradeoff, but the thing is that if you at least make the right tradeoff, passes should work better than they have been.

I mean, if lofty passes were dropped less but knocked away the same as now, bullet passes dropped as now but knocked away less, and the middle position doing a little of both, then that might work. But still, well, I suppose longer passes could have the degree of loft (they'd all need some) affected by that.


I actually have some "DB reaction time" code running in D-Leagues right now.


That's the same problem any game has, really. Being able to accurately reflect the "sight" of a DB in coverage. You either nerf it or have superman backers. Even Madden can't fix it and they have spent millions on it. I do agree there are way too many incomplete passes right now. QBs are missing wide open people with no pressure. There's no reason for a balanced QB build to miss that throw.

Like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79082&pbp_id=638552

Opening drive, agile TE...horrible throw..

That needs to be looked at, but overall the defense is looking good reaction wise.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeauxTigahs



Why is LSU one of the best run defenses in the nation year in and year out? We play tight man coverage on the outside and stuff the box.



Are you serious?

Yeah, the team that has sent 22 (4 first rounders, 12 in the first 3 roundes) of its defensive players into the nfl in the last 10 years is definitely relying on scheme and not talent.

Taking a look at 2007 and your run defense against teams that have comparable talent like Florida (156 yards) and Arkansas with McFadden(385 yards). Hell, you gave up a buck forty five against Ohio State, another team of comparable talent. All while having the best defensive tackle in the nation. Yeah, I'm gonna buy that argument.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.