If you can select which region you want to buy a team in, why can't you select what level range as well when you sign up? It might be a bit more work on the back end programming but shouldn't be impossible to do.
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
sois
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ehran
If you can select which region you want to buy a team in, why can't you select what level range as well when you sign up? It might be a bit more work on the back end programming but shouldn't be impossible to do.
Won't work. Everyone will select the lowest league.
If you can select which region you want to buy a team in, why can't you select what level range as well when you sign up? It might be a bit more work on the back end programming but shouldn't be impossible to do.
Won't work. Everyone will select the lowest league.
Kevin Smith
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.
No they wouldn´t. Have a "ripple up" system whereby the appropriate number of teams gets promoted from the adjacent leagues, all the way down to where the team is moving to.
IE: Pro Team gets sold, goes all the way to the bottom tier; two teams from the correspending AAA get promoted to the Pro League conference, two teams from AA go to AAA. Which teams get the extra promotion spot could be decided by an extra playoff game/s.
It would be the fairest solution IMO, and the best way to keep the leagues as competitive as possible.
1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.
No they wouldn´t. Have a "ripple up" system whereby the appropriate number of teams gets promoted from the adjacent leagues, all the way down to where the team is moving to.
IE: Pro Team gets sold, goes all the way to the bottom tier; two teams from the correspending AAA get promoted to the Pro League conference, two teams from AA go to AAA. Which teams get the extra promotion spot could be decided by an extra playoff game/s.
It would be the fairest solution IMO, and the best way to keep the leagues as competitive as possible.
Ehran
offline
offline
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by Ehran
If you can select which region you want to buy a team in, why can't you select what level range as well when you sign up? It might be a bit more work on the back end programming but shouldn't be impossible to do.
Won't work. Everyone will select the lowest league.
<shrug>
Level cap the leagues for signing new players.
Originally posted by Ehran
If you can select which region you want to buy a team in, why can't you select what level range as well when you sign up? It might be a bit more work on the back end programming but shouldn't be impossible to do.
Won't work. Everyone will select the lowest league.
<shrug>
Level cap the leagues for signing new players.
PinTBC
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
On a related note (not addressed to AcidBee):
I think the thing that some people are missing is that if the team has no owner, no GM's, and a bunch of players left on it, those players are going to come and complain about having to stuck on a CPU team, ALL THE TIME.
It sounds all well and good to say "your contract will run out at the end of the season" but what if my owner sells on day 1 or 2 of the season? I'm stuck on a CPU-owned team until day 40? People who have signed on human teams want to play on human-controlled teams with people they know, not in the D-League. We need to let them go if they want.
I guess I am missing why the team would have no owner. The first guy sells it back, and it goes to the first person on your wait list. If you reset everyone on the team's contract to expire at the end of the season, then the new owner gets a season to "win over" the guys on the team if he chooses. He of course could release them if he chose, but it should stop the neccessity of the team gutting for people selling their team right now.
It also addresses the CPU controlled team idea which I think is a very bad idea.
PinTBC
On a related note (not addressed to AcidBee):
I think the thing that some people are missing is that if the team has no owner, no GM's, and a bunch of players left on it, those players are going to come and complain about having to stuck on a CPU team, ALL THE TIME.
It sounds all well and good to say "your contract will run out at the end of the season" but what if my owner sells on day 1 or 2 of the season? I'm stuck on a CPU-owned team until day 40? People who have signed on human teams want to play on human-controlled teams with people they know, not in the D-League. We need to let them go if they want.
I guess I am missing why the team would have no owner. The first guy sells it back, and it goes to the first person on your wait list. If you reset everyone on the team's contract to expire at the end of the season, then the new owner gets a season to "win over" the guys on the team if he chooses. He of course could release them if he chose, but it should stop the neccessity of the team gutting for people selling their team right now.
It also addresses the CPU controlled team idea which I think is a very bad idea.
PinTBC
trentw
offline
offline
I have to say if this is instituted it is extremely unfair to anyone who has bought gutted teams in high level leagues over the past 3 seasons. They basicaly had to spend 1 - 2 seasons paying to own a team in a league they couldn't compete in, and now they see brand new owners getting to drop all the way down to the bottom league and have a chance at a good team right away. I guess it is a good idea but it just seems like a big F U to everyone who has already or currently is dealing with the same problem.
sois
offline
offline
Originally posted by trentw
I have to say if this is instituted it is extremely unfair to anyone who has bought gutted teams in high level leagues over the past 3 seasons. They basicaly had to spend 1 - 2 seasons paying to own a team in a league they couldn't compete in, and now they see brand new owners getting to drop all the way down to the bottom league and have a chance at a good team right away. I guess it is a good idea but it just seems like a big F U to everyone who has already or currently is dealing with the same problem.
Yeah thats a shame, but it is a good idea to fix it. Your thinking doesn't make sense. Slavery was unfair to some in the past, so I guess you think fixing that was a bad idea. Probably not.
I have to say if this is instituted it is extremely unfair to anyone who has bought gutted teams in high level leagues over the past 3 seasons. They basicaly had to spend 1 - 2 seasons paying to own a team in a league they couldn't compete in, and now they see brand new owners getting to drop all the way down to the bottom league and have a chance at a good team right away. I guess it is a good idea but it just seems like a big F U to everyone who has already or currently is dealing with the same problem.
Yeah thats a shame, but it is a good idea to fix it. Your thinking doesn't make sense. Slavery was unfair to some in the past, so I guess you think fixing that was a bad idea. Probably not.
SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by trentw
I have to say if this is instituted it is extremely unfair to anyone who has bought gutted teams in high level leagues over the past 3 seasons. They basicaly had to spend 1 - 2 seasons paying to own a team in a league they couldn't compete in, and now they see brand new owners getting to drop all the way down to the bottom league and have a chance at a good team right away. I guess it is a good idea but it just seems like a big F U to everyone who has already or currently is dealing with the same problem.
Yeah thats a shame, but it is a good idea to fix it. Your thinking doesn't make sense. Slavery was unfair to some in the past, so I guess you think fixing that was a bad idea. Probably not.
lol yeah, im pretty sure the end of slavery wasn't a "slap in the face" to those that had been slaves
Originally posted by trentw
I have to say if this is instituted it is extremely unfair to anyone who has bought gutted teams in high level leagues over the past 3 seasons. They basicaly had to spend 1 - 2 seasons paying to own a team in a league they couldn't compete in, and now they see brand new owners getting to drop all the way down to the bottom league and have a chance at a good team right away. I guess it is a good idea but it just seems like a big F U to everyone who has already or currently is dealing with the same problem.
Yeah thats a shame, but it is a good idea to fix it. Your thinking doesn't make sense. Slavery was unfair to some in the past, so I guess you think fixing that was a bad idea. Probably not.
lol yeah, im pretty sure the end of slavery wasn't a "slap in the face" to those that had been slaves

sois
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
No they wouldn´t. Have a "ripple up" system whereby the appropriate number of teams gets promoted from the adjacent leagues, all the way down to where the team is moving to.
IE: Pro Team gets sold, goes all the way to the bottom tier; two teams from the correspending AAA get promoted to the Pro League conference, two teams from AA go to AAA. Which teams get the extra promotion spot could be decided by an extra playoff game/s.
It would be the fairest solution IMO, and the best way to keep the leagues as competitive as possible.
How can you replace one team with two? That doesn't make sense.
The complication here is the pyramid league structure. Get rid of that and you have an easy fix. One AAA flows into Pro, One A flows into AA... etc.
I don't get why we have a pyramid structure, its not like the leagues have enough intraleague interaction to warrant this. GLB leagues essentially feel like two different 16 team leagues operating under one name.
No they wouldn´t. Have a "ripple up" system whereby the appropriate number of teams gets promoted from the adjacent leagues, all the way down to where the team is moving to.
IE: Pro Team gets sold, goes all the way to the bottom tier; two teams from the correspending AAA get promoted to the Pro League conference, two teams from AA go to AAA. Which teams get the extra promotion spot could be decided by an extra playoff game/s.
It would be the fairest solution IMO, and the best way to keep the leagues as competitive as possible.
How can you replace one team with two? That doesn't make sense.
The complication here is the pyramid league structure. Get rid of that and you have an easy fix. One AAA flows into Pro, One A flows into AA... etc.
I don't get why we have a pyramid structure, its not like the leagues have enough intraleague interaction to warrant this. GLB leagues essentially feel like two different 16 team leagues operating under one name.
Last edited Jul 1, 2008 14:51:42
SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
No they wouldn´t. Have a "ripple up" system whereby the appropriate number of teams gets promoted from the adjacent leagues, all the way down to where the team is moving to.
IE: Pro Team gets sold, goes all the way to the bottom tier; two teams from the correspending AAA get promoted to the Pro League conference, two teams from AA go to AAA. Which teams get the extra promotion spot could be decided by an extra playoff game/s.
It would be the fairest solution IMO, and the best way to keep the leagues as competitive as possible.
How can you replace one team with two? That doesn't make sense.
The complication here is the pyramid league structure. Get rid of that and you have an easy fix. One AAA flows into Pro, One A flows into AA... etc.
I don't get why we have a pyramid structure, its not like the leagues have enough intraleague interaction to warrant this. GLB leagues essentially feel like two different 16 team leagues operating under one name.
this makes the most sense, and if they went to 17 team leagues, you get the same 16 game schedule for those whining about getting bad luck in their inter-conference matches.
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
No they wouldn´t. Have a "ripple up" system whereby the appropriate number of teams gets promoted from the adjacent leagues, all the way down to where the team is moving to.
IE: Pro Team gets sold, goes all the way to the bottom tier; two teams from the correspending AAA get promoted to the Pro League conference, two teams from AA go to AAA. Which teams get the extra promotion spot could be decided by an extra playoff game/s.
It would be the fairest solution IMO, and the best way to keep the leagues as competitive as possible.
How can you replace one team with two? That doesn't make sense.
The complication here is the pyramid league structure. Get rid of that and you have an easy fix. One AAA flows into Pro, One A flows into AA... etc.
I don't get why we have a pyramid structure, its not like the leagues have enough intraleague interaction to warrant this. GLB leagues essentially feel like two different 16 team leagues operating under one name.
this makes the most sense, and if they went to 17 team leagues, you get the same 16 game schedule for those whining about getting bad luck in their inter-conference matches.
We're not getting rid of the pyramid structure. It actually gives teams at the bottom a chance to make it to the top in a reasonable amount of time, instead of starting at ZZZ and having to win 50 seasons in a row to make it to Pro.
We would have to have 100's of regions to do linear progression, which doesn't fit into our plan for a world champion at all.
We would have to have 100's of regions to do linear progression, which doesn't fit into our plan for a world champion at all.
trentw
offline
offline
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by trentw
I have to say if this is instituted it is extremely unfair to anyone who has bought gutted teams in high level leagues over the past 3 seasons. They basicaly had to spend 1 - 2 seasons paying to own a team in a league they couldn't compete in, and now they see brand new owners getting to drop all the way down to the bottom league and have a chance at a good team right away. I guess it is a good idea but it just seems like a big F U to everyone who has already or currently is dealing with the same problem.
Yeah thats a shame, but it is a good idea to fix it. Your thinking doesn't make sense. Slavery was unfair to some in the past, so I guess you think fixing that was a bad idea. Probably not.
My thinking makes perfect sense, I am sure that when slavery ended there were plenty of blacks that while happy, still felt angry, and that "they" were done wrong. Have you ever heard of the term reparations?
Originally posted by trentw
I have to say if this is instituted it is extremely unfair to anyone who has bought gutted teams in high level leagues over the past 3 seasons. They basicaly had to spend 1 - 2 seasons paying to own a team in a league they couldn't compete in, and now they see brand new owners getting to drop all the way down to the bottom league and have a chance at a good team right away. I guess it is a good idea but it just seems like a big F U to everyone who has already or currently is dealing with the same problem.
Yeah thats a shame, but it is a good idea to fix it. Your thinking doesn't make sense. Slavery was unfair to some in the past, so I guess you think fixing that was a bad idea. Probably not.
My thinking makes perfect sense, I am sure that when slavery ended there were plenty of blacks that while happy, still felt angry, and that "they" were done wrong. Have you ever heard of the term reparations?
Buck Nutty
offline
offline
Hmmm #1 I think that is kinda Simple if Team a and B win this season and go to The Pro league then half way throught the season team c decides well hell I do not want the team any more then go back to the previous league and see who came in third for the Team moving up Kinda Like a runner up if Team a or b can not full-fill thier duties as prom queen you are the red headed step schild that gets to take thier spot.
Just a thought
Just a thought
sois
offline
offline
Fair enough.
So one of the remaining debates here is how to determine which team moves up. I like a lot of the ideas presented so I've picked some elements from each and summarized this as a possible suggestion:
Consolation style playoff bracket. This will allow true 1-16 results of the playoff teams. Of the two possible teams up for promotion (#2 seed in each league), measure which team got further in the playoffs. If they (for example, both won championship tourneys) then a playoff game to determine who gets the promotion.
Ideas?
So one of the remaining debates here is how to determine which team moves up. I like a lot of the ideas presented so I've picked some elements from each and summarized this as a possible suggestion:
Consolation style playoff bracket. This will allow true 1-16 results of the playoff teams. Of the two possible teams up for promotion (#2 seed in each league), measure which team got further in the playoffs. If they (for example, both won championship tourneys) then a playoff game to determine who gets the promotion.
Ideas?
Last edited Jul 1, 2008 15:25:05
Cedo
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cedo
1: That's the best question i think. Who's move up?
It's very complicated not really what the most users think...
First step: little final or losing final for each team losing the conf final. So you have 2 teams who move up and a reserve of 2 teams with a rank (3 and 4) for possible gutt relegation.
Ok but that's one league! There's another league who deserve the right to be promoted!
Example AAA1 and AAA2. Each league have the #3 and #4 teams in reserve.
So if we have 2 teams gutted that will be all #3 who are promoted. But if we have only one???? I think, like someone told, we must choose the best team and it's the best standing in regular season. Same rule as regular season to pick one team from same standing.
Now we must think about something: it's a pyramidal system so if you relegate one team from top to bottom, that will have consequencies into ALL leagues.
So with (example) 1 more team in AAA1 who move up. There's a need in AA1 and AA2 to a promotion! Same rule as above.
Etc... etc...
IS there a weakness? In AAA league we have a reserve of 4 teams waiting for promotion. I don't think there will have more than 4 teams over 32 that will be gutted same season.
That's the same structure for the level below with 4 teams over 32. 4 teams in AA1 and AA2, 4 teams in AA3 and AA4 etc... For A level, 4 teams in A1 and A2 etc...
That's plenty of teams available to promotion.
But i see 1 problem: How make this system automatic with some coding? i'm not a coder i don't know. Perhaps that will need an admin hand and that's a lot of work...
My idea for Who must be promoted
1: That's the best question i think. Who's move up?
It's very complicated not really what the most users think...
First step: little final or losing final for each team losing the conf final. So you have 2 teams who move up and a reserve of 2 teams with a rank (3 and 4) for possible gutt relegation.
Ok but that's one league! There's another league who deserve the right to be promoted!
Example AAA1 and AAA2. Each league have the #3 and #4 teams in reserve.
So if we have 2 teams gutted that will be all #3 who are promoted. But if we have only one???? I think, like someone told, we must choose the best team and it's the best standing in regular season. Same rule as regular season to pick one team from same standing.
Now we must think about something: it's a pyramidal system so if you relegate one team from top to bottom, that will have consequencies into ALL leagues.
So with (example) 1 more team in AAA1 who move up. There's a need in AA1 and AA2 to a promotion! Same rule as above.
Etc... etc...
IS there a weakness? In AAA league we have a reserve of 4 teams waiting for promotion. I don't think there will have more than 4 teams over 32 that will be gutted same season.
That's the same structure for the level below with 4 teams over 32. 4 teams in AA1 and AA2, 4 teams in AA3 and AA4 etc... For A level, 4 teams in A1 and A2 etc...
That's plenty of teams available to promotion.
But i see 1 problem: How make this system automatic with some coding? i'm not a coder i don't know. Perhaps that will need an admin hand and that's a lot of work...
My idea for Who must be promoted
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























