User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
ANOTHER NOTE:

My suggestion also has the benefit of encouraging those that want to get the most experience to sign with the worst teams in the highest league possible. It would be a real recruiting boon to gutted teams as they'd be able to offer the most experience to players.
 
spotty
offline
Link
 
i would simplify it...anyone that is 8 levels above the average starting position in the league would take a 10% hit...this would only affect the ones that probably shouldnt be playing in the league anyways...pro's would have no limit...also anyone going above 8 levels after day 1 couldnt be penalized if already on a team...you dont want to penalized someone that is boosting...would only be in effect for players that are over at the start of day 1 and anyone that signs as a free agent or is traded after this point...i think this would be fair and have a wide range for freedom of signing players...

also throw out the high two averages and the lower two averages in determining the average starting level...dont think a gutted team should effect the average player levels like they could as we go higher in levels...

Last edited Jun 6, 2008 20:57:33
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by spotty
i would simplify it...anyone that is 8 levels above the average starting position in the league would take a 10% hit...this would only affect the ones that probably shouldnt be playing in the league anyways...pro's would have no limit...also anyone going above 8 levels after day 1 couldnt be penalized if already on a team...you dont want to penalized someone that is boosting...would only be in effect for players that are over at the start of day 1 and anyone that signs as a free agent or is traded after this point...i think this would be fair and have a wide range for freedom of signing players...

also throw out the high two averages and the lower two averages in determining the average starting level...dont think a gutted team should effect the average player levels like they could as we go higher in levels...



I agree in principle but would argue that the line should be 5 or 6 levels above the average. So if the league average is 13.5 you wouldn't be penalized unless you started the season at 20...and it shouldn't matter when you are that many levels over, only that you are. The league average will increase as everyone boosts througout the season, and the guy that is 5 or 6 levels higher won't be penalized for boosting...but it needs to capture the player that comes into the league via free agency or trade in the mid-season and is way out of their league.

although the trade issue may be a bit out of the player's control in many cases

 
Freakshow
offline
Link
 
From what I've seen a difference of 1-3 levels are not enough to make a difference in the outcome of a game. Our team has been beaten by lower level teams with higher chemistry (possibly better game plan as well).

If a higher level player (team) is going to be penalized by less xp, I believe it should be a level difference of 5 or more.

Otherwise I like the idea.

I think the end result should not be too extreme. While I know there are people out there who just want to PWN the weaker teams, there are teams out there (like mine), who bought a team at the start of the 2nd season and invited all of their R/L friends (who already started players from season 1 as well). What ended up happening was we looked like we were trying to juice our team but that was not the case. Also like I first stated, although our team was higher in level, we still lost to lower level teams. Higher level doesn't necessarily mean success (or else noone would play )
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
I dont like it you punish good team and reward bad ones.

After a few Seasons the best teams will be together threw moving up or down in Leagues.

It will take time just let it do its work.

All players no matter the level the competition or the league should earn XP the same way.

My Vote for XP based on level
100% no
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
I dont like it you punish good team and reward bad ones.

After a few Seasons the best teams will be together threw moving up or down in Leagues.

It will take time just let it do its work.

All players no matter the level the competition or the league should earn XP the same way.

My Vote for XP based on level
100% no


It isn't punishing teams...just players that are completely out of their level. For example if a BBB league had an average level of 10, and signed a player who was level 18, that one player on the team would get less XP than if he'd just signed one level up where the average was 13 or 14.

It makes sense. The rest of his team still gets all their XP, it just lowers the incentive for a Lv18 to sign in a low level league. If he does, the rest of the league (including his teammates) will catch him quicker than they would've without this penalty.

If he wants to stay ahead of lower level players all he has to do is head to the appropriate league level.

 
spotty
offline
Link
 
i just think 8 levels will calm people a little better and is more fairer than 5 or 6 but that is debatable...i would be even up for going higher before lower on this point...possibly even 10 is a nice number...but its just my opinion...

i still think say we go 5 levels and i'm 4.5 with only a half level of clearance i should be able to boost and just because others dont i shouldnt be penalized...say with all the boosting the average goes us 1 level for starters but since i boosted 3 i now am over...i just think you dont want to discourage the boosters...
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by spotty
i just think 8 levels will calm people a little better and is more fairer than 5 or 6 but that is debatable...i would be even up for going higher before lower on this point...possibly even 10 is a nice number...but its just my opinion...

i still think say we go 5 levels and i'm 4.5 with only a half level of clearance i should be able to boost and just because others dont i shouldnt be penalized...say with all the boosting the average goes us 1 level for starters but since i boosted 3 i now am over...i just think you dont want to discourage the boosters...


I boost all 10 of my players, so I understand your point. My point wouldn't be to have you not boost, but rather that saying that the only number that matters is the number at the start of the season makes a loophole for players that enter the league in midseason. As for the exact number of levels, I see your point, and it is debatable. I have seen what teams that are 4-5 levels up from their opponents do (it generally looks like 100-0 on the scoreboard) and that is why I suggested that be the max line. You'd still be able to boost those players, but generally would have to wait until playoffs to avoid the penalty on XP. Since no Game XP is earned in playoffs it wouldn't hurt you to be uplevel at that point.

p.s. boosting later in the season is better for total growth anyhow.

 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
There should be a bonus for players who are playing above their levels. The bonus could be determined by common positional matchups.

The easy way to do this would be off of the ratings that appear in the matchup screen. They could be used to apply a bonus to each position like this: Passing -> DBs. Rushing -> LBs. Blocking -> DL. Pass Defense -> QB, TE and WR. Rush Defense -> RB. Overall Defense -> OL.

There should be no penalty for playing below your level. The loss of the bonus is penalty enough, especially since the other people in your league will be getting it.

In no way should it be based off of winning percentages. However, winning should give you a bit more XP, thats the easy way to avoid tanking games. Winners get a bit more experience so there is no reason to start throwing games with low level players to level them up.
 
spotty
offline
Link
 
i put in that it would still go for free agents and trading at any point in the season...it would only be for establish players that are under at the point when the season begins...
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Something simple, like "no signing level 10s or above to new leagues" should keep the "DROP DOWN PWN3RS" in check, IMHO.


That's the easy solution for me to put in, and I agree it will force stratification in the leagues. Unfortunately, that seems to be a pretty damn unpopular idea, from what I've seen. People seem to want everything to work out on its own through supply/demand economics.


Hey, can I ask a ? here. I know you probably dont want to hear it... but with the release of teams in here, by stages, why isn't there a FA period that is staged for the lvl of leagues. You want stratification, well, then make FA all at one time, no more half season contracts or year contracts, have all contracts end at Day 40 (respective end season of course).

Then, the first two days of FA, is for Pros. The 3-4 days is for AAA, the 5th for AA, and so on. Instead of just league level caps, also do it through FA. Ya, some trades will go through. So a cap on leagues may also be necessary, just help enforce it through FA also. Alot of players will wait to see what comes in for offers, and may not jump onto the ship to overpower a AA league.

You already rammed it down our throats with the release of new teams, well, just put the foot down, and tell everybody you are going to enforce it through FA and caps on leagues.

As the seasons wear on, and the leagues seperate in lvl's of players, it will work itself out more. But, the FA period stagering will add the ability for teams to sign players that will wait for the Pro's to come a callin, then the AAA's, and so on.

It wont solve the mass moves of players coming to one team, but your new additions of parameters on trades/cuts will solve that. Now, to just keep lvl 18's out of leagues with an avg. of 7.

But, you know what is good for the goose, is good for the gander. I have been called about every name in the book about my ideas on the "staged" release of teams. Been cused up one side, downt he other. Well, if it is a "great" option for me, how about we do this for all teams. Through FA? If I got to wait for the right "time" for my team to arrive, and wait for my players, lets institute this "Philosophy" for everyone. I suppose that just aint feasible though, now that the shoe is on the other foot..........
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Icespyder


Since Africa Pro was released 2 seasons after the first leagues, their "Pros" would be no better then an America BBB team.


That's what's happening anyway. The average level over there right now is around 10.


So why name it Pro and have them earn more money then a USA BBB team?


Yup, just as I was stating in earlier threads. Players that would be for AAA/AA are being sucked up by the Pro teams. And the cycle will perpetuate all the way down....weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
 
DTB88
offline
Link
 
Yes, this might be a better idea than a level cap. I'm for using a league average of figuring out the XP modifier. Use the highest players in each position of a team's roster, not depth chart, to figure it out.

So an example would be if the league average is a level 11.26 and I have a level 9 player, it will get more XP. A level 13 would get less XP. The modifiers could be +15%/-15% or a percentage based on the level difference.
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kaiserfarrow
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by justafish2002


The problem is teams like Utopia in USA Pro will get pounded because they sold their team. So the cycle takes even longer


Can we speed up the process by promoting/relegating more teams each season?


Bingo - I'd vouch for that!! 2 go up from each conference, 4 go down!


Ya, problem with wider parameters, you want to be the guy who got the disasterous AAA team, that needed severe rebuilding. You in USA AAA, and all the future is bright, you got a team in a great league, and bam, ooooo, so sorry, you sucked this year, down to AA. Youb ought the team for two seasons. How you going to protect the contract for the new owner? You probably dont care, some people would want a team bad, so they wouldnt complain. But, you got the power to recruit, your in USA AAA. But, because of rebuilding, yoru in the crap hole, and relegated. Thats special......
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by datongw


I'm not trying to flame anyone here. I understand your situation, but what I am saying is that just because you are in a tough position, you should not punish everyone else in your league for it. Your team might have to tough it out another year, and if you improve and avoid relegation, then great, you are improving. If you still have a hard time competing, then you will be relegated next season. The system already in place is working, maybe just not as fast as some people would like.

If you put yourself in the position of the other 15 teams in your league, why should they be punished in their player development when they play against your team?


Cool enough...but the way I'm reading this proposal, Bort wouldn't make the XP differential be based on that particular game matchup, but rather each player's level compared to the league average...so if the league average is 13.4207 (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=324473) and we have half our line-up at or around level 10, then we'd get a significant bonus. The only players that would be penalized are the lv 17&18 guys on one or two teams that frankly signed at the wrong league level. The entire team wouldn't be punished, just the few players that are playing high school football at 23 years old...


The only question I got about this whole player lvl vs. league lvl bit, are the age of contracts goign to factor into this? I sign a guy at lvl 8, and my team dont do great the first three years, and now that lvl 8 is a lvl 23-25. And my leagues avg.lvl is 16. How is that his fault? And if you do team avg. lvl vs. league avg. lvl, thats going to throw a wrench in the works too, if I got 3 or more of them on the roster. If your a committed owner, and do what is best for your team, and sign guys long term with proper money upfront, then your hosed. I think everyone has gotten so complacent with the 1 Timers on bonuses, I havent saw one word yet on this.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.