User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Stop the trophies for LOL GM's
Page:
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Ahhh, I should've read more than the last page.

I still don't have an opinion here because I have two trophies that I got just for being on the team, and the rest I "earned". I am, however, likely to end up with some loltrophies this season but I'm fine with that.

I do see your point about hiring an OC/DC, etc. but again, I would never do that off of trophies. I would have to have interacted/known the agent for at least a season. I end up OCing myself anyway.

To this point, I remember back in like season two when the Scotch Cocks did this, and I had to fire a guy off my buddy's team because he came in saying he had DC'd the Cocks when I knew the DC and knew this guy had just gone fishing for a trophy.


My point to this thread is to stop the type of players you spoke of for the scotch cocks. I don't have a problem with people getting trophies because they are associated with a team or they get added as GM's since they have players on the team. atleast they are contributing to the team in some way. I would love to see all these guys that are PMing teams wanting them to add them as a GM for a free trophy stopped completely.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hatchman

If you earned them then good for you. just looking at your trophies I see 1 with a actual job title which was a recruiter one. but that doesn't mean you didn't earn them. I do see it though as you took offense when no one spoke of you so there may be something you feel you need to try to defend?


No need to defend myself, I just help out with builds for some teams, do a bit of scouting and sometimes a bit of recruiting. I do whatever the owner asks me tbh
 
eaglesfan20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hatchman
My point to this thread is to stop the type of players you spoke of for the scotch cocks. I don't have a problem with people getting trophies because they are associated with a team or they get added as GM's since they have players on the team. atleast they are contributing to the team in some way. I would love to see all these guys that are PMing teams wanting them to add them as a GM for a free trophy stopped completely.


sounds like a good idea - if you dont have a player on said team or arent given a role(OC,DC,Scout, whatever) then you should be able to be a GM for that team, but granted i guess if people want to build up their online ego they will still find a way

but i agree they should have some something that links them to the team other that just GM of "fill in team", without at least a player on that team
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
I think the main problem we're talking about is the fact that having a player on a championship winning team doesn't give you anything in your profile to show off.

How about this suggestion?

Remove all "GM" spots from teams, leave only the positional jobs.

Give every agent who has a player/players on a championship team a silver or gold or both trophies that say "Agent" of Team so-and-so Season so-and-so.
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brady2moss2endzone
Originally posted by hatchman


If you earned them then good for you. just looking at your trophies I see 1 with a actual job title which was a recruiter one. but that doesn't mean you didn't earn them. I do see it though as you took offense when no one spoke of you so there may be something you feel you need to try to defend?


No need to defend myself, I just help out with builds for some teams, do a bit of scouting and sometimes a bit of recruiting. I do whatever the owner asks me tbh



then this thread is not intended towards you. If you read the thread you will see I explain that I was never meaning this towards players like yourself. I have even outlined the players that this thread is about.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I think the main problem we're talking about is the fact that having a player on a championship winning team doesn't give you anything in your profile to show off.

How about this suggestion?

Remove all "GM" spots from teams, leave only the positional jobs.

Give every agent who has a player/players on a championship team a silver or gold or both trophies that say "Agent" of Team so-and-so Season so-and-so.


Best solution.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Best solution.


Would you even say that's an Epic solution???
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hatchman

then this thread is not intended towards you. If you read the thread you will see I explain that I was never meaning this towards players like yourself. I have even outlined the players that this thread is about.


my first post was just random tbh, lol
 
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Would you even say that's an Epic solution???


Only if you want the idea to die a quiet death
 
LifeJuice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by VolBrian

I think the main problem we're talking about is the fact that having a player on a championship winning team doesn't give you anything in your profile to show off.

How about this suggestion?

Remove all "GM" spots from teams, leave only the positional jobs.

Give every agent who has a player/players on a championship team a silver or gold or both trophies that say "Agent" of Team so-and-so Season so-and-so.


Best solution.


So if my team won the championship I'd get like 50 trophies?
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I think the main problem we're talking about is the fact that having a player on a championship winning team doesn't give you anything in your profile to show off.

How about this suggestion?

Remove all "GM" spots from teams, leave only the positional jobs.

Give every agent who has a player/players on a championship team a silver or gold or both trophies that say "Agent" of Team so-and-so Season so-and-so.


this is a possible option but I know on my own team I have some players in the GM slots that really do jobs for my team. one guy does write-ups for the team forum and he is a very valuable part of the team. I think we need to just band together as owners and stop the LOL GM's completly. as long as a person is associated with your team and they do a job of some sort or have a player then it is fine for them to get a GM trophy in my opinion. But all GM's need to have some sort of role with the team in my opinion.

I also think that there should be a way that when a agent sends a PM asking to be a LOL GM for the playoffs just to get a trophy that we should be able to send that PM to a Mod and have them banned for a few days or some type of punishment. this would stop all the BS PM's.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LifeJuice
So if my team won the championship I'd get like 50 trophies?


Ohh, didn't consider that. Maybe just one "Agent" trophy no matter how many players you've got. "Agent" instead of "Player" I suppose. Still would satisfy the issue imo.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Only if you want the idea to die a quiet death


well played...
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hatchman

I also think that there should be a way that when a agent sends a PM asking to be a LOL GM for the playoffs just to get a trophy that we should be able to send that PM to a Mod and have them banned for a few days or some type of punishment. this would stop all the BS PM's.


I've had at least one team since season one and have never had that happen to me. Maybe my teams don't win enough.....
 
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I've had at least one team since season one and have never had that happen to me. Maybe my teams don't win enough.....


P/much this.

Though, not sure, but you could check into the Spam rules and see if it applies to PM's and if you get other owners that have had the same issue from the same agent.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.