User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > i personnely think the new sims are screwed up
Page:
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arles
Just some additional data points, we had 18 missed tackles - most by the DTs and DBs. What's odd is our DEs (with worse tackling/str) had 10 tackles and 0 missed. Meanwhile, our DTs had 4 tackles with 8 missed. And, one of our DTs that missed tackles had a 71 str and 51! tackling. I wonder if there's something in the sim that sets a penalty for DTs making tackles. Just a thought.


My only thought on this is that while trying to make the tackle, the DT was engaged in a block. If that's the case, then maybe it is working as designed.
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 14:03:30
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdog

IT IS A FREAKING BETA VERSION. THE LAST 3 SEASONS HAVE BEEN A TEST!!! YOU ARE TESTING THE PRODUCT AS WE SPEAK!!!


Don't Beta testers usually either get paid in some way (as in in-game perks) or play for free????????????? I can't speak for anyone else, but I've paid a shit ton o cash to "test" this game and have received absolutely no compensation for my work as a "tester." I completely agree that no one forces me to pay anything. However, so long as they gladly take our $, I do think it is fair to have certain expectations regarding the product we're being sold.

That said, I do think today was to be expected to at least a certain extend. One certainly would be within their rights to argue that the testing phase could have been much more thorough, but BFD. It's a scrim game.

What I do think is a BFD is making significant changes and not really explaining in any real level of detail what that will affect. Simply saying that wrap up will be lessened doesn't really say a damn thing. I'm quite certain that most otherwise intelligent players would believe that a DT with super high str and 40 + tkling wouldn't miss 8-10 tkls because of it. Saying that speed and agil will be tweaked doesn't exactly indicate that a lvl 28 speed WR with 40 + agil now won't be able to get behind a lvl 17 CB.

I'm not so much bitching about the changes as I am the lack of any real solid info on how those changes will impact our existing players. Even the little info out there is buried in all sorts of places, making it extremely difficult to find. Also, there is no longer an excuse for the site to be slow, IMO. As someone else wrote earlier, handling the "little things" should be job #1.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arles
Just some additional data points, we had 18 missed tackles - most by the DTs and DBs. What's odd is our DEs (with worse tackling/str) had 10 tackles and 0 missed. Meanwhile, our DTs had 4 tackles with 8 missed. And, one of our DTs that missed tackles had a 71 str and 51! tackling. I wonder if there's something in the sim that sets a penalty for DTs making tackles. Just a thought.


It does sound like high tackling numbers may not be preventing missed tackles well enough. However, those with lower tackling numbers (the vast majority of players in the game) shouldn't be surprised to miss a lot, and shouldn't get much relief.

And the DT with 51 tackling who missed some could have been facing a running back with 60+ strength and power running SA's plus got a bunch of bad random numbers.

I'm not sure to what extent, if any, tackle missing was over-tuned, but I think that a typical DLineman or LB, who often had 30some Tackling last season, should be missing a lot of them. I'd tend to agree that as Tackling skill rises, missed tackles should drop plenty, though.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arles

Problem with this is I can't set a sub rate on CB right now. Try this:


Should work now.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Last season, my team couldn't run for shit. We only broke 100 yards playing against a gutted team, but we were the #1 passing team in the league.

Today we rushed for 330 yards and 43 points.

Seems to me like everything is working as intended. Our dots just didn't get nerfed like your sorry dots. Oh....snap.
 
Bountytaker
offline
Link
 
Quick question:

Under two minutes to play, we were down 5, 1 and G at their 5. I had the AI set to an HB pass on any first and G in the 4th quarter. However, on the play, our QB threw to the WR. Now, I noticed that I had left the "two minute drill" AI in place, which has the WR as the primary target in the last two minutes. I assumed that, by putting specifics on the one output/input (namely, the position on the field, and down, where I wanted the play run), that it would override a more generic input/output. Now, I'm not so sure.


So, I guess my question is, do quarter specific AI's override each other, and, if so, how do we know which one takes prededence?
 
Link
 
The only complaint I have about he change in the tackling area is it should've happened a long time ago. to hear people say all you have to do is wrap a guy up and he's takled is horsecrap. Seeing guys tackle with a tackling stat of 12 just as well as guys that have a tackle of 35 that is horsecrap. seeing little babies whine cause they've spent their XP on speed and not tackling.....PRICELESS.
Good job Bort!!!! makes it more realistic!!!
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UCHI_MATA_MASTER
The only complaint I have about he change in the tackling area is it should've happened a long time ago. to hear people say all you have to do is wrap a guy up and he's takled is horsecrap. Seeing guys tackle with a tackling stat of 12 just as well as guys that have a tackle of 35 that is horsecrap. seeing little babies whine cause they've spent their XP on speed and not tackling.....PRICELESS.
Good job Bort!!!! makes it more realistic!!!

imo

Good luck with your strength/speed builds. Good job already boosting, so you're at level 26 and will gain maybe 10 SP that you can drop in tackling all season.

Time to retire.
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
2 questions that I've posted elsewhere but this seems to be the hopping new updates forum:

I have a couple of questions about "special cirumstances." Did this provide problems for anyone?

I set my kicker's FG range at 50 yds and he still tried a 52 and 54 yarder, even though I had for FGs to happen only when "within FG range."

Also, in the 3rd quarter, we punted twice from the opponents 28.5 yard line. In my general settings, my 3rd input down (and 1st 4th down one) is a 4th and 3-15 yds between the opponent 30-3 yd line to kick a FG 100% of the time. But I also had the special circumstance set to "within FG range," which should have been 50 yds. yet we still punted.
I had no quarter specific settings for 4th down in the 3rd quarter either.

Anyone else have these problems/can provide any insight?

I assume the AI was on today because another team in our league said they went for it on every 4th down.
 
Link
 
Bounty I can answer that one. the Ai looks from the top of the list to the bottom finds one it likes that matches the situation. If there is one small area that is not exactly right it continues on till it finds the next one, if that one matchesa it ues it. I've learned after this game to not be as specific as we'd like cause when I need the short yardage defense to happen I had it set at 1-4 yardsand the OPPONENT was at 5 yards. So I've gone back and removed some of the specivities. Also you need to figure out where on the "ladder" it needs to go. Too high, and some that are further down won't be used too low and the specific needs won't be met. Give a great deal of strategy to the game when planning it out.
 
Link
 
Exactly superpunk, the "Old Timers" are gonna be angry as hell and won't be willing to stay the season and add to tackling while the younger guys are going to have opportunities to create much stronger, and now by the new "rules" better, players. yeah it does suck for guys that have been around since season one but the game in general will be more real. As I said a guy cannot, in the real world, tackle just because he wraps his arms around somebody. He has to learn. I like the change and am willing to put more points in the tackle stat to make him a better player
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UCHI_MATA_MASTER
The only complaint I have about he change in the tackling area is it should've happened a long time ago. to hear people say all you have to do is wrap a guy up and he's takled is horsecrap. Seeing guys tackle with a tackling stat of 12 just as well as guys that have a tackle of 35 that is horsecrap. seeing little babies whine cause they've spent their XP on speed and not tackling.....PRICELESS.
Good job Bort!!!! makes it more realistic!!!


+1

My only concern is whether guys with truly high tackling are missing tackles.

But in most cases, people will just need to improve their tackling, as they should have to. No more 20 tackling LBs!
 
Link
 
HEY, I'm one of those 20 tackling LB's, well I was. now i've got 5, OH WOAH IS ME!!!!! only five tackles!!!! OMG and 3 missed tackles....I love it!
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XUMuskie85
2 questions that I've posted elsewhere but this seems to be the hopping new updates forum:

I have a couple of questions about "special cirumstances." Did this provide problems for anyone?

I set my kicker's FG range at 50 yds and he still tried a 52 and 54 yarder, even though I had for FGs to happen only when "within FG range."

Anyone else have these problems/can provide any insight?


Your other one, I don't know about. But this one...I'd guess if you set FG range manually it goes by the LOS rather than the length of the FG. So you could have been on the 50 and would have attempted a 67 yard FG.

 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UCHI_MATA_MASTER
The only complaint I have about he change in the tackling area is it should've happened a long time ago. to hear people say all you have to do is wrap a guy up and he's takled is horsecrap. Seeing guys tackle with a tackling stat of 12 just as well as guys that have a tackle of 35 that is horsecrap. seeing little babies whine cause they've spent their XP on speed and not tackling.....PRICELESS.
Good job Bort!!!! makes it more realistic!!!


For what it's worth, I agree with you regarding TKLing to a great extent. I'll even take it farther. I think a player with anything less than 25 tkl being able to go a full game without missing a TKL was ridiculous. Hell, a tkl of 35 is low in my book. I even understand broken tkls against a 50 + TKL player, but not the double digits against those type of players I'm seeing over and over and over as I review games. Still, I can live with that, so long as there is some heads up on what level of change one can expect.

I'm just glad that I haven't boosted any of the guys on my team yet. I feel sorry for those that did. Superpunk is right. As it is now, a lot of players may as well retire and start over...They're toast for many seasons to come.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.