User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tackling: The most useless attribute?
Page:
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
The problem is that in one game he missed 3 tackles out of 7 attempts against a rusher that has Strength and Carrying Stoked. (you can view his stats because you are still a GM there). Vision should have played against strength in those situations where the rusher was hit at the LOS and the superior vision my FS has( and the superior vision of the other FS) should have factored in to the the tackle chance more than it obviously did.


which game?
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
Well, that's the easy way to end a conversation I guess....

Status quo...as is.

A Well-built DB with superior Vision/Tackling should be able to tackle a Strength/Carrying Powerback at least 50% of the time.


5 super vision is not exactly having imo
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
This thread is making me lol........ Meatdawg is correct in almost everything he is saying IMO. This game is really all about "situationals" and DTs have the worst chance at making a tackle because of those. Simply put, we are not talking about 2 different players, one DT and one CB doing 1 on 1 tackling dummy drills.

What we are talking about is a ROLL from a RNG, and quite frankly even with 100 tackling your dude will miss some here and there even when he isn't double team blocked/ tired/ been pancaked 8 times already from a 140 STR Center with Showboat/ all the other things mentioned here. Catching the point?

Where the problem lies IMO, is definitely in the fact jktooley brings up that CBs never miss a fricking tackle against a power back. It is definitely the way the game mechanics work right now, but maybe (just maybe) if CBs were run-the-fuck over every once in a while, then they wouldn't be a 3 attribute build with maxed out SAs? Might mean a pure SPD WR might have merit again.....




Originally posted by jktooley
ib4 : "tool" in ur name bro


and LMFAO!

Edited by We_Rule on May 5, 2010 23:01:51
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PLAYMAKERS
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

Well, that's the easy way to end a conversation I guess....

Status quo...as is.

A Well-built DB with superior Vision/Tackling should be able to tackle a Strength/Carrying Powerback at least 50% of the time.


5 super vision is not exactly having imo


Combined with 70+vision it should be.
 
Veg
offline
Link
 
5 super vision isnt exactly alot. I guess the real question is how much does it add to where he may get the jump on an int/tackle. Im still pretty sure the main function of SV is to not get faked often then the getting a jump on things is a secondary reaction.
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
I hate failed jokes.


isnt this what your mom said when you were born?
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
Combined with 70+vision it should be.


 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Veg
5 super vision isnt exactly alot. I guess the real question is how much does it add to where he may get the jump on an int/tackle. Im still pretty sure the main function of SV is to not get faked often then the getting a jump on things is a secondary reaction.


Look, The DBs both had 70 + vision, and I'm fairly certain the RB wasn't even close. the missed tackels that happened, happened at the LOS. In other words,, the DB "knew what play was coming, they hit the RB, and the RB went through them. In other words, the vision needed by DBs To defend against the pass is useless against RBs with 100+ strength. That is the reason we see playoff games evry season with 70+ rushes and 5-10 passes.

Click on a playoff game from the last 2 seasons, you'll see what I mean.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PLAYMAKERS
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

Combined with 70+vision it should be.




EAD?
 
boondocksaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Veg
5 super vision isnt exactly alot. I guess the real question is how much does it add to where he may get the jump on an int/tackle. Im still pretty sure the main function of SV is to not get faked often then the getting a jump on things is a secondary reaction.


While I agree with your sentiment, this is simply not true. SV does little to nothing to avoid being faked, even though that's what's in the desciption of the SA. I'm not saying it's useless, but to say it does what it says it does is ridiculous imo.

Re: the tackling debate- imo, if a player can get into position for a tackle, and has a high tackling attribute value, said player should make the tackle far more often than not. Personally, I think everyone is caught up in the "getting into position to attempt a tackle" debate, which is a seperate conversation altogether.

I do think that the tackling attribute should play a bit more into the make tackle roll though, fwiw. But I'd be more content if we could fix the fakes part of the sim- also not relevant to this conversation.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Veg
5 super vision isnt exactly alot. I guess the real question is how much does it add to where he may get the jump on an int/tackle. Im still pretty sure the main function of SV is to not get faked often then the getting a jump on things is a secondary reaction.

You're missing the meaning,. when I say superior vision, I don't mean the SA, I'm talking about attributive value. 70 points in a FS's vision should help him tackle a RB at or around the LOS.
Edited by jaxinthebox on May 5, 2010 23:44:45
 
Billy Corman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

You're missing the meaning,. when I say superior vision, I don't mean the SA, I'm talking about attributive value. 70 points in a FS's vision should help him tackle a RB at or around the LOS.


This is the most awesome FAIL post I have read in these forums.
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
tackling is worthless...48 is the most anyone needs
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Billy Corman
Originally posted by jaxinthebox


You're missing the meaning,. when I say superior vision, I don't mean the SA, I'm talking about attributive value. 70 points in a FS's vision should help him tackle a RB at or around the LOS.


This is the most awesome FAIL post I have read in these forums.


thanks for your proof.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Billy Corman

This is the most awesome FAIL post I have read in these forums.


says the troll with no links to support his claim.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.