User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Uncapped Minors = Worst part of GLB / Fix = Top Season 12 Priority
Page:
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by walker1

Originally posted by taurran


Seven pages of debate doesn't change the fact that we need more levels of caps between 38-uncapped, and a revised shuffle in the offseason.


That would be a disaster then for the owners in group 1. It would take them 15 seasons to make it to the WL.


That's what recruiting is for.


I don't think you understand how hard it is to do this. I OC a team, the Staffordshire Spitfires in a level 21 cap. The roster was full of level 13s, and I tried very hard to get as many level 21s as possible. We bascily signed level 21 and level 20 players across the board. We are currently 2-5. So many of these teams have level 28 players across the board and it upsets me a ton. We really should be 1-6, but I found a loophole in the last teams D and exploited the hell out of it. It is much harder then you think.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
I don't think you understand how hard it is to do this. I OC a team, the Staffordshire Spitfires in a level 21 cap. The roster was full of level 13s, and I tried very hard to get as many level 21s as possible. We bascily signed level 21 and level 20 players across the board. We are currently 2-5. So many of these teams have level 28 players across the board and it upsets me a ton. We really should be 1-6, but I found a loophole in the last teams D and exploited the hell out of it. It is much harder then you think.


It's not about how well you recruit, it's about how well you game the system.

If your team is all right at the cap in a capped league at the beginning of the season, you're way under-leveled.
Edited by fallingmercury on Aug 30, 2009 15:50:47
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
This roster is pretty good for a level 21 capped team right? http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=389

We lost this game 104-3

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=758358
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I'm against higher caps, because I want to get to WL sooner, with first generations on a team. Others want more caps. Debate comes and goes once or twice a week. Over in suggestions the other day, DL had a good idea. Change what the caps are, to give higher ones, more space between them, but the same total number. Placates a lot of the issues on both sides.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3204795&page=3#27747353Originally posted by DL24

Originally posted by Robbnva



cap at 42 and maybe even 48 would be nice


I'd rather just space out the caps more:

13 - 18 - 24 - 28 - 32 - 36 - 40 - 45 - Uncapped




Reposting idea from the bottom of the page.Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

This


Hand-picked leagues then? Bort could hire a couple folks to pore through all the teams and manually create leagues that look solid? Done every season?


It'd be a LOT of work for promotions, and people would definitely claim bias. The current way, while often seeming unfair to specific teams, is clearly fair in that it treats everyone equal. "Fair" might not be the best word, but it is impartial.
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Oh that team threw the conference championship game last year anyway. They beat that team in the regular season by 150.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Oh that team threw the conference championship game last year anyway. They beat that team in the regular season by 150.


I remember that shitstorm.


It was awesome.


I wished we tanked, we're gettin' prison raped in a 28 cap with lvl 37s.
 
Argonut
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well, one of those types annoys the crap out of me every 40 days.

Obviously, there are some guys in the middle, but I seem to run into way more #2's. Somehow it is fair for them to keep beating up on the teams they just destroyed and go 20-0 again, but it is not fair for them to move up because they might lose some games.


Well keeping in mind that you stated the #2's are the vast majority of your paying customers ... (so don't crap on them)

There are some relatively easy fixes.

1. If not all teams want to go to World League (and the massive work it entails) ... then make the cloud an option for a team owner.

- Upon qualifying for the "cloud" to shoot up to the top ... the owner can choose instead to ride the caps and go up the (41-44-47) cap tree and NEVER be allowed to rejoin the cloud in the future. This would allow a more uncluttered rise for teams who really want to be elite and allow teams (the majority of your paying customers) a chance to have fun without losing all that fun when they hit a cloud.

2. To make it work better and this has been suggested hundreds of times. Make the CAPS HARD. If you have a team full of 34 lvl players and ONE player is lvl 35 ... then to 38 cap you go. Also .. and this is the BIG one ... do not allow boosting after day 40. Right now you (Bort) allow boosting after teams have been placed in their cap league and then again to start the season. (6 level boost) So teams who want to ride the lines to dominate can only do it because you have made it easy and attractive for them.

Make last day to boost the last of of the season (day 40) and teams will lose their incentive to think they can dominate a cap league ... which in turn may funnel more teams into the cloud.
Edited by Argonut on Aug 30, 2009 16:12:13
Edited by Argonut on Aug 30, 2009 16:10:07
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
I always believed hard caps were fine. That it would be easy to just, say, when you promote, if you have players over the cap for the league you're going into, you could get the two choices

a) You stay in the cap, but the sim cuts all players that over the cap on your team.

b) You move up one higher cap and get to keep your players.

Same for demotion and tanking, (e.g. staying in the cap with current players, dropping down and cutting the over-the-cap players). You can gut, but you're not taking your over-the-cap players for the ride.

srsly guise

















seriously

 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Argonut
Well keeping in mind that you stated the #2's are the vast majority of your paying customers ... (so don't crap on them)


Correction: They are the vast majority of whiners.

And the only solution that would satisfy them, is a league with 31 CPU teams and them.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Another thing, this should have not been happening:

1) sign several players @ cap level
2) triple boost them before season
3) triple boost during season start
4) have 6 level advantage

Some people call it good strategy, but it's just terribly cheesy.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
It'd be a LOT of work for promotions, and people would definitely claim bias. The current way, while often seeming unfair to specific teams, is clearly fair in that it treats everyone equal. "Fair" might not be the best word, but it is impartial.


Sure people would question the judgment of the admins who are manually shifting leagues. But right now we have teams where it's completely obvious that they have no business in their current league. I think manual league creation would cut out all of the srsly inappropriate scenarios we have now.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Another thing, this should have not been happening:

1) sign several players @ cap level
2) triple boost them before season
3) triple boost during season start
4) have 6 level advantage

Some people call it good strategy, but it's just terribly cheesy.


Gaming the system, cheese, etc, is now standard practice. It's the only way to succeed in a lot of leagues. You either do it or you get owned.

Bort has posted that he condones this behavior too, which is very disheartening.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
This roster is pretty good for a level 21 capped team right? http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=389

We lost this game 104-3

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=758358


This is messed up. Bort should look at this IMO.
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by pottsman

I'm against higher caps, because I want to get to WL sooner, with first generations on a team. Others want more caps. Debate comes and goes once or twice a week. Over in suggestions the other day, DL had a good idea. Change what the caps are, to give higher ones, more space between them, but the same total number. Placates a lot of the issues on both sides.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3204795&page=3#27747353Originally posted by DL24


Originally posted by Robbnva




cap at 42 and maybe even 48 would be nice


I'd rather just space out the caps more:

13 - 18 - 24 - 28 - 32 - 36 - 40 - 45 - Uncapped




Reposting idea from the bottom of the page.Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


This


Hand-picked leagues then? Bort could hire a couple folks to pore through all the teams and manually create leagues that look solid? Done every season?


It'd be a LOT of work for promotions, and people would definitely claim bias. The current way, while often seeming unfair to specific teams, is clearly fair in that it treats everyone equal. "Fair" might not be the best word, but it is impartial.


I say put full commitment into yet another reshuffle of the Leagues. Be totally committed that this will be the last one, but don't be afraid to do it because people bitch. They always do. Do it and people will be happy.

Either use a version of my idea(maybe space the caps out even more, whatever you want Bort), but keep the same amount of leagues if you keep a Cloud. It's hell getting out of them as is.

OR

Creating a minor league-like cloud-type system for each region. Have a 13 cap, 21 cap, 28 cap, 36 cap, and Uncapped league for each region, all 8 of them. Hell, there doesn't even need to be all of the current caps in this idea, because it will be a specific region, and you'll only promote 2 leagues if you win your conf., and 1 if you make the playoffs. Everyone else stays in that league. This way, there is no "Preferred Region" BS, you'll know which AA you will wind up in,and you are already in your region, with an identity, creating rivalries, with active league forums. Just have people get on waiting lists by choosing specific regions and caps. (And again, the caps of the various "lower" regional leagues will be up to your discretion, but this Cloud nonsense needs to be straightened out, or ended).
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Argonut
Originally posted by Bort

Well, one of those types annoys the crap out of me every 40 days.

Obviously, there are some guys in the middle, but I seem to run into way more #2's. Somehow it is fair for them to keep beating up on the teams they just destroyed and go 20-0 again, but it is not fair for them to move up because they might lose some games.


Well keeping in mind that you stated the #2's are the vast majority of your paying customers ... (so don't crap on them)

There are some relatively easy fixes.

1. If not all teams want to go to World League (and the massive work it entails) ... then make the cloud an option for a team owner.

- Upon qualifying for the "cloud" to shoot up to the top ... the owner can choose instead to ride the caps and go up the (41-44-47) cap tree and NEVER be allowed to rejoin the cloud in the future. This would allow a more uncluttered rise for teams who really want to be elite and allow teams (the majority of your paying customers) a chance to have fun without losing all that fun when they hit a cloud.

2. To make it work better and this has been suggested hundreds of times. Make the CAPS HARD. If you have a team full of 34 lvl players and ONE player is lvl 35 ... then to 38 cap you go. Also .. and this is the BIG one ... do not allow boosting after day 40. Right now you (Bort) allow boosting after teams have been placed in their cap league and then again to start the season. (6 level boost) So teams who want to ride the lines to dominate can only do it because you have made it easy and attractive for them.

Make last day to boost the last of of the season (day 40) and teams will lose their incentive to think they can dominate a cap league ... which in turn may funnel more teams into the cloud.


Cloud systems suck. Give leagues an identity, REAL and ACTIVE league forums and rivalries. Adding 3 more caps is just retarded. Let the teams play with the big boys if they want to keep winning at a higher level. If they want to keep dominating in half-gutted leagues, let them restart at the bottom of the cloud. #2 types shouldn't be catered too, they should just take whatever the system gives them.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.