As I posted in the EE Pro Private forum
The primary goal of any "solution" is to encourage people to play the game sportsmanlike, you cant hard program any percentage limitations in the AI, people will break that, the point is .. you do it like electricity, you build up more resistance the more often you try to run a play, progressively more.
Originally posted by Randy03
Its not really like its a new problem, thats the main issue.
I mean look at the one time I really exploded last season.
Vaadwaur ran 4 plays against us and they won
Hellas ran 2 plays against Vaadwaur and won
This season its just the trend to do that more often
The ability to gimp the other team has always been there since OAI has been out, its just that until say last season, people were doing it less. It has finally broken down to where USAPL was going that way this season, there were teams pissed that passing got "nerfed" and so they decided that they knew what would work, what had always worked, HB Slam .. then they said .. hey HB Slam cant really be stopped .. so they did it more and more .. and bammo we are where we are.
It has everything to do with giving players an anonymous place to do crap to people that they would never do in RL. It happens with Madden/NCAA online, some dickwad subs in a WR at QB and runs off all of the DBs with the WRs and takes off. But at least in the EA Games, you are playing versus them and can take control of the LB/S and spy him and knock the crap out of him. In a sim, its set, so the issue is that you always have to gamble on the sportsmanship of your opponent, because essentially when you put in a balanced gameplan on either offense or defense, you are assuming that your opponent isnt going to go 100% something, or run 1 play.
Thats why I was upset at the "Swiss Cheese" defense comments last season by Vaadwaur, I have a good defense, I think this season proved how darn good my defense is. Its just that if you have a defense that is designed to stop anything possible, then its likely it will be weak to specific things.
With the present system you can ALWAYS find something that will work pretty often, if its a run, its even more sure that it will be something positive. But of course then with teams coming down against the run, there are even more passing opportunities .. its a pick your poison, which is good tactics .. but the fact that you can ONLY do one thing and since its a SIM and there is nothing you can do to adapt if your opponent puts in their settings, that is the frusterating part, its not live, you cant adapt and until Bort either limits how the offense can be set up or somehow has the defense adapt/get better as the same play is run over and over, nothing is going to change. And if it is a defensive solution, it needs to be a fast progression as I have posted on the suggestions forums
1 time play run = no penalty
5 times play run = no penalty (thats cool, run it 5 times, whole game)
(x-5)*2 = Bonus to ALL defensive player attributes, so then for every time the play over 5 times, the defense gets a 2% bonus, if say the play was run 50 times, the defense would be playing at 190% normal stats, I figure that would cut that crap out in a hurry.
If you wanted to fix things faster and "encourage" people to play nice, it would be a 4% per time the play is run modifier. That means of course that there would have to be tied to each sim (could be erased after the sim server side) counters how often each play was run, I do this myself when I scout teams, I have spreadsheets what plays teams run and how often, in what situations .. I know their OAI inputs, Im pretty sure Havoc does this as well, we have discussed our systems for DC scouting before.
Anyhow .. basically the 4% bonus over 5 times run would give a 20% bonus by the 10th time run, which isnt significant, you could run your favorite play 1/7 of the time (70 snaps is about average) and not get a major penalty (20% is a lot but still not far away from what kind of crap the RNG does to players in a game). But yeah when you start running a play 20% of your plays 14 times, it would be up to a 36% bonus, I figure that would start to get noticed.
Or of course it could be a power or piecewise equation, I know that Bort loves power equations, so maybe from 6-10 the penalty could be 4%, then from 11-15 it would be 20%+ a higher percentage like 6% per play, 16-20 times run it would then be 50%+ 8% per time run, or something like that, so that the more you tried to run it, the higher the resistance would be, much like the attribute system.
With a progressive system like that, if you ran a play x times (assuming 70 plays per team per game, thats the college average I know that)
5 times = no opponent bonus
10 times (14% of your plays) = 20% (1.2)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
15 times (21% of your plays) = 50% (1.5)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
20 times (29% of your plays) = 90% (1.9)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
25 times (36% of your plays) = 140% (2.4)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
etc
The point is .. people would realize that there was a point where there was diminishing returns for doing that kind of crap and you just need to pick a point where Bort/whoever determines "enough is enough", Id say 30% of your plays being 1 play is already very excessive and 1.9x is probably still not enough to discourage people from running 3 plays (29%)x3 = 97%
The primary goal of any "solution" is to encourage people to play the game sportsmanlike, you cant hard program any percentage limitations in the AI, people will break that, the point is .. you do it like electricity, you build up more resistance the more often you try to run a play, progressively more.
Originally posted by Randy03
Its not really like its a new problem, thats the main issue.
I mean look at the one time I really exploded last season.
Vaadwaur ran 4 plays against us and they won
Hellas ran 2 plays against Vaadwaur and won
This season its just the trend to do that more often
The ability to gimp the other team has always been there since OAI has been out, its just that until say last season, people were doing it less. It has finally broken down to where USAPL was going that way this season, there were teams pissed that passing got "nerfed" and so they decided that they knew what would work, what had always worked, HB Slam .. then they said .. hey HB Slam cant really be stopped .. so they did it more and more .. and bammo we are where we are.
It has everything to do with giving players an anonymous place to do crap to people that they would never do in RL. It happens with Madden/NCAA online, some dickwad subs in a WR at QB and runs off all of the DBs with the WRs and takes off. But at least in the EA Games, you are playing versus them and can take control of the LB/S and spy him and knock the crap out of him. In a sim, its set, so the issue is that you always have to gamble on the sportsmanship of your opponent, because essentially when you put in a balanced gameplan on either offense or defense, you are assuming that your opponent isnt going to go 100% something, or run 1 play.
Thats why I was upset at the "Swiss Cheese" defense comments last season by Vaadwaur, I have a good defense, I think this season proved how darn good my defense is. Its just that if you have a defense that is designed to stop anything possible, then its likely it will be weak to specific things.
With the present system you can ALWAYS find something that will work pretty often, if its a run, its even more sure that it will be something positive. But of course then with teams coming down against the run, there are even more passing opportunities .. its a pick your poison, which is good tactics .. but the fact that you can ONLY do one thing and since its a SIM and there is nothing you can do to adapt if your opponent puts in their settings, that is the frusterating part, its not live, you cant adapt and until Bort either limits how the offense can be set up or somehow has the defense adapt/get better as the same play is run over and over, nothing is going to change. And if it is a defensive solution, it needs to be a fast progression as I have posted on the suggestions forums
1 time play run = no penalty
5 times play run = no penalty (thats cool, run it 5 times, whole game)
(x-5)*2 = Bonus to ALL defensive player attributes, so then for every time the play over 5 times, the defense gets a 2% bonus, if say the play was run 50 times, the defense would be playing at 190% normal stats, I figure that would cut that crap out in a hurry.
If you wanted to fix things faster and "encourage" people to play nice, it would be a 4% per time the play is run modifier. That means of course that there would have to be tied to each sim (could be erased after the sim server side) counters how often each play was run, I do this myself when I scout teams, I have spreadsheets what plays teams run and how often, in what situations .. I know their OAI inputs, Im pretty sure Havoc does this as well, we have discussed our systems for DC scouting before.
Anyhow .. basically the 4% bonus over 5 times run would give a 20% bonus by the 10th time run, which isnt significant, you could run your favorite play 1/7 of the time (70 snaps is about average) and not get a major penalty (20% is a lot but still not far away from what kind of crap the RNG does to players in a game). But yeah when you start running a play 20% of your plays 14 times, it would be up to a 36% bonus, I figure that would start to get noticed.
Or of course it could be a power or piecewise equation, I know that Bort loves power equations, so maybe from 6-10 the penalty could be 4%, then from 11-15 it would be 20%+ a higher percentage like 6% per play, 16-20 times run it would then be 50%+ 8% per time run, or something like that, so that the more you tried to run it, the higher the resistance would be, much like the attribute system.
With a progressive system like that, if you ran a play x times (assuming 70 plays per team per game, thats the college average I know that)
5 times = no opponent bonus
10 times (14% of your plays) = 20% (1.2)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
15 times (21% of your plays) = 50% (1.5)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
20 times (29% of your plays) = 90% (1.9)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
25 times (36% of your plays) = 140% (2.4)x bonus to ALL defender attributes
etc
The point is .. people would realize that there was a point where there was diminishing returns for doing that kind of crap and you just need to pick a point where Bort/whoever determines "enough is enough", Id say 30% of your plays being 1 play is already very excessive and 1.9x is probably still not enough to discourage people from running 3 plays (29%)x3 = 97%
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 06:55:31






























