+1... caps are for a reason
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
ChildishGambino
offline
offline
Originally posted by BadBuc99
A lvl 13 team in a league with a lvl 25 team is rediculous PERIOD!
My team's season is shot, and hopeless before it starts. I'm not buying another flex point until it's fixed. That's a good boycott idea!
Although your team is 4-5 levels under the league Cap I agree with you.
Players immensly over the cap should definitely not be in that league.. and players immensly under the cap and fit in a better league ( such as your team would in cap 14 ) should not be there either.. we need to find a common middle ground to fix the caps and promotion systems.
A lvl 13 team in a league with a lvl 25 team is rediculous PERIOD!
My team's season is shot, and hopeless before it starts. I'm not buying another flex point until it's fixed. That's a good boycott idea!
Although your team is 4-5 levels under the league Cap I agree with you.
Players immensly over the cap should definitely not be in that league.. and players immensly under the cap and fit in a better league ( such as your team would in cap 14 ) should not be there either.. we need to find a common middle ground to fix the caps and promotion systems.
Originally posted by Airhead
OK, here's how I'd do it-
Instead of cap levels how about if we set the leagues up based on seasons the player has been active? Then set up A,B,C and D divisions in each league, with A divisions being made up of teams that have won or have boosted alot and D divisions being primarily occupied by teams that don't boost or haven't been very good or are CPUs. That way the league would keep the same teams in them season after season and we could develop rivalries, better make trades, etc.
It would also encourage parity in a league if a team declined, for whatever reason, and slid over to a C or D division from an A or B division, and might eliminate the need for some teams to gut and start all over.
problem with this is that Bort will not separate boosters and non boosters. After 10 seasons boosters are in the mids 60s, while non boosters are only getting to the early 40s. The level differences get to be pretty big. So essentually later in the careers non boosters wouldn't really be viable. Bort doesn't want to separate boosters and non boosters because it might encourage non boosting.
the idea behind the thread is pretty simple. Just enforce the level caps. No reason why someone should be allowed into a league where they are over the cap.
OK, here's how I'd do it-
Instead of cap levels how about if we set the leagues up based on seasons the player has been active? Then set up A,B,C and D divisions in each league, with A divisions being made up of teams that have won or have boosted alot and D divisions being primarily occupied by teams that don't boost or haven't been very good or are CPUs. That way the league would keep the same teams in them season after season and we could develop rivalries, better make trades, etc.
It would also encourage parity in a league if a team declined, for whatever reason, and slid over to a C or D division from an A or B division, and might eliminate the need for some teams to gut and start all over.
problem with this is that Bort will not separate boosters and non boosters. After 10 seasons boosters are in the mids 60s, while non boosters are only getting to the early 40s. The level differences get to be pretty big. So essentually later in the careers non boosters wouldn't really be viable. Bort doesn't want to separate boosters and non boosters because it might encourage non boosting.
the idea behind the thread is pretty simple. Just enforce the level caps. No reason why someone should be allowed into a league where they are over the cap.
Lurchy
offline
offline
How about each owner is allowed two points for over-caps? Each point is equal to a level of one of the players that is over the cap. So, if one player is over the cap by two levels, that sucks up the two over-cap points and the team will be booted to the next highest level if any other over-cap player is signed or not booted off the team. Or, the two points can be used to reserve two players that are each one level above the cap.
I don't know about all sports, but I do know in junior hockey the teams are allowed to keep one or two players only that are above the age limit but only if they are one year or less above the limit. It works fine.
As long as all teams are actually playing by the same rules, for a change, then every team will have an equal chance to be competitive. Getting bumped up two levels just because your coaches and agents are good and you made the playoffs is punishing the people who are actually putting the most into the game. Wrong on so many levels.
I don't know about all sports, but I do know in junior hockey the teams are allowed to keep one or two players only that are above the age limit but only if they are one year or less above the limit. It works fine.
As long as all teams are actually playing by the same rules, for a change, then every team will have an equal chance to be competitive. Getting bumped up two levels just because your coaches and agents are good and you made the playoffs is punishing the people who are actually putting the most into the game. Wrong on so many levels.
I'd rather not introduce any sort of ways to get in a league above the cap. The caps are only 4 levels apart, it shouldn't be too big of a deal to have to move up because you have a player or two over the cap.
I think the root of the problem is that promotions are based on 4 lvl's each. Parity would seem to be better served if it was reduced to 3 lvl's each. Since you can boost 3 lvl's at the end of the season, and boost 3 lvl's at the beginning of a season.....that's 6 lvl's.
Then make it so no players can boost over the initial cap they are in. After all, those teams that get away with being well over the cap can't sign players over the initial cap......why not make it so players can't boost, or be over the initial cap? Problem solved by 98%.
Then make it so no players can boost over the initial cap they are in. After all, those teams that get away with being well over the cap can't sign players over the initial cap......why not make it so players can't boost, or be over the initial cap? Problem solved by 98%.
the root of the problem is that you promote a certain level of caps irregardless of what your player's levels are. If you are in a 14 cap league, and you are all level 14 at the start, if you don't make the playoffs you are promoted 1 cap (level 18), even though if you boost, all your players will be level 22. That's just crazy to me.
We have elite, competitive and regular leagues now. Why are we still promoting a # of caps based on how well you did?
Why not simply have a team promote into the lowest cap that they fit into. If your highest level player is level 30 than you go to a 32 cap league etc. You still have day 41 to cut people off your roster if you have a few guys that are higher level and would pull you into another cap.
then based on where you finished last season (conf champs vs playoff teams vs bottom of the barrel etc etc) you are placed in whichever league style fits your team (elite, competitive or regular)
it doesn't seem that hard to me...
We have elite, competitive and regular leagues now. Why are we still promoting a # of caps based on how well you did?
Why not simply have a team promote into the lowest cap that they fit into. If your highest level player is level 30 than you go to a 32 cap league etc. You still have day 41 to cut people off your roster if you have a few guys that are higher level and would pull you into another cap.
then based on where you finished last season (conf champs vs playoff teams vs bottom of the barrel etc etc) you are placed in whichever league style fits your team (elite, competitive or regular)
it doesn't seem that hard to me...
ChildishGambino
offline
offline
Originally posted by Chysil
the root of the problem is that you promote a certain level of caps irregardless of what your player's levels are. If you are in a 14 cap league, and you are all level 14 at the start, if you don't make the playoffs you are promoted 1 cap (level 18), even though if you boost, all your players will be level 22. That's just crazy to me.
We have elite, competitive and regular leagues now. Why are we still promoting a # of caps based on how well you did?
Why not simply have a team promote into the lowest cap that they fit into. If your highest level player is level 30 than you go to a 32 cap league etc. You still have day 41 to cut people off your roster if you have a few guys that are higher level and would pull you into another cap.
then based on where you finished last season (conf champs vs playoff teams vs bottom of the barrel etc etc) you are placed in whichever league style fits your team (elite, competitive or regular)
it doesn't seem that hard to me...
I completely agree with this.
the root of the problem is that you promote a certain level of caps irregardless of what your player's levels are. If you are in a 14 cap league, and you are all level 14 at the start, if you don't make the playoffs you are promoted 1 cap (level 18), even though if you boost, all your players will be level 22. That's just crazy to me.
We have elite, competitive and regular leagues now. Why are we still promoting a # of caps based on how well you did?
Why not simply have a team promote into the lowest cap that they fit into. If your highest level player is level 30 than you go to a 32 cap league etc. You still have day 41 to cut people off your roster if you have a few guys that are higher level and would pull you into another cap.
then based on where you finished last season (conf champs vs playoff teams vs bottom of the barrel etc etc) you are placed in whichever league style fits your team (elite, competitive or regular)
it doesn't seem that hard to me...
I completely agree with this.
Airhead
offline
offline
Originally posted by Chysil
problem with this is that Bort will not separate boosters and non boosters. After 10 seasons boosters are in the mids 60s, while non boosters are only getting to the early 40s. The level differences get to be pretty big. So essentually later in the careers non boosters wouldn't really be viable. Bort doesn't want to separate boosters and non boosters because it might encourage non boosting.
the idea behind the thread is pretty simple. Just enforce the level caps. No reason why someone should be allowed into a league where they are over the cap.
If we established the leagues by age of the players, and each league had A,B,C,D or E divisions where A is the top level for competitive teams who boost and D or E is for those who don't, then that in itself would encourage boosting at selected times at the least among those players on a C or D division for selected seasons.As it is now non boosting players are rewarded under the current system by being able to train attributes longer and still qualify for a lower league simply because they don't boost- if at the end of ten seasons a player who has never boosted is 25 levels behind players who have boosted and they find their division options to be a CPU team or a non boosting team then whatever, we have the option to boost if we want.
problem with this is that Bort will not separate boosters and non boosters. After 10 seasons boosters are in the mids 60s, while non boosters are only getting to the early 40s. The level differences get to be pretty big. So essentually later in the careers non boosters wouldn't really be viable. Bort doesn't want to separate boosters and non boosters because it might encourage non boosting.
the idea behind the thread is pretty simple. Just enforce the level caps. No reason why someone should be allowed into a league where they are over the cap.
If we established the leagues by age of the players, and each league had A,B,C,D or E divisions where A is the top level for competitive teams who boost and D or E is for those who don't, then that in itself would encourage boosting at selected times at the least among those players on a C or D division for selected seasons.As it is now non boosting players are rewarded under the current system by being able to train attributes longer and still qualify for a lower league simply because they don't boost- if at the end of ten seasons a player who has never boosted is 25 levels behind players who have boosted and they find their division options to be a CPU team or a non boosting team then whatever, we have the option to boost if we want.
ChildishGambino
offline
offline
I disagree with the whole A B C D E league system situation. Like stated above Bort doesn't want to separate boosters and non boosters... if he did he would start losing money IMO.
a non boosting player will be better than any players of the same level that boost (if both built by equally skilled players).
however, a non boosting player will never really make it out of the caps. So for the last oh... 4 + plateau + extended plateau = 8 seasons the boosters are essentually playing with only other boosters or semi boosters.
the thing is, most non boosters WANT a league where they are separated. That proposed system would essentually give them just that.
it's not really something Bort wants to do... no matter if I agree with it or not, Bort has said time and time again (it's even on the NGTH list) that he would not separate boosters and non boosters
however, a non boosting player will never really make it out of the caps. So for the last oh... 4 + plateau + extended plateau = 8 seasons the boosters are essentually playing with only other boosters or semi boosters.
the thing is, most non boosters WANT a league where they are separated. That proposed system would essentually give them just that.
it's not really something Bort wants to do... no matter if I agree with it or not, Bort has said time and time again (it's even on the NGTH list) that he would not separate boosters and non boosters
Airhead
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dustin.
I disagree with the whole A B C D E league system situation. Like stated above Bort doesn't want to separate boosters and non boosters... if he did he would start losing money IMO.
He wouldn't have to separate boosters and non boosters. Non booster teams would gradually slide over to the C,D,E division and booster teams would slide over to the A,B,C divisions. Keep strict year leagues for the first several years and maybe open it up so players can be 2, 3 years apart after they have a few years in and the leagues naturally have to consolidate.
I ain't no Nelson Rockwell, but it seems kinda silly to allow non paying customers an advantage over paying customers, at least as far as lower leagues are concerned, and that's what the current system does, besides discouraging rivalries.
I disagree with the whole A B C D E league system situation. Like stated above Bort doesn't want to separate boosters and non boosters... if he did he would start losing money IMO.
He wouldn't have to separate boosters and non boosters. Non booster teams would gradually slide over to the C,D,E division and booster teams would slide over to the A,B,C divisions. Keep strict year leagues for the first several years and maybe open it up so players can be 2, 3 years apart after they have a few years in and the leagues naturally have to consolidate.
I ain't no Nelson Rockwell, but it seems kinda silly to allow non paying customers an advantage over paying customers, at least as far as lower leagues are concerned, and that's what the current system does, besides discouraging rivalries.
ChildishGambino
offline
offline
Originally posted by Airhead
I ain't no Nelson Rockwell, but it seems kinda silly to allow non paying customers an advantage over paying customers, at least as far as lower leagues are concerned, and that's what the current system does, besides discouraging rivalries.
IMO this is balanced by the fact they won't be able to play Pro or WL.
I ain't no Nelson Rockwell, but it seems kinda silly to allow non paying customers an advantage over paying customers, at least as far as lower leagues are concerned, and that's what the current system does, besides discouraging rivalries.
IMO this is balanced by the fact they won't be able to play Pro or WL.
Originally posted by Airhead
He wouldn't have to separate boosters and non boosters. Non booster teams would gradually slide over to the C,D,E division and booster teams would slide over to the A,B,C divisions.
if all the non boosting teams are in the lower tiers, and all the boosting teams are in the upper tiers... how is that NOT separating the boosters and non boosters. It might not be a forced separation, but it's close.
Originally posted by Airhead
I ain't no Nelson Rockwell, but it seems kinda silly to allow non paying customers an advantage over paying customers, at least as far as lower leagues are concerned, and that's what the current system does, besides discouraging rivalries.
This is an entirely different issue, and all an age based system would do is be a bandaid to the issue. Not to mention make nonboosters damn near unusable in their later seasons due to level disadvantage, which certainly isn't good for business seeing as a lot of people start out not boosting and boost when they get hooked etc.
giving out TP when boosting would be a way to keep people of same level fairly close regardless of age but when you do that, those people that boosted previously will want all their back owed TPs etc
He wouldn't have to separate boosters and non boosters. Non booster teams would gradually slide over to the C,D,E division and booster teams would slide over to the A,B,C divisions.
if all the non boosting teams are in the lower tiers, and all the boosting teams are in the upper tiers... how is that NOT separating the boosters and non boosters. It might not be a forced separation, but it's close.
Originally posted by Airhead
I ain't no Nelson Rockwell, but it seems kinda silly to allow non paying customers an advantage over paying customers, at least as far as lower leagues are concerned, and that's what the current system does, besides discouraging rivalries.
This is an entirely different issue, and all an age based system would do is be a bandaid to the issue. Not to mention make nonboosters damn near unusable in their later seasons due to level disadvantage, which certainly isn't good for business seeing as a lot of people start out not boosting and boost when they get hooked etc.
giving out TP when boosting would be a way to keep people of same level fairly close regardless of age but when you do that, those people that boosted previously will want all their back owed TPs etc
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























