
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This is insane (Promotion complaint)
Jiddy78
offline
offline
So lemme get this straight....Cap 18 is a consolation LOLTrophy for the non-playoff cap 14 teams then?
Oh for f*ck's sake...
*points to signature*
Oh for f*ck's sake...
*points to signature*
djp68
offline
offline
Originally posted by reddogrw
The new announcement pretty much sums it up
http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=289
either complete demotion back to square one or go where your promotions take you
We really need a fixed league option. GLB is a great game, but their management of competition levels leaves a lot to be desired.
The new announcement pretty much sums it up
http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=289
either complete demotion back to square one or go where your promotions take you
We really need a fixed league option. GLB is a great game, but their management of competition levels leaves a lot to be desired.
razor9
offline
offline
This is pretty gay. I don't think that the explanation of the rules was clear enough to begin with. I think a lot of teams let players go thinking that they would be allowed to slide into a cap. With that many people operating under that premise, I think the change was poorly explained.
Cap exploitation's biggest problem was the demotion then boosting, not the demotion itself. The demotion allows teams who might have been successful against crap teams but blown away by others to get on a level playing field where everyone is roughly the same level. The boosting was the part that made it unfair because teams would tank then hold their boosts to 3 levels over the cap, then 3 more to start the season.
It just doesn't make any sense. People can say whatever they want about game planning this and build that, but that's just people who haven't been through it season after season. Competitive is not winning 11 games against crap teams and getting hammered by 5 teams who are 6 levels higher than you on average. Who are you competitive with? Not the teams you beat 100-0 and not the teams that beat you 100-0.
We're addressing a problem here by over fixing it. This is yet another issue that will drive players away from the game.
Cap exploitation's biggest problem was the demotion then boosting, not the demotion itself. The demotion allows teams who might have been successful against crap teams but blown away by others to get on a level playing field where everyone is roughly the same level. The boosting was the part that made it unfair because teams would tank then hold their boosts to 3 levels over the cap, then 3 more to start the season.
It just doesn't make any sense. People can say whatever they want about game planning this and build that, but that's just people who haven't been through it season after season. Competitive is not winning 11 games against crap teams and getting hammered by 5 teams who are 6 levels higher than you on average. Who are you competitive with? Not the teams you beat 100-0 and not the teams that beat you 100-0.
We're addressing a problem here by over fixing it. This is yet another issue that will drive players away from the game.
Catch22
offline
offline
for what it's worth I'm not a fan of how it's done, but it's not going to be changed this off season. Definitely something that needs addressing imo though.
23yrwej
offline
offline
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
apparently you should start a level 1 team in a high level so you can get a demotion the next season...interesting
Or you can just take your losses and not get demoted because you know that promotion will be much faster when your slowbuilds are finished. But who would do that?
apparently you should start a level 1 team in a high level so you can get a demotion the next season...interesting
Or you can just take your losses and not get demoted because you know that promotion will be much faster when your slowbuilds are finished. But who would do that?

Jaxon Voom
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
That's the spirit.
I always think my team's going to do worse than it does. Just remember that levels don't necessarily mean good builds or gameplanning ability. Put in the effort and you can shock some people.
But do I want to if my reward is non-boosting level 22ish dots vs. boosting level 30-35ish dots?
That is the question.
Tbh i've always been against changing the rules for people who don't spend money on the game. I wouldn't think it's fair that your non-boosting team (therefore much better at their levels than regular built teams due to the extra training) should be allowed to snail through the minors just so they can be competitive. If you don't want to boost, it's the price you have to pay unfortunately.
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
That's the spirit.
I always think my team's going to do worse than it does. Just remember that levels don't necessarily mean good builds or gameplanning ability. Put in the effort and you can shock some people.
But do I want to if my reward is non-boosting level 22ish dots vs. boosting level 30-35ish dots?
That is the question.
Tbh i've always been against changing the rules for people who don't spend money on the game. I wouldn't think it's fair that your non-boosting team (therefore much better at their levels than regular built teams due to the extra training) should be allowed to snail through the minors just so they can be competitive. If you don't want to boost, it's the price you have to pay unfortunately.
Jiddy78
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catch22
for what it's worth I'm not a fan of how it's done, but it's not going to be changed this off season. Definitely something that needs addressing imo though.
Why not this offseason?
What the f*ck are you waiting for?
Stamp your mark in this sumb*tch.
for what it's worth I'm not a fan of how it's done, but it's not going to be changed this off season. Definitely something that needs addressing imo though.
Why not this offseason?
What the f*ck are you waiting for?
Stamp your mark in this sumb*tch.
Timetoshine-Metta
offline
offline
Originally posted by jrry32
Or you can just take your losses and not get demoted because you know that promotion will be much faster when your slowbuilds are finished. But who would do that?
ok mr. I have 91 million
Or you can just take your losses and not get demoted because you know that promotion will be much faster when your slowbuilds are finished. But who would do that?

ok mr. I have 91 million
kyxoan
offline
offline
I'm not sure if rules are just being made up as you go along or what, but 2 seasons ago, a casual team I was on made the playoffs and was cap 13, we were slated to move up to cap 24 and requested to be demoted to cap 18 because our players were all 16 - 18 and cap 24 would be stupid to go into, our request was granted.
I restarted my own minors team this year with level 1 players, we were in a bad league with other level 1 teams and cpu teams and went 10 - 6 and I requested a demotion aka stay at the same cap. Our highest player is 11, am I not going to get this request fulfilled because I made the playoffs in a terrible league?
If you are trying to lose customers, this is the way to do it.
I restarted my own minors team this year with level 1 players, we were in a bad league with other level 1 teams and cpu teams and went 10 - 6 and I requested a demotion aka stay at the same cap. Our highest player is 11, am I not going to get this request fulfilled because I made the playoffs in a terrible league?
If you are trying to lose customers, this is the way to do it.
merenoise
offline
offline
Part of the problem is that teams have different levels of pre-planning well before the teams are released and the bottom level of the cloud is a weird mix of levels/goals.
Some teams have an entire roster already set up on a Pee Wee/Farm team the season before they plan on getting their team. These are the teams that are usually competing for a trophy out of the gate and the teams that will quickly rise through the cloud and out into the pyramid. Other teams recruit their capped 14 teams with all level 1s or CPUs to give them a season of extra money towards the stadium. These teams hang out at the bottom of the cloud for a couple of seasons but can become competitive once they begin the real phase of their team. And finally you have some new owners who just try to build a roster once they get their team leaving them with a team that can crush the second group but gets rocked by the first group. This group gets shuffled through the cloud for a while until they realize that they are swimming upstream and gut.
Two things that could help with the problem:
1. No team sales to new agents until they have been on the site at least 1 season. This one is tough because it limits the amount of money Bort can make and limits new agents from owning a team. Still, a waiting period where potential owners learn the ins and outs of how the game works would mean fewer teams recruiting the left over players that don't fit the bottom cap and would give the new owners a little more time to prepare for team ownership before they jump right in.
2. Add a new bottom tier in the cloud for level 1-4 teams. Cap it at level 4 so if an owner wants to work on their stadium with CPUs and/or slow build from the ground up they don't skew the win/loss records in capped 14.
Some teams have an entire roster already set up on a Pee Wee/Farm team the season before they plan on getting their team. These are the teams that are usually competing for a trophy out of the gate and the teams that will quickly rise through the cloud and out into the pyramid. Other teams recruit their capped 14 teams with all level 1s or CPUs to give them a season of extra money towards the stadium. These teams hang out at the bottom of the cloud for a couple of seasons but can become competitive once they begin the real phase of their team. And finally you have some new owners who just try to build a roster once they get their team leaving them with a team that can crush the second group but gets rocked by the first group. This group gets shuffled through the cloud for a while until they realize that they are swimming upstream and gut.
Two things that could help with the problem:
1. No team sales to new agents until they have been on the site at least 1 season. This one is tough because it limits the amount of money Bort can make and limits new agents from owning a team. Still, a waiting period where potential owners learn the ins and outs of how the game works would mean fewer teams recruiting the left over players that don't fit the bottom cap and would give the new owners a little more time to prepare for team ownership before they jump right in.
2. Add a new bottom tier in the cloud for level 1-4 teams. Cap it at level 4 so if an owner wants to work on their stadium with CPUs and/or slow build from the ground up they don't skew the win/loss records in capped 14.
Edited by merenoise on Jan 20, 2010 12:31:35
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Take the highest player on the team at rollover....Cap that he belongs in level-wise is yer cap. The end.
Should be in epic suggestions
To take it one step further
The leagues within a cap level should be sorted by oldest player on team
For example say cap 14 has 10 leagues
If there are several teams with a player 100+ days old, they would go into Cap 14 #1
Once the leagues are formed, you add a creation date cap to the league that is = the creation date of oldest player in league.
Take the highest player on the team at rollover....Cap that he belongs in level-wise is yer cap. The end.
Should be in epic suggestions
To take it one step further
The leagues within a cap level should be sorted by oldest player on team
For example say cap 14 has 10 leagues
If there are several teams with a player 100+ days old, they would go into Cap 14 #1
Once the leagues are formed, you add a creation date cap to the league that is = the creation date of oldest player in league.
austin8214
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by Catch22
for what it's worth I'm not a fan of how it's done, but it's not going to be changed this off season. Definitely something that needs addressing imo though.
Why not this offseason?
What the f*ck are you waiting for?
Stamp your mark in this sumb*tch.
+1
Originally posted by Catch22
for what it's worth I'm not a fan of how it's done, but it's not going to be changed this off season. Definitely something that needs addressing imo though.
Why not this offseason?
What the f*ck are you waiting for?
Stamp your mark in this sumb*tch.
+1
BengalFish
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
You would. Even agents who don't boost or have multi's complain like whiny little kids.
As far as the OP goes, surely the goal is to reach Pro/World Leagues so get there as fast as you can. Your players will catch up with your cap eventually and i highly doubt that your new level 22 league will be full of stacked level 22 rosters. It'll be a bunch of CPU's and teams in the exact same boat as you. Believe it or not, you aren't the only team that's going to be promoted under those circumstances.

What you are not getting is that Support is approving some and not approving others that are in the same exact situation. How can you tell one team who went 11-5 made the playoffs that they can go up 1 tier then tell another one that they have to adhere to the rules and promote two tiers that finished the same exact record in another league comparable levels despite being more under leveled than the original team who got their wish?
You would. Even agents who don't boost or have multi's complain like whiny little kids.
As far as the OP goes, surely the goal is to reach Pro/World Leagues so get there as fast as you can. Your players will catch up with your cap eventually and i highly doubt that your new level 22 league will be full of stacked level 22 rosters. It'll be a bunch of CPU's and teams in the exact same boat as you. Believe it or not, you aren't the only team that's going to be promoted under those circumstances.

What you are not getting is that Support is approving some and not approving others that are in the same exact situation. How can you tell one team who went 11-5 made the playoffs that they can go up 1 tier then tell another one that they have to adhere to the rules and promote two tiers that finished the same exact record in another league comparable levels despite being more under leveled than the original team who got their wish?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























