User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add a MINUMUM cap for each league will solve all!
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by puubescent
You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Players on a CPU team has to ride the storm until next season. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically or a GM can take over the team if he pays to be on the waiting list. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.


Were would these players that shift leagues go? Would they be dropped, randomly picked up? If a team wants to stay together, they should be able to, the owners here want complete control, without that god damn dumb ass rule you just made up
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mrforder
Originally posted by puubescent

You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Players on a CPU team has to ride the storm until next season. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically or a GM can take over the team if he pays to be on the waiting list. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.


Were would these players that shift leagues go? Would they be dropped, randomly picked up? If a team wants to stay together, they should be able to, the owners here want complete control, without that god damn dumb ass rule you just made up




Then lets do away with a league max cap.....whats the point of having a max cap or a max/min salary or a max/min bonus, or a max/min Peewee cap or a max/min concession value, or a max/min etc, etc, etc!!

You didn't read every arguement, please take a seat back under the bridge troll if your going to get dis-respectful!!

 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
The point of this is to push owners to stay in a league where it is intended to compete! Not to farm, not to slow build but to compete. A 24 cap team full of 27 to 20's win that 24 cap season they progress to the next promotion as Bort intended to a 34 cap league.....Now the whole god damn team can still stay together or continue to recruit 34's....NOT dump and sign levle 1's all over again.

If an owner CHOOSES to go that route, they can most definately make that request to support in the offseason to be back to the lowest cap league with a bunch of CPU's. A team like that can and will not be a Pinota in a 34 cap league where all the other hard working owners recruited to compete in a competitive environment! Just look at all the threads popping up about blow-outs again!
 
annil8tion
offline
Link
 
+1 to original idea
 
cowcards
offline
Link
 
Sorry if this has been asked. What about my team where I was handed it late after it was sold back. I got an uncapped team with the starting 1.5 and no stadium. Am I forced to sign people at level x and cost me a bunch of money and possible stadium development and ruin my team in the long haul because there would be no possible way I could sustain a team without being able to pay EQ?
 
glassmatica
offline
Link
 
Uh, why the !@#!#$@# has this not been implemented yet?!
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowcards
Sorry if this has been asked. What about my team where I was handed it late after it was sold back. I got an uncapped team with the starting 1.5 and no stadium. Am I forced to sign people at level x and cost me a bunch of money and possible stadium development and ruin my team in the long haul because there would be no possible way I could sustain a team without being able to pay EQ?



Those starting new AFTER the season has begun should never be in a situation to own an uncapped team. Uncapped should not be an option in the "waiting list" to start with. Its a huge problem when teams like this are handed out no matter what a min/max cap would be, and to be honest is another suggestion that someone can start in another thread.

If your really not satisfied with my answer here ^^, then a comprimise could be made in that if you "ARE HANDED OVER" your new team in an uncapped after the season has started, then the semi/fully built stadium should be inheritted along with the rights to that team.

Now go get your minimum cap players and compete at half strength, then get demoted at seasons end and compete in the league lower.... or recruit to the full potential and intent of an un-capped team ownership....you'll have fun right away and the teams in the league already will not half to play a bunch of level 1's or CPU's with scores of 255-0!!
 
Loganrobert85
offline
Link
 
agreed
 
enasty19
offline
Link
 
But then owners in the higher tier leagues that don't want to sign guys at the minimum level and want to slow build, would go to support and move them down at lowest level leagues to do it the way they want and then they'd have to kick a team out or add that team to the league and fill it up more than it already is.

Also, sorry if it was brought it, i only read the OP and didn't feel like reading through 9 pages of it.
Edited by eastonlax3 on Jun 28, 2009 18:16:58
 
Link
 

I say it again and again, it all goes back to slow building.

There needs to be another or other ways to build players of equal talent when they reach the upper levels.

There are a ton of teams out there were, "slow builds wanted, building team for future."

Send a few players that way, logged in at bare minimum, for just as long as it takes to spend training points before you loose them. These players, team owners that support it, and admins who fail to stop it, really put a damper on the whole experience.

Once everyone realizes that after lv 30 something w/o slow building there players start to suck, this will become a really boring site.

Whats the point of actually particapating in any league unil the pros if slow builing is the only way to build a player that will be any good at these higher levels.

 
didymus
offline
Link
 
futile thread

if an owner wants to start over with slow built team, let him


Under this brilliant plan, preventing such will have an owner with all cpu players,

so instead of 255-0 scores we will have 255-0 scores.

Yeah it sucks playing gutted teams, always has. Let's not go Nazi about it.



Not to mention every time this happens, bunch of retirees and bunch of newly minted 1's - Bort's cash register rings at 30% profit.
 
iBlock
offline
Link
 
+1
 
thebigphish19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
futile thread

if an owner wants to start over with slow built team, let him


Under this brilliant plan, preventing such will have an owner with all cpu players,

so instead of 255-0 scores we will have 255-0 scores.

Yeah it sucks playing gutted teams, always has. Let's not go Nazi about it.



Not to mention every time this happens, bunch of retirees and bunch of newly minted 1's - Bort's cash register rings at 30% profit.


+1000

There really is no way to account for teams that become financially insolvent and need to gut and rebuild or teams that start out in a high cap league. Very often it just takes a little while to build a good enough stadium to afford good players and give them the equipment upgrades they need.

When I started my team I signed players that were too high so that I could attempt to compete with the level I was thrown into and I went 5-11. Im still paying for it. If I would have signed lvl 1s or something I would have my stadium nearly completed by now. As it is I am competitive but will need a couple more seasons to be able to upgrade my players sufficiently. I am trying not to have to gut but every spreadsheet I make tells me that I am gonna need some extremely understanding agents to keep their quality built players on the team long enough to finish my stadium without gutting.

I get the point of all this I really do. Having an occasional blowout is obnoxious but if you have to gut then you have to gut.
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigphish19
Originally posted by didymus

futile thread

if an owner wants to start over with slow built team, let him


Under this brilliant plan, preventing such will have an owner with all cpu players,

so instead of 255-0 scores we will have 255-0 scores.

Yeah it sucks playing gutted teams, always has. Let's not go Nazi about it.



Not to mention every time this happens, bunch of retirees and bunch of newly minted 1's - Bort's cash register rings at 30% profit.


+1000

There really is no way to account for teams that become financially insolvent and need to gut and rebuild or teams that start out in a high cap league. Very often it just takes a little while to build a good enough stadium to afford good players and give them the equipment upgrades they need.

When I started my team I signed players that were too high so that I could attempt to compete with the level I was thrown into and I went 5-11. Im still paying for it. If I would have signed lvl 1s or something I would have my stadium nearly completed by now. As it is I am competitive but will need a couple more seasons to be able to upgrade my players sufficiently. I am trying not to have to gut but every spreadsheet I make tells me that I am gonna need some extremely understanding agents to keep their quality built players on the team long enough to finish my stadium without gutting.

I get the point of all this I really do. Having an occasional blowout is obnoxious but if you have to gut then you have to gut.


Then why have Max cap? What is the logic behind that? so teams don't get blown out by outlevelled teams every game...Bingo, no difference here, otherwise your talking out both sides of your mouth if you defend having a max cap because it contridicts almost every arguement to this idea!



 
madmatg
offline
Link
 
+1 OP
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.