User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Team Captain Feature:
Page:
 
TheChad
offline
Link
 
One simple question.

Why?
 
vinman
offline
Link
 
Captains with bonuses sounds like coaches=Fail
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I really don't see the need for this. There are already SAs to allow certain players to become leaders on the field.


QFT.

Also, it doesn't make you a bad owner just because you would make your player the TC, especially if he is the best player on the team. Kind of sick of hearing this "bad owner" tag thrown around all of the time.
 
CoachCoughlin
offline
Link
 
+1
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
Originally posted by butler312

I really don't see the need for this. There are already SAs to allow certain players to become leaders on the field.


QFT.

Also, it doesn't make you a bad owner just because you would make your player the TC, especially if he is the best player on the team. Kind of sick of hearing this "bad owner" tag thrown around all of the time.
 
Link
 
+1
 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
I haven't checked this thread for a month, and it's still a hotly debated topic.

The ones who are against it aren't going to change their minds. They have some valid points, while others aren't so valid.

For instance:
1. Forget the poll crap. You don't need a stupid poll to implement this feature. It was just an idea thrown out there. We get the fact we don't have the ability to generate a poll. Get over that.

2. This would definitely take a lot of time to code into the system - I know that. That's why Bort hasn't touched it yet, and I completely understand. If this were ever to be implemented, it would come after any sim adjustments and coach implementations. That's what I figure his priority list is.

3. What the heck needs to be changed with the simulation? I hear everyone bitching about how the sim needs improved and "fixed," yet not a single person in this thread, moderators included, ever threw out a single suggestion on how to fix the sim - only that it needs fixed. I'm not saying there aren't things that could be better, but truth be told, I'm happy with the sim basically as it is. Understand that this is Season 13. If you're not happy with the sim by now, chances are you'll never be happy with it.

4. From what I gather, there's still a lot of sentiment to keep this feature going, at least in the future. To some it may be pointless, but to others it would be a fun part of the game. I doubt adding this feature is going to drive anyone away from the game, other than those who've lived in their basement for the past ten years. If it has to come after sim modifiations, so be it - but let's get on with the show and get the Team Captain feature going sooner or later.
 
Montyhawk
offline
Link
 
sign
 
LewisMarty
offline
Link
 
SIGNED
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
How about you take away the Owners ability to select the Captain and make it a secret ballot type thingy. Agents on the team would have a drop down on the team roster page that allows them to select a captain. Once a captain has been selected it would be up to the owner to purchase a captains badge or some such thing that gives the confidence boost.

I like any idea that adds to the game.
 
drezplace
offline
Link
 
I like the team captain idea. good suggest Flash83, this is something that would be positive for the game. If titles like head coach, OC, DC, special teams coach ect.. could be added, why not team captain? Most of your teams sports have captains. Its good hear from both sides even if you disgree with the opinions.

Originally posted by
this is Season 13. If you're not happy with the sim by now, chances are you'll never be happy with it.

Couldn't be more ture!
Edited by drezplace on Dec 1, 2009 13:22:10
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
How about you take away the Owners ability to select the Captain and make it a secret ballot type thingy. Agents on the team would have a drop down on the team roster page that allows them to select a captain. Once a captain has been selected it would be up to the owner to purchase a captains badge or some such thing that gives the confidence boost.



Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

We have no ability to generate "official" polls anywhere on the site--only an admin can do that.

 
this_guy1015
offline
Link
 
+1
 
BenArfa37
offline
Link
 
+1, but it shold be the owners decision, a vote should just give him a nudge in the right direction.
 
drezplace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jwheelie12
+1, but it shold be the owners decision, a vote should just give him a nudge in the right direction.


I agree, to tell some one who spends their flex points to buy and retain their team that they do not have any control over who is his team's captain doesn't sound right. I totally understand people concern of this being abused by some owners. However, it goes both ways when you have some players making demands in order to sign with a team.

A owenr choose their Head coach, OC, DC and every other title. But now people don't want him to chose his team's captain. I owner a team and I have some talented players that would make good team captains instead of my own players. Two of which who have been with me since I bought my team. But to tell me, I can't choose my own team captain I disagree with.

I have done the team voting thing. I have asked my team in the pass to vote on player of the game to do the game ball thing and reward the player of the game. Not many participated in the voting. So I don't think many would take the time to vote on a team captain (however, I could be wrong) It may start off with a bang, but die out after a couple of season (the voting thing). A owner should decide how he wants to elect his team captains. If he decides to elect his owner players, it's not much different then him starting his own players on his team. If a owner is abusing it, it will come back to haunt him when players will not resign with his team. But I also fore see some players demanding to be team captain to sign with a team. All in all, I like the idea of team captains.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.