User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Sorry fella, but this is wanting to much information now. You do realize that real world doesn't apply to GLB right? Two different breeds of animals tbh. Peoples builds should stay off limits if they are closed. If you want a rough guess at it, then watch the game tape.


Game tape is pretty much pointless. Beyond all the variable factors that come into play in any given situation, we have been told flat out that the game films are rough approximations of whats happening, not a pixel for pixel recreation of every precise move.

And even the rough approximation is pointless since you have no frame of reference. Player A throws Player B to the ground. Since we do not know how strong Player B is, this tells us NOTHING about the strength of Player A. Yet in real life, we could either look up his combine report, or simply look at his biceps and tell roughly how strong he is. In GLB, he could be a 20 str or a 90, we just dont know.

As for real life and GLB being apples and oranges, yes of course. It cant be perfect. But being a football sim, it could at least be somewhat vaguely similar to real life football.

And being able to tell roughly how strong or how fast the players on other teams are would be required for the term "Vaguely similar" to apply.
Edited by yello1 on Aug 11, 2009 23:44:36
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by driftinggrifter


Realism is a two sided sword in GLB. Every one uses it for a reason when they want their idea implemented but then they say that realism isn't good if it negativly affects one of their players/teams or is a idea they don't like.


I agree but that's also why I prefaced my original comment by stating that I'm in no way associated with a team that uses a rushing QB.

The audible example was just a way of demonstrating that a push for too much realism could open pandoras box. Defense reacts to offensive formation > offense reacts to defense > defense reacts > ad infinitum > game crashes!


Yo se seņor, I was actually defending the realism debate by you.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Sorry fella, but this is wanting to much information now. You do realize that real world doesn't apply to GLB right? Two different breeds of animals tbh. Peoples builds should stay off limits if they are closed. If you want a rough guess at it, then watch the game tape.


Game tape is pretty much pointless. Beyond all the variable factors that come into play in any given situation, we have been told flat out that the game films are rough approximations of whats happening, not a pixel for pixel recreation of every precise move.

And even the rough approximation is pointless since you have no frame of reference. Player A throws Player B to the ground. Since we do not know how strong Player B is, this tells us NOTHING about the strength of Player A. Yet in real life, we could either look up his combine report, or simply look at his biceps and tell roughly how strong he is. In GLB, he could be a 20 str or a 90, we just dont know.

As for real life and GLB being apples and oranges, yes of course. It cant be perfect. But being a football sim, it could at least be somewhat vaguely similar to real life football.

And being able to tell roughly how strong or how fast the players on other teams are would be required for the term "Vaguely similar" to apply.


Lol bars and game tape imo.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I agree. I wouldn't be opposed to getting scouting reports on players, such as "speed receiver" vs "possession receiver" or "scrambling QB" vs "pocket QB." But any numbers at all need to stay out of it.


How about the "Faster than Your WIdeout" option?

NO numbers at all. Just something you could tell.

But as to the numbers staying out of it, I gotta chuckle. This game is NOTHING BUT numbers. Numbers is how we build players, numbers is how the game determines results. To say we should not know the numbers is saying you want to randomly bumble around with no clue as to what is going on.

Now I do not think we should get the guys precise speed, which if you read my idea would be clear. But having some idea that its above the first or second cap or third cap or below 100 would be a realistic simulation of a scout being able to time the guys forty while watching game films or his combine reports etc.

 
Link
 
Closed builds are just that. Closed. They should stay strictly off limits. If Bort wanted us to know the numbers or felt that we needed to know the numbers, then closing builds would of never been a option.
TBH, I don't even check for open builds when I do any scouting. I get a good idea of everything from watching game tape.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Well using the realism argument, there are some ridiculously exploitive defensive formations. Such as where the middle of the field is wide open and my grandmother could get 6 yards rushing up the middle on her walker, so in the name of realism shouldn't the offense be able to call audibles? Anyway, I'm pretty sure most people have their minds made up on this, so I'll probably leave the conversation at this. The situation reminds me so much of the push for realism following season 6 that everyone was in favor of, which instead set the sim back several seasons. Season 10 was one of the better sims, but it's much closer to the season 6 sim than that of seasons 7 or 8 which were pretty bad.


My sugegstions for audibles have been made (I think, unless thats one of the suggestions sitting in my email waiting to get polished up). So yes, I think there should be audibles.

And yes, play balance and playability (I assume thats what you are referring to) must trump realism and any other considerations (besides profit).

But I do not see any play balance or playability problems with my suggestion. If you know of one, do tell.

 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1

Game tape is pretty much pointless.


I stopped reading there.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Realism is a two sided sword in GLB. Every one uses it for a reason when they want their idea implemented but then they say that realism isn't good if it negativly affects one of their players/teams or is a idea they don't like.


Realism is always preferred in a sim, unless it makes the game lousy or unbalanced.

IE Realism of players being injured has to be weighed against the lousy game play of your player not being able to play.

IE Realism of a Draft has to be weighed against the lousy game play of being forced to pay to play a player on team you did not choose.

Level caps would be an example of realism bowing to balance.

Etc.

But beyond that, where you can add realism you should in a sim.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
How about the "Faster than Your WIdeout" option?

NO numbers at all. Just something you could tell.

But as to the numbers staying out of it, I gotta chuckle. This game is NOTHING BUT numbers. Numbers is how we build players, numbers is how the game determines results. To say we should not know the numbers is saying you want to randomly bumble around with no clue as to what is going on.

Now I do not think we should get the guys precise speed, which if you read my idea would be clear. But having some idea that its above the first or second cap or third cap or below 100 would be a realistic simulation of a scout being able to time the guys forty while watching game films or his combine reports etc.



I've never been in favor of any numbers being known, outside of attributes by the owner. I really wish there were no specific numbers included in VAs. The more numbers you know the more of the formulas you can figure out and the less mystery there is to the game. I don't like there being a set way to do things and the more we know the more a clear cut best way becomes evident and the more cookie cutter builds and all of that stuff you get. I just prefer not to know the specifics.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Realism is a two sided sword in GLB. Every one uses it for a reason when they want their idea implemented but then they say that realism isn't good if it negativly affects one of their players/teams or is a idea they don't like.


Realism is always preferred in a sim, unless it makes the game lousy or unbalanced.

IE Realism of players being injured has to be weighed against the lousy game play of your player not being able to play.

IE Realism of a Draft has to be weighed against the lousy game play of being forced to pay to play a player on team you did not choose.

Level caps would be an example of realism bowing to balance.

Etc.

But beyond that, where you can add realism you should in a sim.


And suggestion that you get to see a vague glimpse at a players build when it's closed is not one of those times.

Gametape will tell you all you need to know tbh.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Lol bars and game tape imo.


Scouting bars are nice, but they measure so many things they do not tell you how large or fast a guy is. And when putting together your match ups, it would be nice to know about the 900 pound gorilla in the helmet on the other side etc.

And yes Game tape can help. Mostly at speed, though they tell us its not that accurate. But it doesnt tell strength. At all.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by yello1


Game tape is pretty much pointless.


I stopped reading there.


Yep, but this quote doesn't surprise me in the least tbh.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Closed builds are just that. Closed. They should stay strictly off limits. If Bort wanted us to know the numbers or felt that we needed to know the numbers, then closing builds would of never been a option.
TBH, I don't even check for open builds when I do any scouting. I get a good idea of everything from watching game tape.


If God Had Meant for us to Fly.....

Yeah, Bort has never changed the game. Why this OP was made by an imposter.

There is a far cry between someones build being opened and using a scouting position in your coaching staff to get a hint at roughly how large one stat is on one opposing player.

 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I stopped reading there.


Okay, so tell me how can you tell the Strength of Player A from watching him play Player B when you do not know the strength of Player B either.

Tell me O Wise One.

And, am I wrong that Bort has said the game films are approximations and not exact renderings? DId I dream that?
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
And suggestion that you get to see a vague glimpse at a players build when it's closed is not one of those times.

Gametape will tell you all you need to know tbh.


Dont you mean TBR, as in To Be Repetitive.

How do I use game film to tell me how strong a player is?

And you think its unrealistic to know what someones strength and speed is when every single NFL Player goes to a combine and has that all measured by every team?
Edited by yello1 on Aug 12, 2009 00:03:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.