User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
There are no apparent energy issues durring a game that arise from having no depth.
You are somehwat missing the whole point of this discussion.


Excuse me for trying to enlighten you.
And you're wrong. A team with depth DOES have some advantages over a team without, mostly because of the energy issues.
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CableJelly


Minimum rosters are already in the works


Unless there are also alterations to minimum depth charts and / or in-game effect of playing too many downs for certain positions, the existence of a minimum roster size will not address this. Just round out the roster with lvl 1 CPU or real players and don't put them on the depth chart. The scheme will still work.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
"There's really only 2 ways I, or anyone who's thinking like me will care about backups:

1) There's a much lower cap put in place for experience (40 or so plays before the big dropoff instead of 90). Then I'll carry a few extra players to have more options. Even under that system, I can't imagine wanting to carry more than 40-45 players. I'd still keep the Energy penalty in the same place (gets much higher after the 80-90 play range) so if a team wants to just have single starters, they can, they're just not helped very much by it.

2) Lower the cap for the point where the Energy penalty hits hard to around 50 plays. That basically forces teams to carry a lot of depth and eliminates single starters across the board (other than maybe P/Ks). I don't like this idea since I don't think teams should be forced into a system like that if they don't want to, but hey, it'll solve the current problem...."
**********************************************

Actually I think both of those ideas could be interesting. If the EXP gain limit is set to 40ish plays, then I know that I would take time to develop some of my backup players to maybe offer different things than my starters do (This would mostly help if we can get situational backups implementd)

The second would be the Stick of the carrot and the stick. By slamming teams with short rosters, the only real thing you force is a decent number of backups and depth. This might be a problem though depending on the population of your game.

PinTBC


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Coach Greedy
Originally posted by holloway4263

I have been upset about this for awhile. I think it is funny how I have read on these forums if you find a BUG and don't report it you risk losing your team. I think by all means this is a BUG issue. It has been stated on this tread time and again that it is not cheating. I agree all Owners could do it. I own a US PRO team and I seen what was going on. I didn't do it.

The only true way to fix the problem is with Injuries. You can't have a one man D.C. if you have the fear of injuries.

I understand a QB can play the whole game in the NFL as can the Oline. But I have not seen a RB avg. 37 carries in a game over the course of the season. It just doesn't happen.

The people fighting this idea are the ones using it. I am sorry Jed the don't hate the player hate the game statement is wrong. If you seen there was a way for you to gain an advantage over the rest of the field you should have reported it as a BUG. The game is Beta that is why we are playing the game. Not to gain a headstart. Fix the issue and make the game better.

I am sure there are going to be people out there riping me or asking how this is a bug. I will tell you right now that if a player can play 90 plus plays a game running the ball and there is no effect on his energy. He doesn't slow down. What do you call it?

I think I want what we all want THE BEST GAME.


I have to totally agree with this post, if nothing is done about this I honestly believe the maturer gamers looking for an as realistic a simulation as possible will walk away. I have already thought about leaving but enjoyed the first season in a relatively fair division so much I thought I would give the developers time to put this ridiculous loophole right.




I agree as well. If you're looking for a "realistic" simulation, then a BUG has been pointed out in thread after thread. I'm aware that the developers are working on containing/minimizing its effects for season 2, but folks need to stop defending a BUG and pretending that they don't understand the problem.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Well, the introduction of team chemistry may lessen the impact of farm teams bringing in depth for playoffs to the top teams... if that happens, it only makes the teams that only keep one player on a depth chart even stronger.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Vilita


Originally posted by CONN CHRIS






It can easily be solved by making a certain depth at each position mandatory for a line-up to be valid prior to game time.



I agree with this thread.

Seriously, injuries is not whats going to solve this. People should not be playing, let alone rewarded for playing just 1 HB or just 2 WR's in a game. Its simply unrealistic and those of us trying to play more realistically or suffering.

I like the suggestion of having a mandatory depth at each position for a lineup to be valid.



Crazy. Maybe a limit on the high side, yes. Low side, no. If someone can play their ppl the whole game then good for them. No one will ever tell me as a coach who or how many players I have to have. Dumbest idea ever. Vilita, you have players in positions that aren't even in USE YET. Get a clue.



Hey genius. Did it occur to you that maybe that I did that so the backup LB's see their name on the front page as starters and feel better about their position on the team?

You might want to ask why people do things before assuming they are as clueless as you.


Wow, if that's what it takes to get your backups motivated, then that's pretty sad.

Player A - 'Look, I'm the starting LILB!'
Player B - 'Dumbass, we don't use that position'

Why not create new positions for all the backups.

Player A - 'I'm the executive substitute linebacking specialist!'



haha, Vilitia I agree with most of what you and others have said, but this above struck me as remarkably dopey.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 10:56:27
 
Bulldog2811
offline
Link
 



Forgive me but, I'm new here and haven't actually seen how the actual simulation works... I'm not sure how much Energy and Morale plays into the actual gametime. That said, I'm sure something similiar could be developed to make injuries/subs important. Here's my take on the subject :

As most Fantasy Football/NFL GM's know... injuries are a HUGE part of the game. So much so that without them, you really couldn't even label this a simulation. There MUST be something in place to emulate that HUGE part of the game.

Maybe there could be a percentage/chance for injury based on position... As stated before, QB's are a big target in the NFL and as such, they'd have a higher percentage of being injured in this sim. "Injury Chance" would be adjusted for ALL positions based on a combination of Attributes (STR/AGI/STAM) as well as Position Played (QB/RB/WR = higher percentage for injury). The impact of an injury could be a MAX of 1-4 quarters and maybe a reduction of Energy/Morale (-25% per quarter). Obviously, each quarter following an injury would raise the player's ENG/Morale by +25%. Add all that with X amount of playing time (more plays = percentage rises) and it'd make subs A LOT more important.

I believe Madden calls these attributes "Injury" and "Toughness"...

Last edited Apr 17, 2008 16:00:03
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Excuse me for trying to enlighten you.
And you're wrong. A team with depth DOES have some advantages over a team without, mostly because of the energy issues.



Originally posted by Malachorn
Well, the introduction of team chemistry may lessen the impact of farm teams bringing in depth for playoffs to the top teams... if that happens, it only makes the teams that only keep one player on a depth chart even stronger.



Does depth have some advantages or does a lack of depth make the team stronger?
 
dusk2k3
offline
Link
 
don't know if any one noticed but Borts thread on Team Chemistry said nothing about Depth Charts or Playing time. It only affects adding and releasing players. This will only encourage those teams with low depth to not add any more because doing so will immediately reduce their Chemistry by 2 for each player. Don't really think this is going to help with the current depth problems

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=76117
 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by holloway4263
I have been upset about this for awhile. I think it is funny how I have read on these forums if you find a BUG and don't report it you risk losing your team. I think by all means this is a BUG issue. It has been stated on this tread time and again that it is not cheating. I agree all Owners could do it. I own a US PRO team and I seen what was going on. I didn't do it.

The only true way to fix the problem is with Injuries. You can't have a one man D.C. if you have the fear of injuries.

I understand a QB can play the whole game in the NFL as can the Oline. But I have not seen a RB avg. 37 carries in a game over the course of the season. It just doesn't happen.

The people fighting this idea are the ones using it. I am sorry Jed the don't hate the player hate the game statement is wrong. If you seen there was a way for you to gain an advantage over the rest of the field you should have reported it as a BUG. The game is Beta that is why we are playing the game. Not to gain a headstart. Fix the issue and make the game better.

I am sure there are going to be people out there riping me or asking how this is a bug. I will tell you right now that if a player can play 90 plus plays a game running the ball and there is no effect on his energy. He doesn't slow down. What do you call it?

I think I want what we all want THE BEST GAME.


Brilliant, insightful and honest post. Well done. I agree completely.

There are too many plays in a game right now as it seems.

BTW, Tpats post was pretty killer too.
 
MLA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Rather than force people to get depth just for its own sake, we make the game inherently reward depth in the same way that real football does. Then owners will get depth without us having to force them to do it because it will actually be in their best interest.

Damn straight. Situational players and actions matter. The game actually mitigates against that at present by having the playing out of position penalty so you're not going to get Mike Vrabel catching TDs in GLB.

Injuries should be a great step forward and the design proposed to have a time-related diminution of some attributes will help if the injuries are significantly severe. I'd personally like to see players get knocked out of the game and so have their backups come in and have the injury cause a small attribute negative for a few games afterwards.

 
TubbyChooChoo
offline
Link
 
We need injuries in the game.
Injuries that could knock a player out for a game or two would be awesome! More than that and you are taking away the fun for someone...but 1-2 game injuries adds strategy and requires people to seat guys in the depth chart.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MLA
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Rather than force people to get depth just for its own sake, we make the game inherently reward depth in the same way that real football does. Then owners will get depth without us having to force them to do it because it will actually be in their best interest.

Damn straight. Situational players and actions matter. The game actually mitigates against that at present by having the playing out of position penalty so you're not going to get Mike Vrabel catching TDs in GLB.

Injuries should be a great step forward and the design proposed to have a time-related diminution of some attributes will help if the injuries are significantly severe. I'd personally like to see players get knocked out of the game and so have their backups come in and have the injury cause a small attribute negative for a few games afterwards.



The recent revelation that being tired doesn't effect play much and the energy bar will never go below 70 really sucks. Both of these factors, if implemented properly would force depth. If a tired player, played significantly worse or if an owner had to decide to rest guys to get their energy bars back up, depth would instantly be a factor.
 
Bulldog2811
offline
Link
 
Having depth in any "real" game is extremely important... From what I've read, it doesn't matter in this game and owners are playing within the rules as stated. Kudos to them. However, for the rest of us that want that REAL GAME experience, IMO it needs to be the first thing addressed.

The NFL has 53 man rosters to allow them to deal with injuries, tired players, and situational plays. The same should be done here... The Energy stat needs to matter more than it apparently does now.

It sounds like a fairly simple change to implement... If your starter gets tired, he'll be subbed out. Problem solved.

Stamina should be tied directly to the Energy Bar... Hell it should be known as the Stamina/Energy Bar instead of an single adjustable Attribute as it is now. Maybe that's the answer to this problem... Remove Stamina from the Attributes.

Last edited Apr 18, 2008 09:09:35
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bulldog2811
Having depth in any "real" game is extremely important... From what I've read, it doesn't matter in this game and owners are playing within the rules as stated. Kudos to them. However, for the rest of us that want that REAL GAME experience, IMO it needs to be the first thing addressed.

The NFL has 53 man rosters to allow them to deal with injuries, tired players, and situational plays. The same should be done here... The Energy stat needs to matter more than it apparently does now.

It sounds like a fairly simple change to implement... If your starter gets tired, he'll be subbed out. Problem solved.

Stamina should be tied directly to the Energy Bar... Hell it should be known as the Stamina/Energy Bar instead of an single adjustable Attribute as it is now. Maybe that's the answer to this problem... Remove Stamina from the Attributes.





53 players on teams with 80k seat stadiums, tv money, etc. etc. Can't expect us to have a roster of that size with 8000 seats and minimal cash. Just won't work. I don't understand the "real" expectation. This isn't "real" and never will be. There are 1000's of variables in the "real" game. In a sim thats just not possibile to replicate.

Last edited Apr 18, 2008 10:22:33
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.