User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Oh my Bort! FG replays!
Page:
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
That's sweet, but can we choose who holds the kick?


Fake FG?
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Seriously though, somebody check on Firenze.


Agreed, hes on the floor having a heart attack.
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman
Ooooh, another topic: Fake field goals?

I know, I know, one step at a time but......


Sounds like a DC nightmare

 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
Has anyone sent Firenze a PM? I'm about to send three
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
The problem with things like onside kicks (and IMO 2 point conversions) is that you run the risk of abuse. I know people here already said "so make the sim so that it is not worth the attempt on a regular basis." Well, sure, that's easy to do for equal matched games. But how do you ensure that for blowout games? It is hard to balance every matchup like that, and you'd get overpowered teams in leagues (and most leagues AA or below have one or two) attempting onside kicks every time.

The problem is, the formulas that lead to balance in close to evenly matched games break down (in terms of balance) in blowout wins. And why turn 96-0 games that were awful enough to watch into ones where the opposing offense NEVER touch the ball? You end up with even more frustrated leagues because of overmatched teams, and the undermatched teams having play time issues.

Having a balanced code that prevents abuse while still allows SOME chance of success would be a near impossible task.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Agreed, hes on the floor having a heart attack.


I am giving him mouth to mouth right now. We might be awhile.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Firenze for FG Replay Mod.
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
The problem with things like onside kicks (and IMO 2 point conversions) is that you run the risk of abuse. I know people here already said "so make the sim so that it is not worth the attempt on a regular basis." Well, sure, that's easy to do for equal matched games. But how do you ensure that for blowout games? It is hard to balance every matchup like that, and you'd get overpowered teams in leagues (and most leagues AA or below have one or two) attempting onside kicks every time.

The problem is, the formulas that lead to balance in close to evenly matched games break down (in terms of balance) in blowout wins. And why turn 96-0 games that were awful enough to watch into ones where the opposing offense NEVER touch the ball? You end up with even more frustrated leagues because of overmatched teams, and the undermatched teams having play time issues.

Having a balanced code that prevents abuse while still allows SOME chance of success would be a near impossible task.


Kickers will finally have something to bitch about. I haven't seen a kicker mad about PT. Just wait till teams are Fake FGing and going for 2pt 100% of the time.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
The problem with things like onside kicks (and IMO 2 point conversions) is that you run the risk of abuse. I know people here already said "so make the sim so that it is not worth the attempt on a regular basis." Well, sure, that's easy to do for equal matched games. But how do you ensure that for blowout games? It is hard to balance every matchup like that, and you'd get overpowered teams in leagues (and most leagues AA or below have one or two) attempting onside kicks every time.

The problem is, the formulas that lead to balance in close to evenly matched games break down (in terms of balance) in blowout wins. And why turn 96-0 games that were awful enough to watch into ones where the opposing offense NEVER touch the ball? You end up with even more frustrated leagues because of overmatched teams, and the undermatched teams having play time issues.

Having a balanced code that prevents abuse while still allows SOME chance of success would be a near impossible task.


Agree that this would be a serious problem. As a solution, we have suggested you only allow these special teams pranks in close games. Once cruise control kicks in, the option to onside kick or block a punt would not be available.
Edited by tjking82 on Oct 20, 2009 16:57:52
Edited by tjking82 on Oct 20, 2009 16:57:21
 
Link
 
Wow, absolutely awesome.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
New question, will these be retroactive? Can I go to a season 10 play and see a fg that missed?


Quoting in hope it gets seen.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
In all honesty I thought it was a running joke about how bad people wanted instant replays on FG's. Guess you guys were serious about it afterall.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
The problem with things like onside kicks (and IMO 2 point conversions) is that you run the risk of abuse. I know people here already said "so make the sim so that it is not worth the attempt on a regular basis." Well, sure, that's easy to do for equal matched games. But how do you ensure that for blowout games? It is hard to balance every matchup like that, and you'd get overpowered teams in leagues (and most leagues AA or below have one or two) attempting onside kicks every time.

The problem is, the formulas that lead to balance in close to evenly matched games break down (in terms of balance) in blowout wins. And why turn 96-0 games that were awful enough to watch into ones where the opposing offense NEVER touch the ball? You end up with even more frustrated leagues because of overmatched teams, and the undermatched teams having play time issues.

Having a balanced code that prevents abuse while still allows SOME chance of success would be a near impossible task.


Perhaps you could restrict the onside kick to only be used in certain situations.

For example

For an onside kick at any time, the team attempting the onside kick must have a score difference of -inf to +7 (winning by 7)
For an onside kick during the last 5 minutes of the game, the team attempting the onside kick must have a score difference of -inf to +14 (winning by 14)
Calling an onside kick when the parameters aren't met results in a normal kickoff.
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Quoting in hope it gets seen.


I am guessing that it would be possible unless Bort changed the FG code, but it might take up too much server space
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
nice
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.