User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This was the best suggestion on how to balance extreme attributes...
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
I have a cb with make tackle aeq and another with wrap up tackle sa, both with break block aeq and they miss a TON of tackles in the backfield on pitches. SYM > make tackle aeq

You're missing the point. CBs appear to make those tackles more frequently than their LB counterparts despite the LBs usually having much more tackling. Or if you prefer different phrasing, there isn't enough of a difference considering the massive gap in tackling.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
Originally posted by sunder B

Reality of the current sim says it? tackling is more important in forcing fumbles, but you can certainly make plenty of tackles and miss few of them with low tackling and wrap up setting.


I believe by making this comment you have just excused yourself from big boy dot conversation...


FWIW, I am referring to tackling in relationship to the other majors. 77 tackling is not high compared to what some people have at speed, strength, agility and even vision at some positions.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

You're missing the point. CBs appear to make those tackles more frequently than their LB counterparts despite the LBs usually having much more tackling. Or if you prefer different phrasing, there isn't enough of a difference considering the massive gap in tackling.


I'll agree that there isn't enough of a difference.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
FWIW, I am referring to tackling in relationship to the other majors. 77 tackling is not high compared to what some people have at speed, strength, agility and even vision at some positions.


Okay, redemption succeeded
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
I'll agree that there isn't enough of a difference.

Which gets to the fact that momentum plays such a huge part in tackling.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
My lb's are just as fast as my cb's though...

edit: really, every dot in my secondary has > 125 speed...
Edited by bug03 on Oct 21, 2010 14:17:36
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
My lb's are just as fast as my cb's though...

edit: really, every dot in my secondary has > 125 speed...


125 isn't really all that fast these days. I would say 135 is where secondary can start to qualify as "fast."
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
My lb's are just as fast as my cb's though...

It's about positioning. Regardless of their top speed, LBs are rarely going as fast during their tackle attempts as CBs are, simply because CBs usually travel more uninterrupted distance before the attempt.
 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

It's about positioning. Regardless of their top speed, LBs are rarely going as fast during their tackle attempts as CBs are, simply because CBs usually travel more uninterrupted distance before the attempt.


Also

LBs are heavier than CBs
 
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
Originally posted by jpjn94

Couldn't another option be to link attributes together to reduce how high they could go?

e.g. You can't go higher than 70 in Speed without having 40 in Agility.

You could even at a third attribute to some like the example above you would need a min of 20 in Stamina. Those attributes could be linked all the way up. Then players would be forced to have say 80 in Agility to have 140 in Speed.





If by "best" you mean "sucks ass the best", then you are correct.

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm ok with the idea of making secondary attributes more important, but get your hands off my build. If I want to put every single SP ever earned into a single attribute, there should be nothing other than the ineffectiveness of my dot to discourage me from doing so.

 
charwh
offline
Link
 
People talk a lot about "imbalanced builds", but in general, they seem to mean "ludicrously fast builds". I think, if anything happens, speed should be addressed specifically.

Borts suggestion for nonlinear velocity curves is likely the best solution in those respects.

*nerd talk

Ability Roles are most likely coded as a weighted geometric mean of attributes multiplied by a random number, which means they already depreciate on a nonlinear curve, as far as in game performance is concerned.

On field velocity, however, doesn't have an ability check, so it doesn't depreciate at all for high values, making it unequally balanced compared to other attributes.

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by charwh
People talk a lot about "imbalanced builds", but in general, they seem to mean "ludicrously fast builds". I think, if anything happens, speed should be addressed specifically.

Borts suggestion for nonlinear velocity curves is likely the best solution in those respects.

*nerd talk

Ability Roles are most likely coded as a weighted geometric mean of attributes multiplied by a random number, which means they already depreciate on a nonlinear curve, as far as in game performance is concerned.

On field velocity, however, doesn't have an ability check, so it doesn't depreciate at all for high values, making it unequally balanced compared to other attributes.




Something like this, yes.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
My lb's are just as fast as my cb's though...

edit: really, every dot in my secondary has > 125 speed...


lb's > 125 is not slow is what i meant
 
B-T-A
offline
Link
 
I think LB'ers have more speed usually than CB's, usually you see CB's at 115 Speed/100 Agility, but LB'ers at 130 Speed, 80 Agility.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by F8n4tune

Too easy and the calculator crowd will cry to no end. Great way to do it though and really doesn't need anything to be thought about. ESPECIALLY since it'll make these descriptions of everything actually mean what they say imo.



Not as easy as you think.

For instance, what happens when you make tackling more important in the make tackle roll?

It decreases the value of momentum, and other attributes like strength, agility, and vision. However, it doesn't counter extreme building. It just means that safeties and LBs add more tackling and less strength and agility to their builds, but still keep uber speed.

Strength based DL still keep uber strength, but then add a crap load of tackling and become super human FF machines.

If you change the SIM so that those DL aren't super human tackling/FF machines, then you are making it so you can't build a DB capable of making a tackle and still able to cover a WR.

The only way to make the other attributes more important without throwing the SIM out of whack is to add more functions to the SIM and make a secondary attributes the primary value for each new function.




That seems like something that should already be there doesn't it ? At least that's the way everything reads as if , imo.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.