User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > FWIW, I totally do not believe in an X-factor
Page:
 
Link
 
Things I don't believe in:

santa claus
spite
miracles
lies
holograms
charity
sin
pinochle
captain crunch
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
Things I don't believe in:

santa claus
spite
miracles
lies
holograms
charity
sin
pinochle
captain crunch


You'll change your mind when the Soggies come for you.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doug_Plank
the sim changes so much that p much every build has their 15 mins of fame. Some get more than that


Great point there
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HULK
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by HULK


But the truth is he was very mediocre for a long time




Hasn't been mediocre since season 3 tbh.


I guess he got good in the middle there. Not elite though. Had tough times in the playoffs if you look, prior to the last 2 seasons.


Pfff, still taking offense to that. He absolutely owned on the HB flood in season 7 playoffs.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
Originally posted by the man of doom

Dooley ahs been on fire for 2 seasons

Megan Raine has blocked for him for 2 seasons

theres ur X factor


McKracken too


fail
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by HULK

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by HULK



But the truth is he was very mediocre for a long time




Hasn't been mediocre since season 3 tbh.


I guess he got good in the middle there. Not elite though. Had tough times in the playoffs if you look, prior to the last 2 seasons.


Pfff, still taking offense to that. He absolutely owned on the HB flood in season 7 playoffs.


i think he went from sucking..to mediocre to finally good in season 9..pre season 9 i don't see much that impresses me

edit: i lied.
Edited by kalkmanc on Jul 23, 2009 15:55:27
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by GG

Well, it's your fault for building generally good solid builds, playing in good leagues and in good teams with winning seasons. It'd be like trying to find an ugly girl in a Miss Universe pageant.

X-Factor is more evident on crappy teams where players just stand out for no reason, with no spectacular builds, no reason for them being so good/fast/strong/etc. Stand out like a tall blonde babe in an arabic third world nation.


I have to admit that I've seen some builds out there that most would consider absolutely horrendous, yet no matter where they go, they always perform at a very high level. I don't know if it's x-factor, or just that the majority of these shit builds are SUPER balanced, so they're able to win rolls with their second & third attributes factored in, whereas what we all consider a "good build" wins primarily on that first attribute, and a little help from #2.



Ex:
WR: 120 speed, 80 agility, 70 catching, 40 carrying, 30 strength
WR: 75 speed, 60 agility, 60 catching, 50 carrying, 50 strength


We'd all expect #1 to outperform, but in many cases, I've seen builds like #2 perform extremely well.


There's your x-factor. Maybe the obsession with cap building and primary stats isn't the gospel most people think it is.

I have a level 26 DT that I built "wrong" as he was my 3rd player. I "stupidly" spent points on a bunch of SAs before I was even at level 10. Now he is on a team with a simialar level DT who has nearly 10 points on him in STR and AGI, and outweighs him by 20 lbs. But the reverse pancakes from my DT are like 3:1 to the one who was built "properly".

Yes, I know he will probably not be in that great of shape long term, but his "bad" build is getting the job done for now.

People who think there is an X-factor need to accept that their cookie cutters aren't as good as they thought they were.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
I've seen and coordinated enough high end player builds to respectfully disagree with Hulk.


 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
Originally posted by Forbin

Originally posted by GG


Well, it's your fault for building generally good solid builds, playing in good leagues and in good teams with winning seasons. It'd be like trying to find an ugly girl in a Miss Universe pageant.

X-Factor is more evident on crappy teams where players just stand out for no reason, with no spectacular builds, no reason for them being so good/fast/strong/etc. Stand out like a tall blonde babe in an arabic third world nation.


I have to admit that I've seen some builds out there that most would consider absolutely horrendous, yet no matter where they go, they always perform at a very high level. I don't know if it's x-factor, or just that the majority of these shit builds are SUPER balanced, so they're able to win rolls with their second & third attributes factored in, whereas what we all consider a "good build" wins primarily on that first attribute, and a little help from #2.



Ex:
WR: 120 speed, 80 agility, 70 catching, 40 carrying, 30 strength
WR: 75 speed, 60 agility, 60 catching, 50 carrying, 50 strength


We'd all expect #1 to outperform, but in many cases, I've seen builds like #2 perform extremely well.


There's your x-factor. Maybe the obsession with cap building and primary stats isn't the gospel most people think it is.

I have a level 26 DT that I built "wrong" as he was my 3rd player. I "stupidly" spent points on a bunch of SAs before I was even at level 10. Now he is on a team with a simialar level DT who has nearly 10 points on him in STR and AGI, and outweighs him by 20 lbs. But the reverse pancakes from my DT are like 3:1 to the one who was built "properly".

Yes, I know he will probably not be in that great of shape long term, but his "bad" build is getting the job done for now.

People who think there is an X-factor need to accept that their cookie cutters aren't as good as they thought they were.


So what you are saying is too many points in every attribute can be a bad thing.

See, there are rational explanations that make much more sense than there being an x-factor.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
another day......another X-factor thread -



things are going to get K-R-A-Z-Y around here in a few more days - and through the offseason -

just something about the air - the natives seem restless
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
another day......another X-factor thread -

things are going to get K-R-A-Z-Y around here in a few more days - and through the offseason -

just something about the air - the natives seem restless


Will probably go crazy when people get air of Dooley's build.
 
PackAttack785
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by TxSteve

another day......another X-factor thread -

things are going to get K-R-A-Z-Y around here in a few more days - and through the offseason -

just something about the air - the natives seem restless


Will probably go crazy when people get air of Dooley's build.


I heard it was ridiculously average.
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackAttack785
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by TxSteve


another day......another X-factor thread -

things are going to get K-R-A-Z-Y around here in a few more days - and through the offseason -

just something about the air - the natives seem restless


Will probably go crazy when people get air of Dooley's build.


I heard it was ridiculously average.


heard wrong...wait you didn't hear anything since I didn't tell anyone
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackAttack785
I heard it was ridiculously average.


It's slightly above average...but not omgwtf.

Also, after seeing Jedi Knight's, his is above average, but still not superior enough to explain the difference I've seen in him and similar HB's.
 
healthguyfsu
offline
Link
 
waaaaaaaaaat....did u not see X-men?

Seriously, my observation is that this so-called "x factor" changes every year and is not directed by the game makers, rather it is an interaction effect of your stats in response to the changing engine of the game...most people forget things in comparisons, height, weight, competition level, % bonuses, VAs, etc. etc.

In essence, the x-factor is like a spontaneous mathematical variable that people either can't (too many predictors and hard to classify/quantify them) or won't (its too much work) define because of all that is involved...so they go to an easy alternative to figure out what works...build testing and sim testing. So one could say that the game has taken on a life of its own via this "x-factor"
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.