User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
No one said you shouldn't do that. But if you are gutting a team in AAA or PRO and moving it to Africa or BBB, then you should pay a penalty. Originally posted by Dudeamis

Originally posted by crawlins


Originally posted by CroBot



Seriously, there goes everybody's recruiting efforts. There's such a thing as too much parity and this is it. Just because a player is in BBB and is level 19 DOES NOT mean that they're cheating, or that they're there to pad their stats. What's the fun in the game when all your recruiting work goes for naught and Bort is forcing everybody to be equal and boring?


OR...you could play against competitive competition. There is a reason they don't let High Schoolers play dodge ball with 1st graders...or are you saying thats fair too? Darn gym teachers forcing everyone to be equal!


So I shouldn't build the best team possible? I should just aim for middle of the road? What NFL team does that? What College team does that?




Seems like we're all paying for someone elses mistakes, its basic training all over again.
 
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
I would like to hear more detail about this before i make a decision.

I just don't want it to be some kind of shadow factor that decides games.
 
Xenetha
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nats Kule
This rule will not affect 99% of the players in GLB. If you bring a superstar to a crappy league the guy will have his XP hit. Overall it is a good rule. How much improvement would Ray Lewis get if he played HS ball?

I'm guessing but it is probably something like this:

The median not the average for the league is determined. If all players in the league were in rank order by level it would be the level of the player in the middle. Should be around a low level starter.

Then there would be the fudge factor, probably something like three standard deviations or something like that, where 99% of the players are fine, and the top 1% will receive less XP, most likely in accordance to how far away from the median they are.

Do you really want level 20 guys in leagues with 10 medians? This shouldn't hurt the 16s or so, just the outliers that are crazy. You can still do it but it stunts their growth. It really only hurts the folks that want to bring a ton of high level guys to a low level league and dominate. Better players in better leagues.


This guy probably has the idea figured out right. Median is definitely better than average and I think this idea could help the game. Bort stated he is not out to hurt teams.

 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
I think a much better solution to the cutting a running to lower and lower leagues would be to stop making lower and lower leagues!

Starting a second server with totally new pyramids seems like a better solution to me.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seven7
all of you know that a lv 8 playing against a lv 19 is not fair , bort is just trying to level the playing field out for us all to make the game more balanced ,


don't you mean mediocre?

10 minutes a day of recruiting is just too much work, I hope Bort can make a rule that will save me all the hassle.
 
hexone
offline
Link
 
Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by nfratami

All MMOs do stuff like this.

You know why? because it allows the mid level "gamers" who aren't intense but make up the majority of the customer base to compete at a high level. This rule no matter how minor or whatever it is, affects the top level of owners who spend a lot of time recruiting high level players and building the best team they can more than anyone else.

You can see actions like this mirrored in other MMOs online...

Star Wars Galaxies - When the game was released Jedi's were very hard to obtain and very hard to make strong. Today anyone can pick Jedi as a profession. This is so that all the moderate/mid-level gamers can get the satisfaction that previously could only be obtained with extremem dedication and effort. There are many more moderate level games that hardcore ones, making this the smart business move.

World of Warcraft - before the burning crusade it was very difficult to obtain Multiple Epic gear items. After the burning crusade every newb on the block is full of purple gear. This was also done to please the moderate games a.k.a. the biggest source of revenue.


Your analogy falls apart because this MMO has a different business model. They should be catering to the hardcore players because they are the ones who dump money into the game disproportionately. Those MMOs you mentioned all use flat rate monthly fees.


I feel like it is a good analogy in that any player here can spend a good amount of money and not spend a lot of time on the site. This punishes the owner who could have quite possibly spent his only purchased FP ever on a team, and then busts his ass of recruiting.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Unconquered
Originally posted by Bigmo6967

Originally posted by Unconquered


Originally posted by Bigmo6967



Its like turning on the light when living in the ghetto. Watch the roaches scurry this way and that. I Like this idea. I think a level 22 player in BBB is just wrong.


What's wrong with lets say a level 20? Because you have trouble signing level 13's? I spend hours and hours a day recruiting this offseason and I was able to sign two level 20's because I am skillful in recruiting. Like any hobby/game the more you spend at it the better you'll get. I don't feel the Owner who spends 1 hour a week on GLB should be given resources to help compete against the guys who spend hours a day. Just my personal opinion though. We'll see how it really affects things though.


I spend perhaps 6 to 9 hours here daily. No lack of effort here. Do I want level 25 guys playing on my team in A? Not really. I don't need to spend most of my day trying to pump up players egos when we can have an active forum talking about real issues like whats your favorite drink?


We just had a discussion

Grilled Cheese or PB&J

For me Grilled Cheese all day.


Man I am PB&J all the way. Maybe thats it. We butted heads due to our philosophical differences on our choice of sandwich. How about beer? Bottle, draft, or cans????
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doger
I don't see this as a negative at all. If it was done strictly by level then I would, but since it's using a median level and longevity is being factored in all I see it doing is discouraging ringer teams, which everyone except the people doing it hated anyway, and encouraging a team to stay together season after season and work to move up.




isn't chemistry suppose to be for this.
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
Originally posted by Unconquered

Originally posted by Bigmo6967


Originally posted by Unconquered



Originally posted by Bigmo6967




Its like turning on the light when living in the ghetto. Watch the roaches scurry this way and that. I Like this idea. I think a level 22 player in BBB is just wrong.


What's wrong with lets say a level 20? Because you have trouble signing level 13's? I spend hours and hours a day recruiting this offseason and I was able to sign two level 20's because I am skillful in recruiting. Like any hobby/game the more you spend at it the better you'll get. I don't feel the Owner who spends 1 hour a week on GLB should be given resources to help compete against the guys who spend hours a day. Just my personal opinion though. We'll see how it really affects things though.


I spend perhaps 6 to 9 hours here daily. No lack of effort here. Do I want level 25 guys playing on my team in A? Not really. I don't need to spend most of my day trying to pump up players egos when we can have an active forum talking about real issues like whats your favorite drink?


We just had a discussion

Grilled Cheese or PB&J

For me Grilled Cheese all day.


Man I am PB&J all the way. Maybe thats it. We butted heads due to our philosophical differences on our choice of sandwich. How about beer? Bottle, draft, or cans????


Dude i'm in Iraq i'd drink Beer out of a damn shot glass I don't care lol.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by nfratami

All MMOs do stuff like this.

You know why? because it allows the mid level "gamers" who aren't intense but make up the majority of the customer base to compete at a high level. This rule no matter how minor or whatever it is, affects the top level of owners who spend a lot of time recruiting high level players and building the best team they can more than anyone else.

You can see actions like this mirrored in other MMOs online...

Star Wars Galaxies - When the game was released Jedi's were very hard to obtain and very hard to make strong. Today anyone can pick Jedi as a profession. This is so that all the moderate/mid-level gamers can get the satisfaction that previously could only be obtained with extremem dedication and effort. There are many more moderate level games that hardcore ones, making this the smart business move.

World of Warcraft - before the burning crusade it was very difficult to obtain Multiple Epic gear items. After the burning crusade every newb on the block is full of purple gear. This was also done to please the moderate games a.k.a. the biggest source of revenue.


Your analogy falls apart because this MMO has a different business model. They should be catering to the hardcore players because they are the ones who dump money into the game disproportionately. Those MMOs you mentioned all use flat rate monthly fees.


yep since I joined in the playoffs of season 1, I've spent over $200. Far more than a casual player, who has spent nothing.
 
hexone
offline
Link
 
If this rule takes effect will you allow owners to switch leagues? This will definately push back season 3.
 
Asparagus
offline
Link
 
No matter how upset people get, this is something that needs to be implemented one way or another. If not whats going to happen a few seasons from now? Level 40s jumping in new leagues to stomp all over the level 8s. People are complaining too much when probably the effect at this point in the game will most likely be pretty minimal.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by El_Windex
I'm pretty sure everyone is flying off the handle for nothing. He said an XP modifier, not an XP destroyer. Maybe it's just me, but seeing level 4 receivers match up with level 18 cornerbacks is a little strange to me.

Plus those people in AAA leagues who moves up aren't going to be at a serious disadvantage. Most of the levels in Pro League at this point should be gained by boosts not necessarily XP since they're all 20+ and XP is getting hard to come by.

I think Bort just looking for people to recruit within reason. Kudos to you for hiring a level 19 Center, but the fact that he's making pancakes on level 7 starter DTs is disparity at its worse and the game just becomes a 40 day wait for season 4.


maybe the owners of those teams the lvl 4 receivers are on should've recruited better.
 
Houndster
offline
Link
 
No one even knows exactly what the XP hit is going to be and how bad it will be. Couldn't everyone refrain from complaining until they actually know how the full situation will affect them.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.