User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by kwankwan


The relegation of teams is a VERY big deal... The WL will make GLB a "one league game" .... so it is a big deal.. so to distribute demoted teams randomly, could go against Bort's wishes.


It would actually probably be best for the overall health of pro league competition, tbh, to demote the teams to wherever they are needed, but it is not an easy pill for quite a few owners to swallow.


This could backfire. Consider that you could end up with 12 USA pro teams in a few seasons if they are demoted to other regions and then get back to the WPL on another regions ticket.


Then that region will have to get better, or never make it to the WPL.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by vrshah

no way....winning teams are not allowed to be pussies.


+1

if they dont want to go in the gut


I agree with the sentiment, but most of the people I see complaining about the prospect of a WPL are teams in weak leagues that are afraid of getting their asses handed to them. I also think random demotion is the only really viable solution, so imagine the complaints if after going 0-16 in the WPL they're demoted to USAPL.

So while I'd also like to force them to play against "real competition", I'd also kind of prefer to give the teams that really want to test themselves and are up for the challenge the shot, not teams who would be constantly whining and complaining about their situation.
 
JHight
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643



World League


Suggested conference structure and promotion / relegation schedule.

* spelling out gart's suggested framework as I understand it (from here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2958454&page=8 )


▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬


► Initial formation of the World League:


○ Season 10's final four teams from each of the eight Pro leagues get pulled up to form the initial 32-team World League.

○ The World League would be built with the same Alpha-Zeta conference structure as the rest of GLB's leagues and teams fill in to the WL according to their established Alpha-Zeta affiliation.

○ Following the initial promotion from the current Pro leagues to the World League, each Pro League will have four more slots to fill from AAA on top of the usual four, plus guts. So, in Season 11, each Pro league would experience an influx of at least eight AAA's (four naturally promoted + four World League replacements + gut replacements.)


World League - Alpha Conference:
1. APL Lion 1
2. APL Lion 2
3. CPL West 1
4. CPL West 2
5. EEPL Alpha 1
6. EEPL Alpha 2
7. OPL Alpha 1
8. OPL Alpha 2
9. SAPL Satchmo 1
10. SAPL Satchmo 2
11. SEAPL Naga 1
12. SEAPL Naga 2
13. USAPL West 1
14. USAPL West 2
15. WEPL Alpha 1
16. WEPL Alpha 2

World League - Zeta Conference:
1. APL Elephant 1
2. APL Elephant 2
3. CPL East 1
4. CPL East 2
5. EEPL Zeta 1
6. EEPL Zeta 2
7. OPL Zeta 1
8. OPL Zeta 2
9. SAPL Dizzy 1
10. SAPL Dizzy 2
11. SEAPL Garuda 1
12. SEAPL Garuda 2
13. USAPL East 1
14. USAPL East 2
15. WEPL Zeta 1
16. WEPL Zeta 2


► Subsequent promotions and demotions to and from the World league:

○ World League teams that qualify for the playoffs (16 teams) remain in the World League.

○ World League teams that fail to reach the playoffs (16 teams) return to their home Pro league.

○ IF IN THE EVENT A PLAYOFF TEAM IN THE WORLD LEAGUE GOES CPU, A TEAM WHO DID NOT MAKE THE PLAYOFFS STARTING WITH THE 9TH TEAM WILL THEN STAY IN THE WORLD LEAGUE IN THE CPU TEAM'S PLACE..

○ Pro league Champions and runners-up (16 teams) promote to the World League.

○ At all times, each region would be repped in the World League by at least 2 teams.

○ At most, 4 teams from any region will be demoted to their original Pro league each season (2 back into each conference.)

○ At most, 2 teams from any region will be promoted to the World League each season (1 from each conference.)

○ When the situation arises that two teams are demoted back into a Pro conference at the same time, room is made for the second team by demoting an additional team from Pro to AAA, and then from AAA to AA if necessary. Removing gutted teams along the way can help with this. This is an idea that has been questioned - fearing the Pro-to-AAA demoted team would not be happy with it. Keep in mind that additional AAA teams were pulled up before they naturally should have been promoted to replace teams headed to the World League, so this is the other side of the same coin.

○ Over time this system allows regions that deserve more representation to get it. If teams from one region are able to succeed (make the playoffs) in the World League, they will stay and others from their region will join them there. In the most extreme case, one region could potentially have 18 representatives while the other 7 regions have only their 2 reps. Getting from the initial 4 reps to the potential top of 18 would take 7 seasons, would be very tough and unlikely, but possible.


► Pro's of this format:

○ Fair initial set-up.

○ Ensures representation from all regions in the future.

○ Allows for stronger leagues to eventually send more reps to the World League.

○ Requirement to stay in the World League (qualify for playoffs) is tough - as it should be for an ELITE league.

○ Turnover rate will be half of the league each season, allowing for new blood on a regular basis.

○ Promotion / relegation is handled in a fair manner.

○ Some regional conference rivalries will be preserved.

○ The long-awaited World League can finally begin.


► Con's of this format:

○ Initial season will not house the best 32 Pro teams in the game.

○ other?


Edited one part in bold to make sure all grounds are covered.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by kwankwan


The relegation of teams is a VERY big deal... The WL will make GLB a "one league game" .... so it is a big deal.. so to distribute demoted teams randomly, could go against Bort's wishes.


It would actually probably be best for the overall health of pro league competition, tbh, to demote the teams to wherever they are needed, but it is not an easy pill for quite a few owners to swallow.


This could backfire. Consider that you could end up with 12 USA pro teams in a few seasons if they are demoted to other regions and then get back to the pros on another regions ticket.


This is why you open up accessibility to 96 teams. Odds are...things such as what you suggested will not occur.
 
tgy1369
offline
Link
 
Yea and the WPL champion get promoted to the super duper WPL and waits 15 seasons for the rest of the teams to promote
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
Glad I couldn't vote on this. I would be highly upset if I was a Head Coach or Co Owner who pretty much ran a Pro team but couldn't vote.

Back to the topic at hand.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.

Edited by Hikariu on Jul 27, 2009 18:46:49
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by kwankwan


The relegation of teams is a VERY big deal... The WL will make GLB a "one league game" .... so it is a big deal.. so to distribute demoted teams randomly, could go against Bort's wishes.


It would actually probably be best for the overall health of pro league competition, tbh, to demote the teams to wherever they are needed, but it is not an easy pill for quite a few owners to swallow.


This could backfire. Consider that you could end up with 12 USA pro teams in a few seasons if they are demoted to other regions and then get back to the WPL on another regions ticket.


Thats not bad, really. The world league is the best teams, so if they can beat every single EE team, why not? This is a huge decision for GLB. If we do all this, there is NO point in having "region team names" anymore. Seasons from now the "PRO" leagues as we know them will be mixed.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Zoblefu

Keep it simple

Top 1 from each conference goes up each year. Top 2 this season only.

Keep always 2 teams per conference in pro league. This means one gets demoted every year, even if it was 2nd place and the other was first.

This way you ALWAYS promote the winners, and you just really compete against the others from your conference to "stay" in the world league. You can request demotion if you want however (if you would normally stay) and get another team to come up from your league.


Why, in a World League, would you just want teams to compete with only teams from their old region to stay? It's a World League, no?


You're still competing against everyone for bragging rights about who is best, but the world league (this way) will always contain the best 2 teams a league has to offer. It gives fair representation to all leagues, and has no problems with promotion/demotion, so it seems like the easiest way.

But as you bolded and pointed out, if you want to STAY in the world league you need to be the best team from your league, period. If you aren't the best from your league, then the next season the pro champion will get a chance to see if they're the best from their league, etc.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by ICRockets


Originally posted by Bort



Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My idea accomodates all of that.

2 demoted teams go to each region every year. There's no "We need to push an extra team down a rung to fill it out right". The BEST demoted teams are likely to get their LAST choice of region, thus ensuring that the most competitive teams are going to the most competitive leagues unless other teams specifically request to do so. AND I have a safeguard against frequent demotees going to the same league over and over and dominating outclassed competition.


That's a horrible system. The best demoted teams should have first choice.

Your system ensures that there will always be imbalances in the Pro League.


So what happens if the best demoted team decides he wants to go to OPL? Say we're talking about Bonn Dynamo. They rocked WEPL, did well in Worlds, but fell just short of the playoffs. But they were close, and feel that if they get back to the World League, they can make it happen this time. All they have to do is get back. So naturally they're going to choose the WEAKEST league possible to be demoted into, so they have the easiest road back to the World Pro League where they feel they belong.

You really think the best option is to FACILIATE THAT?!


Well, to be fair, your overall system is pretty dumb. But I'll play along.

1) End-of-season tankfest. Two 0-14 teams, let's see who can throw the game to get a better choice of leagues!

2) Punishing good teams. Why should a 9th place team have a harder time getting back into WPL than a 14th place team?

Answer those.

3) OPL Inferiority. The weakest team joins the weakest league. The league will never get any better. Bort is trying to have long-run parity in league strength. This goes against that directly.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Galkuris
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Bort


Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


Agreed. This is the problem with all regional quote demotion ideas, even if all WL teams from one region succeed while in the WL, they can't all stay. Have four teams there and all finish int he final four? Too bad, two are getting the boot. Makes no sense in what is supposed to be the best league in the game.


In the long run this would mean better teams going to OPL, EEPL and APL (to try and get easier entrance into WPL), making the Pro Leagues more equal.


That would be the case for most of the ideas mentioned. The easier paths would be ID'd in no time. My question is ... why limit the number of teams that can stay in the WL from one region if they are all deserving of staying and others clearly are not?
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Galkuris



Originally posted by FairForever


Originally posted by Bort



Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


That's why we included the play-in game after. So if Marblehead beat Dryden in the WPL Conference Championship Game, Dryden would face off against CPL East's champion. If Dryden was good enough to make WPL Conference Finals, they should have no problem dispatching the CPL team and staying in WPL.


idk, even yet I think it would mean the best teams are not always going to be in the WPL. A solution should have the Pro League champions always moving up. Teams should not get free passes to stay in the WL when they are worse then other teams that should be there.

It may not be the best now, but in 4-5 seasons that should be the goal. To do that teams that make the playoffs should never get demoted. And teams that earn their way up by winning the Pro Conferences should be in.

Finally, what if CPL East's champion wins CPL and they lose to Dryden. However, the CPL West's champion wins and beats North Delta. How is it fair that the true CPL champion has to keep rotting in CPL while the team they beat moves up?
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.



 
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Bort



Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


Agreed. This is the problem with all regional quote demotion ideas, even if all WL teams from one region succeed while in the WL, they can't all stay. Have four teams there and all finish int he final four? Too bad, two are getting the boot. Makes no sense in what is supposed to be the best league in the game.


In the long run this would mean better teams going to OPL, EEPL and APL (to try and get easier entrance into WPL), making the Pro Leagues more equal.


That would be the case for most of the ideas mentioned. The easier paths would be ID'd in no time. My question is ... why limit the number of teams that can stay in the WL from one region if they are all deserving of staying and others clearly are not?


To create parity you need to have a limit on teams from regions & they all need to be even. Sure it hurts some teams this season but it will only help out in the future.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Bort u havent commented on LOL Soccer idea

do u not like it
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.